Search Captions & Ask AI

Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)

February 05, 2026 / 54:16

This episode covers the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, and the case of serial killer Dennis Nilson. Elina and Ash discuss the chilling details surrounding Nancy's abduction, the emotional impact on Savannah, and the ongoing search for answers. They also touch on local businesses in Minnesota and the concept of 'flow states' in daily life.

The hosts express concern for Savannah Guthrie as her 84-year-old mother Nancy has been missing since Saturday night. They discuss the lack of information from authorities, the possibility of foul play, and the urgency of Nancy's medical needs.

Elina and Ash then shift to a lighter topic about supporting local businesses in Minnesota, linking to resources for listeners to help those affected by recent events.

The conversation transitions to the concept of 'flow states,' where the hosts share personal experiences of achieving focus and enjoyment in various activities. They encourage listeners to find their own flow states.

Finally, they introduce the case of Dennis Nilson, a serial killer known for his necrophilic tendencies, setting the stage for a three-part series on his life and crimes.

TLDR

Elina and Ash discuss Nancy Guthrie's disappearance and introduce Dennis Nilson's chilling case in a three-part series.

Episode

54:16
00:00:00
Hey weirdos. I'm Elina. >> I'm Ash. >> And this is Morbid. [music] This [music] is morbid.
00:00:19
>> This is morbid. And there's a lot going on. >> My goodness. Doesn't it just feel like
00:00:23
that every single day you wake up? >> Truly. >> More and more going on. something very
00:00:27
[music] it's this is one of those things it's very chilling and it's like something that I can't stop thinking
00:00:32
about >> and like checking in on >> um so the today's show anchor Savannah Guthrie her 84year-old mother Nancy
00:00:40
Guthrie has been missing since Saturday night I believe she seen was Saturday night
00:00:46
>> and this story is just wild and heartbreaking and horrifying I can't stop thinking about it
00:00:53
>> no I can't either >> we I mean We we I we haven't been so much recently just because life has
00:00:59
gotten busy, but we used to be such a Today Show house. >> Oh my god. I used to come over like
00:01:03
every single day and we would just watch hours of the Today Show. >> Love the Today Show. Um and like so
00:01:10
we've been watching Savannah forever and it's >> years >> destroying my soul to think of how much
00:01:16
pain she must be going through right now. >> My heart is with her and her family
00:01:19
>> and this story is just wild. I mean Nancy is 84 years old. She's just described as sharp as attack, has a
00:01:27
little bit of mobility issues, so she wasn't going to be getting up and leaving on her own,
00:01:31
>> right? >> She lives in Arizona and there's not a lot coming out, which leads me to
00:01:36
believe that >> they might have something that they're working on that or at least they're
00:01:40
trying to chase something down that maybe they don't want or they something happened that they just don't want us to
00:01:45
know. >> Yeah, because they've said they don't believe it's a home invasion. They don't
00:01:48
believe it's a robbery gone wrong, but there is evidence of foul play. Yeah, it sounds like they're they're pretty much
00:01:55
stating now that she was abducted from her bed. >> An 84 year old woman abducted from her
00:02:00
bed. >> Yeah, it's horrific. >> It's just horrifying. She needs medication every 24 hours to literally
00:02:07
survive. >> It's life-threatening if she doesn't have it. >> And she the medicine was left in the
00:02:11
home, which is very concerning. >> And now her pacemaker is not connecting to her Apple Watch anymore.
00:02:17
>> Yeah, that was the newest update. So, >> it's all really horrifying. And I'm just
00:02:22
thinking about how her family is feeling right now. And I imagine I can't even put my brain in that space, but I just
00:02:29
hope that like by some miracle found alive and well. >> I hope they know more than they're
00:02:35
saying. >> Yeah. >> Um and I hope that they find Nancy because it's really it's the world.
00:02:42
>> Yeah. And Savannah has gone through a lot. >> Yeah. She just I think she just came
00:02:46
back from like a vocal cord surgery or something. Yeah. and just like their family in general. Like it's just so
00:02:51
that's so sad. >> But yeah, we loved the we always love the Today Show and >> you know it just I was like oh
00:02:58
>> yeah it's you like you have these people in your house on the daily so you feel
00:03:02
this like strange connection to them. >> So I felt like super as soon as I heard
00:03:05
I was like oh my god >> it's like your friend is going through this. It feels like
00:03:09
>> it's really sad but just let's let's hope they find Nancy and Savannah's asking for prayers.
00:03:14
>> Yeah. Like damn. Um but yeah, just wanted to point that out. Hopefully there's an update and a good one.
00:03:20
>> A good one. I know. >> Let's manifest that for her. >> But yeah, um in another level.
00:03:26
>> I was going to say going going into another hopefully we a little bit of positivity.
00:03:32
>> Obviously everybody knows how we feel about ice. [ __ ] Ice. We want them out of
00:03:36
Minnesota. We want them out of everywhere. >> Yeah. >> Um but we were thinking of just like
00:03:40
anything we can do to help. >> And Mikey was uh nice enough to help us find this on uh Minnesota.org org and we
00:03:48
will link this in our show notes. They have a full list of small businesses that you can support.
00:03:53
>> Yes. So, we'll we'll link those in the show notes and we'll link we'll try to
00:03:57
link them on I don't think Instagram allows links. It's >> I don't think it does either.
00:04:00
>> It drives me nuts. I'm like, can you allow links? >> I know, Meta. >> Well, we'll link it in the show notes.
00:04:04
Go find those. It's just wherever you're listening to. If you hit like more info,
00:04:07
it should be right there. Yeah. >> I know sometimes people struggle to find them.
00:04:11
>> Yeah. >> Uh so, check those out. Support some local businesses. Yeah. >> It's a great way to just cuz they're
00:04:17
going through a lot more than what we're seeing. >> Yeah. >> We're being news is being suppressed for
00:04:22
sure. >> So just like they they need all the support they can get. >> And anywhere else that you hear of ice,
00:04:27
a great way to fight back and spend your money in a good way is to shop local. >> Exactly.
00:04:32
>> Any any Etsy shops you can find in areas like that, you know, we love local businesses
00:04:36
>> just in general. It's good to do anyways. >> Yeah, that's just good to do anyway. Um,
00:04:40
on a more like lighter note, and this is we're really segueing. >> Yeah. >> I can't believe I'm segueing here.
00:04:47
>> I mean, we need a segue. We need a segway. That's just if you know that's just that's the way the show goes.
00:04:53
>> That was the business at the top and now we're at the banter. >> Do you know what a flow state is?
00:04:59
>> Yeah. What is a flow state? I think like a flow state isn't that when you like
00:05:03
really lock in. I don't Everybody says that like I keep seeing it on TikTok people being like I I ate this ice cream
00:05:11
or I one thing that I keep seeing people saying is like they take a sip of like the most delicious latte and they enter
00:05:17
a flow state. >> Yeah. I think it's like a really locked in state of just like >> like ready to [ __ ] go.
00:05:23
>> So I just looked and I just looked it up. It says like being in the zone um complete absorption, focus, and
00:05:29
enjoyment in whatever activity you are engaged in. >> Okay. I've enjoyed a lot of things in my
00:05:33
life. I don't know that I've ever been in a flow state. >> Oh, I've been in a flow state so many
00:05:38
times. >> Tell me when you're in a flow state. >> I'm in a flow state. >> Give me examples.
00:05:41
>> When I can sit down in front of a computer in a word document and write more than three words, that's a flow
00:05:48
state >> and I I enter a full flow state. If I'm tap tap tapping and [ __ ] is rolling out
00:05:55
and it's happening, flow state. >> Okay. If I make a perfect coffee in the morning, immediately enter
00:06:03
a flow state. >> Okay. >> So, I've probably been in a flow state. >> I'm sure you have. You're just not
00:06:08
recognizing it as a flow. >> I got to recognize my flow states >> when I um when I like organize
00:06:16
and feel like I've actually accomplished some kind of organization. Okay. >> I will enter a flow state.
00:06:22
>> Okay. When I organized my pantry, I was in a flow state. >> You were in a flow state.
00:06:25
>> All right. All right. All right. >> Yeah. Like I decorate for and Ash actually helped me this this time. I
00:06:31
decorate for every holiday like the bathroom that like my kids generally use >> and we decorate it for every holiday.
00:06:39
Like I always put a bunch of just cuz it's fun. They get home from school >> and or like they go to brush their teeth
00:06:46
and they're like, "Oh my god." It's all these like lights and stuff. And so for Valentine's Day this year, we went like
00:06:51
all out and Ash helped me like use the markers that you can write on the glass to like make little candy hearts on the
00:06:57
>> I thought that was so cute. The little like conversation hearts >> and I think in those moments I enter a
00:07:03
flow state. >> Okay. I was when I was doing those hearts even though my knees were hurting
00:07:06
really bad um I was in a flow state. >> Yeah. >> See all that's a flow state. Thank you.
00:07:11
I thought of this last night because I saw a talk of a lady being like, "Oh my god, I just entered a flow state cuz
00:07:15
this latte is so good." And I felt like that was very Gen Z. And I said, "Have I
00:07:20
been in a flow state? What ex I said, I wonder if Alina knows what a flow state is." And I saved it for the pod.
00:07:26
>> I was going to ask you about flow states, but >> But you let it happen. >> I think I'm in a flow state when I shop.
00:07:31
>> Oh, you definitely are in a flow [laughter] state when you shop. >> Yeah. Yeah, I definitely am.
00:07:35
>> Yeah. Yeah. Hopefully we can all get into flow states with things we enjoy right now. There's another tip of the
00:07:43
day. Make sure make it your [ __ ] mission tomorrow. >> Yeah, tomorrow. Right now.
00:07:50
>> I mean, try it now. But it's okay if if you're not like in that place right now
00:07:53
and you need a minute to like really, you know, get it or figure out what your flow state thing might be.
00:07:59
>> Tomorrow, wake up, >> attempt flow state, whatever you need to do. Watch one of those late 90s, early
00:08:07
2000s movies if you need to that flow state. >> Make an awesome coffee. organize, decorate,
00:08:14
just read a book, write down some [ __ ] Like, do whatever you need to do. Enter.
00:08:20
>> Make sure you do not go to bed tomorrow night >> until you have entered your flow state.
00:08:25
Even for a second. >> Even if it's just a quick flow state. >> Oh, I think we all need that every day.
00:08:30
>> This is like a glass shatter moment. I enter a a flow state when I do I almost
00:08:34
said a scloate. [laughter] >> I enter a sloate. I enter a flow state when I do my skin care or an every an
00:08:41
everything shower. That's a flow state. All right, I get it now. I get it. So, see, there you go. Get have a good
00:08:48
shower or something like >> tomorrow make it your business to enter a flow state and then try to enter a
00:08:53
flow state just for one second even every day >> just to give yourself that one.
00:08:58
>> Does a flow state need to be a little bit longer though? A flow state feels longer than one second. I don't think
00:09:03
there's a there's a >> there's no deadline on flow states. I think as long as you feel like you
00:09:08
entered a flow state, even for a second. >> If you drank every time we said flow
00:09:12
state during this, you would die. >> Yeah, you just died. >> That's crazy. >> Um but yeah, do that. I think that
00:09:17
that's my advice for the day. >> I like that. >> My advice to get >> I'm all about flow states right now. We
00:09:23
ordered Jersey Mike's cookies and I'm going to eat one after this and I forgot we had that.
00:09:27
>> Oh, baby. Not only did we order like one, not only did we order two, we got two mini boxes. [laughter] And if they
00:09:33
had more than mini boxes, we would get two of those, too. >> Hell yeah. >> Those put me in a flow state.
00:09:38
>> We're going to need that because we're starting a threepart series that is going to be a harrowing journey.
00:09:46
>> I have to tell you something. When you say we're starting a three-part series,
00:09:51
I know it's about to get dark. >> Yeah. But you try to enter a fugue state at that point. [laughter]
00:10:00
>> That's what you know what your three part I got to say. Let me just like let me let me brownnose you real quick.
00:10:07
>> I really love your three-parters because they feel cinematic to me when I sit and
00:10:10
listen to them. >> Oh, thank you. That's highest praise I could imagine. >> Let me wipe my nose off.
00:10:15
>> I love that. Wipe your nose off. No, I appreciate that. Uh this one's going to
00:10:19
be it's about Dennis Nelson, the kindly killer. He was referred to Feel like I recognize the name. Yeah, we we've
00:10:25
definitely talked about him before. He's he's come up on Crime Countdown. Okay. >> Um he's a lot
00:10:33
>> I bet. >> Um he's a lot part. >> He has many many victims >> and he's got a lot going on. Uh just as
00:10:42
a quick little trigger warning, he um has necrophilic tendencies. Uh so so that's going to be part of
00:10:50
this. >> He's not the vampire one, is he? >> Nope. >> Okay. No, >> just another guy.
00:10:55
>> No, that's another guy. Like that's Isn't that wild that we're just like, "No, that's a whole other guy."
00:11:00
>> Yep. Always a guy. >> Um, so we're gonna talk about him. And this uh this took place in the 80s. So
00:11:07
>> So that usually that's a fun time for some other things like pop culture, but
00:11:11
>> whenever anybody says anything is the '8s anymore, all I can hear is in my head saying it was the '8s.
00:11:16
>> It was the '8s. >> Uh, so we'll start just get by giving a little overview. It was on the morning
00:11:22
of February 8th, 1983, which I did not even realize. >> Yeah. >> That by the time when this comes out,
00:11:28
it's going to be right before it. And then I think the second part will come out like the day after 9th or something.
00:11:34
I didn't do that on purpose. >> That happened so frequently. >> I I did not do that on purp That's.
00:11:38
That's so weird. >> That just I forget which case, but that just happened to me, too. And I just
00:11:41
didn't reference it. >> It happens so often. >> Like that happened to me, too. >> I want you to know we literally never do
00:11:46
that on purpose. never chosen a case based on the date being the date it'll come out.
00:11:51
>> No, it's very strange. >> Yeah. >> So weird. One of those like anomalies. >> Yeah. So on that day, February 8th,
00:11:57
1983, a plumber working in London's Muzell Hill neighborhood opened a drainage cover behind a Cranley Gardens
00:12:05
apartment building. And in that drainage cover, he made a horrific discovery. The
00:12:10
drain was completely blocked by pieces of bone and human tissue. >> Oh, [ __ ] So he called police.
00:12:17
>> That's That's the best people to call. >> Yeah. And detectives arrived on the
00:12:20
scene and they traced the blockage back to one apartment in the building. And when they went into this apartment,
00:12:28
there were additional pieces of evidence in this apartment that suggested that things were exponentially worse than
00:12:35
they had even originally thought they were. >> And they probably thought things were
00:12:39
pretty bad originally. >> And that apartment building belonged to Dennis Nilson.
00:12:43
>> That's crazy. I didn't expect that. Yeah, I know. It's twist. [laughter] >> Wait, the fact that they could trace
00:12:49
like the drainage pipes back to them is nuts. Pipes are nuts. Pipes are crazy. >> I've been talking about pipes for all
00:12:54
week. >> Pipes really go crazy. >> I had a pipe burst in my garage and I said, "Why is there even a [ __ ] pipe
00:12:58
in my garage?" >> True. And you said, "I don't know. >> I don't know. Don't talk to me about
00:13:01
[laughter] it." >> So, let's talk about Dennis Nilson. Who he was before he became this Dennis N.
00:13:06
>> What happened to him? >> So, he was born November 23rd, 1945. Does that make him a Sagittarius?
00:13:12
>> Yes. >> No. I think. >> Does it? Yeah. >> Yeah. I think it's literally like right.
00:13:16
I think 21st starts Sagge. >> There we go. >> He's very close to being a scorp. >> Oh, okay.
00:13:22
>> Hold on. Let me let me make sure cuz sometimes I'm dumb. >> Sometimes I'm dumb.
00:13:27
>> Sometimes I'm dumb when it comes to the zodiac. I'm a new. >> You know, I've started another thing
00:13:31
I've started to do. I think I've said this before, but I started doing it again cuz I fell back into it. Tell me.
00:13:36
>> Um I've started when I like I'll do something or forget something in the house and I'm like, "You're so stupid.
00:13:40
Like go get stop doing that." Okay, you're right. >> Stop doing that. You're right. Because I
00:13:44
liter I did it yesterday. I was like, "Oh my god, I'm so dumb." And then I was like And literally, if anyone heard me
00:13:50
doing this, they'd probably be like, "You're losing. Wow, you're I said, "No, you're not dumb. You just forgot that
00:13:56
thing. That doesn't make you dumb." >> Okay, hold on, Ash. No, you're not dumb. You're still learning this and you're
00:14:00
working on it actively. And actually, you were correct this time. >> Yeah, there you go.
00:14:04
>> So, no, you're right. Because I saw um I saw an article. >> You saw an article that said
00:14:10
>> You watched an article. I watched I watched an article that did say our brains believe what we tell them. So if
00:14:16
you keep telling your brain you're dumb or you're fat or you're ugly or you're this or you're that
00:14:20
>> it's going to believe it. >> It's going to be like wow I suck >> because your brain who is it going to
00:14:23
believe? You like you're the one that it wants to believe. >> You think you're going to sound kooky. I
00:14:27
looked at myself in the mirror the other day and I said you look beautiful today
00:14:30
as you should. >> Yeah. So start doing that too. >> You absolutely should. I I truly believe
00:14:34
like we need to be stop being so negative to ourselves because I think a lot of people who are complete [ __ ] ass
00:14:40
pieces of [ __ ] out in the world. Well, and also they're mean to themselves too.
00:14:45
>> Yeah, absolutely. >> And they've taught themselves to be these like toxically negative people and
00:14:49
they're like and it makes them feel like [ __ ] They've done it to themselves usually and then they put it out to
00:14:55
everybody else. >> In the words of Rupaul, how the hell are you going to How are you going to love
00:14:58
yourself? How in the hell are you going to love yourself if you can't? I don't know. RuPaul [laughter] said
00:15:06
I've watched so much Drag Race. How did I I feel like the hell LGBT card [laughter]
00:15:13
you said? I don't know. >> How in the hell are you going to love somebody else if you can't love Mikey?
00:15:19
What does he say? Mikey. Mikey, help. >> Mikey, help. Gay help. What is What [laughter] does Rupaul say? How in the
00:15:26
hell you gonna love somebody else if you cannot love yourself? >> No. [laughter] Why am I saying it so
00:15:32
wrong? >> I'm looking at >> Are we straight right now? >> Mikey. >> Mikey, >> you can't love
00:15:38
>> If you can't love yourself, how in the hell are you going to love somebody else? That's exactly it.
00:15:42
>> Okay. >> Can I get an amen? >> Can I get an amen? Yeah. Oh my god. I don't deserve the amen. [laughter] Don't
00:15:47
give it to me. Oh my lord. >> Oh my god. >> That was crazy. That was crazy. I just
00:15:53
looked it up. I just did the [laughter] I just did the Capricorn thing and I said I'll look it up. Don't worry,
00:15:58
>> guys. That was the opposite of a flow state. >> That was That was >> That was the opposite. Do you ever do
00:16:05
something like that and you say, "Do I have a cognitive issue?" >> Yes. All the time.
00:16:11
>> I'm going to do a Sudoku later. Anyways. Anyways, >> the whole point of that was stop telling
00:16:16
saying you're dumb and being mean to yourself. That's another piece of advice. Do that.
00:16:20
>> Yeah. >> Uh it's really hard right now. >> Do crosswords too of that. Holy [laughter] [ __ ] So, yeah. So, Dennis
00:16:25
Nielsen um was a Sagittarius and he was born that's where we >> [ __ ] [laughter] that's the
00:16:32
roundabout. >> That's where we started. >> And he was born in uh in Scotland. >> Oh, [ __ ] him for doing that,
00:16:39
>> right? Like Scottish people don't do that. >> No, >> dick. >> That's not Scottish.
00:16:44
>> So, this he was the second of three children born to Elizabeth and Olaf Mokshim.
00:16:48
>> Sorry, but it's always the middle child. Um they later adopted the surname Nilson.
00:16:52
>> Got it. >> Uh they had met several years earlier um when Olaf saved Elizabeth from being
00:16:59
attacked by another man. >> Wow, that's a great me. >> What a me cute. Yeah. >> Uh they started dating and very soon
00:17:05
after they were talking about marriage and on May 2nd, 1942, they married. >> Love.
00:17:10
>> Olaf and Elizabeth's first child was Olaf Jr. Uh he came a short time after they got married and he was followed
00:17:17
quickly by two other children, Dennis and Sylvia. Uh despite their whirlwind romance and growing family, Olaf Senior
00:17:25
never really took to the whole marriage and family life. So he was just frequently absent from home. Yeah. Uh he
00:17:32
that was either due to his responsibilities in the military or his general uninterest in being a father.
00:17:39
>> Okay. >> We're not sure which or it was an amalgamation. >> Kind of a little bit of both.
00:17:43
>> Okay. Um, as a result, Elizabeth continued to live with her parents and the children were raised as much by them
00:17:49
as by their mother. >> Well, that's kind of nice. I loved my grand. And I still do, in fact.
00:17:54
>> Yeah. Years later, when he reflected about his parents' marriage, Dennis wrote, cuz he did write a memoir, by the
00:18:01
way. >> Oh, no. >> Yeah. >> They always do. >> They always do. He wrote, "In the heat
00:18:06
and uncertainty of war, my father married my mother primarily on lustful grounds and ignoring some irreconcilable
00:18:13
cultural and personality differences which doomed the match to failure." >> Oh, [ __ ]
00:18:18
>> Which is like weirdly insightful. [laughter] Yeah, >> that is insightful. >> Although their father was hardly ever
00:18:24
home and really only saw the children on rare occasions, his presence, or maybe more his absence, was pretty influential
00:18:32
on the family. Mhm. >> Um the detached nature of Olaf and Elizabeth's relationship appears to have
00:18:38
filtered down to their children. Uh and it kind of prevented them not just forming a bond with their parents, but
00:18:43
with one another as well. >> Oh, yeah. This led to all the Nilson children, but Dennis in particular,
00:18:50
becoming very isolated and withdrawn. For Dennis, this meant spending hours alone every day, escaping into an
00:18:58
increasingly intense fantasy world. Uh, in fact, Nelson even described himself as quote,
00:19:04
"An an unhappy, brooding child, secretive and stricken with inferiority." >> Oh, that's horrifying.
00:19:12
>> Yeah. >> It's true that Dennis felt a very uh tenuous connection to his parents and
00:19:17
siblings, but the family wasn't entirely like fractured. >> Yeah. Because his grandparents were such
00:19:22
a constant presence in his early life, he formed a very big like very strong bond with his grandfather, Andrew White.
00:19:30
Unlike Dennis's mother, who was generally detached and permissive, Andrew was actually a harsh and deeply
00:19:37
religious man with an incredibly rigid sense of morality. >> Oh, I was relieved for like one second.
00:19:43
>> Well, the thing is when it came to his grandson, he was very warm and compassionate.
00:19:47
>> Okay. >> And it was really maybe the only connection Dennis had to the world outside his fantasies. And because of
00:19:54
this, Dennis was devastated when in the fall of 1951, 62year-old Andrew died from a heart
00:20:01
attack while he was on a fishing boat. >> That is so young. >> Yeah. In one of his earliest memories,
00:20:06
Nelson recalled being brought into the house during the funeral to view his grandfather's body.
00:20:11
>> Uh he said, "Grandd was wearing glasses and expensive long johns. He was barefooted and needed a shave. He looked
00:20:18
as if he was sleeping." >> Oh, that's really sad. Many years later, Dennis would trace his
00:20:23
pathology back to this event. Uh he wrote, "My troubles started there. It blighted my personality permanently.
00:20:30
I've spent all my emotional life searching for my grandfather. And in my formative years, no one was there to
00:20:35
take his place. Father and grandfather had walked out on me, probably for a better place, leaving me behind in this
00:20:42
not so good place alone." >> Oh man. >> Which if he wasn't such a complete piece
00:20:46
of [ __ ] you'd be like, "Oh my god, that's so sad." >> Yeah. You feel bad for the kid.
00:20:50
>> Exactly. In the wake of his grandfather's death, Dennis became much more isolated. He spent his free time by
00:20:56
the water watching the fishing boats come and go. And during one of these occasions, he claimed to have walked
00:21:02
into the ocean to try to end his life. >> Oh, [ __ ] >> But he was saved by an older boy who
00:21:07
spotted him from the beach and pulled him back to shore. Now, in his memoirs, he claimed that this savior of his
00:21:15
potentially sexually assaulted him. >> Oh. But because he was unconscious at the time, he was unable to provide any
00:21:22
details of the attack or his attacker. >> Okay. >> That said, Nilson himself acknowledges
00:21:29
his tendency to blend fantasy with memory. >> Uhhuh. >> And reality with not reality um when
00:21:38
recounting events from his life. So, it's kind of impossible to know which aspects of his early biography are true
00:21:45
and which are pieces he made up. Mhm. You know, >> yeah, that's tough. >> Um, not cuz they never were able to like
00:21:50
identify this person. They don't even know if he actually walked into the ocean.
00:21:54
>> Exactly. Right. >> It might have never happened. >> Okay. >> Now, not long after the death of his
00:21:58
father, Elizabeth married a second time to a man named Adam Scott. Adam Scott is
00:22:04
not the one that was on Parks and Recreation. >> Oh, I forgot that was Adam Scott.
00:22:09
>> Not Ben Wyatt. Uh, I was [laughter] I second guessed myself immediately. >> Oh, that's why I was confused. I was
00:22:15
like, "Is his name Adam?" You were talking his government name. >> Yeah, his government name, not Ben
00:22:19
Wyatt. >> Um, unlike her previous husband, Scott was a local man with strong connections
00:22:24
to the area and a solid work history in the building trade. He was, according to
00:22:29
author Brian Masters, quote, "A quiet, solid, and reliable man who gave her four more children in four years."
00:22:36
>> Okay. Wow. Yeah. A lot of kids >> getting busy. So, if Elizabeth Nilson had maintained a casual and detached
00:22:42
relationship to her children before her second marriage, she definitely doubled that marrying Scott. And
00:22:48
>> babe, why'd you have four more >> and adding four more children to the house?
00:22:51
>> Also, the additional kids in the house pushed Dennis further away from his mother and deeper into isolation.
00:22:57
>> Uh, he wrote, "In those days, I could hate Adam Scott very easily. I sometimes
00:23:01
felt that we, the Nilson kids, were an impediment to my mother's fulfillment in her new life and family."
00:23:07
>> It's a very common feeling. It is. As he grew older, Dennis was able to make a
00:23:11
few friends, but he still chose to spend a lot of his free time alone. When school ended every day, he would go
00:23:16
home, put on his headphones, and just lose himself in music for hours at a time, or he would go into the woods and
00:23:22
just go on long walks. Uh when he was 14, he joined Army Cadet Force, a military prep organization for teenage
00:23:29
boys. his participation in the group gave him a structure that he was definitely lacking at home and he gave
00:23:35
him kind of a sense of purpose in a life that was like a little chaotic at times.
00:23:40
>> He said, "I felt proud and useful in my battle dress." And he also tried to tried to become like he tried his hand
00:23:47
at sports basically too, but that didn't really pan out for him. >> Okay. >> So, it seemed like the military stuff
00:23:53
like was the thing that really tickled his fancy. >> Yeah. For the most part, his early life
00:23:58
was that kind of like most boys at the time. But an incident in his mid- teens would definitely disrupt that path of
00:24:05
normaly and provide some pretty serious consequences in his later life. I think >> one afternoon when Dennis was about 14,
00:24:13
a local elderly man from the village went missing and the whole town turned out to look for him. and Dennis and
00:24:20
another boy, Gordon Barry, decided to search down by the river Uji, where they eventually stumbled upon this old man's
00:24:26
body. The local doctor later said that in his confusion, the man had probably wandered out of his house in the middle
00:24:32
of the night and fallen into the river and drowned. >> Oh, that's so sad. >> Nilson said, "He reminded me of my
00:24:38
grandfather, and the images were firmly fixed in my mind. I could never comprehend the reality of death."
00:24:43
>> That's very standby me. >> Yeah. When he was 15, he decided to leave school and join the military. And
00:24:49
in September of 1961, he reported to London for duty. It was, he hoped, an opportunity for a fresh start to like
00:24:56
get away from this tiny village and all the limitations he felt were there and to learn a new trade that hopefully was
00:25:02
just going to carry him to adulthood. But if he was looking for like a whole new experience, which he definitely was,
00:25:09
he was definitely disappointed with the reality of army life, especially for someone so young.
00:25:14
>> Yeah. Rather than being sent off to some exotic location like he thought he would
00:25:18
be, Dennis and his peers spent the next four years stationed in Aldershot, a military town in Hampshire, New England.
00:25:24
So >> their life was pretty much the same as it had been when he before he left home
00:25:30
with military responsibilities, just replacing school work. Yeah. >> And his fellow soldiers replacing his
00:25:35
classmates. >> In 1964, he passed his exams and was promoted to the rank of private. um
00:25:41
which was an important step in what he thought was going to be a lifelong career in the military. And while this
00:25:47
was a momentous occasion for him, his entire experience in the military had been undermined by his growing awareness
00:25:53
of his own sexuality and his grow his his interest in men. >> Sure. >> Especially at the time period this this
00:26:00
was tough. >> Yeah. Not accepted and especially in the military back then. >> He was repressing everything though and
00:26:05
the repression and of those urges was always accompanied by like deep guilt and shame. Yeah.
00:26:11
>> Um, and he would carry that with him for a long time. He later said, "I was always afraid that I must somehow look
00:26:17
different and that my innermost thoughts would be exposed." >> Oh, that's sad. >> Which is so sad.
00:26:21
>> It is very sad. >> But he's such an [ __ ] Like it's that's it's like you see you hear these
00:26:26
things. And again, this was he's still a kid when this was. >> So you feel bad for like you said, feel
00:26:30
bad for the kid. >> And [snorts] as is often the case, Dennis was only able to conceal this for
00:26:35
so long. And in his mid20s, he was engaging in a lot of like, you know, one night stands with with men, just like
00:26:42
quick anonymous sexual encounters. >> It's like you're I mean, you're living your life and you're you have to
00:26:47
>> people have needs. You can't just deny yourself forever. >> And he was he made sure they were devoid
00:26:51
of a lot of emotion or attachment because that was kind of his life up until that moment.
00:26:56
>> So common, too. >> And this is this works for some people, of course, but for Dennis, it was
00:27:01
different. He'd always been a loner and he had created this rich fantasy life in
00:27:06
which the needs and wants of others were irrelevant. >> His were the important ones.
00:27:10
>> Okay. >> Now, as an adult, it was as though he was blurring fantasy and reality,
00:27:15
treating the real people he came in contact with who came and went in his life as though they were dolls that he
00:27:21
could just act out life on. >> And that's frankly disturbing. >> And then he could just put them away
00:27:27
when he was done. >> And life does not work like that. Oh, in the fall of 1972, his career in the
00:27:33
military came to an end when he was discharged after 11 years. >> Wow. >> Uh the following day, he turned 27 years
00:27:40
old and found himself right back where he started. >> That's crazy. Like almost all of your
00:27:44
20s just gone and then you're asked to start a new life or expected to. >> Yeah. Now he was living in his mother's
00:27:50
house, unemployed, and alone again. His decision to leave the military was pretty simple. He just wanted to try a
00:27:56
career outside the army. >> Yeah. But now that he was out, he kind of felt like unmed, like, "Where do I
00:28:01
go?" >> I That happened so often. >> Yeah. For 5 weeks, he sat in his mother's house wondering what the [ __ ]
00:28:06
to do with his life. And his mother, on the other hand, was more concerned with his lack of interest in finding a wife.
00:28:12
Uh, a short time later, Dennis's brother, Olaf, Olaf Jr. >> told their mother that he suspected
00:28:19
Dennis was gay. >> And this speculation, no. And this speculation, Dennis would never forgive
00:28:25
him for. >> Yeah, I'd be pretty [ __ ] out other people. >> But if she believed it was true,
00:28:31
Dennis's mother never said anything to him about it, preferring instead to just ignore it and let Dennis have his
00:28:37
private thoughts and that was it. >> Also not healthy. >> No. Olaf's speculation about his
00:28:42
brother's sexuality ruined their relationship entirely. It just wasn't something that was able to be recovered.
00:28:48
>> That's really sad. >> It is sad. In December 1972, he moved to London and enrolled at the Metropolitan
00:28:54
Police Training School. Uh he was determined to parlay his pretty exemplary military service into a career
00:29:00
in law enforcement now, which is a pretty like, you know, lateral move. >> Yeah. Uh Dennis completed his training
00:29:06
in April 1973 and entered the Metropolitan Police Force as a junior cadet, which is an entry- level position
00:29:13
that while technically a member of the police force was more like admin [ __ ] >> and required the supervision of a parent
00:29:19
officer. >> So you got to like work your way up the ladder. And when he enrolled in the
00:29:23
training program, he envisioned finding the same level of camaraderie that he loved in the service. Like his military
00:29:29
brothers and sisters were like BFFs. >> Yeah. >> But he learned that the police force
00:29:33
wasn't built around friendships. >> And he found himself lonely and isolated again.
00:29:39
>> Throughout his youth, he had dealt with frequent isolation and loneliness by retreating into his fantasy world. And
00:29:45
in his efforts to avoid loneliness, he started exploring, you know, the countless pubs and nightclubs around
00:29:51
London, uh, where he eventually discovered that, you know, that the culture that he could exist in as he
00:29:57
was, like the gay culture, right? >> And in the small number of gay bars around the city, he kind of felt like he
00:30:03
had found somewhere. >> Uh, for the first time in his life, he didn't have to hide who he really was
00:30:08
from the world. But his unrealistic expectations made his early experiences with this community deeply
00:30:14
disappointing, >> right? >> He wasn't finding a lot of long-term relationship prospects here
00:30:19
>> because he wasn't really looking for that or treating people that way. >> Well, it's like he kind he like wanted
00:30:23
it, but he wasn't treating people that way. So, it's like he wanted that. He just wasn't he didn't seem to know how
00:30:29
to go about it. >> Yeah. Um, and for a man with such a deep and powerful fear of abandonment, the
00:30:34
casual like culture of like hookups and one night stands that he was involving himself in now, especially in the early
00:30:41
'7s. Do >> some damage, >> that was like the thing, it proved very destabilizing and demoralizing for him.
00:30:47
>> Yeah. >> Uh, he wrote in his memoir, "I was left with an endless search through the soul
00:30:51
destroying pub scene and its resulting one night stands. A house is not a home and sex is not a relationship. We would
00:30:57
only lend each other our bodies in a vain search for inner peace. >> Wow. >> I don't know. It's like he comes off
00:31:03
[laughter] so like so like uh deep. >> Yeah. Now, during his first year with the police force, he was developing um
00:31:11
like an identity and a philosophy that was very much at odds with his professional life. Throughout his time
00:31:17
in the military, he had developed a pretty progressive leftist worldview that made it pretty impossible to ignore
00:31:24
the per imperialistic nature of the British military. Oh, >> okay. >> That was at least partially what
00:31:29
motivated him to not seek a second term in the army. He was like, I just don't think it it doesn't align with my
00:31:34
beliefs. >> Now, as a young police officer, he was kind of in the same position, enforcing
00:31:39
laws that seemed outdated and targeting groups that he himself was a part of. >> Right. To make matters worse, in August
00:31:45
1974, he received word that his father, Olaf, Senior, had died at the UK military base in Ghana. He had left his
00:31:52
children a bit of money, but that was it. Given how disillusioned he was with his circumstances, he waited until the
00:31:58
end of the year, and in December, he quit his position with the police force. >> Okay.
00:32:03
>> Now, leaving the police force at the end of the year was intended to be a big
00:32:07
life change that would set him on the right path. Unfortunately, it turned out to be just another exercise in
00:32:13
disappointment. When the f when the money his father left him started to run out, he was forced to go out and find
00:32:19
whatever job he could, which at the time was not really easy. He ended up working
00:32:24
a series of pretty unfulfilling jobs. You know, he worked at a job center. He just did things that like he were not
00:32:30
his passion at all. >> Yeah. >> It was there that Nilson would have another powerful experience that in
00:32:36
retrospect would have sinister undertones. Oh, >> while working at the job center in 1975,
00:32:43
Dennis met a young man named David Painter, who came in looking for work. During his visit, Painter mentioned he
00:32:49
was currently out of work and without a place to stay. At the time, there were no jobs for the young man, so he left
00:32:54
without anything. A few days later, however, Dennis ran into Painter on the street by chance.
00:33:00
>> And knowing his circumstances, he invited David Painter back to his apartment. What Dennis didn't know at
00:33:06
the time was that David was only 17 years old and had run away from home and was reported missing by his parents.
00:33:13
>> Oh, [ __ ] >> When they got to Nelson's apartment, the two watched a movie, had several drinks,
00:33:18
and then Painter be became tired, and went to Nelson's bed to lay down. >> Mhm. >> Misreading that situation, Dennis
00:33:26
followed and tried to engage in sex with David Painter. Mhm. >> Uh so he David immediately rejected him
00:33:33
and was like, "Nope, that's not what I was doing." >> Yeah. >> And eventually Nelson gave up. And a few
00:33:38
hours later, >> the eventually >> Yeah. Uh exactly. Very telling. >> A few hours later, Painter awoke to find
00:33:45
Dennis standing over him with a video camera filming him while he slept. >> What the [ __ ]
00:33:50
>> The details that of what happened next are pretty murky but and like kind of confusing. But when he woke to the
00:33:57
camera in his face, he was clearly naturally very frightened and upset >> and tried to leave the apartment.
00:34:03
>> And Nilson tried to stop him, but David apparently, according to uh Nilson, became aggressive and began trashing the
00:34:11
apartment, >> which I think he was probably fighting to get out of the apartment.
00:34:15
>> Yeah. >> He cut his himself on a glass partition in the process. >> Oh, wow. >> It was only then that Dennis finally
00:34:21
called the police in an ambulance. >> Okay. when he was interviewed by police at the same station, by the way, that
00:34:27
he'd worked as an officer. >> Later that afternoon, he feigned ignorance, claiming that the young man,
00:34:32
quote, went berserk for no clear reason. >> That usually happens, >> although it seems highly unlikely that
00:34:39
nothing happened in Dennis's apartment. David Painter's parents were reluctant to press charges, and the police were
00:34:45
satisfied that if nothing else, Painter hadn't been sexually assaulted. So the whole thing ended that afternoon with
00:34:51
Dennis being let off with a warning. >> You have to wonder if he was sexually assaulted.
00:34:56
>> And I wonder if his parents didn't want to press charges cuz they just didn't
00:34:59
want him involved in what they assumed was >> something unourred. Yeah. >> You know,
00:35:05
>> now obviously most people don't end up going home with someone who ends up being a prolific serial killer.
00:35:11
>> No. >> Luckily, >> thankfully. Um, and in the context of Dennis Nilson's life and later murderous
00:35:17
activities, that incident, even though it wasn't viewed as bad enough, quote unquote, to press charges at the time,
00:35:23
it can be viewed as a like precontemplative phase. >> Yeah, for sure. >> Where he's beginning to explore these
00:35:29
darker fantasies and considering whether or not to act on them. Yeah, definitely.
00:35:33
>> This was clearly an escalation, a slight one. >> Uhhuh. Now, while there's evidence to
00:35:39
indicate Nilson was at least considering his predatory impulses at the time, the
00:35:44
period between 1975 and 1977 was a lot of like personal growth and contentment for him,
00:35:50
>> which is interesting. >> Yeah. After a few years of, you know, one night stands and hookups and casual
00:35:55
sex, Dennis met David Galachan in November 1975, and by the end of their first night drinking together at the
00:36:03
bar, he and David agreed to move in together. >> Wow. very quick. Using what remained of
00:36:08
the money left him by his father, Dennis and David found a small apartment on Melrose Avenue in London. And Dennis
00:36:14
even worked it out so that would have exclusive use of the garden and patio in the back of the house.
00:36:18
>> Nice. Oh no. Hate that actually. >> Yeah, it's not great. Dennis had finally found someone with who he could spend
00:36:25
his nights. >> Not long after moving in together, they got a dog, a black and white mut they
00:36:30
named Bleep. >> Bleep. [laughter] >> Yes. >> Stop. >> That's actually hilarious. I don't want
00:36:35
them to have a dog. >> And they spent their days working on the garden and their nights watching films
00:36:39
and listening to music. >> Oh, I hate how lovely this is. >> Yeah, it seemed at least to Dennis as
00:36:45
though he'd finally locked into a stable relationship. >> Okay. >> Things though, they might have only been
00:36:51
in his head that it was like that. >> What? >> According to author Brian Masters,
00:36:55
quote, "The relationship was nonetheless fragile because it was relentlessly artificial." Oh. as he'd done with
00:37:02
several other men before for much shorter period of times. Dennis had built up this relationship with David
00:37:08
into something it almost certainly was not. Um although it was true they did share an apartment and occasionally they
00:37:14
slept together. According to Masters, quote, "There was no deep bond of affection between them and David was
00:37:20
remote and uninterested." >> Did they get a dog named Bleep? >> They did. >> Oh.
00:37:25
>> In truth, David and Dennis's relationship was one of convenience. Dennis paid most of the bills and made
00:37:31
all the decisions and David continued carrying on other relationships with other people.
00:37:35
>> Oh no. >> That the relationship lasted two years. It was due in large part to the fact
00:37:40
that David had such a passive personality that he was willing to go along with whatever Dennis wanted most
00:37:45
of the time. It was just kind of like whatever. It was more like roommates >> with benefits a little bit.
00:37:51
>> That's rough. >> But Dennis saw it as like >> this beautiful domestic life. Despite
00:37:57
this, not a lot of relationships can last without 100% effort and commitment. Yeah. Um, and it wasn't just that David
00:38:04
contributed far less to the household than Dennis or that he continued to see other men. There was also the fact that
00:38:10
the two shared very little in common. >> And according to Dennis, David was quote, according to Dennis, David was
00:38:16
quote, inferior intellectually and dependent socially. >> That's rude. >> Yeah. By the summer of 1977, both men
00:38:24
had begun seeing other people and barely spoke to each other when they were at home.
00:38:27
>> Oh wow. >> Finally, in late summer, it had become clear that this was coming to an end.
00:38:31
>> Yeah. >> According to David, he simply packed up his bags one night and left in search of
00:38:36
somewhere new. >> Said, "Peace out." >> In his version of events, Dennis says that he insisted that David move out.
00:38:42
It's unclear which one of these is accurate, but because of Dennis's really deep fears of abandonment and his
00:38:49
propensity for fantasy and embellishment, it's entirely possible that he created his complete own
00:38:54
narrative just to protect himself from the psychological pain of this whole thing.
00:38:58
>> Yeah. Damn, this is [ __ ] tragic. >> In the months that followed this, Dennis
00:39:02
filled most of his time with work, working his regular job at the employment center and picking up shifts
00:39:08
with a catering company. And when he wasn't working, he could be found at one of the local pubs. But if he hoped
00:39:13
either of these things were going to improve his life, he quickly learned otherwise. The bars were still full of
00:39:18
people who seemed pretty uninterested in having a relationship with him. And at both jobs, his employers frowned upon
00:39:24
his politics and, you know, life in general. Yeah. >> And as a result, he was just let down by
00:39:30
everything. Feeling aimless, he applied to the branch chairman school in the fall of 1978, and he felt very at home
00:39:37
there in the intellectual and political circles of academia. At 33 years old, he
00:39:42
was somewhat older than the other students, but his passion for intellectual subjects and politics made
00:39:48
him fit right in. The new environment of school was exciting, but it did little to curb his loneliness. He was still
00:39:54
cripplingly lonely. >> Yeah. During this time, Dennis had many one night stands, but every time he met
00:40:02
someone that he even had a little bit of interest in like a long-term relationship with, they just rebuffed
00:40:08
him. >> Oh, that's >> just wasn't working out. >> He was clearly offputting. >> I was going to say clearly [laughter]
00:40:14
>> you got to there's got to be something up there. >> These disappointments caused Dennis to
00:40:18
retreat deeper into his fantasies each time. >> Yeah. >> Which by then had grown very dark. Well,
00:40:25
you have to wonder, and this is obviously just speculative, but he becomes a necrophiliac and a serial
00:40:31
killer. >> I do wonder if some of these one night stands the there had to have been some
00:40:36
off-putting sexual tendencies or something like that. >> For sure. >> For for there to not be repeat nights,
00:40:42
you know? >> Exactly. Yeah. >> And >> and of course that's speculative, but >> but it kind of makes sense. And
00:40:48
>> Dennis had a like fetish for deaths. >> Yeah. like he was very interested in it.
00:40:55
>> That could make sex weird. >> It could for sure. >> But by this time, he had stopped
00:40:59
resisting this and he started indulging it. >> Okay. >> He said later, "I put tulk on my face to
00:41:06
erase the living color. I smeared charcoal under my eyes to accentuate a hollow dark look. I lie staring eyed on
00:41:13
the bed in front of the mirror and let my saliva foam and drip from my mouth. I step outside myself in detached
00:41:20
imagination." That might be the darkest [ __ ] you've ever said to me. >> Yeah. >> What the actual [ __ ]
00:41:30
>> That's like some [ __ ] out of a horror movie. >> And he would just do this >> a lot. That wasn't just a one time
00:41:36
thing. >> No, >> even a one-time thing I cannot get past. >> And fantasy wasn't the only place that
00:41:42
he was starting to experiment with like risky and like interesting behavior. He'd also started creating dangerous
00:41:49
situations where he could rescue his sexual partners from danger. >> Oh, which is very interesting because
00:41:55
that's how his father and mother got together, >> right? >> Yeah. >> One night in late fall 1978, after
00:42:02
inviting three men back to his house for a drink. >> Damn, >> I know. >> [ __ ] sharpshooter there.
00:42:07
>> Yeah, he's he's hedging his bets, I guess. Dennis waited until all three had passed out before placing his winter
00:42:14
jacket on the stove and setting it on fire. After he gathered up his dog and went out into the garden, the apartment
00:42:22
filled up with smoke. When the men woke up, Dennis burst back into the apartment, putting out the small fire
00:42:28
and opening all the windows, appearing to have saved their lives. >> What the [ __ ]
00:42:32
>> Yeah. >> Almost like, damn. You're going to risk your apartment just to be a hero?
00:42:37
>> Just to be a hero? That's a complex and a half. >> And in retrospect, these dark fantasies
00:42:42
and risky behaviors would be seen as clear indicators that Nelson was spiraling deeper into something bad
00:42:48
>> big time. >> He later said, "I was becoming depressed and conditioned to a belief that I was
00:42:52
impossible to live with." But rather than seek any kind of medical or psychological help, he found a new way
00:42:58
to cope with his stress anxiet anxiety while also indulging his fantasies. I >> feel like it's probably not good. By the
00:43:04
end of December, his isolation and loneliness had become unbearable. And on the night of December 30th, he mustered
00:43:10
the energy to get dressed and headed out to a local pub. After spending weeks alone in his apartment, feeling sorry
00:43:16
for himself, he was very vulnerable and precarious emotionally. >> Uhhuh. >> And just in general,
00:43:23
>> and he was also desperate to find someone to just stop the negative thoughts that were running through his
00:43:27
head. And on top of that, he was certain that anyone that he met that night was just going to leave him.
00:43:32
>> Yeah. like he just didn't want people to leave him. That's all. It's very um Jeffrey Dmered.
00:43:38
>> And he later said that night things began to go terribly and horribly wrong. >> I think they had already started.
00:43:44
>> They certainly did. Rather than visit one of his usual bars, he went to a different one. He went to Crinklewood,
00:43:49
the Criclewood Arms, which was an Irish bar near his apartment. He sat there and
00:43:54
he drank pint after pint of Guinness >> and he spent the first hour. I know. I love Guinness. Uh Dennis spent the first
00:44:01
hour or so of the night watching people in the bar, just kind of like chatting with whoever sat down next to him, but
00:44:06
not really making any attempt for big conversation. Eventually, he found himself talking with a young Irishman
00:44:12
who introduced himself as Steven. >> Years later, Nelson would tell police police he had quote no idea who this
00:44:18
youth was. >> As this really is very Jeffrey Tom. >> Yeah. As Steven had no identification on
00:44:25
him at the time or anything to indicate who he was or where he'd come from. That
00:44:29
said, he wouldn't have needed a driver's license or some other ID to tell that who he was talking to was still very
00:44:35
much a teenager. >> He looked it. >> E. >> Uh, he was Steven Holmes, a 14-year-old
00:44:41
runaway from Kilburn. >> Oh, god. A baby. >> Yeah. >> Steven had been out at a rockabilly
00:44:46
concert that night and was waiting for a bus outside the Criclewood Arms when he
00:44:50
decided to go inside to get warm. Nelson convinced Steven to come back to his apartment where they spent a few hours
00:44:56
drinking and listening to music until the boy passed he passed out on Nelson's bed. Um though Dennis swore there was no
00:45:03
sexual contact between them. He said quote I snuggled up to him and put my arm around him. Then he pulled the
00:45:09
blanket down and looked at the boy who was undressed. >> Sexual contact. >> He said I remember thinking that because
00:45:16
it was morning he would wake and leave me. >> Oh no. Dennis looked down at the pile of
00:45:21
clothes on the floor beside the bed and spotted his neck tie. He said, "I remember thinking that I wanted him to
00:45:27
stay with me over the new year whether he wanted to or not." >> "Oh, fuck." >> Dennis reached down and picked up the
00:45:33
tie and then he slowly and carefully ran it underneath Steven's neck. He said, "I
00:45:39
quickly straddled him and pulled tight for all I was worth." At that moment, Steven awoke with a jolt, obviously
00:45:46
struggling, and they to they fell to the floor. But Nilson ended up on top of him
00:45:50
again. And unfortunately, Holmes was no match for his very much adult attacker, and with a minute or two, he lost
00:45:56
consciousness again. Aware that he could wake up at any moment now, Nielson went
00:46:01
to the kitchen and filled a bucket with water, he returned to the other room, dragged Steven over to the bucket on the
00:46:08
floor, and held him by his hair, pushing his head under the water and held it there until he couldn't see bubbles
00:46:13
anymore. >> Oh my god. >> Once once Steven was dead, Nelson dragged his body over to a chair and propped him up
00:46:23
in a seat. And then he said, "I just sat there shaking, trying to think clearly about what I had just done."
00:46:30
It was still early in the morning, so everything's quiet, but he knew everybody was going to wake up in a
00:46:36
matter of hours. What am I going to do? So, he spent the next hour or so cleaning up the room where the murder
00:46:42
had occurred. Then, he moved Steven's body to the bathtub, where he carefully washed the entire body before putting it
00:46:48
back in bed. Ew. All the while, he was fully expecting a knock at the door, certain that someone
00:46:56
had traced Steven back to his apartment. When a few days passed and he's kept Steven's body
00:47:03
>> and that no one ever came, Nielson's anxiety eased and he said there appeared
00:47:08
to be no reports in the paper of the missing boy or the usual public anxiety that followed the disappearance of a
00:47:13
child. >> It was only then that it occurred to Dennis that he'd gotten away with it.
00:47:18
>> Yeah, that's not good. With the act of murder now behind him in the natural process of decomposition having set in.
00:47:24
>> Uhhuh. >> Dennis grew disinterested in the body of his former guests and concluded that he
00:47:29
needed to get rid of it. >> His former guest. >> At first, he thought it would be easiest
00:47:33
to disarticulate the limbs and break down the body by boiling it. >> Oh my god. >> So, he went so far as to buy a large
00:47:41
electric carving knife in a stockp for this purpose. But when he got home, it occurred to him that that was going to
00:47:47
be pretty arduous, that task. >> This is so gnarly. >> And he said it would he felt like it
00:47:52
would be beyond his capabilities. And he said it was also unlikely to produce the
00:47:56
desired result that he's looking for. Instead, he pulled up several floorboards in the kitchen of his
00:48:02
apartment and found the space beneath to be pretty big and actually pretty cool in temperature.
00:48:08
Perfect place to put a body. >> Oh. So, after dressing Steven in the clothes that he had come to the
00:48:13
apartment in, Dennis lowered his body into the space under the floor and put the boards back. And now he's got a
00:48:18
makeshift tomb for Steven under his kitchen. >> What the [ __ ] >> A week passed and and Dennis's curiosity
00:48:25
finally got the better of him. >> No. No. Don't you say that to me. >> I wondered if his body had changed at
00:48:31
all or if he had continued to decompose. So he pulled up the boards and removed Steven's body from beneath the floor to
00:48:38
find that to his great surprise very little decomposition had occurred. >> That'd be very cool.
00:48:43
>> It seemed that the conditions under the floor were such that the natural processes of decomp had been stalled.
00:48:50
Seeing the body in that state, and this is a trigger warning, Dennis was excited
00:48:55
by this, and he violated Steven's body multiple times before returning it to the space beneath the floor where it
00:49:02
would stay, being periodically taken out for 8 months. 8 months? Eight months. How [ __ ] cold was it? I don't think
00:49:14
it stayed in great condition. Oh my god. Yeah. Now, in the months after this or the
00:49:23
month after this, >> months. What the [ __ ] brother? >> So, in the month after this, Dennis kept
00:49:29
a pretty low profile. He went to work, occasionally went to the bars, but mostly he stayed at home and and avoided
00:49:35
inviting anyone back to his apartment. >> Gee, I wonder why. >> At times, he said he considered turning
00:49:40
himself in and confessing. >> I doubt it. >> But the thought of spending the rest of
00:49:44
his life in jail was enough to deter him from doing that. Besides, he had no intention of doing anything like that
00:49:49
ever again. So, he said, "You know what? I I [ __ ] up." >> I don't think you can just like live the
00:49:55
rest of your life. >> Yeah. He was like, "You know what? I'm not going to do it again."
00:49:59
>> That like once you do that once, I don't think you necessarily stop doing that.
00:50:04
>> So, he continued to live his low-key life for several months until the secret
00:50:08
under his floorboards became a little too much to bear, at least in his own mind. One night in October 1979, he
00:50:14
pulled up the floorboards in the kitchen and removed the desiccated body of Steven from the hiding space and carried
00:50:20
it out to the back garden under the cover of darkness. There he had built a small bonfire and he placed Steven
00:50:26
Holmes's body into the bonfire and stood and watched the flames engulf every part
00:50:32
that it would. >> Oh my god. Once the fire had burned away all it was capable of destroying, he put
00:50:37
the fire out and removed the remaining bone fragments and he buried that in the backyard.
00:50:43
Maybe it was because he'd rid himself of his terrible secret um under the floorboards of the kitchen. Or maybe he
00:50:48
just lost his ability to control his clear impulses here. Whatever the case, within a month of destroying Steven
00:50:55
Holmes's remains, Dennis seemed to have forgotten his promise to himself about not committing another violent act. had
00:51:02
a feeling. Had a feeling and we're going to end there for part one. >> That's probably good. Part two is going
00:51:07
to be rough. >> All right. >> Um, this was rough, obviously, but >> horrific. >> It's going to be rough.
00:51:15
>> Why is he called the kindly killer? >> Um, >> do we do we get into that? >> We will get into that. Yeah.
00:51:21
>> Interesting. >> Yeah, cuz nothing about this so far is kindly No. >> All right. What's your fun fact for me,
00:51:27
Boyd? One in 18 people have a third nipple. >> Wow. >> It's called polythelia and it's caused by a mutation in
00:51:36
inactive genes. >> How many one in 18? >> One in 18. That's a lot. >> A lot of people.
00:51:41
>> Yeah. >> What you guys doing out here with your third nipple? >> Right. What you What you doing out here?
00:51:46
>> Damn. Is it easy to have a nipple removed? I wonder. >> I don't know. Like I wonder if you have
00:51:51
a third nipple if you can just get it removed. >> I don't know. Do you have a third
00:51:56
nipple? Everybody let us know. I don't, you know, let us know. I don't, but I would love to hear.
00:52:01
>> Think about like like dinner parties or like at a wedding probably like two people there have a third nipple.
00:52:07
>> I didn't know where you were going with that. And for a second I thought you were being like imagine at a dinner
00:52:11
party you just like have a third nipple. Like I [laughter] was like what? No, I meant Imagine I was think I was saying
00:52:16
like large gathering like wow like >> couple of these people have a third nipple
00:52:21
>> potentially. Yeah. One in 18 seems nuts. >> That is crazy. >> I don't know about that. I'm saying,
00:52:25
>> but you say it's a fact. >> So, get crazy out here with your third nipple. >> Get crazy.
00:52:32
>> We hope you do. We hope you keep listening >> and we hope you >> keep it weird.
00:52:37
>> Keep it so weird that you tell us if you have a third nipple. I'd like to know is
00:52:41
if you're willing to share. >> It's weird in a cool way. >> Yeah. Rock on with your third nipple.
00:52:44
[laughter] >> With your bad self. >> With your bad. >> With your third nipple self.
00:52:50
[music] >> [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music] [music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 80
    Biggest twist
  • 75
    Most intense

Episode Highlights

  • Dennis's Early Life
    Dennis's childhood was marked by isolation and a lack of parental connection.
    “Dennis became very isolated and withdrawn.”
    @ 18m 44s
    February 05, 2026
  • The Death of Dennis's Grandfather
    Dennis was deeply affected by the death of his grandfather, Andrew.
    “My troubles started there. It blighted my personality permanently.”
    @ 20m 28s
    February 05, 2026
  • Dennis's Struggles with Identity
    Dennis faced challenges with his sexuality while serving in the military.
    “I was always afraid that I must somehow look different.”
    @ 26m 15s
    February 05, 2026
  • Disappointment in Police Work
    Dennis left the police force seeking change but faced further disappointment.
    “Leaving the police force was intended to be a big life change.”
    @ 32m 02s
    February 05, 2026
  • Dennis Nilson's Dark Escalation
    Dennis begins to explore darker fantasies, leading to a tragic incident with a young man.
    “This was clearly an escalation, a slight one.”
    @ 35m 33s
    February 05, 2026
  • The Fragile Relationship
    Dennis's relationship with David is revealed to be more of convenience than affection.
    “The relationship was nonetheless fragile because it was relentlessly artificial.”
    @ 36m 55s
    February 05, 2026
  • The First Murder
    Dennis commits his first murder, leading to a chilling realization of getting away with it.
    “It was only then that it occurred to Dennis that he'd gotten away with it.”
    @ 47m 16s
    February 05, 2026
  • The Third Nipple Fact
    Did you know one in 18 people have a third nipple? That's a lot of people!
    “One in 18 people have a third nipple.”
    @ 51m 31s
    February 05, 2026
  • Embrace Your Uniqueness
    The hosts encourage listeners to keep it weird and share their unique traits.
    “Keep it weird.”
    @ 52m 34s
    February 05, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • A house is not a home and sex is not a relationship.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)
  • You have to wonder if he was sexually assaulted.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)
  • I put tulk on my face to erase the living color.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)
  • I just sat there shaking, trying to think clearly about what I had just done.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)
  • One in 18 people have a third nipple.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)
  • Keep it weird.
    Episode 754: Dennis Nilsen - The Kindly Killer (Part 1)

Key Moments

  • Whirlwind Romance17:03
  • Grandfather's Death19:56
  • Isolation and Loneliness20:51
  • Meeting David Painter32:43
  • Aggression Escalates34:09
  • Dark Fantasies41:01
  • First Murder45:41
  • Celebrate Uniqueness52:43

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown