What is a Blockchain in Cryptocurrency?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton’s Kevin Werbach discusses the future of blockchain, emphasizing the need for clear regulations to address risks and protect investors. He also explores how time is essential for blockchain to evolve beyond crypto and reshape global finance.
PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.
Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Brief Summary
Kevin Werbach discusses blockchain technology, cryptocurrency regulation, and the future of digital assets in this episode of The Ripple Effect.
Key points
- The Ripple Effect Podcast Introduction. Join host Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton faculty.
- Understanding Blockchain's Impact. Kevin Werbach discusses the current state and future potential of blockchain technology.
- The Need for Regulation. Exploring the necessity of regulation in the evolving landscape of digital assets.
Episode highlights
- Understanding Blockchain's ImpactKevin Werbach discusses the current state and future potential of blockchain technology.“Blockchain technology has been around since 2008, and we still don’t know who Satoshi Nakamoto is.”1:27Jan 21, 2025
- The Need for RegulationExploring the necessity of regulation in the evolving landscape of digital assets.“Every time there has been a major, unregulated financial instrument, there have been abuses and fraud.”7:22Jan 21, 2025
Transcript
Werbach: So if we're talking about the blockchain technology, if you are going to your Robin Hood account and you're deciding whether to buy Bitcoin or to buy some meme stock, it's just another name, and you can think about it as an investment. But that's not fundamentally revolutionary. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. Well, the conversations around cryptocurrency are surging right
now, and the path of what might happen with crypto investing and regulation in the next several years has turned many investors thoughts to be very robust. But there is also other areas to focus on when you're talking about cryptocurrency, and that is blockchain, the tool that makes a lot of these digital assets and digital payments possible. Pleasure to be joined here in the studio today by Kevin Werbach, who's a Professor of Legal Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. He's also Chair of the Legal Studies and Business Ethics Department. Great to see you again. It's been a while to do this face to face. Always great to talk to you, Dan. - Thank you. You've done a lot of research and work in and around
blockchain. Where do you think we stand right now with its understanding, its adoption, its kind of place in the overall business landscape? Blockchain technology has been around since 2008, when Satoshi Nakamoto— and we still don't know who that is or was— issued a white paper developing the idea of Bitcoin. And Bitcoin's a cryptocurrency. It's a form of digital asset, but it rides on this ledger technology called blockchain. And blockchain is actually much more general in terms of its applications, as you mentioned. So we're something like 16 years in to blockchain technology being widely available. It was actually built on even earlier foundations. And the question is
whether that's a long time or a short time. We see a great deal of interest. We see lots of experimentation. We see certainly lots of trading activity around digital assets. We see building of distributed platforms on the vision of Web3, a kind of distributed internet powered by tokens. We also see use of blockchain in payments, and we see companies using it as a record-keeping technology for understanding information as it flows across their networks and between companies. We don't yet see any real scaled use cases that are not predominantly powered by financial investment type incentives. And so that's really the question of how far along we are. How do you think, then, we kind of take it from where it is now to
get to that point where there is more of a larger scale use of blockchain? It's not clear exactly what blockchain is going to be best for. When I— when I talk about this—and as you said, I've been studying this for a decade at least— I always say there are these different application categories, these different use cases. And it may be the case that the significant use case is just as a— an investment asset, and that's really the one that has the most heft around it in terms of the activity. Or it may be the case that when we look back 20 or 30 or 50 years from now, we say, "This is the new rails, the underlying technology that powers the financial system as it evolved in the next stage." Or we might say something else. I don't think we should assume
that we know the answer to that. We should think about looking at applications and use cases as they develop. And then if it actually is a better technology, if it really has advantages, then it will ultimately succeed in the market. What's interesting is that as we try and find out more about what it can do and how it can help, it's really— it feels like it's kind of up and down the spectrum in terms of who is trying to figure this out. You have conversations about this going on with the Federal Reserve. Commentary by Chair Powell. You have so many different companies in different sectors that are kind of wondering, is it something that works with how they run their operation? It truly is, it still feels like it's very much a
learning process right now. Yeah, I think people don't realize how foundational a change this technology represents, if we're talking about the blockchain technology. If you are going to your Robin Hood account and you're deciding whether to buy Bitcoin or to buy some meme stock, it's just another name, and you can think about it as an investment. But that's not fundamentally revolutionary. The technology, though, really is. It's a decentralized ledger technology that provides trust without any central entity that is the administrator that everyone relies on. And that's incredibly powerful, and that's— has implications for all sorts of use cases. It has really significant implications for
finance in many ways. So that's why we have all these conversations. Unfortunately, though, it always tends to get pulled back or influenced by this conversation about the speculative investments. And again, there's nothing wrong with an interesting new investment asset class, but that's really the piece that everyone gets fixated on. But then when you look at what's happening out there, we see really interesting growth of some of these other use cases as well. Does the up and down nature of things like cryptocurrency have an impact on the mindset around the potential use of blockchain? Oh, absolutely. And again, that's what I'm talking about, that people assume that it's inherent to blockchain that it is highly
volatile, and all about crazy, wild speculation. And also, we should mention fraud, scams, illicit activity. We saw the collapse of FTX. Celsius, another company that collapsed in fraud. The CEO just plead guilty to criminal charges. So all of that gets wrapped up into this. But when you actually talk about the ledger technology, it doesn't necessarily have that attribute. So for example, one of the major applications of blockchain technology in finance is to create what are called stable coins, and these are digital assets that are typically pegged to the US dollar or to some other stable reference point. They're not volatile at all. Now they potentially could be risky if the assets that are backing them are not truly
stable, or they don't actually have the assets they claim to. So there's certain important regulatory issues. But those— those really aren't at all about volatility. So I think it is important to differentiate it out when we're talking about something that's purely investment versus something else. So you mentioned regulatory, and that's obviously another area where you focus. And there's a lot of conversation right now around digital assets in general. We're going into a time of switching administrations in the White House, and the belief is that maybe we're going to see a shift in terms of mindset. When you think about regulation and all of these components around digital assets, where should we potentially land, do you
think, at some at some point? - Well, one starting point is that you look at history. Every time there has been a major, unregulated, new kind of financial instrument that is accessible to lots of people, there have been horrible abuses and fraud and crimes. Now that doesn't mean that those financial innovations were bad or should have been or were prohibited, but that's why we need regulation. That's why we had the birth of things like the Securities and Exchange Commission coming out of the Great Depression, where there was horrible abuse and fraud in financial markets. We see that with digital assets. We see that with crypto, which doesn't mean that it should be prohibited. Unfortunately, what happened was
that the Biden administration was actually on its way to what I think was a really thoughtful and sensible approach to coming up with what it called responsible digital asset regulation. So, you know, we want to allow this technology to exist and promote the innovation, but ensure that there were the same appropriate kinds of checks. If you, again, go to your Robin Hood account and you're investing in a digital asset, you have the same kind of confidence that you're getting accurate information and the information you need, and the person on the other side is not trying to scam you, as if you're buying an equity that's traded on the New York Stock Exchange. That makes
sense. What happened was, in the interim, we had the explosion of the crypto bubble and the collapse of things like FTX, which really soured a lot of people in and around the US government at that time in this whole space. They really, I think, over indexed on protecting against any harms happening. Those are true of the banking regulators as well. And unfortunately, didn't differentiate out between the firms that were really shady and questionable, and the ones that were saying, "Tell us how to comply. Tell us how to— we don't understand. It's really hard to map all of the existing rules onto this new technology. We want a path to clarity." They didn't make that distinction, and as a result, you got a
backlash from certain loud, powerful voices in the industry and in the venture community, who eventually seized on Donald Trump as the one who would bring them a new, less regulatory environment for crypto. And they started supporting his campaign. Not the whole industry, but some very powerful figures. And they are now part of the new administration, and will very certainly take this in a very different direction. So then are we, to a degree— should we, with the growth that we have seen in terms of the pricing of things like Bitcoin and Ethereum and some of the other assets in recent months, should we believe that there is an unbelievable strength that's
kind of building up around cryptocurrency, or is it still kind of a wait and see, because there is this influence that's kind of pushing things forward? I don't give investment advice, and especially in this space where, you know, there are so many uncertainties. I think it's really easy to come up with simple explanations. This— this decision happened, and then the price of Bitcoin moved this way. When you actually understand how the Bitcoin market works, actually very highly concentrated, actually fairly illiquid. There has been, historically, lots of evidence of market manipulation, and it's— it's a kind of a meme currency. People are buying in because of their belief about
the potential of the technology. And again, that in and of itself, doesn't mean that it's not an investment that you can make money on. But it's really not a simple answer that this happened yesterday and the price went up or down today. You even look at the crypto market behavior after the Trump victory. Bitcoin went up a lot. A few of the other ones, like XRP, which was associated with this company, Ripple, that had a lawsuit against the SEC and so forth, that went up a great deal. Ethereum, which is the second biggest cryptocurrency, barely budged after Trump's election. Many of the other coins, at least right after the initial time, didn't seem to have a big impact. So look, this is— again, these are investment
assets. There are ways to invest thoughtfully. There are different ways to come up with a— an understandable valuation. And certainly it is affected by— by the vibe, certainly is affected by regulation. But I think people too often just assume that that's a simple equation when it really isn't. Well, and for a while there, there was a conversation about, you know, whether or not we were going to see digital assets used as currency by different countries. And there were attempts to do that. But then you hear, you know, the commentary from Chair Powell about, it should be more tied to gold than it should be traditional currencies. And so are we past the point, do you think, of— of believing that it's
something other than really an investment of a, you know, of that type of nature? That's different. That's what are called Central Bank digital currencies, or CBDCs. So going back to what I said before, blockchain is the underlying technology. You can use it to issue these tokens which are not really backed by anything, and are volatile, and essentially are investment assets— or they're used for payments. Bitcoin itself, the whole idea is that it's a store of value, independent of governments, and it's a new kinds of mean of— means of payment. Or you can think about having them be stable assets, either privately issued stable coins or publicly issued digital
currencies. China has issued a central bank digital currency. It's not— none of these are on exactly the same kind of totally decentralized blockchain technology as assets like Bitcoin and Ether, but they have a similar kind of ledger technology. The European Union is fairly far along in a digital euro. The UK is somewhat far along. They're still skeptical, but trying to come up with the foundation for a digital pound, and the Federal Reserve has done a good deal of research on a digital dollar. But it is true, they have been fairly skeptical that we should implement this. The question is always, really, what problem does it solve? So much of the currency is already digital. - Yeah.
And what problem does it solve that these private stable coins, which create this new decentralized platform are not already solving in the marketplace? Where do you think, then, we head with blockchain and that technology in terms of kind of building the framework so that it becomes, you know, something greater than what it already is right now? One thing is that the technology is maturing. For a while, there were serious issues about scalability. There's been a lot of progress on that. There's been a lot of progress on privacy and other aspects. There is also development in that marketplace, once you get beyond Bitcoin, which is kind of a unique thing. There are questions about different
platforms. Ethereum, which for the longest time has been the second most valuable and the most prominent digital asset for these other kinds of uses of blockchain. There are other platforms like Solana that have certain advantages that seem to be maybe catching up. So there's— there's all of these questions about maturation. But— but I think ultimately, it's just a matter of, first of all, we do need a good, clear regulatory environment so that we can put that to the side and we can address these appropriate concerns, the concerns about investors, the concerns about fraud and crime and sanction violations, very real issues that need to be addressed. And it's not just a matter of deregulating. It's a matter of
actually regulating and having a clear framework, which will almost certainly take legislation to address these issues. We need that first. And then we just need time. Because again, we're talking about here, just to take one of these use cases, use for payments in the financial system. This is re-architecting the pipes of global finance. There are trillions and trillions of dollars at stake here. This is not something that's going to happen overnight. I believe it's going to happen. It's just fundamentally a better technology than the accumulation of things that we have now underlying the financial system. But that's— that's a period of many years to really realize
that potential. Great to see you again, Kevin. - Thanks very much. My pleasure. Kevin Werbach, Professor of Legal Studies and Business Ethics here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.





