The Job Market Outlook for New Graduates in 2025

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In this conversation, Wharton School Professor Matthew Bidwell discusses the current challenges facing recent college graduates entering the workforce. While the broader labor market remains relatively strong, Bidwell notes that unemployment among college graduates has been trending upward for several years, reaching its highest level since 2015.

He explores the reasons behind a stagnating job market—highlighting employer caution, reduced hiring and quitting rates, and overall economic uncertainty. Bidwell also addresses the long-term career implications of accepting lower-quality jobs during economic downturns, the value of early career mobility, and the tradeoffs of remote work for new graduates.

Recorded during the 2024 graduation season, the discussion provides timely insight into employment trends and strategic advice for navigating early career decisions in a cautious hiring environment.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#LaborMarket #EmploymentTrends #WorkplaceTrends #JobMarket ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Brief Summary

Matthew Bidwell discusses the rising unemployment rates for college graduates and the cautious hiring trends in today's job market.

Key points

  • Job Market Concerns for Graduates. Matthew Bidwell discusses the challenges college graduates face in the current job market.
  • The Frozen Labor Market. Bidwell explains the current state of hiring and job security for graduates.

Transcript

Dan Loney: Well, we are at the time of college graduation, and so that means an influx of new people into the workforce full time. But with a labor market that's still holding its own, companies are concerned obviously around tariffs and consumer spending in the months ahead. What should graduates expect? Pleasure to be joined by Matthew Bidwell, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School. Hi Matthew, great talk again. Matthew Bidwell: Hi Dan, nice to see you again. - So I guess we're at a point round with these graduations occurring, many graduates may already have a job, so they're fairly set. For those that are still searching, what's the landscape look like?

- I'm sorry to say it's not great. There are, I think, slightly weird things going on in the market for college graduates. And so, you're right, when you look at the labor market overall, unemployment is not that far off historic lows. It's still, the labor market overall, people have jobs, but unemployment for college graduates has been trending up for about three or four years now, and it's higher than it's been since about 2015. And so, yeah, it's not catastrophic, but it's not what it has been. I mean, it's not as positive a picture as I would like to paint. - What do you think is driving it? - All sorts of things. I think there's one thing that's fairly

straightforward, one thing that's a bit weirder. The straightforward piece is, as you said, the labor market's kind of good, but there are a lot of headwinds, and so it's a little bit frozen. And so you're seeing this -- what you're seeing is most people have jobs, which is great. There's not a lot of firing going on, also great. But there's not a lot of quitting, and there's not a lot of hiring. And so I think, given all the uncertainty that we're seeing, employers are doing what I think is exactly the right thing, I wish they did more regularly, which is to be slow about firing and slow about hiring. I think they're kind of seeing it's like, you know, to fire people today and then try and rehire them in a few months time is

incredibly expensive, and let's not do that. So they're not letting go of people. But they're also saying, "Because we don't want to have to do that, we're pretty nervous about taking on new people." And so the rates of hiring are much lower than they have been recently, which, you know, again, if like you, like me, you're in a job, that's not a big concern. But if you're a college graduate and you're looking for a job for the first time, you're one of the groups that's really going to be hit there. - So what potentially leads to then shaking loose some of those people, maybe saying, "Look, it's time for me to move. I'm going to go to a new company." Because I think a lot of people feel like they need to have the security right now.

- Yeah, I mean, if you look at why there's not so much quitting going on, I think it's largely related to there's not much hiring going on. So companies are being very cautious. People who are in jobs, that makes it harder for them to move. They're maybe not kind of exiting some of these entry level positions and creating room for college graduates. And so the whole thing is slightly in stasis while everybody tries to figure out what's going to happen next. - How much then, if somebody is able to procure a couple of offers for a new job, in terms of understanding and really researching which is the best option for them, taking the time and thinking about that best option? - They absolutely

should. I mean, there's a tricky dilemma here, which is, you know, when you know the job market is not as good as it has been, certainly you want to search harder, but maybe you want to settle for something that maybe, if you've been looking two years ago, three years ago, you wouldn't have settled for, because kind of that great job may not be out there anymore. On the other hand, kind of the job that you take does have implications for what you learn and where you go to next. And so one of the unfortunate things that we've seen from prior research is that people who graduate in recessions where it's really hard to get a job tend to see these kind of lasting penalty, because you end up being hired into lower paying

jobs, and the experience you're getting is not so good, and so on. So I think, you know, it's you need to balance being realistic with trying hard to get a good job. And I do think to the extent to which people find they end up in jobs that are a little bit disappointing for them, being prepared to move. So, like I say, the labor market is a little frozen at the moment. It could unfreeze, it could get worse. It will not stay frozen forever certainly. And so I anticipate, certainly, two, three years we expect things to be better. And so I think if people do end up in jobs that they find they can't get the right job for them, being prepared to try really hard to move subsequently, and kind of doing what it takes to move up

I think is important to get their career back on track. - Is the expectation then of getting a job offer and having it have some component of remote work, is that going away a little bit, or is that still in the mix a good bit? - It's still in the mix. You know, if you read the news, there's no such thing as remote and hybrid work anymore. You know, I speak to more and more people whose companies are dragging them back in. If you actually look at the survey data and other things, it hasn't changed that much over the last two years. There's a lot of hybrid work, there's a lot of remote work. And I suspect, frankly, for a lot of fresh college graduates, you know, small companies, young companies, they don't want to

pay for offices. I would also say it's a double edged sword for college graduates. And we've talked about this before. I'm a fan of remote hybrid work. It's like, let people work where they want to. But I think if you are a fresh college graduate, there's a lot to be said for being around other people. Partly, it's fun. It's a time in your life you want to be around other people. But particularly, it's easier to learn that way. And so I actually think if I was coming out of college, I would really be putting a premium on experiences where I could actually be in an office around other people and get a better chance to figure out what's going on. - Matthew, always great to talk. Thanks very much. - Good to speak

with you. - Thank you. Matthew Bidwell, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School,

Related episodes