The Economics Behind IRS Audits and Taxpayer Compliance
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton’s Ben Sprung-Keyser discusses recent research on the effectiveness of IRS audits across income levels. The conversation explores audit trends, the Inflation Reduction Act, and the return on IRS spending when targeting high-income taxpayers. Key findings suggest that auditing wealthier individuals yields significantly higher federal revenue, with implications for tax policy and enforcement strategy.
ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
#TaxPolicy #TaxCompliance #PublicPolicy #Economics #IRS ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Well, with the change of administrations in the White House also comes a change in policy path. One area where the
- current administration may have an impact is around the IRS and the number of audits that the agency conducts or doesn't
- conduct. That number, already low, may even go further lower. Ben Sprung-Keyser is an Assistant Professor of Business Economics
- and Public Policy here at the Wharton School, and he has looked deeper into this and joins us right now. Ben,
- pleasure to have you with us today. Thanks for your time. Great to be here. I guess we need to start with where we kind
- of are in the— the level of audits we are seeing, which, as from a historic perspective, has
- been going down over the last few decades. Yeah, Yeah. So that— that's exactly right. I think you can think of sort of
- audit rates as being on a real roller coaster over the last 15 years or so. They hit a high water mark in about 2010 or so,
- fell pretty precipitously in the five years afterward, and declined until around 2020 or so. Then there was— as part of
- the Inflation Reduction Act signed by President Biden, there was a substantial increase in funding allocated to the IRS, in
- part to try to recover audit rates to where they had been previously. And a big topic of conversation right now, of
- course, is whether that will be sort of allowed to proceed, or whether those audit— those new IRS employees, for example, will
- will not end up conducting the audits that they were once expected to conduct. So the research that you were a part of looks at how an audit
- can impact an individual depending on the wealth level that they are at, correct? - Yeah,
- that's right. So— so the question we were thinking about in our work is, what is the return to an IRS audit? So if you think about it,
- the IRS is going to spend sort of one more dollar auditing an individual. How much revenue does the IRS get back? And the
- sort of old adage is clear in this case, that you got to spend money to make money in the context of IRS audits. And the
- thing we were interested in is, well, how does that differ across the income distribution? There's a limited quantity of
- resources that the IRS can think about allocating to think about who might be subject to an audit, which is obviously going
- to be determined based on an assessment of who may not have paid their tax obligations. We know as a sort of pre-
- established fact that those tax— unpaid tax obligations are heavily concentrated at the high end of the income distribution,
- so about 60% of all of the dollars that you might think of as being owed to the federal government but are unpaid
- appear to come from the top 10% of taxpayers. Now, that doesn't necessarily tell you how the IRS should think about sort of
- allocating resources from the perspective of audits, because it may also be, for example, that that money is particularly
- difficult for the IRS to collect. That high-income taxpayers have complicated returns. They have complicated
- business structures, or whatever that may be that may make it difficult for the IRS to collect revenue there. And so the
- question we asked is, well, if the IRS is going to spend money conducting audits, what does it get back from those audits, and
- how does that differ across the income distribution? And obviously that is something that an agency like the— like the
- IRS wants to make sure that they maximize. The dollars that they spend are obviously going in a in an area or a focus that
- can return the most on that investment. So that's exactly right. The consideration— one of the
- considerations for the IRS, of course— or at least, you know, I think a reasonable consideration might be, how do you think about
- the return on your individual dollars here? And so in the context of our research, what we find is that the return on IRS
- spending is higher when auditing high-income taxpayers as compared to low-income taxpayers. And so the estimates
- here, for example, suggest that the IRS may return about $12 for each individual dollar it spends auditing when it focuses on
- taxpayers in the sort of top 10% of the income distribution. That number is sort of less than half when it comes to
- lower-income taxpayers. Does this suggest any potential policy changes that an agency
- like the IRS should probably consider, then, moving forward, in order to be able to maximize the revenues that they— that they
- have from the federal government? So I think— I wouldn't say that our research comes with a specific
- recommendation of doing policy X or policy Y. But the idea, at least our hope, is that it should inform how folks who are
- thinking about constructing those policies might look. So, just to give one example, when it came to the funding under the
- Inflation Reduction Act, there was then clarification that came back from the IRS Commissioner after that was passed,
- suggesting that that revenue would be— or that, the funding would be exclusively used to audit taxpayers above $400,000
- in earnings. And certainly, I think our evidence suggests that that focus on those high-income taxpayers is a good way to think
- about prioritizing where those dollars should be spent. But if we're talking about a time where maybe the IRS is going to
- have a lower number of potential audits, then you're talking about that revenue number having a direct impact down the road as well.
- So that's certainly right. It's certainly the case that, for example, a reduction in IRS spending means a reduction in
- revenue, in this case, as it comes from that. And if that reduction is concentrated amongst high-income taxpayers,
- that may be particularly costly for the IRS when it comes to doing this. Now, this is not to say, by the way, that one should
- generalize these results to say one should do exclusively auditing of taxpayer group X versus group Y. I should note,
- for example, that there are complicated questions regarding, you know, deterrence considerations. So if you knew
- with 100% certainty you were not going to be audited, that might change your calculation about how likely you were to, you
- know, underpay your tax obligations, things of that sort. When the IRS is making its decisions, I suspect it is
- calculating and considering a very wide range of other factors, for example, with that in regard. And similarly, for
- example, the IRS is— I think rightfully so— very focused on only auditing taxpayers who they suspect of unpaid tax liability,
- right? So you wouldn't want to sort of just throw darts at a dartboard when choosing the process of choosing what
- taxpayer to audit, because we also care about the hassle burden imposed by the audit, and we want to try to make sure that
- one minimizes that. - So having done this research, what do you think is the takeaway
- that people should truly understand about the process and maybe what we will see in the future?
- So I think the takeaway here is, I don't know what the future will bring, right? I think the takeaway is that when you think
- about sort of the efficient use of government funds, that, at least from our perspective, we seem to believe that the return
- to auditing higher-income taxpayers is substantially higher than the return to auditing lower-income taxpayers,
- and to reduce that spending is, in fact, a cost government revenue. Right? That it brings in more money than it costs. So
- in the respect of sort of reducing overall deficit, for example, IRS audits can be a quite effective way of doing that. I
- think that's the kind of clear takeaway that comes from the paper. I think the other sort of clear takeaway that comes from
- the work is that one of the reasons why IRS audits can be so effective in generating government revenue is that they
- can change behavior in a sort of consistent and durable way. So one of the things we think about in the paper is if someone is
- faced with an IRS audit in a given year and they're deemed to have unpaid tax liability, how does that change what they pay
- back to the government in the future years? And the evidence seems to suggest that it produces a sort of durable
- effect on those individual taxpayers. Think about it, if you're not allowed to deduct your home office, because it
- turns out it's not a home office, you're probably not going to go ahead and try to do that again in the next year as
- well. And so that's one of the clear things that we see in the results, and it gives an intuition for why it could be so
- cost effective for the IRS to sort of conduct audits of— of those folks that it believes are particularly non-compliant taxpayers.
- And certainly people, once they get audited— audited the first time, they want to try and avoid going down that road a second time.
- I think that's absolutely right. Right— rightfully so. Ben, great to meet you. Thanks very much for your time today.
- Great to be here. Thanks so much. Thank you. Ben Sprung-Keyser, Assistant Professor of Business, Economics and Public Policy here at the
- Wharton School.
Brief Summary
Ben Sprung-Keyser discusses IRS audit rates, their effectiveness, and the impact of the Inflation Reduction Act on high-income taxpayers.
Key points
- Impact of IRS Audits on Revenue. Research shows that auditing high-income taxpayers yields significantly higher returns for the IRS.
- Future of IRS Audits. The discussion raises questions about the future of IRS audits and their effectiveness.
Episode highlights
- Impact of IRS Audits on RevenueResearch shows that auditing high-income taxpayers yields significantly higher returns for the IRS.“The return on IRS spending is higher when auditing high-income taxpayers.”3:33May 30, 2025
- Future of IRS AuditsThe discussion raises questions about the future of IRS audits and their effectiveness.“I don’t know what the future will bring, right?”6:17May 30, 2025





