Everstone's Roopa Purushothaman on India's Coming Urbanization Phase

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Roopa Purushothaman, Head of Research for Everstone Investment Advisors at the 14th Wharton India Economic Forum,on India's Coming Urbanization Phase. 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] Rupa thanks very much for joining us today thanks for having me you were a
  2. co-author on the report dreaming with bricks and I the first question I wanted to ask you is whether or not you feel
  3. that that report has stood the test of time I do it's been seven years actually since we first published it was in late
  4. 2003 and you know for India in particular um the growth rates that we talked about kind of trend over the long
  5. run was 6 and a half% so I think if anything um what we've seen since then is that a lot of people think that
  6. that's probably too conservative um for China it's still sort of yet to be seen because we had sort of high Trend rates
  7. but they fall off pretty dramatically once you get to about 2017 2018 again because of China's demographics Brazil
  8. and Russia are a little bit more so I would say for China and India more than anything even as we've seen the global
  9. sort of downturn happen they've kind of taken up more market share um particularly when you look at things
  10. like Global demand and that was the inspiration for the the peace in the first place it was it wasn't to say
  11. these are four economies look at how they're going to grow it was to say that as Global sort of investors when you
  12. think about market demand um Global demand is going to shift toward these economies Brazil and Russia I think the
  13. projections for Trend growth were relatively um uh um conservative and so I think again they're about 3 and a
  14. half% over the long run and I think we're going to see that they're just going to be a little bit more because
  15. they're the other two China and India are more commodity um takers and the other commodity producers so you're
  16. going to see them particularly now kind of go through sort of different um ups and downs at different times so they're
  17. an interesting sort of basket together but I think the story if anything um the numbers have come out when you look
  18. between then and now more aggressive than we projected um but you're going to just see a lot of for Trend growth over
  19. such long period I think it's obviously we know that each year we're not going to hit it and I think we're going to see
  20. a lot of submerging and and some Sometimes some years where they overshoot but I think it's pretty much
  21. intact we wouldn't change anything and we hadn't right well if you were to if you were to write a new report today are
  22. there any other markets you'd squeeze into that acronym I think there's been lots of
  23. different variations of that acronym thrown around um I don't think so I mean the point of that was really to be
  24. representative and you know the the idea of taking those four markets were really
  25. that they were the four largest developing countries and we really wanted to say if we take big population
  26. economies that are growing relatively fast it's not rocket science but they're going to be able to change the face of
  27. global demand over the long run there's a whole set not really you can't really just go down to largest GDP but if you
  28. look at economies that have um relatively fast growth but big populations as well there's a Nexus of
  29. sort of another group um and Goldman Sachs has actually done a whole piece on um the next 11 so there are a whole set
  30. of other countries that are both large population we sort of ort of see you know things changing in terms of their
  31. reform processes demographics and so on that really kind of push them to be again big changers in terms of their
  32. weights in global demand over the next few decades okay well moving on to uh a more recent project you wrote a report
  33. the next Urban front tier 20 cities to watch in India uh can you tell us uh sort of the top trends you you noted in
  34. that report sure you know I think just as a little bit of background um in the role that I play now I had research for
  35. um for Everstone investment advisers and the research is still very longterm and
  36. it really focuses on demographics um but trying to look beyond the headline demographic numbers and really trying to
  37. see over the long run what structural changes are going to define the economy so um urbanization is one um that we
  38. think is going to be a big theme that everyone has talked about a lot but actually in India urbanization has
  39. played out in a very different way to what we've seen in China um you've actually seen urbanization peak in the
  40. 1970s the pace of urbanization and it's since then fallen off um in India in India so in between 2005 and 2010 we
  41. think we're going to start to see that inflection point sort of change and we're going to see an an increase again
  42. um but what we wanted to say with this uh most recent paper was that it's really the next sort of coming Trend
  43. that when it happens to India it's really going to affect global urbanization patterns we think about on
  44. very conservative estimates about 380 million people are going to be added to India's Urban spaces over the next few
  45. decades so that's more than the entire population of the us sort of moving into uh into urban India so that's going to
  46. be one of the most defining changes that we have yet to see um and even when you
  47. look now at what's happened any growth that we have gotten um in urban spaces it's largely been due to natural
  48. increase so people within cities having kids we haven't seen migration take off um either in the way that it has been
  49. hyped up in the press or in the media or um when you just look at social issues and what's taking place I think there's
  50. a lot of hype around it but we haven't seen it on the ground tap to the degree um that you see it talked about in the
  51. papers and it hasn't taken place to the degree that we've seen in other uh parts
  52. of the region so we have yet to see that happen but that's going to be a a huge change when we did this paper we um
  53. partnered with the National Council of Applied economic research because we really wanted to say you know no one
  54. understands first of all everyone thinks this process is just happening to the country and for policy um either we're
  55. just going to let it happen to us or we're going to try to stop it that's almost been the up till now up till
  56. recently almost been the kind of attitude towards it and we wanted to say look this is a process that is going to
  57. happen um could be hugely beneficial to the economy in terms of providing an outlet for semiskilled labor um to be
  58. able to find pockets of employment but we need to understand how the process is actually occurring on the ground so we
  59. try to take the survey that NC does which basically looks at income expenditure patterns across India um and
  60. and try to look at the top 20 cities to see how these things evolve and you really get quite interesting patterns
  61. you know for India anytime you talk about averages um it's really masking these huge swings so averages mean very
  62. little um so when you look at anything uh from uh the percentage that households spend uh of their income just
  63. on on average uh spending it goes from you know houses in Mumbai and alabad spending about half of their income um
  64. every year all the way up to if you go to a BAL and a jaland jolander they spend 75% of their income so you get
  65. very big changes which has implications not necessarily income that matters but it's almost um you know different sort
  66. of uh uh spending behaviors as you go across geographies that really determine um what's happening so there might be
  67. these smaller cities um might not be as big as the 5 million plus cities might be a million or or or just under um and
  68. they don't have income levels that are as high as the biggest cities but they just spend a lot more so what you're
  69. seeing is that in some small towns consumer spending patterns are actually evolving more quickly so there are some
  70. deeper markets for certain areas um you know well I think a lot of it has to do with
  71. you know India is not by any means a homogeneous Market it's a bunch of heterogeneous markets that have a lot to
  72. do with um cultural patterns um with regards to spending so it's not just as your income Rises you instantly see
  73. Evolution towards certain things is there an explosion of credit for example that's happening again it you know what
  74. you've seen for credit is that um there's probably a lot more penetration than people um expect in tier 2 cities
  75. so the cities I was just talking about were tier three tier two which again are big demographics probably just under
  76. between one million and five million um and uh and they're kind of the next big pocket for sectors that are kind of
  77. geared towards demographic so food apparel financial services so these guys actually are pretty um some of them it's
  78. very idiosyncratic but you'll get some tier tier 2 cities that are very well penetrated some tier one cities so these
  79. 5 million plus cities that we always talk about um that actually aren't that there's still a lot of legs to go for
  80. the financial sort of penetration story to play out particular particularly with
  81. respect to credit so you get some of these when you look at the highest penetration they'll be these tier 2
  82. cities that are the highest so again it's very it you can't really go by large sads to to pick out where you're
  83. you know what city you're going to to penetrate you really need to look individually because there are a lot of
  84. idiosyncratic patterns what would you say are the are the biggest changes you've seen in consumer
  85. Behavior you know I think um again when you go back to the demographics that are
  86. driving things you basically what we see for India before I get to the demographics is that we're at when you
  87. look at India relative to the rest of the bricks we're at about um you know just over $1,000 per head so we're less
  88. than half of the next highest brick which is China so what our consumer spending profiles look very different
  89. even if we're in the same bracket of the bricks we're at this point where we're just entering sort of this sweet spot
  90. when you get to about $1,500 per head um to $3,000 per head where you get um um for an increase in income you start to
  91. get a rapid sort of increase in absorption of basic consumer durable so we're still getting to that point where
  92. you start to see from televisions um you know cars and so on that big sort of s-shaped curve we're just at the
  93. beginning of it so you have that happening across the economy I think but um there are also things that are
  94. structurally changing that once they happen they don't you know you can't reverse them um and one big thing is
  95. women are going to work and I think as that happens we've started to see um between 2000 and 2005
  96. um when you cut employment patterns by geography by age you don't see any changes the only big change you see is
  97. that there's been a rise in in the participation rate of women and that's big because when you go as far back in
  98. the data back to the 1980s as we have it participation rates have been low and they've been falling so this is the
  99. first time that we see a rise and it's a pretty significant rise and that has really influenced um at least in urban
  100. India um because that's largely where we see the wage and and salary employment take place um that's kind of
  101. um sparked a big shift in terms of how people consume so you see where households where women have started
  102. going to work a big increase in financial services any spending on children whether it's clothes toys
  103. education that's a huge Rise um Personal Care uh and and things like Transportation so I think there are
  104. certain trends that are happening that again are pretty longterm and that has held the country pretty well throughout
  105. the the last sort of downturn that we've seen and are savings down would you say
  106. now no savings actually have veren yeah household savings ofen so again I think we have a lot of we have a lot of um
  107. sort of propellers I think for uh for the economy to go forward particularly with respect to again when you look at
  108. demographics our savings rates are just they're rise they're poised to rise and and they will rise for quite a while
  109. going forward and we're seeing that happen in the data which hopefully will uh will help our investment rates as
  110. well uh in light of all the the potential Urban growth how do you see uh rural India fairing so you know we've it
  111. it's been an interesting balance of the economy throughout the last two years you know when um you know when the fall
  112. of 2008 hit um middle income sort of consumption tanked tanked is you know that's pretty dramatic because for India
  113. at our lowest our trough for GDP growth was 5.8% so the markets took a huge hit but in terms of real activity um we
  114. still stayed pretty strong but you did see a dip in in Middle um middle income sort of consumption but at that time
  115. actually because beforehand we had a relatively um good Monsoon rural spending um stayed pretty healthy not
  116. even just healthy it was pretty robust so when you look at fast moving consumer goods for example you saw um rises in
  117. consumption for these kinds of goods um much higher than people expected even taking into account or adjusting for the
  118. downturn so um so the rural sort of spending story stayed very healthy and then by the time um 2009 rolled around
  119. you sort of Saw um the manufacturing sector revive we saw GDP sort of get its its footing back um you saw middle
  120. income consumption actually recover so there was about two quarters where we saw a dip and then and then we we saw it
  121. kind of revive by that point the monsoons started to play into people psychology so spending in in rural India
  122. kind of was rained back a little bit so we've had sort of this you know for want
  123. of a better word sort of a balancing where kind of the rural consumer really took up the gauntlet in 2008 early 2009
  124. and then this year what we see going into um uh into the coming year it's really the return of the urban consumer
  125. well looking looking ahead five or 10 years what would the composite of the urban consumer look like again I think
  126. you know for India it's so difficult because it's you know to basically cut it AC yeah it it it it depends where you
  127. are and what city you're talking about um you know I think for when you looked at um overall kind of uh um spending we
  128. saw mid we saw these top 20 cities really account for um about100 million of um of consumer
  129. spending um in 200 uh 627 um and a third of it was devoted to to food but again that masks if you go
  130. to coin bethor there was a much lower share spent on food a much higher share spent on health um I think that share is
  131. going to continue to shrink um of food food and kind of move towards um food uh to clothing to um personal care to
  132. higher value added Services um but we're that that change is happening very uh very differently as you move across
  133. geographies and so does the report or would you make recommendations to companies in terms of how they can
  134. approach the Indian consumer it sounds like it's a very granular thing to degree it's quite a granular thing um
  135. you know and I think that uh the thing is is that for India relative to China the thing is is that India has a huge
  136. amount of Demand right close to 60% of our GDP um is composed of of demand consumption private final consumption
  137. expenditure so um we have a very different sort of composite of our economy relative to let's say a China so
  138. there's a huge amount of demand the issue is that we haven't figured out our supply whereas in China Supply is
  139. completely figured out and trying to stimulate demand is more the issue so you know everything I think there's
  140. demand for many things but companies that stay strong have really figured out how they're going to get consistent
  141. Supply over the long run because you see a lot of Products that come to Market and they're successful for a year or two
  142. years and then they disappear so you know I think the real important sort of thing is to to make sure that the best
  143. companies really stay capitalized um and figure out a a a long-term sort of Supply strategy um and uh and if they
  144. can do that uh you'll find that there is demand for for good quality um products
  145. but I think there's really hard it's very hard for companies to have stamina in the Indian market just to figure out
  146. uh the logistics in the supply chain that's the biggest issue great well thank you very much for speaking with us
  147. today thank you

Brief Summary

Rupa discusses BRICS economic growth, urbanization in India, and evolving consumer behaviors influenced by women's workforce participation.

Key points

  • The Rise of Urbanization in India. Urbanization is set to redefine global patterns, with millions moving to urban spaces.
  • Consumer Behavior Shifts. The rise of women in the workforce is significantly changing spending patterns in India.
  • Demand vs. Supply in India. India's economy is driven by demand, but supply chain issues remain a challenge.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes