Caja Navarra CEO Enrique Goni: 'Banks Must Treat Customers as Citizens'

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Banks have had a difficult time in the recent global economic crisis. Not only have some closed shop and others have had to be bailed out by governments, but also their image has taken a bad beating. This will have serious consequences in the long term, many analysts say. The way forward is to empower the bank customer, says Enrique Goni, CEO of Caja Navarra, a savings bank in Spain, in this conversation with Wharton management professor Mauro F. Guillen.

Brief Summary

Enrique G discusses banking challenges, mobile technology, and rebuilding trust with customers through transparency and participation.

Key points

  • Challenges Facing the Banking Sector. Enrique G discusses the top challenges banks face today, including capital and technology.
  • The Importance of Mobile Banking. Mobile banking is reshaping the banking landscape, enhancing efficiency and profitability.
  • Rebuilding Customer Confidence. Mr. G emphasizes the need for transparency and customer participation to regain trust.
  • Trust and Strategy. A discussion on the importance of belief in strategies for personal and societal benefit.
  • Gratitude and Farewell. Closing remarks filled with appreciation and well wishes.

Transcript

[Music] [Music] we have the pleasure today of having with us Enrique G who is the uh president of uh kaha Navara a Savings Bank in Spain and also uh responsible for industrial Investments at kaisa bank which is one of the largest uh Savings Banks in all of Europe in fact uh Mr G thank you so much for coming thanks thanks a lot my blessure uh so uh given your you know very long experience in the banking sector in a key European economy um I would like to begin by asking you uh a very very general question which I think a lot of people are wondering about which is what are the main challenges that the banking sector is facing nowadays uh if you had

to choose two or three which ones do you think are the ones that uh are uh at the top of the list uh in the minds of uh Bankers around the world these days well first of all well thank you very much Mao this my pleasure to be here um answering first of all uh of course getting more more more and more Capital raising Capital second from my point of view is how to find Finance the the new the new requirements for it uh Technology Innovation and third one from theological point of view is how to rebuild the peace with customers and with Society in general how to get once again the

confidence and stable confidence between the and Society between the banks and the society yes okay so these are the three the three main challenges facing Banks today uh putting aside at least for for a second uh uh the need for more Capital uh you mentioned as the second Big Challenge uh finding the the resources to invest in technology and uh and in Innovation which specific areas uh do you think banks are in most need of uh investing in uh let's say over the next three or five years yeah well first of all of course uh Mobile Banking uh second could be how to to make ouring but first of all to compete better uh in the markets Mobile Banking

how to resolve this and uh thinking about the European and the Spanish situation uh what new models or what new experiences uh uh would you say are the most important taking place right now in the area of Mobile Banking well the immigration from from the cards uh to the phones to the cellular we have uh some virtuous examples in the worldwide and uh and European banking have the the whole attention and the have put the Isis in this okay so it's replacing old forms of payment for for new forms of of payment that's right uh do you think that uh the uh uh social virtual or digital social networks uh which of

course people uh you know are increasingly using through their mobile phones do you think banks can benefit from this new social technology which is social networks and uh you know how uh people's behavior are being is being affected by what their connected others are doing do you think social networks digital social networks will have an impact on banking yeah yeah yeah I'm I'm sure I'm sure uh from from the point of view of the banking activity from the point of view of the bankers uh to use the mobile instead of the conventional other conventional payments models introducing us a high potential in in efficiency second The

Experience tell us that uh customer uh use 20% more in the through the mobile than with the uh for example the credit C or the or the Plastics so it's more uh much more business and less uh less expenses MH so Mobile Banking is going to make uh perhaps Banks more profitable yeah than of course of course of course that is the idea uh which uh countries in the world um do you think are more advanced uh in terms of the implementation of Mobile Banking well we have two two very clear examples uh one is uh Japan uh Japan is is the pilot the the housing pilot or the model and uh Japan is showing us very great examples of getting new efficiency ratios and how

people is increasing their their operation and the bation with the bank and in in in in other world and in in other geography it could be Kenya Kenya uh in the top of the progress Japan but uh in the new new emergence in Africa Kenya okay so those would be the uh the most the places to uh to observe to emulate under my point of view yeah that's right okay and uh uh at your own uh Bank MH um what has been the most significant challenge that you faced in terms of using these new mobile technologies uh for conducting business what has been the most important uh obstacle or challenge well uh two two

challenge uh one one is not from my point of view is not problematic is how to train the organization and how to train the uh the the people the customers but I think I think this this is going to be easy second is how to uh deal with uh the it how to to deal with the it companies because there are a lot of business to share and what par is in this size and what par is in the size of the bank of course so are you suggesting that those big uh benefits or profits that you were referring to a second ago uh may not only go to the banks they may also go to the it providers or maybe the

telecom companies for sure for sure for sure they are going to they are going to get a relevant part part of the of the profit they are going to increase the use they are going to increase the their turnover uh so uh they are going to make much more profitable or their Investments uh so how to manage with this and how to deal and how to negotiate it what part of this uh is going to be support by the banking Banker Bank activity and what is going to be support by the it or telecom companies and what part of the turnover can be share uh are the the two deals for the managers okay and uh what do you think

should Banks do in order to ensure that they get a uh you know sufficient uh share or part of those profits I mean are there one or two things that Banks should definitely do in order to protect their own share of the profits uh that may be created by Mobile Banking two ideas um first of all first of all it's very evident but uh first of all how to uh protect theel uh both self that uh you are going to be a telecom company and not a bank and I'm going to be a bank how how I'm going to be in my in my site and how are you going going to be in your because we are going to build

something together very very uh relevant and uh that is going to receive the 70% of the whole transaction worldwide and second second who is going to invest second who is going to invest who's going to put the money right make who's going to do with the money uh in the infrastructures and uh for sure in the development yeah and uh research on development do you think banks should establish um relationships with several telecommunications operators or providers uh that's one possibility or should they uh instead Focus their attention on just one of them and uh proceed in that way you know in order to

implement a uh Mobile Banking applications what what is better from the point of view of the bank if for a long-term relationship the second the second but uh but but but I'm sure that uh that is a world that is open and so the first uh steps everybody is going to to talk with everybody but but uh I I think that uh finally you can uh you can uh be much more competitive through a Widing a a good a good a good marriage instead of having uh several relations okay okay now you mentioned as a third very important uh challenge facing Banks today uh the uh addressing the one of the biggest uh problems that banks have uh uh seen since the since the crisis which is the the the loss of confidence

on the part of uh customers and uh and Regulators of course and uh more broadly society as a whole so banks have essentially lost uh quite a bit of Faith they have lost uh you know trust uh they have a big deficit not just in terms of capital but also in terms of confidence so what do you think uh uh you know should Banks do uh over the next uh you know two years or five years in order to rebuild that uh confidence well um for sure there are many many ways and different respon different answers um I think I think that uh one that have in count the full transparency uh promote the

participation and uh and uh try to consider the customer or the client like something more than this like uh something like a citizen uh could be a a good way I think I think that the past have show us uh a lot of things that we could not repeat this the the crisis of confidence is a crisis uh first of all of transparency uh and and it's very very very difficult to get the the virtues of transparency if there are not participation I can show you uh an account and I can show you which has the secrets of these accounts but if you are not interested in this I can be very transparent but it doesn't mind

so be transparent is good but it's not enough you have to promote the real interest uh of the customers in the bank uh because there are something in need for them yes of course but because they have a role better and higher that be customer so they have new politician economics or social rights for example I think this could be and this could be the message of the new ways of the of the new time uh people people don't want to feel like a subet uh in a in a company people people want to to feel they have uh something relevant to to say and something relevant to share with the shareholders mhm so I've seen you say in the past

that you think that the clever companies of the future should be like republics yeah uh with citizens and uh and these citizens of course include not only customers but also suppliers and that they have rights yeah uh so could you explain a little bit more how do you think this model uh you know should work what are the different components of this model of the the bank right as a republic right as opposed to just uh simply as a company that tries to make money yeah but it could be a bank it could be another company the question this the question is um having a look at the history we have an example of of free citizens that want to be much more than

anything citizens it was Roman Republic well the Romans they have a lot of troubles and mistakes etc etc etc but they build something that during 20 centuries it was the relevant and the the the core of the world what what was the beginning of this the beginning of this was created for from the well something like a very old condition of citizeness something brilliant something that is demanding for everybody well this is an example put it into into the companies into a bank how to how to to design a bank who is going to be love it love it I said by the customers well the only way the only way is if they have not only um participation a

cosmetic participation because you answer uh you you make some questions about the product the quality of the services Etc no no no it's because they are they are very close the KE the key decisions they want to know and they want to to have the a participation in space in which is the price policy why uh this uh guarantees uh how how they can uh concentrated much more products have a low rate I I mean I mean there are many ways to put your interest as close as the bank or are the company that you even go in defense of this brand and this is sure sure sure uh interest and uh under my point of view

the key question is how to open the ownership and the property rights and share is with the customer having having in count that the property right the shareholders they always have to uh something like uh two two basic rights first of all having the the the capital the capital gains and second having the accounts how you organize a company but in the middle of this you can go ahead and put uh the new formulas like social marketing CSR etc etc uh go ahead of this and open the space to share opinions and to share policies so what do you think shareholders of a bank uh

would want to support this kind of comprehensive uh relationship that you're talking about where customers perhaps even suppliers participate uh in uh in the bank why would shareholders want to go shareholders want shareholders want to to to to increase their capital gains and so if this if this work uh work on in this way uh for sure the shareholders will be very very strongly glad happy so you're essentially predicting that Banks or other types of companies that succeed at implementing a model such as this will gain a competitive advantage over other Banks or other companies yes I think thinks I

well I think so not because of the banking industry only I said that this is a message of the new time uh new time is citizeness New time is you have the accet of the full information through the technology so new time is uh the word of the companies couldn't be a closed War okay in your own Savings Bank k you have implemented a model that follows uh these principles yeah could you just explain so that we see the relationship between the third challenge about uh you know confidence its relationship to the second challenge with those technology what role does technology play in your bank yeah uh when it comes to uh helping

customers participate yeah in the bank well uh this is a capital a capital role a fundamental role is impossible is impossible to promote this new kind of relationship if you don't have the basis of an a strong technology and an open by the way an open model of technology to integrated this new um data of relationship yes and and and and fortunately we have it and uh and we could we could did it so you mentioned that in information Technologies uh are very important mhm uh when it comes to implementing a system in which customers can participate as Citizens in this Republic right so what specifically does the it system need to do uh so that uh customers can

participate you have to you have to have as minimum you have to have a strong base of uh data warehouse and you have to to have spec techniques um abilities in data mining those two those two are the the the basis and for sure it's much better if you have uh personal accountability to every customer you know how much are you earning with a customer Etc so you need to know how much money the bank is making with each customer and you need to be able to communicate to each customer yeah of course how much money is been made and then what is we did it right and in your uh system what is the customer supposed

to do with that information uh can the customer take action once he or she knows how much the bank yeah is uh the sense the S the sense of sending this information is because we recognize uh the right in the customer of knowing how much the bank is earning with the the mortgage of the credit card Etc we recognize the the the right to allocate a part of this earnings in the social or Community per they want okay so in other words instead of the bank making the decision as to what uh corporate social responsibility initiatives to do or to undertake what you're doing is you're delegating that to the customer the customer then can choose yeah the bank

has made $50 with me yeah then I get to say uh a fraction of that money uh how it is spent on CSR activties yeah my point and summarizing who are which are the companies that are cled be because they rebild the relationship as republics is is the companies that empower the customers soaring is is give power to the the customer and Power customers upgrade their conditions mhm mhm yeah give them additional rights and in your experience uh do customers that are given these rights that are empowered do they stay more with the bank uh do they uh increase their loyalty to the bank yeah yeah yeah of course of course of course the increase the the the un

loyality uh rate decrease from 12 till 8 this is the turnover in yes in four years in four years but this is this is much more relevant if you consider you have in count that sector the average in the sector were increasing so so it's very it's very clear this is an example uh how about uh for example if a company recognize their customers the right to have an opinion about the bonuses of the managers or the team are you doing that in your bank yes we we did it how does that system work so customers determine how much money Executives like yourself yeah my like myself yes yes yes and how does it work the system well uh

this work this work because we made a very big random survey through even 40 ,000 customers in a year asking them questions like uh and and and and asking them question like for example do you think we are going by you in the bad moments or only the good ones do you think we are managing a language you can understand or are incomprensible in comprensible juron to remind that we are powerful that you know do you think um we believe believe uh we trust in people and we spread of mission what do you think we are are as interested in you as in your money please rank us from 0 to 10 MH and the board of

directors every year they rank a a classification for for example we need a seven and two years we get the seven but one year it was 60. 6.3 I know and I lose lost 30% of my bonus so those this was real fire so those customer ratings essentially yeah at least in part determine the bonuses of Executives at bank yeah why not why not it is a republic yeah and and it's good for the shareholder because you are off in good turnover good payout uh good uh efficiency Etc and you are giving the the owners of the company that you are building a longterm relationship and this is not uh how how to how to offer your shares to be

invested if your customers are disappointed with you how can a responsible chief executive officer make make this it's impossible so shareholders this is not shareholders can think this is my right who is going to say if my chief executive is going to get 100% of the bonus this is my right I don't want to share it but the question is why not why not could you also let us know what are the implications uh of of this uh model of the bank as a as a republic for the employees of the bank mhm well first of all first of all employees didn't believe this this this can be

through um but uh a very relevant part of them they feel like uh authentic supporters they feel that this is something like we're going to do good business by doing good things so we are going to we are going to go to to do uh to do it well by doing the good the good things so um this represent the opportunity to not only be bunker or be in another company this give you the the the the opportunity to feel much more than a briak in the life in the in the in in the in the worldall of a company no you are you are a promoter of a new model of society MH where companies are real citizens and they promote a new kind of

citizens of citizenship and so and so for the employees it it represent a challenge because how how to be in one hand how to say no and how to say no but I'm going to remain you you have right no no how to say no I'm very credible and continue be confidence in the other hand then you need you need uh to believe in this and you need to uh want uh and to trust that this is not because is only an strategy is an strategy of course this is uh something that is is good is good for you and is good for the society okay okay well Mr G thank you so much uh for being with us uh today and uh we wish you a lots of

success at your bank okay thank you thanks a lot [Music]

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes