00:00:00
[Music] up next a couple goes on vacation and is never heard from again they're not looking for a missing person
00:00:11
because adults don't go missing adults leave a trail and there's no trail okay police find
00:00:16
evidence the couple may have been shot hodge shock brain of ammunition is specifically designed for use against
00:00:24
human beings the last place they were seen was at a well-known nightclub in the resort town that was taken at
00:00:30
secrets nightclub the last night they were alive but there were other secrets that night
00:00:36
like what really happened to these two people [Music] it was at an office party where josh
00:00:51
ford and jeannie crutchley first met both had been married previously and the two were instantly attracted to one
00:00:57
another despite a considerable age difference josh was 32 years old jeannie was 51
00:01:06
and my normal response is if the shoe was on the other foot you wouldn't think twice about it
00:01:10
in joshua 4 genie crutchley found a younger man who was exciting fun to be around
00:01:17
who also wanted to do new things in life josh was a very successful mortgage broker
00:01:23
jeannie was an accountant for an insurance company after dating for two years they moved in
00:01:29
together sharing a house in fairfax virginia they were two spirits who really had the same
00:01:35
personalities so when those same two personalities clicked i don't think the age made
00:01:41
that much difference to them they just fell in love the couple rented a condo for the memorial day weekend
00:01:47
in ocean city maryland a well-known resort town along the atlantic shore but neither one
00:01:55
showed up for work when the holiday weekend was over they worked hard they never missed work
00:02:02
they were on time they did their jobs when jeannie didn't show up for work her co-workers were
00:02:08
really concerned and that's when they notified the ocean city police police went to their rented condo and
00:02:15
found genie's car in the parking lot it was obvious to the police right away that the car had been there
00:02:22
for an extended period of time in ocean city with the sand blowing around constantly sand begins to
00:02:27
accumulate very quickly and nothing was out of place in the condominium there's absolutely no sign of foul play
00:02:34
there wasn't any break in there wasn't any broken glass the place was relatively clean jeannie's car keys were
00:02:41
still in the condo so with their clothes computer and camera it was as if they'd gone out for a walk
00:02:50
and never came back it just looked like they just decided well let's go down the street and maybe go to
00:02:56
the bar or something like that that's exactly how i look neighbors at the condo didn't see or
00:03:02
hear anything unusual the entire memorial day weekend condos are more for private vacationers so you have the
00:03:10
outside entrances it's much more private a background check revealed josh and jeannie use their credit card to buy
00:03:17
drinks at the green turtle a sports bar on saturday night investigators found the waitress who
00:03:24
served josh and jeannie she recalled they were sitting alone she remembered the couple nothing
00:03:31
unusual she did remember that he was a fan of the celtics and was tuned into the game
00:03:36
from there investigators learned that josh and genie took a bus to a nearby club one of the hottest
00:03:44
nightclubs in ocean city where everybody just floods to secrets and that's where they were
00:03:49
heading the bus driver identified josh and jeannie from a photo lineup and said they were talking with another
00:03:58
couple on the bus a caucasian couple in their late twenties or early thirties they actually
00:04:06
when they got off the bus all four of them waited in line for over an hour to get in
00:04:12
witnesses saw the two couples drinking together and also saw them leave together
00:04:18
but there was no trace of josh and jeannie after that no cell phone activity no credit card activity no nothing these
00:04:28
people were just plucked off the face of the earth that day [Music] less than a week after josh ford and
00:04:38
jeannie crutchley went missing police were called to a hooters restaurant in ocean city maryland
00:04:45
a silent alarm went off after midnight telling police there was a robbery in progress
00:04:51
upon the officer arriving he finds a jeep backed up to the door and two people walking out with arm loads of stolen
00:05:00
merchandise the robbers a man and a woman were arrested on the spot they were so intoxicated that the male
00:05:09
the husband says to one of the officers thinking it would be okay can't we just put it all back and we'll be cool
00:05:17
benjamin and erica sifrit weren't your typical married couple they weren't your typical burglars
00:05:25
either erica sifrit comes from an upper middle class family great student excellent basketball
00:05:32
player statistically her three-point shooting was top five in the country her freshman
00:05:37
or sophomore year benjamin suffered or bj as he was known was a former navy seal who had finished
00:05:46
first in his class [Music] he was an expert shot he was the cream of the crop i was told by some of his seal buddies
00:05:54
that this was the type of guy who could go out all right drink all night long okay
00:06:00
stay out till five o'clock in the morning go back to the dorm sleep for an hour or two and do a
00:06:06
20-mile run the next day and beat everybody because it was up here he's motivated up here
00:06:12
neither one had ever been arrested before but inside their car police were surprised
00:06:18
by what they found these people are armed to the teeth she has a gun in her waistband
00:06:25
it's a 357 five shot revolver i mean he's got a sig sauer nine millimeter that's fully loaded ready to go
00:06:31
and then in the vehicle there's a 45 caliber hnk combat weapon so you know you look at looking at that
00:06:38
they mean business and the arresting officers discovered something else inside erica's purse
00:06:46
with the virginia driver's licenses of joshua ford and jeannie crutchley and automatically
00:06:54
the hair on the back of their neck stands up and they realize this is a lot bigger than just a burglary at
00:06:58
hooters with handguns when asked where she got the licenses erica said she and bj
00:07:04
found them and denied ever meeting or even seeing josh and jeannie it's very very
00:07:11
possible that they found these licenses on the beach or maybe they're planning a future
00:07:15
crime of maybe stealing someone's identity in the back of the sifrit's vehicle police found
00:07:22
ski masks and flex cuffs it makes you think maybe they've held these people hostage or taken them
00:07:28
hostage and they're holding them somewhere against their will investigators now had
00:07:33
probable cause to search the seyfritz nearby condo they found a lot more than they
00:07:39
bargained for on the table outside the dining room they find two spent bullets police also found
00:07:48
evidence that bj and erica lied to them they find a stack of photographs uh really a cache of photographs and on the
00:07:57
top is a picture of jeannie and joshua at secrets that was taken at secrets nightclub
00:08:05
the last night that they were alive one of the pictures in the siffritz condo showed a ring on josh ford's hand
00:08:15
in another picture taken two days after josh and jeannie went missing erica siffred is wearing josh's ring
00:08:23
on a chain around her neck and when she was arrested for the robbery police found that ring in her purse
00:08:34
even more damning police found in the separate's possession a key to the atlantis condominiums where
00:08:42
josh and jeannie had been staying they turned the key it unlocked the door it was the key to
00:08:49
josh and jeannie's unit police were now certain that the separates had something to do with josh and
00:08:57
jeannie's disappearance but what the last known photograph of josh ford and jeannie crutchley was taken
00:09:09
at the secrets nightclub from a photo lineup the bus driver identified b.j and erica
00:09:16
sifrit as the couple he saw with josh ford and jeannie crutchley when he dropped
00:09:23
them off at secrets and witnesses saw the two couples leave secrets together but what happened after that
00:09:34
investigators took a much closer forensic look in the bathroom of the siffritz condo
00:09:41
and there they noticed something i saw some orange colored substance on the tile i noticed a little bit running
00:09:48
down the side of the shower stall and when i saw that i thought well you know maybe this could be blood they pull out
00:09:55
the sink stopper for the washing sink and they find all kinds of hair attached to it
00:10:01
with blood and flesh underneath that sink investigators discovered a bullet hole
00:10:08
that went clear through the wall into the adjacent bedroom this matched the two bullets found
00:10:16
on the seyfritz coffee table one of them looked like i had some drywall dust in it
00:10:21
one oven looked like i had blood in the crews and joints and stuff like that on the large glass window inside the
00:10:27
bathroom crime scene technicians discovered a partial palm print tests on the blood in the bathroom and
00:10:38
on the mangle 357 slug found on the coffee table yielded a dna profile investigators took samples from josh and
00:10:49
jeannie's toothbrushes and hairbrushes and generated their dna profiles most of the dna that we tested came back
00:10:58
mixed dna both of joshua ford and jeannie crutchley the dna on the mangled 357 slug found
00:11:06
on the coffee table was josh's so that bullet had been in joshua ford's body at some point and
00:11:13
then dug out or pulled out and kept as a trophy by the separates we didn't have the bodies but we knew
00:11:21
that somebody had met a very brutal and gruesome end in that room [Music] bullets test fired from erika siffritz
00:11:32
357 revolver were compared to the damaged bullets when the hollow point expands soft tissue it'll mushroom out many
00:11:42
people might think that this expansion is damaged to a bullet and might prevent or even hinder
00:11:47
firearms examination however this is just simply not true the two bullets recovered from the
00:11:53
dining room table positively associated or in other words matched back to the 357
00:11:59
magnum revolver when faced with this evidence erika sifrit made a deal with prosecutors
00:12:08
she agreed to lead them to josh and jeannie's bodies and testify against b.j in exchange for a reduced charge
00:12:18
she told investigators they dismembered josh and jeannie's bodies and put them in dumpsters in the
00:12:25
neighboring state of delaware 10 miles away for investigators this was a lucky break
00:12:35
delaware has a unique system of dumping they know where everything they dump they know what plot it is at their
00:12:41
dumpsite eight days after josh and jeannie went missing parts of their dismembered bodies were
00:12:48
found bullets recovered from josh's body matched erica sifrit's gun josh's palm print matched the print on the bathroom
00:12:59
window in the separates condo incredibly josh ford and jeannie crutchley were random victims of a couple for whom
00:13:09
breaking the law had become a strange romantic obsession but just when investigators thought
00:13:18
the case had been solved erica came forward with a story they could hardly believe
00:13:31
i think she has her own evil side and i think he has his evil side together they were exposed like a civil
00:13:36
poor one's a match one's a fuse prosecutors made a deal with erica sifrit if she told them the truth about what
00:13:45
happened to josh ford and jeannie crutchley she would face a reduced charge one of the requirements
00:13:52
of the deal was that she had to pass a polygraph test originally she told prosecutors that she
00:14:00
had nothing to do with the murders that all she did was help dispose of the bodies
00:14:06
later however she changed her story she admitted during the pre-test interview that she was more involved in
00:14:14
the homicides than she had told us up to then she admitted taking the knife and stabbing jeannie
00:14:21
erica also admitted the tattoo on her abdomen had a special significance following
00:14:28
the stabbing of jeannie crutchly she got a tattoo on her side in the same place where she stabbed
00:14:35
jeannie crutchley and that was so she could forever be reminded of that night she was involved from the get-go and she
00:14:48
essentially admitted she ordered the killings so based on that you know we couldn't uh
00:14:53
couldn't continue with this deal first degree murder charges were filed against both
00:15:00
bj and erica sifrit each ended up turning on the other as the trials approached investigators struggled to find a motive
00:15:12
for the crime we believe that these murders were committed simply for the fun or the thrill of killing
00:15:22
we've come up with no other possible motive in this case the couple owned a scrap booking store near a mall in
00:15:30
altoona pennsylvania but two months before the murders they began turning to a life of crime according to erica
00:15:39
there was very little sexual contact between her and her husband b.j she told me that bj
00:15:45
thrived on the burglaries and doing things of risk and that's what got him off they start out burglarizing places close
00:15:53
to where erica and bj own the business that's not fun anymore okay so they upped the annie they needed
00:16:02
more thrill more thrill more thrill they were a strange strange couple together that's
00:16:06
for sure prosecutors say the separates were hunting for thrills when they met josh and jeannie
00:16:15
at secrets nightclub after some conversation they all decided to go back to the seyfritz condo
00:16:24
for more drinking conversation and a dip in the hot tub but the separates decided
00:16:31
to toy with josh and genie erica claimed her purse was missing with her expensive jewelry
00:16:38
inside [Music] anywhere and she wanted josh and genie to help look for it but only erica and bj
00:16:49
were in on the game [Music] if josh and jeannie found the purse they could live if not they'd have to pay the price
00:17:02
when josh and jeannie didn't find the purse bj accused them of stealing it you took it apart
00:17:13
where is it we don't have it prove it take your clothes off are you serious [Music]
00:17:24
josh and jeannie made a run for the bathroom and locked the door they tried to escape with josh leaving
00:17:32
his palm print on the window the evidence shows four shots were fired the first two went through the door and
00:17:43
hit josh in the torso erica said bj fired the third shot into josh's head prosecutors believe erica fired the
00:17:54
fourth shot towards genie and missed either accidentally or deliberately as part of their cruel game
00:18:03
[Music] the bullet went through the wall into the adjoining bedroom erica told prosecutors she stabbed
00:18:11
jeannie in the abdomen with a knife [Music] later when erica brought some rags and
00:18:26
detergent to clean up the blood she said bj was in the hot tub with the heads of their two victims
00:18:39
she said bj removed the slug from josh's head to keep it as a trophy over the next 24 hours the couple
00:18:51
dismembered the bodies placed them in garbage bags and put them in various dumpsters throughout delaware
00:19:01
they also went to a hardware store to buy a new bathroom door and more cleaning supplies to
00:19:08
repair the bathroom as best they could afterwards the couple acted as if nothing had
00:19:16
happened drinking beer having a great time going to miniature golf nobody would have
00:19:21
suspected them of being the animals they are erica wore josh's ring as a trophy and carried around their driver's
00:19:29
licenses and kept the slugs from the shootings i've never seen a crime like this where
00:19:37
a couple just kills another couple for the thrill of it they had nothing against these people
00:19:41
they did nothing to them they were chosen the story was so incredible that without forensic evidence no one
00:19:50
was likely to believe it even the best cleaning doesn't always get it up like in this case i mean there
00:19:56
was still blood there that was visible you just had to know what you were looking for erica and bj
00:20:02
were tried separately her defense was i didn't do it he did his defense was i didn't do it
00:20:09
she did in the absence of any physical evidence against him and the fact that erica's gun was used
00:20:17
in josh's murder bj was convicted of only one count of second degree murder he was sentenced
00:20:26
to 38 years in prison erica was convicted of both murders and sentenced to life in prison plus
00:20:35
20 years she had the gun in her possession she has you know the victim's identification in her purse
00:20:42
she has all the souvenirs if you will with her and her possession or in her purse
00:20:46
still bothers me why this case stands out i'll probably never see another case like this in my career
00:20:54
and hopefully in my lifetime without the forensic evidence it would have been difficult to get
00:21:01
a um a conviction of homicide in any degree as to these two defendants it was possible
00:21:09
um but it would have been much much more [Music] difficult you