Search Captions & Ask AI

Forensic Files - Season 9, Episode 7 - Cloak of Deceit - Full Episode

January 01, 2022 / 21:42

This episode covers a series of bank robberies in Calabash, North Carolina, committed by the Bellamy brothers, who were former law enforcement officers. Key discussions include the robbers' methods, the use of forensic science to identify them, and the eventual capture of the criminals.

The episode begins with the description of the quiet town of Calabash, where two masked men robbed a bank in broad daylight in 1991. Despite the robbery being captured on surveillance cameras, law enforcement struggled to identify the robbers due to a lack of forensic evidence.

Over the years, the same robbers returned to the same bank multiple times, becoming increasingly violent. Witness accounts and surveillance footage eventually led investigators to identify the robbers as the Bellamy brothers, who had law enforcement backgrounds.

Forensic garment analysis played a crucial role in the investigation, as a jacket found in one of the brothers' homes matched the clothing worn during the robberies. This evidence, along with witness testimonies, led to their arrest.

The episode concludes with the Bellamy brothers being convicted of multiple counts of bank robbery, highlighting the irony of law enforcement officers committing such crimes.

TLDR

The Bellamy brothers, former law enforcement, committed a series of bank robberies in North Carolina before being caught through forensic evidence.

Episode

21:42
00:00:06
for seven years a group of bank robbers flaunted their expertise in front of security cameras
00:00:13
and law enforcement could do little more than watch and marvel they left no forensic evidence behind
00:00:20
and always got away before police arrived but how they stood what they said and the clothes they wore all told a story
00:00:30
one that could be deciphered by forensic science [Music] [Music] um [Music] calabash north carolina is a quiet
00:01:05
fishing town located just over the state line from myrtle beach south carolina to sum it up is a perfect place to live
00:01:13
quiet the best seafood in the world and that's how calabash was known in september of 1991 in broad daylight
00:01:23
two masked men with handguns walked into one of the local banks a teller pushed the silent alarm
00:01:30
but the robbers got away with forty thousand dollars before police arrived the closest police station was our
00:01:38
county complex which is about 25 to 30 miles away the bank was equipped with surveillance
00:01:43
cameras that used 35 millimeter film in most instances we have bank surveillance videotapes which don't give
00:01:51
us a lot of quality and don't allow us the opportunity to enhance the photos
00:01:56
the pictures showed a well-organized crime some individuals go in banks with no gloves no mask and no plan those are the
00:02:06
easiest ones to catch the folks that are well planned well orchestrated prove to
00:02:12
be the most difficult challenge in law enforcement the men entered the bank just after an
00:02:17
armored truck made its daily delivery of cash from the federal reserve bank they
00:02:22
didn't walk around the bank like nervous or anything and they had a getaway car
00:02:25
waiting and they were watching the getaway car the whole time they could see us at the door
00:02:29
the high resolution pictures gave investigators a good look at the getaway car driven most likely by a third
00:02:36
accomplice we were able to determine it was a camaro we were able to determine the
00:02:42
year of the vehicle certain packages that came with the vehicle that were not standard
00:02:48
but without the license plate number it would be difficult to find the car with so few clues the robbery went
00:02:56
unsolved until one year later it happened again at the very same bank it was turning our quiet town
00:03:10
known for its seafood into a quiet town known for its bank robberies a bank employee recognized them
00:03:21
she recognized the voice the way they stood the same directives she was positive the same people were robbing
00:03:26
her over and over again in fact the statement she made was deja vu of the robbers is about five foot eight
00:03:34
and nearly 300 pounds it was fairly uh distinct they got identified that way as being
00:03:39
the same people [Music] the robbers warned the tellers not to throw dye packs in the money bags
00:03:47
dye packs are rigged to explode later leaving a permanent die on the bills one of the news crews had come down it
00:03:56
sort of made me mad that reporter stood in the middle of the street in calabash and made the comment if you want to rob
00:04:01
a bank calabash is the place to come and do it over the next several years these same
00:04:07
men robbed other banks in the area the getaway cars were stolen and abandoned miles away
00:04:16
they were not making a lot of mistakes they were going in they were getting what they needed to get and they got out
00:04:20
of the bank we had no hairs we had no fibers we had no confessions we had no money
00:04:26
we had very few bits of real physical evidence [Music] over a four-year period there were six
00:04:37
bank robberies stretching from calabash north carolina down to myrtle beach across the state line
00:04:45
each robbery lasted between two and five minutes and none of the branches had armed security personnel
00:04:53
very meticulous very structured very organized in out and gone and you're in a rural area i think
00:05:01
you have to be both lucky and good and the crimes were becoming increasingly violent one usually the obese robber in
00:05:12
this case went behind the tellers counter and threatened to kill him and the other
00:05:17
one rounded up any customers or other bank employees sometimes force them into one office or forced them onto the
00:05:23
ground in one particular bank robbery a warning shot was fired at a bank manager
00:05:30
we had several instances where tellers were struck were dragged or beaten were threatened
00:05:36
in one instance when an employee hesitated in opening the bank vault it almost cost her her life
00:05:43
she was shaking so badly she couldn't do the combination that individual cocked the weapon against her head and
00:05:53
said this is your last chance you open the vault or you're dead investigators tried to predict where and
00:06:02
when the robbers would strike again but they never imagined what would happen next
00:06:10
the robbers returned to calabash and hit the same bank for the third time it turned out to be their biggest heist
00:06:20
to date they walked out of the bank with a hundred seventy-five thousand dollars
00:06:26
but this time there was a witness outside i had to kind of take a double take to
00:06:32
make sure i was seeing what i thought i saw and and then i realized it was a bank robber in progress
00:06:38
king saw two men run from the bank and get into a green car driven by a third man
00:06:43
[Music] king wrote down the license plate number then did something law enforcement
00:06:49
officers discourage he followed them the chase reached speeds of 80 miles per hour
00:07:00
at one point the robbers stopped their car turned around and confronted him they were sitting in the intersection
00:07:06
stopped aimed back in my direction and one of the guys was out of the car with with a gun
00:07:12
and so i just laid over in the seat and just kicked it you kicked the gas and just shot by as fast as it could
00:07:19
he still had the license plate number which identified the car as stolen it was later found abandoned in the same
00:07:29
area as the other getaway cars along a deserted road in south carolina we told him how brave and how not brave
00:07:37
it was particularly the death that he helped us but we didn't want him to get
00:07:40
hurt and luckily he didn't i don't think what i did was anything close to heroic i think it was just a
00:07:46
it was a civic duty almost to to to try to help catch these guys the robbers didn't strike again until
00:07:55
almost a year later this time in myrtle beach about 20 miles away they always seem to be one step ahead of
00:08:05
law enforcement and investigators were beginning to understand why it was something they saw in a
00:08:13
surveillance picture for prosecutors and cops that work in bank robberies not many robbers wear
00:08:19
holsters okay and this guy wore a police type holster on his belt to carry his gun which was quite distinct
00:08:27
and it was clear that the two men inside the bank knew how to handle a weapon this wasn't the first time this
00:08:33
individual had ever picked up a gun and we felt like there was some training involved and planning involved in these
00:08:39
robberies there was also something strange about the way one of the robbers stood
00:08:46
the old weaver stance which was a type of a stance that you're trained to do in
00:08:50
police work back in the late 80s and 90s and he just had a manner in which he held his his gun in
00:08:57
his hand that was unusual it's hard to describe we thought there was a high possibility that it was somebody that
00:09:04
had maybe gone through some kind of law enforcement training or even military training
00:09:09
investigators now knew how the robbers were getting away with the crimes [Music]
00:09:20
police now believe that the men robbing banks throughout north and south carolina were somehow involved in law
00:09:26
enforcement over a six-year period they had gotten away with close to a half million
00:09:33
dollars their favorite target was the small town of calabash at the time the nearest police station
00:09:41
was a 20-minute drive away they robbed the same bank three times i think that they had a nerve to go into
00:09:53
these banks on more than one occasion but also to stay into the inside the banks as long as they stayed in
00:10:01
why the individuals chose north carolina national bank three times we do not know
00:10:08
but we do know that apparently they did this because they have been successful and i think with each robbery it became
00:10:14
easier and easier and they became more confident the robber's next target was a bank
00:10:19
right up the street a customer at the drive-thru window witnessed the robbery he also noticed a third man in a pickup
00:10:30
truck who appeared to be the lookout and he wrote down the license plate number when the robbers drove away in a red suv
00:10:40
the customer followed them that individual followed both of those vehicles along a route that in one of
00:10:46
the previous bank robberies another witness had followed the getaway vehicle and they both took exactly the same
00:10:52
route the bank customer eventually lost the robbers but the license plate number
00:10:58
turned out to be an enormous break the truck belonged to alvin bellamy a landscaper who lived in rural south
00:11:07
carolina the fbi went to the bellamy's home neither alvin nor the truck were there
00:11:15
but alvin's wife was she proceeded to tell us where he was that he was with his brothers claude
00:11:21
bellamy and larry bellamy so that is the first time we come up with three names around 1am
00:11:29
a car approached the bellamy home but it wasn't alvin it was alvin's brother larry who was a lieutenant with
00:11:37
the myrtle beach police department they gave me the name of lieutenant larry bellamy and the
00:11:43
my initial reaction was they've made a bad mistake there's no possible way that
00:11:48
that they've got the right person or that they should even be looking at this
00:11:52
particular person larry vehemently denied any involvement in the robberies alvin came home a short time later in
00:12:01
the truck identified as the lookout vehicle the fbi found a hundred and sixteen dollars in brand new bills in alvin's
00:12:13
wallet fresh crisp fives and ones i started writing down the serial numbers to the one and five dollar bills
00:12:23
there was basically one of those ploys that you use i told him that i was going to take him
00:12:28
back to the bank and compare it with the stolen money from the bank he got very agitated got very upset demanding he'd
00:12:34
never seen that money before the next morning investigators went to the third brother's home nearby
00:12:44
claude bellamy was a heavyset man with a similar bill to the man in the security
00:12:48
pictures he was also a former policeman he also denied any involvement in the robberies and investigators found no
00:12:58
large sums of money in his home but in his bedroom closet investigators found a black and white
00:13:06
czech jacket it happened to be the only garment hanging in that closet which was interesting to me and why you would
00:13:14
have this coat hanging separately in a room they didn't use a closet it didn't
00:13:17
appear to use the jacket was sent to fbi expert david davies he's a photographic technologist
00:13:24
with 20 years experience in garment identification at first glance davies knew he was dealing with a
00:13:32
mass-produced product you could have 10 million jackets that look like that davies used computer enhancement
00:13:42
software to improve the quality of the bank's security photos [Music] he then photographed a model wearing the
00:13:50
jacket standing the same way as the robber shirts and jackets are manufactured differently depending on the price and
00:13:59
quality of the garment for example in more expensive shirts the manufacturer lines up the breast pockets
00:14:07
to match the overall pattern on the garment anytime you have a pattern that has to
00:14:13
be aligned it's got to be done by a human and it costs the company money therefore the more alignment you have in
00:14:22
the pattern the more expensive your shirt is going to be in an inexpensive shirt the manufacturer
00:14:29
in this case the arrow company doesn't even attempt a match by going to aero
00:14:34
we ask the people who are there okay exactly what are you trying to line up here
00:14:42
exactly what are you doing when you make this shirt the manufacturer aligned the breast
00:14:48
pocket at a 45 degree angle because of the pattern all points of alignment at the seams happen at random
00:14:57
the more seams i can see and the more uniqueness that i can determine in this case
00:15:06
the bank robbers stood at the same place and basically turned around a couple times
00:15:14
and i had some outstanding views of various scenes and davies discovered the alignment of
00:15:22
the pattern at all of those random points was identical in the surveillance pictures
00:15:31
davies noticed another distinctive mark a discoloration in the fabric on the left sleeve
00:15:39
i saw a little light mark in what should have been a gray square you're seeing the uh
00:15:46
the white threads that's below the dyed gray he found the same anomaly a tear in the material
00:15:56
in the exact same spot on bellamy's jacket i was absolutely sure that it was that
00:16:03
jacket so there's no doubt whatsoever no doubt the examination of plaid shirt by
00:16:08
the fbi was exceptional we've never seen or heard of this before this was a new
00:16:11
process to us what i couldn't tell was who the bank robber was but what i could tell was
00:16:19
the jacket robbed the bank investigators now had to prove that one of the bellamy brothers wore
00:16:27
the jacket [Music] and they also wanted to find the money [Music] the fbi's photographic analyst
00:16:38
determined that the jacket found in claude bellamy's home had been worn by one of the bank robbers
00:16:47
from the surveillance pictures it appeared to be larry bellamy larry was a lieutenant in the myrtle
00:16:54
beach police department his supervisor warren gaul recognized him in the pictures by the way he held
00:17:00
his gun i have been on the range numerous times with larry when we were qualifying
00:17:07
for the police department and i knew his stance i knew his pose and it was exact
00:17:16
larry's shooting stance was unique it was a combination of two different styles taught at the police academy
00:17:24
larry had never really adjusted to the new stance and shot with a hybrid sort of stance in between the old square stop
00:17:31
and shouldered stance and the newer weaver stance that was quite distinctive a number of these witnesses had been on
00:17:38
the shooting range practicing with them for years and recognized that shooting stance
00:17:44
larry knew a great deal about bank robbery because he was a crime scene specialist
00:17:50
he worked bank robberies as a crime scene officer he took fingerprints photographs he communicated with bank
00:17:57
tellers and employees in the fbi in the incidents that occurred in myrtle beach he was aware of evidence he was aware of
00:18:04
what is looked for in terms of evidence at a crime scene incredibly larry bellamy helped investigate one of
00:18:11
his own crimes hindsight being 2020 looking back at the day that we located this stolen car i remember larry
00:18:23
bellamy showing up on the scene offering his assistance to us because he was a crime scene
00:18:32
officer with the myrtle beach police department larry's timesheets indicated he was not
00:18:37
working when the robberies occurred investigators also discovered an interesting clue in the way the getaway
00:18:45
vehicles were abandoned they were so successful for so many years that they just got sloppy and towards
00:18:52
the end they started using their own cars to carry out the robberies investigators found the red suv used at
00:19:01
their last robbery at a safe house the brothers rented about a hundred miles away in aberdeen north carolina
00:19:09
by the time the fbi found it everything else was gone we never recovered the money from these
00:19:16
bank robberies and there was a total take of approximately eight hundred thousand dollars
00:19:21
when you break down that amount of money over that time frame split maybe three ways
00:19:27
we felt that it would be easy to spend that type of money without a great deal of notice
00:19:32
or even if they put it away which to this day we don't know ironically the bellamy brothers lived
00:19:38
just across the highway from the robbers roost golf club in 2000 they were arrested and charged with
00:19:48
numerous counts of bank robbery they pleaded not guilty but the forensic garment analysis was
00:19:57
more than enough to satisfy the jury most of the evidence they had was circumstantial
00:20:04
and this was the only forensic evidence that was basically a fingerprint that was very unique
00:20:11
that pointed to one of the bank robbers all three were convicted larry and claude were each sentenced to
00:20:20
50 years in the federal penitentiary they were the men who had taken an oath to protect these people from violent
00:20:29
criminal activity and they're the very people preying upon them and so we felt that there was a
00:20:35
certain amount of culpability that went to those two that didn't go to alvin
00:20:40
alvin was sentenced to 15 years and i think it was the shirt that an fbi investigator at the lab was able to
00:20:48
identify that this is the exact shirt that was worn in this robbery and it matches identical to the surveillance
00:20:54
film inside the bank i think that that became the straw that broke the camel's
00:20:59
back and broke the case [Music] [Applause] [Music] you

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most intense
  • 80
    Most surprising
  • 75
    Biggest twist
  • 70
    Most shocking

Episode Highlights

  • The Perfect Crime
    For seven years, a group of bank robbers executed heists flawlessly, leaving law enforcement baffled.
    “They left no forensic evidence behind.”
    @ 00m 18s
    January 01, 2022
  • A Town Transformed
    Calabash, known for its seafood, became infamous for bank robberies after repeated heists.
    “It was turning our quiet town into a quiet town known for its bank robberies.”
    @ 03m 10s
    January 01, 2022
  • The Inside Job
    Investigators discovered that the robbers had law enforcement backgrounds, complicating the case.
    “Police now believe that the men robbing banks were somehow involved in law enforcement.”
    @ 09m 22s
    January 01, 2022
  • The Unraveling
    The Bellamy brothers were arrested after a breakthrough in the investigation linked them to the robberies.
    “The forensic garment analysis was more than enough to satisfy the jury.”
    @ 19m 57s
    January 01, 2022

Episode Quotes

  • I think it was just a civic duty to try to help catch these guys.
    Forensic Files - Season 9, Episode 7 - Cloak of Deceit - Full Episode
  • They were the very people preying upon them.
    Forensic Files - Season 9, Episode 7 - Cloak of Deceit - Full Episode

Key Moments

  • Seven Years of Crime00:06
  • The First Heist01:25
  • Witness Intervention06:30
  • The Big Break11:01
  • The Arrest19:46

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown