Search Captions & Ask AI

Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 12 - With Every Breath - Full Episode

November 04, 2021 / 21:46

This episode covers the mysterious disease outbreak among young Navajo Indians in 1993, the deaths of Merrell Bahi and Florina Woody, and the investigation that followed.

The episode begins with the alarming rate of deaths on the Navajo reservation, where more than 20 young people succumbed to an unidentified illness. Key figures include Merrell Bahi, a talented runner, and Florina Woody, who both died from acute respiratory failure shortly after giving birth to their son.

Health officials struggled to identify the cause of the outbreak, initially fearing a contagious disease. The situation escalated as more deaths occurred, prompting the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to investigate.

Traditional Navajo medicine men provided crucial information about the disease's potential link to environmental factors, particularly an increase in deer mice populations. The CDC eventually discovered a new strain of hantavirus, which was responsible for the outbreak.

The episode highlights the collaboration between Navajo traditional healers and medical scientists, emphasizing the importance of both perspectives in solving the mystery of the disease.

TLDR

A mysterious hantavirus outbreak in 1993 claimed young Navajo lives, leading to a unique collaboration between traditional healers and medical investigators.

Episode

21:46
00:00:04
[Music] in 1993 on an indian reservation in the southwestern united states young navajo indians were dying at an
00:00:16
alarming rate more than 20 people would die from the mysterious disease one that health officials had never seen
00:00:25
before but the navajo medicine men provided a critical piece of information which led
00:00:32
investigators around the world to a most unlikely killer [Music] covering 25 000 square miles of high
00:01:08
desert in four states utah colorado new mexico and arizona is a navajo indian reservation in an area known as the four
00:01:19
corners it's the largest navajo community in america with some 1200 members of the
00:01:27
tribe living throughout the desert hills the scenery brings thousands of tourists
00:01:35
each year a vital source of revenue for the navajo who have inhabited the area for
00:01:41
centuries but poverty is endemic and was a fact of life for people like nineteen-year-old meryl bahi
00:01:50
but meryl bahi had something that set him apart merle was a very phenomenal person but
00:01:57
where he stood out was his running ability and i think if you talk to anybody that saw
00:02:05
him run you know they would tell you that it was a gift that he had in running and he loved to run
00:02:13
meryl bahi was so fast he won a full scholarship to the santa fe indian school a boarding school that was miles
00:02:21
away from his home both physically and culturally he didn't really know how to put a sheet on a bla on a bed or
00:02:33
you know it was like he threw the blanket on and that was this that numeral you um
00:02:38
you put this down first so i i had to show him how to to make up a bed bahi slowly adjusted to his new life he
00:02:48
did well in school but the transition to life in the city was difficult until he met florina woody
00:02:56
something magical happened he met another navajo girl at a pueblo school and they fell in love so intensely that
00:03:03
the track coach decided to make florina the manager of the track team to hand out the towels so that
00:03:10
merrill would keep his mind on his running not long afterwards they had a son maurice and planned to get married but
00:03:18
shortly after the baby was born florina woke up one morning with what she thought was the flu
00:03:25
she was all cold she kept you know having these chills and it was it was something like
00:03:34
you're getting a cold or getting sick from a common cold their lungs were white out meaning they
00:03:40
were just solid they should usually be dark from from the air and they obviously had something in there fluid
00:03:46
in there doctors raced to find out what was wrong they administered oxygen to help florina
00:03:53
breathe but she went into shock i saw one of the nurses coming out of her room all disturbed and she was crying
00:04:02
and i i knew there that something was happening none of the standard procedures worked
00:04:09
and florina's heart stopped beating the pressure on her lungs was simply too
00:04:15
much for her body to bear the cause of death acute respiratory failure florina woody died on mother's day
00:04:25
she was just 21 years old and they told us that she was gone then they allowed us to go to our room
00:04:34
i just couldn't believe that my my baby has gone i didn't want to leave her i just want
00:04:41
to hang out right there doctors had no idea what had caused florina's sudden death
00:04:49
and they feared that whatever kill florina woody might be contagious florina's death was a particularly cruel
00:05:00
blow to merrell bahi the mother of his infant son was dead as bahi prepared flo farina's funeral he
00:05:09
too started to develop similar symptoms meryl bahi was beside himself he wasn't feeling well
00:05:18
but it didn't occur to him that that it could possibly be the same thing that affected florina merrill's physical
00:05:28
condition quickly deteriorated and he was rushed to the crown point hospital the same hospital that treated florina
00:05:36
after an initial consultation merrill did not want to be treated where florina died so his family drove him to the
00:05:44
indian medical center in gallup an hour away shortly before arrival merrill lost
00:05:50
consciousness as doctors rushed him into the emergency room he died the cause of death
00:06:02
acute respiratory failure meryl bahi was only 19 years old ironically merrill died during florina's
00:06:11
funeral service which was taking place directly across the street from the hospital
00:06:17
the freedom was going on and there we had a meeting with our medical investigator
00:06:23
and meryl's family were coming in for a flow's journal and they were told there
00:06:30
and everything just started happening here and there and that's when i went to
00:06:35
shock health authorities had no explanation for what killed the young couple the
00:06:41
only way they could determine the cause was to perform a complete autopsy but autopsies are not permitted in the
00:06:49
navajo community it's forbidden in among traditional napos to have autopsies done and the napa tribal
00:06:58
government can forbid that if they want to and i don't think the government people really understood
00:07:04
that we have that sovereign power to do that even if it's a medical emergency
00:07:09
but with her daughter and future son-in-law dead beta begay wanted answers she took the unusual step of defying
00:07:18
tradition and the tribal elders by giving doctors permission to perform the autopsies
00:07:26
the autopsy findings took on a new importance when merrill and florina's infant child maurice also fell ill
00:07:35
he was rushed to the hospital and quarantined what is it where did it come from or
00:07:42
what is is it gonna is it gonna be here or how you know i asked i had that i had those questions
00:07:50
and i wanted to find out as authorities awaited the autopsy results the disease continued its deadly
00:07:59
rampage within a week of florina and meryl's deaths the number of dead had risen to
00:08:06
six and each day more people were being hospitalized with symptoms new mexico officials feared
00:08:15
they had an epidemic on their hands and panic gripped the region we were getting calls from concerned
00:08:22
citizens and concerned physicians and concerned school administrators and concerned everybody
00:08:28
and that always will happen when something as dramatic as this and as frightening as this is occurring and
00:08:34
when you do really don't have any good answers the autopsies on merrell bahi and
00:08:40
florina woody answered few questions the mystery illness could not be identified
00:08:48
and until it was more people were destined to die doctors in the four corners area are on
00:08:59
alert to a deadly respiratory illness may 1993 navajo radio stations in the four
00:09:06
corners indian reservation broadcast an alert young navajo were dying at an alarming
00:09:13
rate and new cases were being reported every day so little was known that health
00:09:19
officials were not able to tell listeners what precautions to take against the disease
00:09:26
it was frightening for people who came down with a fever and cough and headache at the time as a physician we're sending
00:09:33
people home who we had to accept the possibility that they could drop dead within hours of leaving the hospital
00:09:43
the outbreak was now national news and since it appeared that only navajo were affected it was dubbed the navajo
00:09:52
flew there was pandemonium it's impossible to keep a string of deaths like this a secret for very long
00:09:59
one possibility was bubonic plague the dreaded black death that killed millions during the middle ages and still strikes
00:10:08
more than a thousand people worldwide every year plague symptoms particularly the high
00:10:15
fever muscle pain and fluid buildup bore similarities to the four corners disease
00:10:22
bubonic plague still crops up in new mexico from time to time and so the state is very well equipped
00:10:29
to do that test and much to the to the uh chagrin of the investigators um the test
00:10:39
was negative it was chagrin because they still didn't know what had killed this young couple
00:10:46
another possibility was pneumonic plague a highly contagious disease it attacks the lungs and kills quickly which is
00:10:55
what happened to the four corners victims since it could be treated with large doses of antibiotics doctors actually
00:11:04
hoped that this was what they'd find but the autopsies turned up something different the capillaries of the victims
00:11:12
had collapsed leaving the lungs wet like large sponges this was not consistent with pneumonic
00:11:20
plague and it did not resemble anything medical investigators had ever seen before
00:11:27
and it was very puzzling and it was it was frustrating because you felt like how come we're not smart
00:11:32
enough to figure this out you know this shouldn't be that hard so i haven't had i haven't had that many
00:11:39
cases at one time but i didn't understand local health officials called in the centers for disease control in
00:11:45
atlanta georgia the cdc special pathogens team was sent in to look for possible causes
00:11:54
and they started their investigation in the trailer that meryl bahi and florina woody once called home
00:12:01
we had no idea what this was we didn't know whether it was contagious we didn't
00:12:05
know whether working with the tissues was going to be dangerous we didn't know
00:12:08
whether you could get this in the laboratory or from somebody outside in the field
00:12:14
the outbreak was considered a bio safety level for hazard the most lethal designation
00:12:23
dressed in specially designed suits to keep them free from any contagion cdc specialists searched the trailer and
00:12:31
the surrounding area they wore something like that you know the astronauts that they're they're sending
00:12:37
off to outer space and you know how they dress they were dressed like that when they came to our
00:12:43
place and that was even scarier that there was fear they they scared us while the medical community turned to
00:12:55
their scientific experts the navajo turned to their own specialists the traditional healers or medicine men who
00:13:03
were responsible for the health of the reservation they said they were familiar with this disease and that it had struck
00:13:09
before they were saying that this outbreak had occurred in this century in 1933 and 1918 when
00:13:17
it was preceded by two years of plentiful rains and heavy winter snows in the mountains
00:13:25
the tribal healers said the heavy rains had resulted in a dramatic increase in the number of mice on the reservation
00:13:32
and they suspected there was some connection between the large number of mice and these deaths but they could not
00:13:41
say what it was there was an old naval saying that i learned as a child that if a mouse ever runs over your clothing
00:13:48
you should burn it and nobody ever knew what that whole thing meant records indicated that there were heavy
00:13:55
rains in 1991 and 92 the two years preceding the current outbreak but health officials could not find any
00:14:05
link between the rain the growing deer mice population and the outbreak meanwhile in what's known as the maximum
00:14:15
containment section of the cdc labs an area reserved for the study of the world's most dangerous germs and viruses
00:14:24
investigators performed an elisa test or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay on the tissue samples from the victims
00:14:34
when a disease strikes the body reacts by producing antibodies which are unique to that disease
00:14:42
the elisa test can isolate those antibodies in order to compare them to the thousands of samples in the cdc
00:14:49
files comparison after comparison was made and no matches were found until the investigation took an unexpected turn
00:15:01
one that would take medical detectives back in time and halfway around the world
00:15:11
[Music] within six weeks of florina woody and merrell bahi's deaths more than 12 other
00:15:17
young people had also died of the same mysterious disease investigators got a break in the case
00:15:24
when a tourist from iceland after visiting the reservation developed symptoms of the disease
00:15:31
investigators now realized the outbreak was probably environmental and was not confined to the navajo
00:15:39
unfortunately somebody sort of identified this as a navajo disease which it very obviously wasn't
00:15:46
because we were seeing there there were other cases occurring in in navajos but but that that was
00:15:53
particularly offensive i think to people when cdc investigators compared the antibodies from the outbreak victims to
00:16:01
those in their vast file of known diseases they made a surprising discovery the only sample that was in any way
00:16:12
similar was one that was 40 years old it was a sample taken from a soldier stationed in korea in 1950
00:16:23
during the korean war more than 3 000 troops developed high fevers and kidney failure about 400 died
00:16:32
doctors called it hantavirus because it was traced back to korea's han tan river
00:16:38
that region was home to large numbers of striped field mice feces and urine from infected mice
00:16:46
carried the virus when it dried out it became airborne and was then inhaled by the soldiers
00:16:55
from there the virus attacked the kidneys but investigators were uncertain whether this was the same as the four
00:17:03
corners virus there had never been a hantavirus reported in north america and the four
00:17:08
corners disease attacked the lungs not the kidneys i had no idea what honda virus was
00:17:15
and look looked in you know my textbook which had a very short section on it and of course it describes a disease
00:17:22
that occurs in asia which which sounded nothing like what we were dealing with was this the same disease
00:17:30
and if so how did it travel from korea to a north american indian reservation cdc investigators then remembered what
00:17:41
they'd been told by the navajo traditional healers the medicine men had said when a
00:17:47
remarkably wet winter was followed by the masting of the the pinyon trees when the penum trees put out
00:17:56
an abundant supply of nuts the rodent populations in the state began to to grow and when that happened young navajo died
00:18:10
investigators caught and tested deer mice from the four corners area they found the mice were shedding a
00:18:17
virus with the same dna profile as the virus found in florina woody and merrell bahi
00:18:25
but the dna profile of this virus was not identical to the korean hanta virus although the dna profiles were similar
00:18:35
the strain from the navajo reservation was a new one unique to north america what we found when we did the comparison
00:18:42
was that this was a new honda virus that is the sequence was far enough from any other known hanovers
00:18:49
that we were convinced that it was a new virus it wasn't just a minor variant on one of the old viruses cdc
00:18:57
scientists and navajo medicine men suspected the north american hantavirus had been around for centuries but since
00:19:04
the cases were so isolated it had always been misdiagnosed the navajo made up a greater percentage
00:19:13
of the victims only because they lived in more rural areas with large deer mice populations
00:19:20
in the two years before the outbreak heavy spring rains created a bumper crop of pinyon nuts a rich source of food for
00:19:29
the growing mice population authorities believe that merrell bahi and florina woody inhaled the dried
00:19:37
urine and fecal matter from the infected deer mice when they were house cleaning
00:19:42
or digging in their garden in my heart i think it's it was god's will that
00:19:50
this is what was supposed to happen to both of them and they were meant for each other and
00:19:56
they were meant to go together health officials recommend that masks and gloves be worn when cleaning rodent
00:20:06
droppings and that people do everything possible to keep rodents out of their homes
00:20:13
they also point out that the four corners outbreak was identified through the wisdom of the navajo medicine men
00:20:22
and the scientists who were smart enough to listen we were discovering a an old disease
00:20:29
that the traditional healers had discovered long ago and that was the i think to me that was the most exciting
00:20:34
thing about this whole investigation the navajo using an entirely different approach looking at the balance of
00:20:40
nature were able to identify factors that led them to the same conclusion that when
00:20:49
rodent populations explode the way they did in the four corners in the spring of 1993
00:20:56
young navajo died these two very different sets of people set out on very different paths and
00:21:04
arrived in the same place [Music] [Music] [Applause] [Music] you

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Most heartbreaking
  • 80
    Most dramatic
  • 80
    Best concept / idea
  • 80
    Biggest twist

Episode Highlights

  • Mysterious Disease Outbreak
    In 1993, a mysterious disease struck young Navajo Indians, leading to alarming death rates.
    “More than 20 people would die from the mysterious disease.”
    @ 00m 18s
    November 04, 2021
  • Tragic Loss of Young Couple
    Meryl Bahi and Florina Woody both succumbed to a mysterious illness, leaving their infant son behind.
    “Florina Woody died on Mother’s Day; she was just 21 years old.”
    @ 04m 25s
    November 04, 2021
  • Discovery of Hantavirus
    Investigators linked the outbreak to a new strain of hantavirus, previously unknown in North America.
    “This was a new hantavirus, not just a minor variant.”
    @ 18m 44s
    November 04, 2021

Episode Quotes

  • I just couldn’t believe that my baby has gone.
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 12 - With Every Breath - Full Episode
  • It was frightening for people who came down with a fever and cough.
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 12 - With Every Breath - Full Episode
  • We were discovering an old disease that the traditional healers had discovered long ago.
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 12 - With Every Breath - Full Episode

Key Moments

  • Mysterious Illness00:18
  • Tragic Deaths04:25
  • Investigation Begins11:51
  • Hantavirus Discovery18:44

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown