Search Captions & Ask AI

Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 3 - Ultimate Betrayal - Full Episode

November 04, 2021 / 21:42

This episode covers the tragic story of Michael Ferrar and Deborah Greene, detailing their troubled marriage, a mysterious house fire, and the subsequent investigation into the deaths of their two children. Key topics include the couple's relationship struggles, allegations of poisoning, and the arson investigation that led to charges against Deborah Greene.

Michael Ferrar and Deborah Greene met in medical school and married in 1977, raising three children in Kansas City. Their marriage deteriorated due to Michael's long work hours and Deborah's struggles with depression and alcohol. Michael's affair with a nurse added to the tension, leading to their separation.

After Michael fell seriously ill with symptoms resembling ricin poisoning, he discovered Deborah had purchased castor beans, which contain the toxin. He suspected her of poisoning him, prompting an investigation into their tumultuous relationship.

On the night of a devastating fire in their home, Deborah and one daughter escaped, but two children perished. Investigators found evidence suggesting the fire was intentionally set, leading to suspicions against both parents.

Deborah Greene was ultimately charged with murder and attempted murder, and after pleading no contest, she was sentenced to life in prison without parole. The episode highlights the tragic consequences of their conflict and the loss of their children.

TLDR

Michael Ferrar's marriage to Deborah Greene ends in tragedy after a house fire kills two children, leading to murder charges against Deborah.

Episode

21:42
00:00:06
on a windy october night in 1995 a mysterious house fire swept through the palatial home of a doctor and his family
00:00:15
two of the family members made it out alive two of the children did not in the debris
00:00:24
medical detectives discovered much more than simply how the fire started [Music]
00:00:56
michael ferrara and deborah green first met in medical school in 1977 both were gifted students with near
00:01:04
genius iqs there was an instant attraction and they married less than a year after they met
00:01:11
over the next 16 years the couple raised three children jennifer timothy and kelly in an affluent suburb of kansas
00:01:19
city kansas to outsiders their lives seemed perfect but the marriage was showing signs of
00:01:26
stress at the north kansas city hospital dr michael farrar was a successful heart
00:01:34
specialist who worked very long hours often at the expense of time with his children
00:01:41
deborah quit her own medical practice when the children were born she battled depression weight gain
00:01:47
and was rumored to have a drinking problem you got the impression that deborah wasn't
00:01:53
the easiest person in the world to live with she was i don't want to say well let's just leave it at that
00:02:05
in an effort to rekindle their marriage the couple decided to go on a school trip to peru with their son tim
00:02:14
while sightseeing along the amazon river and among the incan remains an attractive blonde nurse caught
00:02:22
michael's attention she was the mother of one of the other students when they returned to kansas city
00:02:29
michael continued to see his new friend which soon blossomed into a sexual affair it didn't take debra long to find
00:02:38
out about her husband's affair she moved into a separate bedroom and her drinking
00:02:43
increased her whole identity was her marriage and her family because she didn't
00:02:48
she no longer had her own career i felt it you know maybe it was just really hard for her to let go of that
00:02:55
maybe she felt like she could change or something could change and they could somehow stay
00:03:02
together and michael had some serious problems of his own shortly after the peru trip michael
00:03:09
developed diarrhea vomiting and chill so severe he was admitted to the local hospital
00:03:16
he'd been in south america where he might have had access to a whole variety
00:03:22
of things that that could make him very sick despite undergoing a full battery of
00:03:28
tests doctors could not determine the cause of dr farrar's illness when i saw
00:03:33
him it's like mike man you look bad i'm sorry but you don't look good and he
00:03:37
said he'd been really really violently ill since he got back from peru he assumed that he got some
00:03:43
tropical parasite from hell michael ferrar was rapidly losing weight dropping to just
00:03:50
125 pounds whatever was causing this illness was a mystery [Music] for a cardiologist who seemingly had it
00:04:06
all dr michael farrar's life in 1995 was one crisis after another when he was released from the hospital
00:04:14
for the illness many believed he caught in peru michael took another step towards
00:04:19
divorce by moving into his own apartment across town his wife deborah was angry depressed
00:04:26
drinking heavily and would stay in her bedroom for days at a time [Music] michael was concerned for her welfare as
00:04:39
well as the safety of their three children while visiting the house to pick up some
00:04:49
of his things michael noticed something suspicious in his wife's purse a packet of castor beans
00:04:58
on the label was a warning that the beans were poisonous with so many packets of castor beans in
00:05:06
her purse michael suspected that his wife was planning to commit suicide so he was telling me that he was pretty
00:05:14
sure she was going to try and kill herself with these poisons which really to me didn't make any sense because dr
00:05:20
green is a bright woman i mean she's extremely bright woman and is an oncologist and if you're a doctor i mean
00:05:28
doctors kill themselves all right i mean in professional people do commit suicide
00:05:32
but fortunately we've got the best of drugs available to us i mean if you're
00:05:36
going to go why would you go stooling yourself to death i mean you aren't going to want to die with
00:05:42
bloody diarrhea i mean that is a very horrible bad way to die dr ferrard decided to do a little
00:05:51
investigating of his own the castor beans were purchased from the earl may garden center
00:05:58
a receipt from that store in deborah's purse indicated she purchased the beans
00:06:03
just four days before michael first got sick while consulting his medical textbook
00:06:11
farrar learned some terrible news that castor beans contain verizon a deadly toxin with no known antidote
00:06:22
and the symptoms of ricin poisoning were vomiting nausea diarrhea and gastrointestinal bleeding
00:06:30
symptoms which were identical to his own [Music] farrar quickly took a sample of his own
00:06:40
blood for testing but ricin leaves the body quickly and the lab could find no trace of it in his
00:06:47
system although he had no proof farrar was convinced that his wife had somehow poisoned him with ricin and this
00:06:58
was the cause of his mysterious symptoms a few days later michael confronted debra during an angry telephone call
00:07:07
i told her that i was very angry with her that i thought she was crazy that i thought she had been poisoning me that i
00:07:16
thought she needed uh serious psychiatric help i don't have to listen to this
00:07:24
[Music] one hour later around midnight a fire broke out in the farrar family home
00:07:32
by the time firemen arrived the home was totally engulfed in flames i've never
00:07:38
seen a fire spread as fast throughout the house as i have on this one the heat was tremendous there was no way that
00:07:46
anyone can even get close to the house of course the flames were roaring out probably 20 to 30 feet
00:07:56
deborah and her ten-year-old daughter jennifer both escaped during questioning on the night of the
00:08:03
fire debra learned the tragic news that her other two children had been trapped and died in the fire oh god
00:08:12
beautiful family beautiful joy are both dead jesus christ did they make any attempt
00:08:19
at all to save her six-year-old kelly died of smoke inhalation in her own bed thirteen-year-old tim
00:08:29
burned to death christ i saved one of the kids and i could have gotten the second one out and
00:08:35
didn't will never forgive myself for that investigators immediately suspected
00:08:43
arson it's fair to say that deborah greene was a suspect early on it's fair to say that
00:08:49
mike farrar was a suspect early on both had motive both had opportunity if the fire had been deliberately set
00:09:00
the charge would be more than arson it would be murder [Music] while investigating the suspicious house
00:09:13
fire that killed tim and kelly farrar police looked a little deeper into the relationship between michael and his
00:09:20
estranged wife deborah a few weeks before the fire the couple had a fight at the house
00:09:26
michael said his wife was intoxicated angry and threatening to kill herself the police were called and took deborah
00:09:34
to the hospital for psychiatric evaluation dr pamela mccoy was the physician on duty
00:09:41
pam mccoy indicated that at first she was somewhat skeptical about whether or not debra green was really that mentally
00:09:46
ill and is sitting there in the uh in the waiting room of the ku medical center emergency room talking to debra
00:09:54
greene about these issues asking her if she's okay if there's anything she can
00:09:59
do to help her and trying to get a read on her mental state when in my in walks michael ferrara when they met in our
00:10:06
kind of entryway there she just like turns on him like she's i mean for a minute i kind of hold her
00:10:12
like i think she's going to physically attack him and she spits at him and calls him a cult and then she says
00:10:19
you're going to get these kids over their dead bodies deborah said she made the statement in
00:10:25
anger and denied having anything to do with the fire [Music] she said she was asleep when the fire
00:10:35
alarm sounded she said she opened the bedroom door saw flames and smoke closed the door and ran
00:10:47
outside through a door in the bedroom [Music] deborah said she told her son tim to
00:10:56
stay inside until firemen arrived and ran to the next door neighbor's house for help
00:11:03
to find out whether an accelerant or flammable liquid was used in starting the fire
00:11:09
arson investigators used specially trained dogs that can identify vapors which remain after the fire this is a
00:11:17
dog that has been through several weeks of training on how to how to detect different types
00:11:23
of liquid accelerants like diesel fuel or kerosene or gasoline or charcoal lighter
00:11:29
fluid the dogs identified a number of suspicious areas investigators found melted plastic
00:11:38
containers on the floor possibly used to carry flammable liquids throughout the house
00:11:44
next to dr farrar's desk investigators found another clue that the fire had been intentionally set
00:11:52
we found an empty liquor bottle laying on the floor right behind this desk again this it's possible
00:12:02
that the contents of this bottle were poured out and ignited on the desk a section of the basement floor had what
00:12:11
appeared to be a poor pattern where an accelerant was ignited as a test the accelerants also gave investigators
00:12:20
a clear path of the fire the path led directly to deborah green's bedroom door
00:12:29
that fire was set at that bedroom door with the intent of doing a tremendous amount of damage
00:12:36
to that house and cutting off the escape route of those children upstairs and the analysis of the burn patterns on
00:12:44
the bedroom door contradicted debra greene's story debra said her bedroom door was closed
00:12:52
when the fire alarm sounded and that she closed the door before running outside for help
00:13:00
but the carpet underneath the door revealed the door had been open the door jamb revealed the same thing
00:13:08
if the door had been closed the door jamb would have been protected from the fire instead
00:13:15
it was completely covered with soot in the bathroom was debra's bathrobe wrapped in a ball
00:13:24
on the floor on the underside of the robe were burn marks at some point the person wearing the
00:13:31
robe had been very close to the flames the neighbors said deborah's hair was
00:13:41
wet when she ran over asking for help this did not come as a surprise to arson investigators
00:13:49
when dr greene actually ignited that accelerant outside of her bedroom door and in the hallway that
00:13:57
there was enough vapors present that there was there was quite a flash more of a flash than she probably was
00:14:03
prepared for when she did that i believe that is when she got the hair singed on the right side of her head
00:14:12
with a search warrant detectives took a sample of deborah's hair microscopic analysis revealed the
00:14:19
deborah's hair showed signs of heat damage consistent with singing from a high intensity flame
00:14:27
the damage to deborah's hair was extensive since the sample wasn't collected until after she had her hair
00:14:33
cut for her children's funeral bill chapin is a forensic chemist whose job was to analyze the fire debris
00:14:41
evidence from the farrar home fire debris is stored in metal canisters which preserve any vapors which may
00:14:48
still be present the canisters are heated to between 80 and 90 degrees centigrade
00:14:55
and the air inside removed if the vapors contain accelerants or hydrocarbons they're trapped in charcoal
00:15:04
filters the filters are then rinsed with the neutral solvent carbon disulfide and the
00:15:10
mixture is placed into a gas chromatograph mass spectrometer for analysis after two days of testing
00:15:19
bill chapin found what he was looking for in this particular case the accelerant
00:15:24
that i found was an accelerant called isoparaffin isoparaffins are often used in odorless
00:15:32
charcoal lighter fluids there was an empty container of charcoal lighter fluid on the floor of the
00:15:38
farar's garage investigators were now convinced that deborah green set the fire that killed
00:15:45
two of her children the only question that remained had she also tried to kill her husband with castor beans
00:15:57
when dr michael ferrar told police he was sure his wife had been poisoning him with castor beans investigators were
00:16:04
unsure of where to start since the local laboratory could find no evidence of ricin and michael ferrara
00:16:11
system his blood was sent to the fbi to dr drew richardson an expert in chemical
00:16:18
and biological research at the naval medical research institute in washington dc people in the intelligence community
00:16:26
are quite familiar with ricin based on a handful of cases that most everybody would know about very few people in the
00:16:32
late public and even highly trained professionals such as medical doctors would be quite unlikely to know much
00:16:38
about rice and if anything ricin is an antigen that causes a breakdown of red blood cells at the
00:16:45
tissue level in large enough doses it can be fatal when an antigen enters the body the
00:16:53
immune system's response is to produce antibodies which fight the invading organism
00:16:58
to find out whether rice and antibodies were in michael ferrara's system dr richardson used a technique called elisa
00:17:07
which stands for enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay a 96-well plastic plate is coated with
00:17:14
the solution containing ricin in theory any rice and antibodies in dr farrar's
00:17:21
blood would bind to the ricin coated on the plate which is exactly what happened
00:17:28
next dr richardson analyzed the blood of goats that had been exposed to small amounts of ricin it appeared that the
00:17:36
goats and michael ferrar both had similar antibodies in their systems antibodies designed and structured to
00:17:44
recognize and seek out the target invader ricin dr richardson discovered something else
00:17:53
the number of rice and antibodies in farrar's system was staggering in the case of dr michael ferrar it's
00:18:00
thought that perhaps he was exposed three times a certain immune response would have been produced the first time
00:18:06
a response would have lasted a few weeks on second and third and perhaps other exposures a separate immune response
00:18:14
would have been produced for each one of those exposures and the latter exposures would have
00:18:20
produced a response and antibodies that would be present in the blood for again many months to perhaps a few years debra
00:18:27
greene was charged with two counts of murder and two counts of attempted murder prosecutors believe that when deborah's
00:18:36
attempts to kill her husband failed she feared losing custody of her children in the impending divorce
00:18:44
i don't have to listen to this after the argument on the telephone prosecutors believe that deborah poured
00:18:56
accelerants throughout the house with special attention to michael's possessions and making sure to cut off
00:19:03
the children's escape route the path of the accelerants led directly to the door of debra green's bedroom
00:19:17
[Music] but she used too much accelerant the vapors ignited causing a mini explosion
00:19:24
that singed her hair while dousing her head with water she saw that her bathrobe had also caught
00:19:33
fire and discarded it ten-year-old jennifer survived by crawling out her bedroom window and
00:19:46
jumping to the ground deborah told tim to stay inside with the six-year-old sister until firemen
00:19:53
arrived sadly tim did what his mother had told him to do he and kelly both died before firemen
00:20:02
could reach them deborah green's trial was scheduled to begin one week after michael's brain
00:20:09
operation to repair damage caused by the rice and poisoning but the trial never took place
00:20:17
deborah greene pleaded no contest to the charges avoiding a possible death sentence
00:20:23
my attorneys are ready willing and able to present evidence that i was not in control of myself when tim and kelly
00:20:29
died however true that may be defending myself at trial on these charges would only compound the suffering of my family
00:20:36
and my daughter she was sentenced to life in prison without possibility of parole
00:20:42
for 40 years well i think these kids in this case were sort of the ultimate pawn
00:20:49
the ultimate weapon that deborah green used in this fight with michael ferrar she in some ways probably loved those
00:20:56
kids in other ways viewed them as an expendable resource to be used in this war [Music]
00:21:18
[Music] so [Applause] [Music] you

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 95
    Most heartbreaking
  • 90
    Most shocking
  • 90
    Biggest twist
  • 85
    Most intense

Episode Highlights

  • Marital Strain
    Michael and Deborah's seemingly perfect life hides deep marital issues and personal struggles.
    “To outsiders, their lives seemed perfect, but the marriage was showing signs of stress.”
    @ 01m 24s
    November 04, 2021
  • Tragic House Fire
    A mysterious house fire claims the lives of two children, leaving the family shattered.
    “Oh god, beautiful family beautiful joy are both dead.”
    @ 08m 12s
    November 04, 2021
  • Suspicion of Arson
    After the fire, both Michael and Deborah become suspects in a potential arson case.
    “Investigators immediately suspected arson.”
    @ 08m 40s
    November 04, 2021
  • Deborah's Confession
    Deborah pleads no contest to charges, avoiding a possible death sentence.
    “I was not in control of myself when Tim and Kelly died.”
    @ 20m 25s
    November 04, 2021
  • Life Sentence
    Deborah is sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for 40 years.
    “She was sentenced to life in prison without possibility of parole for 40 years.”
    @ 20m 38s
    November 04, 2021

Episode Quotes

  • I mean, doctors kill themselves, alright?
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 3 - Ultimate Betrayal - Full Episode
  • Oh god, beautiful family beautiful joy are both dead.
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 3 - Ultimate Betrayal - Full Episode
  • She was the ultimate pawn.
    Forensic Files - Season 4, Episode 3 - Ultimate Betrayal - Full Episode

Key Moments

  • Mysterious Fire00:09
  • Family Tragedy00:18
  • Marital Issues01:24
  • Affair Uncovered02:34
  • Suspicious Beans04:51
  • Fire Erupts07:26
  • Investigation Begins08:40
  • Trial and Sentencing20:07

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown