Search Captions & Ask AI

Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13

March 09, 2017 / 42:54

This episode of Unsolved Mysteries covers several intriguing cases, including the disappearance of businessman Gary Simmons, the murders of two models, a triple shooting in Sacramento, and a haunted farmhouse lawsuit.

The first story involves Gary Simmons, who disappeared after paying $30,000 for a horse. His remains were discovered nearly 20 years later, leading police to suspect foul play related to a bogus horse deal. Tom Dixon, the last person seen with Simmons, also vanished shortly after.

Next, the episode discusses the murders of two models, Kimberly Pandy Leos and Linda Soic, found in the Angeles National Forest. Investigators initially believed the cases were connected to photographer Charles Rathburn, who was later convicted of Linda's murder. A new suspect, David Ramaker, was identified in Kimberly's case, leading to his conviction as well.

The episode then shifts to a triple shooting at a convenience store in Sacramento, where six victims were killed in two separate incidents. Eric Ry Leonard was arrested and convicted for these murders, which police described as execution-style killings.

Finally, the episode features a haunted farmhouse in England where the new owners, the Smiths, sued the previous owners for not disclosing the alleged haunting. The court ruled against the Smiths, concluding that the reported occurrences were likely not supernatural.

TLDR

Businessman disappears after horse deal, models murdered, haunted farmhouse lawsuit, and a triple shooting case are featured in this episode.

Episode

42:54
00:00:00
[Music] next on Unsolved Mysteries a businessman Forks Over $30,000 for a horse and then disappears
00:00:13
his bones are found almost 20 years later what happened two models on two different photo shoots are found dead in
00:00:22
the same area is it the work of the same killer six people are murdered all for no apparent reason the police are
00:00:31
baffled who is the killer finally a family says that the Farmhouse they just bought is haunted so they're suing the
00:00:39
previous owners what do you think the court will decide these are stories you won't want
00:00:46
to miss I'm Dennis finina and this is Unsolved Mysteries [Music] here at Unsolved Mysteries we receive a
00:01:24
lot of viewer mail one of those letters was from a man with an unusual request he was experiencing strange
00:01:33
premonitions which he simply couldn't explain they were about a murder and he
00:01:38
asked us to look into the case Independence Missouri K I don't get off to S you take
00:01:51
it Tyrone Rollins was hired as a school bus driver from the beginning he had an eerie feeling about the Rocky out
00:02:00
croppings behind the bus yard I'd be sitting up in front of my bus and I'd feel like somebody watching
00:02:09
me from behind and I'd look back there and there wouldn't be nobody on the bus
00:02:14
for a while there I just thought I was going crazy this is strong feeling like some
00:02:20
pulling inside me wanting me to do something and I just couldn't figure out what it
00:02:24
was finally Tyrone gave in he simply had to investigate the north side of the Hill there he discovered a hidden
00:02:36
cave that strong feeling was back again I knew I had to go in there for some reason it was like an amazing adrenaline
00:02:48
rush just the feeling of being in there I didn't know if it was from not knowing
00:02:52
what was in there when I shine my flashlight towards the Rocks you could see little tiny specks look like
00:02:57
crystals so I started examining the rocks and it was just then that I Haden to glance over and I seen a pair of
00:03:06
boots was just shocked I just couldn't believe what I was seeing dental records
00:03:12
confirmed that the remains were those of Gary Simmons a businessman from Overland
00:03:17
Park Kansas 25 miles [Music] away an autopsy showed that he was shot in the head Tyrone's incredible Discovery
00:03:29
became a nightmare for the police they were confronted with a killing that happened 17 years earlier an
00:03:37
investigation seemed almost pointless but the police had no choice Gary Simmons was dead and whoever killed him
00:03:45
was still on the loose Neil Gary had owned an operated a lucrative chain of gas stations his
00:03:57
hobby was horse trading yeah beautiful horse Gary always worked hard I believe he got involved in horses in order to
00:04:05
have a form of relaxation and a means of doing something that was fun with his family how you doing just got back from
00:04:13
a show down tuls Oklahoma man I saw some of the most beautiful horses I've seen a
00:04:16
long time is that right to bet anything I might be interested in the day before he disappeared Gary learned of a prized
00:04:23
horse for sale you know Tom Dixon Tom Dixon yeah yeah he had one of the most beautiful purebred appoes I've seen a
00:04:33
long time raised him from a cat how much is he asking for him he's asking $30,000
00:04:38
for [Applause] it hi can I help you yeah I'm here to see Mr Simmons do you have an
00:04:47
appointment uh yeah we talked earlier on the phone uhhuh and your name please Tom
00:04:51
Dixon it was the beginning of a mysterious encounter which lasted all day in which police are still trying to
00:04:59
peace together excuse me Gary there's a Tom Dixon here to see you oh sure hi
00:05:03
Gary a little while later he left his office with Dixon okay uh I'll follow you sure it's a great horse you're going
00:05:10
to love Gary told his secretary that he would return shortly but he didn't say
00:05:15
where he was [Music] going 15 minutes later he called in and asked his secretary to write a check to
00:05:24
Tom Dixon for $30,000 okay 30,000 h hi can I help you with something yeah I'm here to pick up
00:05:32
a check 30 minutes later Dixon picked up the check and walked out of the office yes he did and um I've drawn up the
00:05:39
check but you're going to have to get Gary's signature on it Dixon then took
00:05:43
the check to Gary Simmons for his signature but no one knows where that meeting took
00:05:49
place later Gary was spotted at a truck stop 10 miles from his office the owner saw Gary Simmons
00:05:58
walking back and forth between the counter and the window he remembers that Gary Simmons
00:06:04
was alone and there did not seem to be anybody with him or waiting with him it was the last time anyone saw Gary
00:06:14
alive just before noon Dixon showed up at Gary's Bank Gary Simmons had called
00:06:20
the president of the bank and had informed him that Tom Dixon was on his way to cash the check the bank president
00:06:28
recognized Gary Simmons voice and he did not recognize anything unusual in his voice to raise his suspicions
00:06:36
either around 5 hours later Dixon was seen at a salvage yard 11 M from the bank he was driving Gary's Lincoln
00:06:45
Continental where did you get that link H it's not my car it's something I need
00:06:50
to get rid of I was wondering if you could uh use your machine to sort of crush it for me yeah I can make it flat
00:06:56
for you you want to get rid of it you're going to have to melt fed's been keeping a real close eye on
00:07:03
the furnace you got any uh better ideas yeah put a brick on the accelerator and drive it in the Missouri
00:07:11
River hey thanks for the advice the following day one of Tom Dixon's friends
00:07:15
dropped him off at a truck stop near Kansas City Dixon said that he was catching a ride with a CrossCountry
00:07:22
trucker all right we're ready to go guys no one has seen Tom Dixon since 6 months
00:07:28
went by Gary Simmons Lincoln Continental was pulled from the Missouri River less
00:07:34
than 6 miles from the salvage yard where Dixon tried to get rid of it all you had
00:07:39
was two grown men that had disappeared and that happens every day in America it was unknown whether they had disappeared
00:07:48
and not wanted to be found or if Foul Play had indeed occurred upon finding Gary Simmon's body it became a homicide
00:07:57
investigation police suspected that Gary was the victim of a bogus horse deal that Dixon acting alone or with a
00:08:05
partner stole his money and killed him then during the filming of this story a new witness came forward oh Gary
00:08:14
knew a horse that's for sure he knew what a good horse was and Roy Hilton is
00:08:18
a local Rancher he says that he knew both Gary Simmons and Tom Dixon he claimed that he heard Gary calling his
00:08:26
office and the bank from the whispering Downs horse r on the day he disappeared $3,000 Roy also said that Gary showed
00:08:36
him the horse that he was buying this murder didn't come down over a $30,000
00:08:41
horse deal it had to come down on some black market gas I'm almost positive of
00:08:47
that because Gary was Simmons was having problem getting fuel fore stations Roy Hilton's testimony complicated and
00:08:54
already confusing case Gary was struggling to save his chain of gas stations in the face of saring oil
00:09:01
prices the year before his death Gary closed uh the bar of his stations because of lack of gasoline
00:09:09
after Gary disappeared there was numerous rumors that Gary might have been involved in Black Market
00:09:15
gasoline who murdered Gary Simmons and why a premonition a horse trade gone bad black
00:09:23
market gasoline there may be only one man who knows Tom Dixon this Photograph has been aged to show
00:09:32
how Tom Dixon might look today he is 5' 8 in tall with brown or graying hair and
00:09:38
green eyes he may be working as a house painter or general contractor if you have any information about Tom Dixon or
00:09:45
the murder of Gary Simmons please log on to our website at unsolved.com next two beautiful models are found
00:09:57
murdered 2 years apart could it have been the same killer in the vast Angeles National
00:10:10
Forest of Southern California two bodies are discovered at different times both victims appear to be
00:10:21
models and both were reportedly connected to a photographer named Charles wurn the the similarities are eerie and
00:10:31
investigators are wondering if this is the handiwork of one killer Kimberly Pandy Leos was a
00:10:39
20-year-old aspiring model and actress she was married and had a 14-month-old son she told her husband
00:10:47
that she had been booked to model at an outdoor photo shoot in the Angeles National Forest authorities believed she
00:10:54
responded to an ad in a local [Music] newspaper Kimber torched car was found the following day near the Monte Cristal
00:11:03
Campground in the park a search of the area didn't turn up any clues detectives were stumped and the
00:11:12
case went cold Flash Forward one year the LA County Corner was called to investigate
00:11:19
human bones that had been found in the Angeles National Forest using dental records the coroner
00:11:25
identified the remains as those of Kimberly 2 years later it was a model shoot that
00:11:36
also lured 27-year-old Linda SOC to Angeles National Forest Linda was a successful model and
00:11:44
a former Los Angeles Raiders cheerleader her family and friends were frantic when a few days passed and no
00:11:52
one heard from her police began to focus on Charles wurn after they found his signature on a car rental agreement in
00:11:59
the area of the photo shoot he claimed that Linda soic died in a freak car accident during the
00:12:06
shoot he said he panicked and that he buried her days later Rathburn helped police find Linda's body it was just 5
00:12:15
miles from where Kimberly's body had been found the corer reported Linda's
00:12:19
injuries were not caused by a car update Charles Rathburn has been charged with first-degree murder Rathburn was so
00:12:32
distraught that he tried to kill himself before the trial he was convicted of first-degree
00:12:38
murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole with the conclusion of the soc
00:12:48
murder trial police now focused on tying Rathburn to Kimberly's murder we do have some similarities
00:12:55
between the death of Kimberly pandelos and Linda sobec we we also have a person who has con fored and indicated that
00:13:02
they saw Kimberly pandelos in the company of Charles Rathburn inside a Denny's restaurant shortly before her
00:13:10
murder investigators tried but were unable to link Rathburn to the case and then they finally got the break they
00:13:19
needed update a new witness came forward with information proving that these cases
00:13:26
although similar were not connected Mana senu told police that her boyfriend David ramaker had repeatedly talked
00:13:34
about Kimberly's murder he also threatened to hurt her the same way he hurt Kimberly if she broke up with him
00:13:42
with mana's cooperation the police secretly recorded conversations between mana and ramaker these calls and other
00:13:50
evidence led to his arrest ramaker was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the
00:13:57
possibility of parole in Sacramento California police respond to reports of shots being fired at a convenience store
00:14:14
44 Ed got a man down at the park what we found is that we in fact had a triple shooting a customer been
00:14:24
shot outside the front door two clerks have been shot behind the counter and looking at the scene uh we had the
00:14:30
feeling that there probably was very little conversation between this shooter and his victims and that it appeared he
00:14:36
walked in the store maybe had not said anything to him and simply started shooting and they were all head shots
00:14:42
the one thing that really struck us immediately was it was more an execution not a robbery it seemed like the primary
00:14:48
motive for whoever the shooter was in that case went in there to kill people 35-year-old Steven Anderson a
00:14:55
store employee was dead Anderson was the father of three young Sons two other people were mortally
00:15:03
wounded an employee Zade Ahmad oby and a customer 42-year-old Thor Johnson Senior investigators had no
00:15:15
eyewitnesses there wasn't too much to go on the Killer's identity was a complete
00:15:20
mystery none of the victims were gang members and very little money was taken the detective's first step was to look
00:15:27
through the cash receipts from the night of the killings late that evening a woman left
00:15:33
the store after buying a magazine apparently the next customer was the gunman he bought two 99
00:15:46
items his sales were rung up but never totaled a customer Thor Johnson came to the store just seconds before the killer
00:16:02
left Johnson was shot in the back of the head the biggest feeling we take away from that is just that it was very cold
00:16:10
blooded very unnecessary and we were really concerned that are we looking for somebody who may
00:16:16
do this again can I help you you want some money then exactly one week to the hour
00:16:25
after the convenience stor murders the killer struck again this time he targeted a pizza parlor less than one
00:16:33
mile from the convenience store three employees were closing the restaurant the victims were 18-year-old
00:16:43
Sarah Cook and 19-year-old Kyle Reynolds two local college students and 30-year-old Andrea coladangelo once
00:16:52
again investigators were left with three victims but not a single eyewitness the second event at the pizza parlor
00:17:01
only confirmed our worst fears instead of any kind of traditional motive murder now we were probably dealing with more
00:17:07
of a psychological motive the obvious psychological motive being that here we had a guy who killed because he likes to
00:17:13
kill he was getting a thrill out of killing ballistics reports confirmed that the same weapon a small caliber
00:17:20
pistol was used at both murder scenes the person committing these crimes has little sophistication about weapons uh
00:17:27
you'd get to feeling that it may be someone who may even be a younger person
00:17:32
borrowing the weapon from uh Daddy's nightstand or something of that sort of
00:17:37
nature update after we first broadcast this story 22-year-old Eric Ry Leonard was
00:17:45
arrested for the six murders incredibly Leonard tried to execute all of the possible
00:17:54
Witnesses but his attempts failed and the people who saw him near the crime scene identified him as the
00:18:01
killer police found a 25 caliber Beretta in Leonard's Father's House ballistics test proved that this
00:18:09
was the gun used in all six murders Leonard was convicted on multiple murder charges and sent to death row where he
00:18:17
remains today next debris from an ancient ship is found Frozen in a Turkish Glacier
00:18:26
some believe that it's part of Noah's Ark we've all heard of Noah's Ark it's
00:18:40
one of the best known stories in the Bible and while some people say that it's only a tale others insist that it's
00:18:47
not only true but that there is proof they claim that physical evidence of Noah's Arc has been found on Mount arat
00:18:58
Mount [Music] Ararat according to the Bible the area where Noah's AR came to
00:19:08
rest after the great storm it's a desolate area Rising above the headwaters of the Tigris
00:19:16
River in recent years several Expeditions have explored the Ararat mountains and Incredibly two separate
00:19:23
teams believe that they may have found the Ark in two different locations just 17 mil miles
00:19:29
[Music] apart one of the sites is on Mount ararat's northeast side under a permanent 23 squ M
00:19:39
Glacier a Turkish businessman named George hakopian said that when he was a young boy in 1906 he saw noark wedged in
00:19:48
a melted part of the glacier Hagopian described the vessel to archaeological illustrator Alfred Lee he said it looked
00:19:55
like a long box it's rectangular and the the corners were kind of rounded a little bit the the sides sloped in
00:20:05
slightly the roof he said was basically flat with just a slight pitch to it and there was a stair kind of apparatus at
00:20:14
one end his uncle hoisted him up onto this ladder and he walked on up onto the roof and there all the way down the
00:20:22
middle of the roof he saw these holes and he stuck his head in and it was dark he shouted and his voice echoed
00:20:28
and re-echoed inside it was Hollow George agopian went back a couple years later saw the same thing but ice and
00:20:36
snow were beginning to cover it up again 17 years later Alfred Lee met Ed Davis who was station in Iran with the United
00:20:46
States Army Davis said that he also had seen the ark when Ed Davis started talking the
00:20:55
hair on the back of my head just stood up because I could like hear an echo of George Hagopian from years before Ed
00:21:03
Davis's setting occurred in roughly the same area as George hopan however when
00:21:08
Davis saw what he thought was the ark it had broken into two we waited a while and the fog kind
00:21:17
of lifted and it Shone through kind of a funnel and it showed the Ark in the end
00:21:27
you could see in the end of it and we saw both parts you stand there with your mouth wide open Ed Davis described three
00:21:36
decks inside and large cages on the bottom deck smaller cages on the second deck and on the roof a venting system
00:21:46
with many holes so that you could see how the light and ventilation can go clear to the bottom deck in this
00:21:53
illustration Alfred Lee reconciled the two accounts the intact AR is George Hagopian sighting in 1906 and below are
00:22:02
the two pieces described by Ed Davis although Hagopian and Davis weren't able to pinpoint the exact
00:22:10
locations their stories intrigued amateur archaeologist Don shaki I can't think of anything more
00:22:17
exciting that I could be doing in my lifetime than having a small part in seeing this whatever it is verified and
00:22:25
we have good reason to believe it's there's something there we we got we got
00:22:29
to prove it Don shaki launched an expedition to mount aret after studying classified us
00:22:36
satellite photos for 3 Days Don and his guides climbed up the Mountain's South Side our
00:22:47
whole goal was to get to the spot over the top down the glaciers to this particular location and verify what the
00:22:54
satellite information had told us the Turkish government prevented them from traveling to the north side so ahed a
00:23:02
Turkish guide continued on by himself Ahmed crusted Mount aret and started down the North Slope at an elevation of
00:23:10
nearly 16,000 ft he spotted something half buried in the snow from a distance of 300 y he took
00:23:20
this photograph which seems to show the end of a rectangular object with a peak roof
00:23:27
he came back and and I said is anything showing he said a coup a coupe and I said what are you talking about I me a
00:23:34
coup a coup like a chicken cou oh he kind of had a pointed top and he said that you could see the outline of it in
00:23:41
the side he said in all of my years he have never seen anything like it he said there's some artifact there Don shaki
00:23:49
believed that AMT might have glimpsed the remains of Noah's Ark shaki returned
00:23:55
to the states and took the photograph the forensic anthropol ologist Dr Jim Ebert it certainly does not look natural
00:24:03
it looks very strikingly man-made to me uh what I see uh when I look at this is something that stands out from the rest
00:24:12
of the uh terrain and that is a what looks like a solid uh structure you'll never know until you get up there and
00:24:22
can see it and stand next to it shaki returned to Mount Ararat and studied the mount M from the air unfortunately the
00:24:30
site was now covered by snow shaki stopped his search but remained convinced that he might have
00:24:37
found the resting place of Noah's Ark others disagreed we've been told for
00:24:43
years that the Noah's Ark is on top of Mount arat because that's what the Bible
00:24:47
says and that's not what the Bible says uh the Bible says the ark came to rest
00:24:51
uh on upon the mountains of aat that word is in the plural David fossil was a former Merchant Marine officer and
00:24:59
Merchant Salvage expert he believes that the ark was buried here a full 17 Mi south of Mount Ararat fossils teams
00:25:08
searched the area and discover traces of iron which do not appear to be natural deposits every 20 to 30 in uh
00:25:19
approximately we have the remains of an iron fitting or an iron pin of sorts that are still there in the soil and
00:25:25
discernible well this is uh one of uh 5 400 iron fittings uh that we've located
00:25:31
of course we haven't pulled them all out of the boat uh it's been it's been cut
00:25:34
in half by a diamond saw scanned by electron microscopes at Los Alamos National Laboratory and um this
00:25:41
particular iron fitting is 94. 84% man-made rod iron looking at the mound from above the iron deposits form a
00:25:51
distinct pattern of intersecting lines which fossil believes is the framework of the arc the bolts length is 515 ft
00:26:00
and the width averages 85 ft the same measurements recorded in the Bible given the shape of the thing and the size of
00:26:07
the thing and where where they found it I mean if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck until somebody finds
00:26:12
something else uh what else could it possibly be but Noah's Arc are the metal fittings remnants of
00:26:19
Noah's Ark some have suggested that David fossil found the remains of an ancient
00:26:26
Mongol Fort others say it's a geological formation however the Turkish government
00:26:33
has declared the mound the official site where no is Arc rests the man who is in
00:26:39
charge Professor Sali Bak tutan uh who is also a geologist he says it's it's
00:26:45
Noah as Arc 200% it is not a geological anonyyymous more exploration and Analysis before
00:27:00
we'll know the answer but for now noark remains an intriguing and Elusive unsolved
00:27:08
[Music] mystery next a 21-year-old college student is missing after a night of partying who's responsible for her
00:27:20
disappearance one spring afternoon in kusada Louisiana Carol and Luke long received a
00:27:36
call from a friend of their 21-year-old daughter Wendy good listen I have Wendy's car I just want to know how to
00:27:42
get it back to you guys where's Wendy hie honey Wendy drove to sheveport to shop and to party with her friends for
00:27:50
the weekend her parents expected her home by Sunday afternoon instead they received the news
00:27:58
that Wendy had disappeared I thought you was with you no I haven't seen her since Friday night
00:28:05
we called the police and told them that we thought something had happened to Wendy and that's where it all started
00:28:12
somebody knows where Wendy's said and we just want to find her so bad Wendy long
00:28:19
had taken a semester off from college and planned to return in the fall at the time of her disappearance she was living
00:28:26
with her parents one of her flaws may have been that she's too trusting she thought everybody she met was her
00:28:34
friend she was one of those people that made friends with everybody sweetie shortly afternoon Wendy left her
00:28:44
parents home driving her own car and headed to shreport 50 mi from kusada on the way she picked up two
00:28:52
friends from nakatosh after an afternoon of shopping the three picked up another friend Tommy
00:29:00
who lived in the shreport area nothing how's it going later that evening they
00:29:05
arrived at a Shri Port party there was drinking at the party uh and I'm told that Wendy had quite a bit
00:29:13
to drink that night so that when it came time for them to take Tommy back home she didn't want
00:29:21
to drive in fact she didn't want to go with them at all she decided to stay where she was are you okay to drive her
00:29:28
two friends that she came to shreport with drove Tommy back to where he was staying at the
00:29:33
time after dropping Tommy off Wendy's friends got into trouble their statement is that they
00:29:40
went to get some food and they were stopped by a state trooper and one of the friends was arrested for
00:29:48
DBI and taken to the Benton jail Tommy told the police that he was concerned that Wendy might be stranded at the
00:29:55
party so he drove his own car back to to the party and picked Wendy up on the way to kushat he stopped for
00:30:04
gas and a qut of oil when he came back out of the the gas station Wendy was talking to two young
00:30:15
men in a black Chevy truck hey Tommy come here this is Mike and zance Tommy said that it appeared that
00:30:23
she knew them and Wendy told Tommy at that point not to worry about it that she was going to go with them and they
00:30:29
were going to get her home are you sure you know these guys I yes I'm sure I
00:30:33
know these guys I will get home okay just go home all right Tommy said that that was
00:30:41
the last time that he saw Wendy Tommy agreed to take a polygraph test which he passed Tommy did extremely well on the
00:30:53
polygraph uh the polygraph examiner himself was very impressed with him and the details that he could remember
00:31:01
at that point they decided that it would be beneficial to hypnotize Tommy to see
00:31:07
what else he could remember under hypnosis Tommy provided a more detailed description of the black Chevy pickup
00:31:14
truck and the two men a police artist produced these sketches but no one came forward to
00:31:23
identify them on the day after Wendy vanished her ex-boyfriend claimed that he received a
00:31:30
message from Wendy on his answering machine hey Mark this is Wendy this is a really bad connection hear me hello he
00:31:39
said that the it sounded like she was on a cell phone and he didn't hear everything that she said he did clearly
00:31:47
hear uh the words this is Wendy he said the rest of it was very staticy and he erased the
00:31:54
message at that time he didn't even know that Wendy was Miss missing Wendy Long's
00:32:00
missing person's case is filled with many more questions than answers a key question involved another
00:32:08
of Wendy's ex-boyfriends just tell me who you were with last Friday night there are quite a few reports that
00:32:15
indicate that there was some physical violence in between them no the thing that concerns me about
00:32:25
Wendy's exboyfriend is the fact that another girlfriend of his came up missing years prior to this
00:32:35
and that she was never found but Wendy's ex-boyfriend apparently had an alibi the boyfriend
00:32:42
cannot be placed in shreport anytime that Friday or Saturday um I consider him to be suspect
00:32:52
only because of the prior things that happened for Wendy Long's parents the nightmare that began with a single phone
00:32:59
call continued we've had people call and said that they've been praying for us
00:33:04
and praying for Wendy I'm just trusting God to answer our prayers and to lead us
00:33:10
to wherever windy might be update 5 months after Wendy's disappearance a surprising
00:33:19
development Tommy whose real name is Robert Stewart was arrested for check fraud
00:33:27
police asked more questions they focused on the inconsistencies in the story that
00:33:31
he had told about the last time that he saw Wendy long investigators said that Robert Stewart Alias Tommy eventually
00:33:39
broke down confessed to the murder and pinpointed the location of Wendy's body Stuart pled guilty to the rape and
00:33:47
murder of Wendy long and was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole next
00:33:58
it seemed like the classic English Farmhouse an oasis of peace and quiet and then the nightmare
00:34:06
[Music] began in the beautiful English Countryside sits Lowe's Cottage a 250y
00:34:22
old farmhouse that some say leaves its guests with an impression that is quite haunting it's very frightening we we
00:34:32
think the place is haunted we've seen ghosts we've had articles thrown about
00:34:37
we've seen candles move all the time the inside of your stomach's churning up uh
00:34:44
expecting something to happen even when it's quiet you're still on edge The
00:34:49
Smiths are not only scared they're also angry they're suing the former owners
00:34:54
for selling them a haunted house and the former owners are counter suing they say
00:35:00
the Smiths are making the whole thing up so they don't have to pay for the house
00:35:05
and now a court must decide is the house really haunted Andrew Smith and his wife Josie
00:35:14
moved their family to an old farmhouse in the village of upper Mayfield they thought that it would be
00:35:21
the perfect place to raise their two children in the about 6 weeks after moved in we
00:35:28
noticed things happening but if you stand over here it's really cold you'd
00:35:34
walk into our bedroom when the temperature would be a couple of degrees lower than the rest of the house
00:35:38
definite temperature drop the rooms you could never really see the ceiling there
00:35:43
was always this hazy it was always hazy but the former owners two sisters who grew up in the cottage say that they
00:35:51
never experienced anything out of the ordinary our parents myself and myself sister never saw any ghosts or heard any
00:36:01
strange noises or anything associated with the Paranormal I don't think it's
00:36:06
haunted I would lived there for about 25 years never saw anything heard anything but the Smiths insisted that
00:36:17
living there was a [Music] nightmare you get this feeling when you're in the room that if this thing
00:36:29
was a person with its little finger it could flick you straight across the room one night we stayed awake till about
00:36:36
3:00 in the morning then we just fell asleep through exhaustion and within minutes of us falling asleep I felt this
00:36:42
pressure on my throat strangling [Applause] me when Josie was being strangled that
00:36:56
was that's what you call Fe that was that made my hair shoot straight up one
00:37:02
night I was in the kitchen that was downstairs it was about 8:00 at night and I turned around and I saw this young
00:37:10
girl she had the old gathered top with the body on the gathered skirt and I thought oh there's somebody outside it
00:37:19
wasn't until I thought about it that I realized I could see the window frame
00:37:22
through her the former owner Sandra padmore says no way that's rubbish absolute rubbish we never
00:37:31
saw any Ghosts no unusual happenings there was nothing flying around rooms there was no vile smells and
00:37:39
Mists nothing at all the Smiths however were worried that they were up against some sort of demon
00:37:48
we have requests that come from uh individuals who are very deeply upset to people who have buildings that causing
00:37:55
them problems you know various smells apparitions anything really that is to do with the
00:38:01
supernatural Lowe's Cottage comes out fairly near at the top of the list of this The Smiths then asked the Reverend
00:38:09
marford to bless their home to R this house of all evil after the Vic could bless the place the house just lit up
00:38:18
everywhere it just seems so light when when you see the reaction to a prayer in the house that's when you
00:38:27
kind of really amazed and there's no two ways about it there's definitely
00:38:32
something The Smiths believe the Vicar's prayers would finally bring them peace
00:38:37
but later that [Music] evening doing I don't know perhaps you left the timer
00:38:51
on switch it off me okay then the Smith's talk to their neighbors so you're the young couple
00:39:00
that's taken over L's Cottage this is a story about that cage you know the Smith soon found out that
00:39:09
everyone else in town seemed to know about the tragic history of Lowe's Cottage except for
00:39:15
them during the 1860s a milkmaid named Elaine Herring lived in the cottage with her lover Joseph
00:39:26
Phillips the Smiths checked the town records and discovered that indeed the young couple really had existed Elaine
00:39:34
was murdered by her employer and died in the cellar of Lowe's cottage which is now the
00:39:41
kitchen when Joseph Phillips heard about Elaine's death he hung himself in despair or so The Story Goes The Cottage
00:39:50
isn't taunted the cottage has no reputation in Upper Mayfield of being haunted or in ashborne for that matter
00:39:57
it's all untrue there's no record whatsoever of Elaine Harring and Josie
00:40:02
Phillips ever living at Lowe's Cottage then local newspapers began writing stories about the hauntings as a result
00:40:09
the bank refused to refinance their house saying that the publicity had decreased the home's value so the Smiths
00:40:16
filed a lawsuit against Susan Melbourne and Sandra pador had we known any of this any of at
00:40:25
all we wouldn't have bought the place we wouldn't have stayed clear of it we
00:40:29
should have been given the choice if anybody had bought our house instead of us with a weak heart I'm sure it would
00:40:34
have killed them the Two Sisters thought that the whole thing was ridiculous absolute rubbish nothing happened at
00:40:41
Lo's Cottage Mr Mrs Smith are have come up with this story about the ghost um to
00:40:48
try and get out of pain The Smiths hired two paranormal investigators to videotape their home
00:40:58
they'd hop to get evidence to support their case the investigators used a night vision camera and placed two
00:41:05
candles to capture evidence of a haunting suddenly the lower candle tumbled down the stairs and the other
00:41:14
candle flew through the air was well literally scared to death we didn't know what to think what to do
00:41:23
but you just definitely got the presence that there was somebody with you they definitely not imagining it because
00:41:29
we've had the experience we definitely believe that they should have told us the house is
00:41:35
haunted we have got to tell people if anybody should anybody in their right mind want to buy our house we have got
00:41:41
to tell them what has happened and the fact that it's haunted and I think the
00:41:44
same should apply to them update the court battle went on for years finally the arguments concluded
00:41:53
and the English judge reached the verdict in less than 5 minutes he ruled against the
00:42:00
Smiths he concluded that the unearthly happenings were most likely the work of a person and not a ghost since then
00:42:07
there have been no reported ghostly sightings [Music] [Music]

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Biggest twist
  • 75
    Most intense
  • 70
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • The Mysterious Disappearance
    Gary Simmons vanishes after a horse deal, leading to a chilling investigation.
    “$30,000 for a horse and then disappears.”
    @ 00m 09s
    March 09, 2017
  • The Haunting Discovery
    Tyrone Rollins uncovers a hidden cave and a shocking secret inside.
    “I knew I had to go in there for some reason.”
    @ 02m 36s
    March 09, 2017
  • A Chilling Pattern
    Two models found dead years apart raises questions of a serial killer.
    “Could it have been the same killer?”
    @ 10m 00s
    March 09, 2017
  • Murder Charges
    Charles Rathburn is convicted of first-degree murder in a shocking case.
    “Rathburn was so distraught that he tried to kill himself before the trial.”
    @ 12m 32s
    March 09, 2017
  • The Search for Noah's Ark
    Expeditions claim to have found evidence of Noah's Ark in Turkey.
    “We have good reason to believe it’s there.”
    @ 22m 27s
    March 09, 2017
  • Noah's Ark Discovery?
    David Fossil believes he found Noah's Ark's resting place, challenging biblical claims.
    “What else could it possibly be but Noah's Ark?”
    @ 26m 10s
    March 09, 2017
  • Wendy Long's Disappearance
    A college student vanishes after a night of partying, leaving her family desperate for answers.
    “Wendy's missing person's case is filled with many more questions than answers.”
    @ 32m 02s
    March 09, 2017
  • Haunted House Lawsuit
    The Smiths sue former owners over a haunted house, claiming they were misled about its history.
    “We definitely believe that they should have told us the house is haunted.”
    @ 41m 33s
    March 09, 2017

Episode Quotes

  • It was a nightmare for the police.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13
  • This murder didn’t come down over a $30,000 horse deal.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13
  • There may be only one man who knows.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13
  • What else could it possibly be but Noah's Ark?
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13
  • Wendy's missing person's case is filled with many more questions than answers.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13
  • We definitely believe that they should have told us the house is haunted.
    Unsolved Mysteries with Dennis Farina - Season 2, Episode 13

Key Moments

  • Disappearance00:09
  • Haunted Farmhouse00:37
  • Murder Investigation03:29
  • Noah's Ark Discovery18:23
  • Noah's Ark Theory24:59
  • Wendy's Disappearance27:30
  • Haunted House34:14
  • Court Battle41:50

Tension Over Time

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown