I Kissed Dating Goodbye Part 3: Purity Culture’s 4-Step Plan for Control | #45

Ex-Homeschoolers Club

  • Jul 31, 2025
  • 1:33:16
  • Full Episode

This week I'm diving into Part 3 of I Kissed Dating Goodbye by Joshua Harris—a section packed with so-called "practical tools" for keeping Christian teens pure. Spoiler: it's just more purity culture with a fresh coat of patriarchal paint.

In this episode, I unpack chapters 8 through 11, covering Harris’s infamous four-step plan for building godly relationships. We look at what it means to “start with a clean slate,” why he thinks you need your parents’ permission to date, and the mental gymnastics required to avoid every ounce of human attraction. I also share personal stories about awkward birthday ceremonies, homeschool dating dynamics, and how being taught to distrust your own body messes you up well into adulthood. This one’s heavy but important—especially if you're trying to untangle the emotional damage of purity culture.

*In This Episode, I Cover:* - The “Four Steps” to godly dating and why they don’t hold up - How purity culture reinforces shame, secrecy, and lack of bodily autonomy - My own cringe memories of gendered homeschool rituals and toxic birthday parties - How mentorship, boundaries, and even lust are twisted in this framework - Redefining intimacy, friendship, and trust outside of evangelical fear-mongering

*Want More Like This?* Subscribe to Ex-Homeschoolers Club wherever you get your podcasts, leave a rating or review (it helps a ton!), and join the newsletter (⁠https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/subscribe⁠)  for show updates, behind-the-scenes notes, and community discussion.

If this episode brought back memories or stirred something in you, I’d love to hear your story. Share your thoughts with me on Instagram (⁠https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/⁠)  or drop me an email at ⁠[email protected]

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub Email me at [email protected]

Brief Summary

Jacob Gooden critiques Joshua Harris's "I Kiss Dating Goodbye," discussing purity culture and the complexities of romantic relationships.

Key points

  • Four Steps to God's Plan. Jacob outlines the four steps for a godly lifestyle in relationships.
  • The Dangers of Mentorship. Jacob warns about the potential pitfalls of seeking mentorship in relationships.
  • The Reality of Media Influence. Criticism of media's portrayal of love and relationships raises questions about societal expectations. 'Don't put up with it. Tune it out.'
  • Navigating Attraction and Friendship. Finding balance between friendship and romantic feelings can be challenging. 'Finding that balance is anything but easy.'
  • Understanding Intimacy. Exploring the difference between friendship and intimacy reveals deeper connections. 'We need to redefine what intimacy truly means.'
  • The Importance of Self-Care. Discussing the need for self-care amidst a culture of constant service.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

More from Ex-Homeschoolers Club