A Public School Teacher's Honest Take on Homeschooling

Want to be alerted when new episodes drop? Join the newsletter: https://exhsclub.beehiiv.com/

In this episode of Ex-Homeschoolers Club, I sit down with my cousin Amanda, a second-grade public school teacher with 13 years of classroom experience, to explore education from the “dark side.” Haha!

Amanda shares what it’s really like inside today’s public schools: what works, what’s frustrating, and what’s changed over the last decade. From student teaching stories to advocating for kids who need services, she offers an honest look at the realities teachers face, including funding challenges, inclusion classrooms, and navigating parents who are (and aren’t) involved.

We also talk candidly about homeschooling; the myths, the shifts in perception, and the surprising reality that even a public school teacher might consider homeschooling her own children.

*Key Points* • Why Amanda believes second grade is the “sweet spot”  • What student teaching really looks like (including full classroom takeover) • How public education has shifted in the last 13 years • The reality of funding and where resources actually go • Why parental involvement makes a massive difference • The biggest myth Amanda had about homeschooling • Why she’s now reconsidering homeschooling for her own kids • What kids actually remember about school (hint: not the standards)

If this episode hit home, share it with a parent, teacher, or anyone who's ever wondered what's really going on in our schools. Leave a comment and tell Jacob what landed for you.

*Connect with Me* Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exhsclub/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@exhsclub Email me at [email protected]

*Chapters* 00:00 Why She Loves Teaching the Little Ones (Kinder–3rd Vibes) 00:42 Growing Up Public Schooled: Favorite Teachers & Loving School 02:40 When the ‘I Want to Teach’ Lightbulb Turned On 05:15 College Path + Getting Credentialed (5-Year Track) 06:36 Student Teaching Stories: Kindergarten, 6th Grade & Full Class Takeover 09:43 13 Years in the Classroom: Landing in 2nd Grade for Good 10:47 Why Second Grade Is the Sweet Spot: Independence & Interests Bloom 13:23 Which Grades Are ‘Best’ to Teach? (And Why Junior High Is a No) 15:19 Homeschooling From the Other Side: Myths, Social Life & Changing Views 18:19 Homeschool Reality Check: Isolation, Co-ops, and Different Kids Thrive Differently 20:00 How Public School Has Changed: Funding, Services, and Advocating for Kids 23:14 Fighting for Students Without Support at Home 23:40 Where the Money Goes: New Schools vs. Student Services 25:32 Is Public Education ‘Broken’? Advocacy & Community Support 26:21 Parents: Get Involved, Ask Questions, Know Your Rights 29:39 Beyond Parents: Voting, Bonds, and Showing Up to Board Meetings 32:03 Has a Public School Teacher Considered Homeschooling? 34:10 Homeschool Reality Check: Space, Structure, and the Mom/Teacher Blur 36:44 How Much Freedom Do Teachers Have? Standards, Pacing, and Customization 40:57 What Kids Actually Remember: Hands-On Learning Over Test Prep 42:36 Final Takeaway: Whatever You Choose, Stay Involved 44:29 Wrap-Up, Thanks, and Call to Action