00:00:00
Tonight on Dateline. We heard all this talk around the town that Jessie was dead.
00:00:05
To know that the last moments that she spent on this earth, she was in so much fear.
00:00:09
It's not fair. If he's still out there, he could still be plotting, he could still be hunting.
00:00:17
Who's next? Jessie gave her all. To everything she did. She was on a mission her whole life.
00:00:26
And then someone took it all away. I was like, Jesse? Nothing. I jiggled for a little bit, and then I knew, this is not good.
00:00:35
What's the problem? My daughter won't wake up. She had been murdered in her own bed after coming home from a pool party, a party that hadn't been all fun and games.
00:00:46
She was 19, and these were men in their 40s. We wanted to talk to them. Did something happen at that party? What was happening around this small town?
00:00:55
I hear somebody running behind me. Then I noticed he had a knife in his hand. Someone was stalking young women.
00:01:03
It was either I try to save myself or let this guy do whatever he wants to me. His dreams were their nightmares.
00:01:11
There were searches on serial killers, searches on bondage. Could he be caught before he killed again?
00:01:17
Oh my God, I knew he had done it. Now I needed to go out and prove it. I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.
00:01:25
Here's Andrea Canning with Obsession. She was a young woman who devoted her whole life to making music.
00:01:46
An accomplished musician who played several instruments, acted, even wrote her own songs.
00:01:55
That was her biggest passion. She saw music as a way to change the world. That's the only friend I had that sang and did all the violin and piano.
00:02:02
It's got a really unique sound. Yeah. So who could have predicted that on July 15, 2013,
00:02:09
the music and a young girl's dreams would end so suddenly? We were in shock and disbelief.
00:02:17
It was hard to understand and to come to grips with. Oh my God, oh my God, oh my God.
00:02:24
A small town was faced with a mystery, with police asking what was real and what was a performance.
00:02:35
He's an actor. He's two different people. Who is this guy? Who does he think he is that he can go around doing this to women?
00:02:43
Ask anyone who knew Jessie Blodgett growing up in Hartford, Wisconsin, and they'll tell you she was happy, passionate, full of life.
00:02:52
Her dad, Buck, says she had always been that way. Did she have a happy childhood?
00:02:56
Oh, yeah. I'll show you 600 photos on my computer. You can be able to count on one hand the ones you can find where she's not beaming and smiling.
00:03:05
She was a really happy kid. Jessie, an only child, was the light of her parents' lives, their miracle baby.
00:03:12
Buck and Joy Blodgett thought they couldn't have children, so they cherished their little girl that much more.
00:03:18
We bonded from day one when that little purple head came out. and every day since.
00:03:23
We talked about drugs, we talked about sex. There was nothing off limits. And her mom says Jessie's friends were like part of the family.
00:03:30
They always seemed to hang out at our house. Yeah, we did. She would find any reason to throw a party.
00:03:38
Ian, Jackie, and Amelia were three of Jessie's closest high school pals. We all just kind of hit it off right away, I guess.
00:03:44
Hard not to. I mean, she has a really contagious personality. But Jessie also had a more serious side,
00:03:50
one that loved to debate issues and fight for causes she believed in. Jessie sounds a little like an old soul.
00:03:58
Is that fair? She liked old people stuff? Yeah, she did. I don't really know much high schoolers that are super activists about animal rights.
00:04:05
She made herself well-versed in just a lot of different opinions and viewpoints.
00:04:15
Jessie wanted to make a difference. That much was clear. But what made her happiest was sharing her gift.
00:04:23
Every time I went over to Jess's house, she would always be playing the piano. Even though when I was trying to talk to her, she'd be like,
00:04:27
I'm like, hello, Jessie. Jessie's passion for music grew even stronger in college.
00:04:34
In the summer after her freshman year, she teamed up with an old boyfriend and theater pal, Dan.
00:04:40
And together, they wrote this heartfelt song. We had a music room, he had a music room at his house.
00:04:55
So he'd bring his guitar and they both sang. That summer, Jesse also won the title role in the local production of Fiddler on the Roof.
00:05:03
Jerry Becker directed the show. Did she just fully embrace it? She did. She enjoyed being the person who really opens the show and sets the mood, sets the feeling.
00:05:14
It was July 14th, after the Sunday matinee. Jesse and the cast gathered for a pool party.
00:05:23
He went out to a cast member's farm. He had a pool and some llamas and other animals there.
00:05:29
I left early with my family, and I remember her sitting there and said goodnight and thanked her for her performance.
00:05:35
She came home around what time? It was late, 12.30, I believe. You were still awake?
00:05:41
I waited up for her. I couldn't go to sleep until I heard that she was in the house.
00:05:45
They chatted briefly and said goodnight. The next morning, Jessie's mom popped into her daughter's room before work
00:05:52
and saw Jessie still fast asleep. Nothing that you would ever think was odd when you left I would imagine No and this was her first morning to sleep in in a very long time Joy returned home for lunch and saw that Jessie wasn downstairs ready for her afternoon violin lesson
00:06:10
I went to the top of the stairs and I was like, Jessie? Nothing. So then I went in, I came around the bed and then I kind of jiggled her a little bit and nothing.
00:06:25
and then I knew, this is not good. This is not good. Joy made a frantic call to 911.
00:06:32
What's the problem? My daughter is blue. I went to wake her up, and I just got home for lunch, and she won't wake up.
00:06:41
Is she breathing? I don't think so, no. Okay, you're trying to do CPR? I'm trying to just pump her chest.
00:06:48
Just hours before, she had seen her daughter sleeping peacefully. Now Joy, a chiropractor, was fighting to save Jessie's life.
00:06:57
Your mother instincts were kicking in and your doctor instincts. Yeah. I just kept thinking, oh, she fell asleep and stopped breathing in the pillow or something.
00:07:08
As Joy moved Jessie to the floor to better perform CPR, first responders arrived.
00:07:14
Did you at that point start to feel her slip away, that hope was dwindling fast?
00:07:19
I think I just was thinking, they'll do it. They'll take her to the hospital. Oh, God, they can do all kinds of stuff, you know.
00:07:27
But they never took Jessie to the hospital. It was too late. She was gone. A tragedy and now a mystery.
00:07:36
What happened to Jessie Blodgett? When we come back, when Jessie got home that night from the party, she was upset.
00:07:45
What's going on? She said, oh, the guys, you know. What about the guys? Joy Blodgett had come home for lunch and discovered her 19-year-old daughter, Jessie, dead in her own bed.
00:08:10
Jessie's father was at work. You had to call your husband. I wanted to let him know as soon as possible
00:08:18
because I knew how much he loved his little girl and I knew I had to get on the phone and tell him as soon as possible.
00:08:22
But I didn't want to get him on the phone until I knew for sure. She said, honey, honey, honey, it's Jesse.
00:08:28
Then she busted out crying and I knew something was really, really wrong. I said, is she gone?
00:08:35
And joy, no more words came, just tears. So I raced home. But when Buck arrived home,
00:08:42
Police cars and a crime scene truck were already in the driveway. I went in the door through the yellow tape,
00:08:49
and when I saw Joy's eyes in the living room, then I knew that Jess was gone. Did you quickly ask how? How did this happen?
00:08:57
No. My whole first thing was I wanted to see her. I wanted to touch her. I wanted to tell her goodbye.
00:09:06
But they wouldn't let me. Buck wasn't allowed in Jesse's room because police were in there
00:09:11
trying to figure out what had happened. Detective Richard Thickens of the Hartford Police Department
00:09:17
was one of the first on the scene. He looked around, saw a typical teenager's messy bedroom.
00:09:23
Nothing strange there, but when he saw Jessie's body, it was clear to the detective that Jessie didn't die of natural causes.
00:09:31
The first thing I noticed was there was a very red mark running pretty much all the way across her neck.
00:09:37
Did you need an autopsy to tell you what you were seeing? No, it was very apparent that this was a ligature mark at that point.
00:09:45
Jessie had been murdered, strangled. But inside her bedroom, there was no murder weapon, no sign of a struggle.
00:09:53
Except one thing did seem odd about Jessie's bed. The covers were over the bed in a perfect manner.
00:10:00
And a kid who had stuff strewn all over the bed, there was nothing on the bed. It was very apparent that the scene had been changed.
00:10:05
This is certainly a possibility of somebody trying to ensure that they didn't leave anything of themselves behind.
00:10:12
Did they finally let you go upstairs when they had finished to say a proper goodbye?
00:10:17
They released her room as a crime scene at the end of the day and brought her down.
00:10:24
And after waiting all day and finally getting my moment to say goodbye and tell her I love her and tell her I'm sorry,
00:10:31
suddenly everybody's around watching me. And I never really had that moment with her alone to say goodbye.
00:10:39
That is heartbreaking. Yeah. Having barely digested the news of their daughter's death and still in shock,
00:10:49
Buck and Joy sat down with investigators to tell them everything they knew. There was no sign of forced entry to the house,
00:10:55
but they explained, like most people in this quiet, safe town, they often left a door unlocked.
00:11:01
This individual found that one door. The house wasn't ransacked. It looked to us that this person knew right where to go to find her.
00:11:12
To the detective, it didn't seem random. It was clear Jesse was targeted. One of Buck's first thoughts, a crew of tree cutters that recently worked outside Jesse's window.
00:11:23
It made me wonder if they had had thoughts when they were in the trees, liminar trees above her bedroom and she was sleeping in there.
00:11:29
just wondered if they noticed that here's this teenage girl sleeping home alone when Joey and I are at work while they're in our yard.
00:11:37
Bach also told the detectives about a problem Jesse was having at her part-time restaurant job,
00:11:42
trouble with a co-worker. She had come home a couple times and said that he was inappropriate with her.
00:11:48
What was he doing that was inappropriate? He would often make sure that she had to rub against him as she passed him That must make you nuts as a parent when you hear stories like that When I first heard that I was almost out that door to go over and talk to him The restaurant was just down the road
00:12:05
It seemed possible that this co-worker Jesse found creepy knew where she lived, had been watching the house.
00:12:12
Certainly we're going to take any possibility. We don't want to close any avenues of investigation at that point.
00:12:19
Then Joy told the detective something that really caught their attention. Jessie had come home from that fiddler-on-the-roof cast party, clearly upset.
00:12:29
I said, what's going on? She said, oh, the guys, you know, they're always making passes,
00:12:35
and I don't know why they have to always turn it to there. Jessie told her mom two older men from the cast were flirting with her,
00:12:43
and it made her uncomfortable. One pulled her on his lap. The other told a dirty joke.
00:12:49
At the time, Joy thought the flirtations seemed harmless, and her young daughter simply didn't know how to handle it.
00:12:55
She didn't like men taking, you know, privileges on women. But perhaps the incidents were more serious than her mother thought.
00:13:04
Jesse wrote about them in her diary that night, ending her final entry with God Be With Me.
00:13:09
She was 19 and from what Joy understood, these were men in their 40s. Is that a bit of a red flag for you?
00:13:17
Can be. We wanted to talk to him. Detective Thickens could see the pretty, talented teenager could attract unwanted male attention.
00:13:26
Now he had to figure out if any of it had to do with Jesse's murder. Coming up, a possible suspect.
00:13:34
Someone that was flirting with her less than 24 hours before her death. We thought it was him. I mean, who else could have been?
00:13:41
When Dateline continues. It was hard to believe a murder like this could happen in peaceful Hartford, Wisconsin,
00:14:01
let alone to a warm and loving teenager like Jessie Blodgett. Within hours of her death, word had spread.
00:14:08
Jessie's close friends, Jackie and Amelia, raced to the Blodgett house. We drove up her driveway and her parents were standing outside and they said,
00:14:16
Jessie's no longer with us anymore. Was that when it became real for you? It was just...
00:14:24
I don't know, it was just like... really shocking, I guess. It's probably the worst pain that anyone could ever feel.
00:14:37
Jesse's theater director, Jerry Becker, was also stunned, having just celebrated with Jesse in the cast of Fiddler on the Roof the night before.
00:14:46
The best way to describe it is simply surreal. That kind of thing doesn't happen here.
00:14:50
And to someone like Jesse. Exactly. Jesse was someone you could not imagine a bad thing happening to.
00:14:58
Finding Jesse's killer became the police department's number one priority. This is a girl that's been attacked at her home where she should be safe.
00:15:06
And I think that it definitely did put people on edge. Detectives talked with cast members from Fiddler on the Roof
00:15:13
and heard again how Jesse had been upset after the cast party. in particular with one man named Randy Talley.
00:15:20
We made contact with him and asked him to come in to speak with us. Are you thinking that this could be the guy?
00:15:26
He's significantly older, someone that was flirting with her less than 24 hours before her death.
00:15:33
So he's certainly a person of interest. Randy came in for questioning and admitted to joking around playfully with Jesse at the party
00:15:41
and swore there was nothing more to it. but part of Randy's story didn't sit well with Detective Thickens.
00:15:48
Where had he been during the time of the crime? He was working or was scheduled to work through a temp agency.
00:15:56
He didn't actually go to work that day. So where was he then? He said he spent most of the day actually at his apartment by himself.
00:16:02
Did you just come right out with it? Did you have anything to do with the murder of Jesse?
00:16:07
I asked him if he had any involvement in her death. He said no. But the detective wondered, was his story straight out of a script?
00:16:15
He's an actor, and it's hard for me at that point to gauge if he's acting or being truthful.
00:16:21
Investigators issued a search warrant for his phone records. We're going to verify where Randy was and look at his alibi.
00:16:29
Was his cell phone anywhere near that house in this time period? Jesse's friends quickly heard the police were looking at a cast member.
00:16:36
What was being said about the cast member? Just that he was kind of creepy, and we thought it was him.
00:16:43
I mean, who else could have been? But the play's director, Jerry Becker, didn't believe it.
00:16:49
He couldn't imagine Randy being responsible for Jesse's death. Did you pick up the phone and call Randy when he was going through this?
00:16:56
Yes. He was saddened by all this. How did that conversation leave you feeling? I was exceptionally confident at the end of that phone call
00:17:05
that he was not involved in this in any way. And when the detective got his hands on Randy's phone records,
00:17:13
he began thinking the same thing. Did his phone records tell you anything that was of significance?
00:17:19
No. He hadn't been talking to her on the phone that we could see in this time period
00:17:23
that we were looking at, and he hadn't been near the house. We haven't eliminated him, but we're having to look at other options.
00:17:31
So, working day and night, they went over the other leads from Jesse's parents. They interviewed the tree trimmers who might have been peering into Jesse's window.
00:17:41
There was nothing of significance found as far as their possible involvement. And they tracked down the restaurant co-worker Jesse had been upset with.
00:17:52
He was actually out of the country as our understanding was at the time this would have happened So case closed on that one He not going to be involved And remember Joy mentioned a second man from the cast party who made Jesse uncomfortable
00:18:05
The one she claimed told an inappropriate joke. Turns out that guy was none other than Jerry
00:18:11
Becker. I got to believe it was sort of some misunderstanding with regard to who Jesse was
00:18:16
talking about. So it was a surprise to you that she had brought up your name specifically?
00:18:21
Absolutely. Did you have anything to hide about that night? No. My daughter and my son were there at the picnic with me.
00:18:29
Jerry told us he'd had just a brief conversation with Jesse that night. There was nothing flirtatious about it.
00:18:36
Detectives didn't think it sounded like much of a lead, and Jerry never became a suspect.
00:18:41
In fact, the investigation was going nowhere, leaving the town on edge. Every time someone would come up behind me, I would jump, even if I knew they were coming up behind me.
00:18:51
Then, news of another crime heightened everyone's fears. It was an attack so brutal she had to get 15 stitches on her hand.
00:19:00
It happened in a neighboring town. Another attack on a young woman close to Jessie's age in a park less than 10 miles from her house.
00:19:10
Did you think that there was any possible connection to the park attack? They were too similar.
00:19:16
They were too violent. They were against young women. They must be connected some way or another.
00:19:21
What had happened in that park, and could it lead detectives to Jesse's killer? Coming up, a harrowing first-person account of that vicious attack.
00:19:33
You grab the knife with your bare hands. It was either I try to save myself or let this guy do whatever he wants to me.
00:19:41
Was someone stalking young women around this small town? After the vibrant 19-year-old with a passion for music was strangled in her own bed,
00:20:04
Jessie Blodgett's grief-stricken parents couldn't stop thinking about the way she died.
00:20:10
That's such a dark place to go, to think about her last moment. It doesn't get any darker than that.
00:20:15
And I laid on her bed early on and held my breath as long as I could, longer than I've ever been able to in my life,
00:20:21
trying to black out to see how that was, which is nothing like what she went through.
00:20:26
Police thought Jessie had been targeted, but now some of Jessie's friends wondered
00:20:31
if her murderer was the same person who attacked a woman in a nearby park. When I found out about that,
00:20:37
I was almost thinking in my head, like, who's next? You know, if he's still out there,
00:20:42
he could still be plotting, he could still be hunting. I was like, who is this guy?
00:20:48
This is Melissa Richards, the victim of that attack. It happened three days before Jesse was killed.
00:20:56
Her courageous story of survival is amazing. You arrive at the park, and what's the first thing you see?
00:21:02
A blue minivan. Anything out of the ordinary? No. Melissa Richards and her dog, Remy, went for a walk in Richfield Park.
00:21:10
And when they returned... The guy was still parked in the car, and what I noticed was him looking out of the driver's side window.
00:21:20
Did it seem weird? I just thought he wanted his privacy. And then about here, I hear somebody running behind me.
00:21:28
So I look back and go, oh, you scared me. Then I noticed he had a knife in his hand and he was still coming towards me.
00:21:38
Before Melissa could run, she was knocked to the ground and her attacker pinned her down on her stomach.
00:21:45
But Melissa fought back and did something almost unthinkable. She grabbed the knife by the blade.
00:21:52
You grabbed the knife with your bare hands. Right. What possessed you to do that?
00:21:58
Well, it was either I tried to save myself or let this guy do whatever he wants to me.
00:22:05
With Melissa resisting, the attacker apparently panicked and seemed to give up. He finally was just kind of got up off of me.
00:22:15
He was still holding onto the knife and he's like, can I just go? And I said no.
00:22:21
A defiant Melissa wanted her attacker to stay put and answer for his crime. But instead, he dropped the knife and fled.
00:22:29
So he ended up running back to his car. I got in my car and I got out of here as fast as I could.
00:22:35
Wounded and bloody, Melissa picked up the knife and got herself to a hospital for stitches.
00:22:41
There, she was met by Detective Claussing of the Washington County Sheriff's Department.
00:22:45
This wasn't a robbery. He didn't say, give me your purse. This wasn't a dog napping. He didn't say, give me your dog.
00:22:51
This was a vicious personal attack on a stranger. Melissa had never seen her attacker before,
00:23:00
but lucky for investigators, she had an almost photographic memory. He was wearing glasses. He had blonde, shaggy hair.
00:23:10
I said he's about 6'2", 210 pounds. Did he look like a normal guy? Mm-hmm. Yeah, especially with what he was wearing, just normal clothes from Kohl's.
00:23:20
Melissa could even tell police the make and model of his van. She knew it was a blue Dodge Caravan, likely around 2000 to 2002.
00:23:32
Despite that great description, investigators could not identify Melissa's attacker,
00:23:37
and he was still at large when Jesse was murdered. And while some of Jesse's friends
00:23:43
had been speculating about a link, investigators disagreed. You're not linking the two crimes
00:23:48
or trying to force them to fit together? Not at all. One's in a park with a knife
00:23:55
and the other one's in a private home with strangulation. The investigations remained separate, and Hartford police continued to look for new leads in Jessie's case.
00:24:06
One by one, they called in her heartbroken friends to ask them what they knew. Did you consider any of her friends as possible suspects?
00:24:15
Never. Not one friend? Never. The interviews with Jessie Blodgett's friends revealed nothing new.
00:24:24
Then, detectives in the park case got a huge break, one that would change the course of both investigations.
00:24:32
Melissa's description of her attacker's van triggered the memory of a deputy who routinely patrolled the park where she was assaulted.
00:24:40
Deputy Meyer had approached us in the detective bureau and said, several weeks ago, I was in that park.
00:24:48
There was a blue van parked in the exact same spot that you had described, parked the exact same way.
00:24:55
At the time, the deputy thought the van seemed suspicious and ran its license plate,
00:25:00
but he found nothing alarming and continued his patrol. Now, his intuition was telling him
00:25:06
the van was the same one involved in Melissa's attack. He had no paper record of the plate,
00:25:12
but in his squad car, the computer kept a log of old searches. And after hours of backtracking, bingo.
00:25:19
It wasn't a bingo, but it was very good. Yeah, it was close. The van belonged to Alora and Melvin Bartelt.
00:25:26
Records showed that Melvin was too old to be Melissa's attacker. But detectives learned the Barteltz had a 19-year-old son who matched Melissa's description perfectly.
00:25:37
And when Detective Klossing called that son's cell number, it rang somewhere that would surprise everyone.
00:25:44
He answered. I introduced myself. I said I needed to speak with him. His name had come up in an incident.
00:25:51
I asked him where he was. He told me he was at the Blodgett house. I said, where?
00:25:58
Coming up, was this the break detectives so desperately needed, or just a strange coincidence?
00:26:05
We were saying, no, not this kid. There's no way that he could kill our friend. When Dateline continues.
00:26:21
It was a promising lead for investigators searching for the young man who so brazenly attacked Melissa Richards with a knife.
00:26:30
They had a suspect who matched her description, a suspect whose parents owned a blue minivan just like the one she'd spotted at the scene.
00:26:39
He was showing up in 15 minutes, so we were talking about how we were going to talk to him.
00:26:45
Their person of interest arrived, friendly and cooperative. My name is Joel Klaus, and I'm Aaron Walsh.
00:26:52
And almost immediately, investigators noticed suspicious cuts and bruises on his body.
00:26:59
What have you done with your thumb? Cut the stab with a screw at work. Oh. Grab off.
00:27:06
I have like a card that I move my stuff around on there. He had a cut on his thumb. He had road rash on his leg.
00:27:11
He had injuries which looked consistent with the injuries someone might have had with attacking Melissa Richards.
00:27:18
It's supposed to be a work. Detectives were skeptical about the work injury story.
00:27:23
In fact, they weren't sure this 19-year-old even had a job. If we check with your employer, would you still have your job?
00:27:33
No. Okay. That's what I thought. How long? When did you lose your job? A while ago.
00:27:39
It's the first time we had him in a line. Picked up my chair, moved it over next to him.
00:27:45
We started a different phase of the interview. No more lies. This just makes things worse.
00:27:52
So after the detective's warning, the suspect tried another story. This time, he claimed he'd cut his finger while cooking.
00:28:00
Nobody in their right mind would lie about cutting themselves if it happened at home
00:28:06
cooking. Okay. What happened? Just be honest. I've gone to the park before. I've been there.
00:28:18
As the police continued to press the young man, he began to crack and quickly. And you were in your van, correct? Or your mom's van or your gifts?
00:28:27
And you went after that girl, right? Yes. He admitted to going after Melissa Richards with a knife and then offered a bizarre explanation for why he did it
00:28:51
Detectives placed him under arrest, but were far from finished. The reason? Remember what he told detectives when they reached him by phone.
00:29:04
Hartford, Jessica Lundsos. That's right. The confessed attacker was also a friend of Jesse's.
00:29:12
Is that the girl that just passed? Yeah, we were visiting her next. His name was Daniel Bartelt.
00:29:20
Dan to his friends. And he was the same Dan Jesse had been writing this music with that summer.
00:29:27
Yo, Dan. Detective Klossing called Hartford police right away. They had a suspect for them in custody.
00:29:39
Jessie's parents refused to believe the news. We were saying, no, not this kid, no.
00:29:44
He's a friend of ours and our daughter's... Yeah, he's a little screwed up. He just got back from college and he doesn't know what he's doing right now.
00:29:51
Blah, blah, blah. But we don't think it's dad. After all, Daniel was more than Jessie's friend.
00:29:57
He was her first love in high school and had never been in trouble. He had everything going for him.
00:30:03
He was a top-notch student, straight-A student. I've never shared a general enthusiasm.
00:30:09
He got the lead role in most of the musicals, very talented. I was like, I like this kid, you know, just because, you know, he could make me laugh.
00:30:16
And he came from a nice family. We said, it's not Dan. He's a good kid. Jesse's friends agreed.
00:30:23
When detectives called Daniel's cell phone, they were with him at the Blodgett house, grieving together.
00:30:29
We were all crying, and our friend Dan, his phone rang, and he was like, I got called into the police station for questioning.
00:30:37
Amelia and Jackie were the ones who drove Daniel to the police station that afternoon.
00:30:42
They'd assumed it was just routine questioning about Jesse. He was like, well, you know, Dan, like, they might question you as a suspect.
00:30:49
That's what they've been doing for all of her male friends. And he's like, oh, yeah, I didn't even think about that.
00:30:55
Now, even with Dan under arrest for the park attack, they couldn't imagine their friend was capable of murder.
00:31:03
I was thinking it was a mistake. Like, yes, maybe Dan did attack this girl in Richfield, but there's no way that he could have killed our friend.
00:31:11
But the detective who just interrogated Daniel thought the opposite. Did you believe Daniel could have killed Jesse?
00:31:19
Yes. It was just a sense you got, a feeling you got. That you were sitting across from a killer?
00:31:25
Yes. Detective Thickens went to grill Dan himself. So I was hopeful that we might get more information that would advance our case.
00:31:34
When was the last time you saw her? Last week, I think. Daniel admitted to having romantic feelings for Jesse,
00:31:43
but swore through sobs he had nothing to do with the murder. What do you think happened to Jesse?
00:31:54
I have no idea. Do you think it could have been accidental? I don't know why someone wouldn't do that.
00:32:05
But detectives didn't believe him, and he fit the profile of the killer they were looking for,
00:32:11
someone who knew Jesse and her habits. She usually wouldn't get up before 11 or 12.
00:32:16
I would text her in the morning, ask if she wanted to hang out or something. He knew where she was going to be.
00:32:26
Knew she didn't have a dog in the house. Knew she didn't have siblings. Knew where her parents were going to be.
00:32:31
And as for his emotional denial, they thought it was an act. He was making these noises, gulping and sobbing noises, as if he was crying.
00:32:42
He didn't shed a tear during that tired time I talked to him. And my God, I knew he had done it, and now I needed to go out and prove it.
00:32:50
Coming up, Daniel faces a jury and Jesse's family. Buck, Joy, I can't give you the answers that you're looking for.
00:32:59
Daniel Bartelt had confessed to a violent attack against a woman in a park But after police spoke with him they realized he could also be guilty of something far worse
00:33:24
Did you leave that interview having any doubt that Dan was the killer? None whatsoever.
00:33:30
Daniel told investigators on the morning Jesse was killed, he was in a park reading a book.
00:33:36
And when they checked the security cameras... We found video that put him there.
00:33:40
But that didn't mean Daniel was innocent. Detectives decided to search the park, combing through more than a dozen garbage bins,
00:33:51
hoping to find anything that linked Daniel to Jesse's murder. And in one garbage can, this cereal box full of ligatures.
00:34:01
Ropes that were very likely the murder weapons used to strangle Jesse, plus a whole lot more.
00:34:07
Bloody sanitizing wipes, tape, shoelaces. I guess he didn't believe that we would have made the effort to go through the garbage to find anything.
00:34:19
Police sent the evidence for testing, and forensics showed that both Jesse and Daniel's DNA were on the ropes found in the park.
00:34:28
Detectives shared the incriminating discovery with Jesse's parents. I had trouble getting it, that it was Dan.
00:34:35
The realist in me knew it was him. The other half of me was like, what happened to Dan?
00:34:42
Daniel Bartelt was officially charged with murder. Buck and Joy tried to wrap their heads around what happened to the funny teenager
00:34:50
and had nothing but empathy for his parents. They didn't do this. They did nothing wrong.
00:34:56
They provided a great environment for him, for his sister. They're good people. I can't say that he's totally evil, but something went very wrong. I don't know what.
00:35:07
And they also felt sorry for Randy Talley, the cast member briefly rumored to be involved, now completely cleared.
00:35:14
I felt bad. Just more collateral damage from one person's evil choices. And though the DNA evidence linking Daniel to the murder seemed to give the DA a slam dunk case, Daniel pleaded not guilty.
00:35:28
Gary Schmouse was his attorney. Some people might say that there was overwhelming evidence against Daniel.
00:35:35
Why go to trial? You go to trial when your client, and in this case Dan, denies having committed the crime.
00:35:45
Whether the defendant is guilty or not guilty, When Daniel's trial began, the courtroom was full of conflicted hearts.
00:35:52
Supporters on both sides knew or cared for Jesse and Daniel. What was it like watching one friend being tried for killing another?
00:36:02
It's like I was watching a TV show. You're in the same room as the person that murdered your friend.
00:36:10
It's crazy. It was the strangest mix of emotions. When he walked in from the back room of the courtroom,
00:36:17
I wanted to hug him and make him feel better. I felt his humiliation and shame. I wanted to punch him.
00:36:26
Prosecutors said from the start there was no easy explanation for why Daniel did what he did.
00:36:32
Why did he pick Jessie? Was he mad at Jessie? No. He wasn't mad at Jessie. He picked Jessie because she was convenient.
00:36:40
But the D.A. did say there was evidence that showed this seemingly sweet young man had been secretly obsessed with murder.
00:36:48
On his computer, police found disturbing Internet searches. What does he do in the days and events leading up to this crime?
00:36:56
He does a search for serial killers on Wiki. A little bit later, serial killers by number of victims.
00:37:02
Their most alarming find was a violent, pornographic film with a plot eerily similar to how Jesse was killed.
00:37:11
Prosecutors claim Daniel used it as an instructional video. At some point in the movie, he pulls out a binding
00:37:19
and places around her neck. He then strangles her. There were searches on serial killers.
00:37:27
There were searches on bondage. Did Dan then, who was big into the theater, a straight-A student,
00:37:34
was he also a serial killer in training? I think that's the potential. Prosecutors showed the jury all the physical evidence,
00:37:45
the DNA, the tape, the wipes, the likely murder weapons that tied Daniel to Jesse's death.
00:37:52
Through it all Daniel sat quietly at the defense table looking at no one and showing little emotion Even when the DA presented evidence the public had never heard before
00:38:06
DNA that the state argued showed he not only killed Jessie, but also raped her. Daniel's DNA was found under Jessie's fingernails and inside her.
00:38:16
That must have been one of the toughest pieces of evidence to combat in front of the jury.
00:38:22
Difficult. Difficult. You know, didn't have really an alternate explanation for that.
00:38:30
And don't have one, as I sit here right now. In any case, Daniel was never charged with rape.
00:38:36
And for the murder, the defense rested without calling a single witness to the stand.
00:38:42
The jury deliberated just three hours. We, the jury, find the defendant, Daniel Bartelt, guilty of first-degree intentional homicide as charged in the information.
00:38:51
Ladies and gentlemen, was this your verdict? It's not a good day for anybody. Nobody won.
00:38:59
I'm Jesse's father, Buck Blodgeon. Months later, at the sentencing, Buck stunned the courtroom when he said this.
00:39:08
Dan, I forgive you, as I have every single day since we found out it was you. And in response to such unbelievable grace, Daniel looked straight at Joy and Buck and continued to deny his guilt.
00:39:24
Buck, Joy, I can't give you the answers that you're looking for. I pray for you, for all of you.
00:39:39
And I hope that I believe that someday I will be before a court that will know that my conscience is good.
00:39:51
I love you. I'm so sorry for your loss. he's such a liar. He looked right in our face.
00:39:59
I mean, with all this evidence that there's just no refuting it. Do you know what I mean?
00:40:03
And then for him to still be looking at me saying this, I'm thinking, kid, do you honestly believe
00:40:09
that I believe you with this? I think Dan's a sociopath. He doesn't seem to have the conscience,
00:40:18
or if he does, he doesn't care. Buck and Joy have accepted they may never hear the truth from Daniel
00:40:24
or know why he turned so violent. But the Blodgetts are doing their best to move on.
00:40:31
For Buck, Jesse's untouched room is a constant comfort, while for Joy, it's a painful reminder.
00:40:38
Are you going to move? I'm staying here because that's what he wants, but I would move tomorrow.
00:40:45
Do you feel that if you leave, you're leaving Jesse? If you move? Not exactly. I feel like she's with me everywhere.
00:40:52
and maybe we should talk again because I didn't know you still felt so much that way.
00:40:58
Daniel was sentenced to life in prison without the chance of parole. For the attack on Melissa Richards,
00:41:04
he was sentenced to five more years. Melissa's our hero. If it wasn't for her, they wouldn't have caught him.
00:41:10
We are forever indebted and thankful to her for that. The police and the Blodgetts commend you
00:41:16
and do feel that other women could have been murdered if it wasn't for you? Well, I tried to help out as much as I could.
00:41:26
I just wanted to help him out. I don't know. I tried. Jesse's parents have started an educational campaign
00:41:38
in their daughter's honor called Love is Greater Than Hate. I'm doing it for the millions of people who will be Jesse,
00:41:46
if not murdered, sexually assaulted, and have their lives changed forever because of it.
00:41:50
Those who love Jessie say her zest for life changed them for the better and still lives on through her music and her spirit.
00:42:00
We started thinking differently because of her. We started acting differently because of her.
00:42:06
Have the tables turned? You were always the one proud of her. And now, do you feel she's the one proud of you?
00:42:12
I feel like now she's the one lifting me up and encouraging me through life, where it used to be the other way around.
00:42:18
There's nothing I wouldn't do. I'll be here I'll be here for you That's all for now.
00:42:30
I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.