00:00:00
It was a small New Year's Eve party. We took off and then shortly thereafter we saw the police car.
00:00:09
My gut was telling my feet to run back to that house. This can't be happening. When the party ended, the mystery began.
00:00:21
It was just crazy. I didn't understand what was happening and why. His wife, the hostess, had seemed fine all night.
00:00:30
Then, her death was ruled a suicide, but not everyone agreed. I always was afraid he was going to hurt her.
00:00:42
Always. Always. Did a fight that night lead to something much worse? I knew that Ashley wouldn't take her own life.
00:00:50
A troubled woman or a troubled marriage? That wound on the back of her head isn't where she can do it herself, Tom.
00:00:58
It is not. Bull! Bull! Bull! Suicide or murder? I didn't do this. I just knew that my whole world is never going to be the same again, ever.
00:01:12
I'm Lester Holt and this is Dateline. Here's Keith Morrison with After the Party.
00:01:23
What is so optimistic as a party on New Year's Eve? What night is hopeful, as full of anticipation, as the clean slate midnight drinks?
00:01:35
It was a small New Year's Eve party. Just family and friends. Disappointment is inevitable, of course.
00:01:42
Clean slates, no matter how ardently desired, are messy all too soon. We noticed that there was a lot of alcohol out.
00:01:50
Still we celebrate possibilities and drown past sorrows and watch the clock that ticks toward our new beginnings.
00:01:59
And our ends. On December 31st, 2011, an hour north of Denver in West Evans, Colorado,
00:02:12
Ashley and Tom Fallis, surrounded by friends and family, danced to the music that brought them together, their wedding song.
00:02:20
They decided to get up and dance in the middle of their living room. Everybody watching.
00:02:25
With everyone watching. Very romantic. I mean, I think I said, like, oh, this is sweet.
00:02:29
It was their party, Ashley's and Tom's. She'd invited her co-workers like Andrea.
00:02:35
It was casual, but she verbally told everyone at work, like, you should come. They worked together at a rehabilitation hospital where Ashley was a respiratory therapist.
00:02:45
She was crazy, nice. Crazy? Just funky, yeah, just full of energy. She was a happy person.
00:02:53
She laughed a lot and joked. Their friendship was new. Andrea didn't know a lot about Ashley,
00:03:00
but had listened to her chatter about jobs and marriages and her three kids, the youngest of whom was born with a dangerous condition called hydrocephalus,
00:03:10
which causes life-threatening fluid buildup in the brain. She talked about it a lot.
00:03:15
Yeah, did she? Yeah, but I didn't get the impression that she felt burdened by it by any means.
00:03:19
I felt like that was the cards that she was dealt. Well, in fact, she embraced the challenge, said Ashley's mom, Jenna.
00:03:25
became a public advocate. She went to Washington, D.C. in the fall of 2011 to speak before Congress for funding for hydrocephalus.
00:03:35
So she had a full plate. So did Tom, for that matter. I liked Tom. He was a pretty good guy.
00:03:41
I am very intelligent. Jeff Rodriguez was Tom's boss at the Weld County Jail. They were corrections officers.
00:03:48
He was a good employee. He had a son that was sick, so he did miss more work than what most fellow officers liked.
00:03:55
Stressful, draining thing, caring for a sick child. So maybe their New Year's Eve party was a way to hope for better times.
00:04:03
And take a break, too. Ashley's adoptive dad, Joel, was at the party. There was dancing going on. People were having a good time.
00:04:12
But Ashley seemed to be having a fine time, said Andrea. She and Tom seemed to be getting along fine.
00:04:18
They seemed to be getting along fine. that's when Ashley and Andrea went off into the kitchen
00:04:24
had a little party of their own what were you drinking? jungle juice and jello shots
00:04:30
I've heard of jello shots but what's jungle juice? just juice of whatever kind and then vodka and everclear
00:04:40
whatever kind of hard alcohol oh my I was having a good time I intended to have a good time
00:04:46
There was one unusual thing, though, said Andrea. Ashley had just gone through something kind of awful.
00:04:54
She found out that she had a miscarriage that day, and I said, oh, I'm sorry, like, are you okay?
00:04:59
And, oh, yeah, it's fine. Did that strike you as odd? No, I didn't think that it was odd.
00:05:04
Was she unhappy about the miscarriage? My impression of it is she already has her beautiful family.
00:05:12
It seemed like her life was already complete, So I don't think that she was devastated that she had found out that she had a miscarriage.
00:05:20
No tears, Andrea said. Just a quick, casual mention. And then the conversation moved on.
00:05:27
Went on to talk about other things. Went on to talk about other things. Probably went and got another jello shot.
00:05:35
Midnight arrived. There were, as there always are, kisses and smiles and toasts.
00:05:41
By 1230, the party was over. I gave her a hug, told her bye. We talked about future plans.
00:05:48
How did she seem? Happy. But oh how quickly the New Year clean slate darkened As an uncle prepared to leave Ashley asked him for a bit of his marijuana to smoke later she said Tom the sheriff department employee was furious and reminded Ashley family that her employer required regular drug tests
00:06:11
Was it the alcohol that amped up the family's screaming match? Whatever. Ashley's parents had their own recollections.
00:06:19
He walks by me, and he says that he hated us all and wished we would all bleeping die.
00:06:26
And he went into the bedroom and slammed the door. Ashley came out of the bathroom and was just like, what's going on?
00:06:34
And we're like, well, we're going to leave. And then she's like, hey, I'm having a Super Bowl party in a couple weeks.
00:06:40
You know, don't forget about that. But Ashley's parents were rattled. They drove away, then pulled off to the side of the road to talk.
00:06:49
Ashley's mom sent a text to Tom. And I'm like, you know, hey, there's kids in the house, calm down.
00:06:56
Which arrived as their young granddaughter was involved in quite another discussion with 911.
00:07:04
Can you go open the door and let the officers in? Okay. I gotta do it. I gotta do it.
00:07:12
The new year was less than an hour old and off to a very bad start. When we return...
00:07:19
Chaos. It was shocking. A frantic race to save a life. What happened in that house?
00:07:26
I just knew that my whole world is never going to be the same again, ever. 2012 was not even an hour old.
00:07:49
New Year's celebrants had only just poured themselves into their cars to head home.
00:07:54
And in a little house in West Evans, Colorado, it was already the worst year ever.
00:07:59
the man on the phone was tom phallus begging for help and willing his wife to live
00:08:15
tom told the dispatcher she shot herself then he put the phone down he was holding his hand to her
00:08:25
head trying in vain to stop the bleeding. So he had his nine-year-old daughter pick up the phone.
00:08:30
Honey, are you there? Yes. Okay, can you go open the door and let the officers in? Yes. Okay.
00:08:37
Honey, don't go. Okay, okay, we're going to help her. I need you to go open the door.
00:08:43
Brian Spencer was a Weld County Sheriff's Deputy back then. He arrived within minutes
00:08:48
to discover that the local police, the Evans Police, had beaten him there. I believe there
00:08:53
There was three there ahead of me, and then there was more sirens, lights. You could hear them coming.
00:08:58
It's a pretty fast response. Very fast. And this bit of news was going around fast, too.
00:09:04
This was a sheriff's employee, a jail employee. Not that that should matter. The effort then was save Ashley Fallis' life.
00:09:13
This was recorded by a police body camera. Shows the paramedics arriving. Chaotic?
00:09:18
The scene, very frantic. The officers located Ashley Fallis. somewhere in the home.
00:09:25
The local police took charge. They asked Brian Spencer to watch the front of the property.
00:09:29
And that's when, from his post on the front porch, he saw Tom. That's him in the background in the white T-shirt.
00:09:36
He was pacing around in the front yard and front sidewalk area, frantic, screaming.
00:09:43
Screaming what? Do you remember? I heard him say, she's dead. A lot of mumbled stuff.
00:09:48
He would put his hands up over his face and screaming and crying. By this time, Ashley's parents had pulled off the road home to talk and worry about the fight that ended the party.
00:09:59
When they heard the sirens, saw the lights flash by, headed that way. Something automatically felt bad.
00:10:06
And I whipped a U-turn. He didn't have the car stopped and I was out running to the house.
00:10:12
Were you able to go and see Ashley? No, I could hear what was going on. I had all three kids and they were just crying and crying and screaming and I'm crying.
00:10:22
See, it was just crazy. It was like a nightmare. I can see blood splatter on the wall, the master bedroom wall.
00:10:30
What was that like? Chaos. It was shocking. Did you understand it was your daughter?
00:10:36
Yes. I do recall just being hysterically upset and crying and thinking that this can't be happening to my daughter.
00:10:46
This can't be happening to us. But yet it was. Inside the master bedroom, Ashley was alive, but the wounds to her head were catastrophic.
00:10:57
The police body camera shows officers kneeling on the floor, trying to stabilize her condition.
00:11:05
Paramedics went in and they made a decision to do what we call a load and go, which means they're not going to spend any time doing life support stuff.
00:11:13
Ashley's mom, Jenna, huddled with her grandchildren in a neighboring bedroom, listened to it all through a closed door.
00:11:25
Is there any way to describe what it's like for a mother to be in that situation?
00:11:30
No. Your brain does funny things. I just knew that my whole world is never going to be the same again, ever.
00:11:39
Outside, Brian Spencer watched Tom, pacing back and forth, crying, talking to himself.
00:11:45
I noticed he's wearing a white t-shirt and he's covered, I believe it was on his left
00:11:51
side, in a large amount of blood. It was odd Brian thought that the Evans police officers didn take Tom clothes or bag his hands for gunshot residue He still had evidence on him And he needed to be preserved
00:12:06
He needed to be controlled. He needed to be processed. And clothing removed. Everything.
00:12:11
But that's not what happened. Not at all. And soon after Ashley was rushed off to the ER, Tom got in the back of a squad car and was driven away.
00:12:22
but surprisingly not to the hospital. Coming up, Tom tells his story. I heard her gun caught and I looked out.
00:12:34
I was like, what are you doing? But police don't seem to believe it. That wound on the back of her head isn't where she can do it herself, Tom.
00:12:43
It is not. Oh, bull, f***. It is not. Bull, f***. When Dateline continues. In the first cold, dark hours of 2012, Ashley Fallis' parents followed an ambulance to the hospital and caught up to her in the ICU.
00:13:11
We walked into her bleeding out of everywhere. There wasn't really any hope. They could see that. She was going to die.
00:13:22
I just sat down and held her hand. But Tom wasn't there to hold her hand. Tom Fallis was at the Evans police station, answering questions.
00:13:34
I don't know what's going on. I have no idea, and that's why I'm asking to speak with you.
00:13:40
It was 2 a.m., and Tom was still wearing blood-stained clothes, the ones a sheriff's deputy thought should have already been bagged as evidence.
00:13:49
How was your relationship with your wife? Really good. But, said Tom, Ashley was devastated when she miscarried the very day of her New Year's Eve party.
00:14:02
It was hard for Ashley. It was hard for me. But I didn't think that it was just getting to this point.
00:14:14
Still, at the party itself, said Tom, she seemed all right. They got on fine. until the argument about the marijuana.
00:14:22
Tom admitted he was furious at Ashley's family, said he was trying to protect her, and they weren't.
00:14:28
I told Ashley, I was like, you don't need to get high. I was like, if whatever happened today with the miscarriage,
00:14:37
I was like, it happened. I was like, you know what? F*** your mom. F*** everybody.
00:14:43
So, there was no love lost between Tom and Ashley's parents, that was clear. And Tom admitted that he and Ashley kept arguing as they got ready for bed.
00:14:53
And then he turned around and went to the closet, he said, and it was all over. But while I was in the closet, I heard her gun caught.
00:15:02
And I looked out. I was like, what are you doing? And before I even had a chance to finish my sentence or close the door.
00:15:08
There was smoke. I heard it. There was smoke. I just ran over to her and I just grabbed her head.
00:15:30
Tom told detectives that sadly he had been worried about just this sort of thing for more than a year
00:15:35
because Ashley had threatened suicide before. What was she saying that she wanted to do to herself?
00:15:41
Oh, just that she wants to end it. She's like, you and the kids would be better off without me.
00:15:46
And so she had just said those words, but she never acted on anything. No. And so how long has she...
00:15:53
Never once, never once has she ever grabbed her gun. Has she ever loaded it? Has she ever made this type of gesture whatsoever?
00:16:04
By this time, while the doctors tried to save Ashley, Tom had been answering questions for hours.
00:16:10
I have to ask these questions, that I have to understand what your relationship is.
00:16:15
But the problem is, is that I've been here since frickin' what, 2 o'clock, and now it's already 5 o'clock, and I don't know what's going on with my wife.
00:16:23
About then, the detective noticed something else about Tom. The scratch mark that's on your chest, what is that?
00:16:31
What? You have like a long red... Oh, probably because I've been doing this all freaking night.
00:16:38
This one just goes straight across here. Oh, probably. I don't know. It's just me. It's not.
00:16:44
Okay, so it isn't... And I just had to ask. The detective left the room and spoke with Ashley's parents,
00:16:50
who'd arrived with the purpose of telling officers just one thing. Their daughter did not shoot herself.
00:16:58
We had just seen her seven minutes before this. She was completely fine. You know, she wouldn't do anything like this.
00:17:03
She was in good spirits when they left, they said. She was already planning her next party.
00:17:10
But Tom, he'd always had an awful temper, they said. I always was afraid he was going to hurt her.
00:17:16
Always. Always. Why? What about him? His temper. You can't go from zero to a hundred and think clearly.
00:17:27
I think that he was just in a fit of rage and he shot her. Armed with that new information, the detective went back to talk to Tom
00:17:36
and zeroed in on those scratches. Officers had given him something clean to wear so they could collect his bloody clothing.
00:17:44
And you have scratches on your body. Okay. See this? This is a shaved chest. Do you know how bad this hurt in itches?
00:17:53
So when I sitting there I do this all freaking day This is actually her blood It comes off See Oh my gosh it coming off It her freaking blood That actually a scratch Okay That a scratch
00:18:07
Still, the detective pressed him. He had motive and opportunity, she said. So when you went upstairs, you were arguing with her. And you know you were arguing with her.
00:18:17
She was also reluctant to believe the shooting happened so quickly. No threats or warnings or hesitation.
00:18:23
She went from saying I'm going to do what I want to just pull in. Yeah. Yeah, she did.
00:18:32
I'm not lying to you. And when the detective gave a description about the gunshot wound,
00:18:37
a description that turned out to be inaccurate, that really set Tom off. That wound on the back of her head isn't where she could do it herself, Tom.
00:18:47
It is not. Oh, bull. It is not. Bull. Bull. Bull. Bull. And then quite suddenly, in the middle of it all, completely out of nowhere, the detective made an abrupt declaration.
00:19:01
And I have to let you know, your wife did not make it. Your wife did not make it.
00:19:12
She was breathing when I was holding her. She was breathing. They told me she was breathing when she left out.
00:19:20
Ashley died while Tom was in police custody. I didn't shoot my wife. I didn't shoot the mother of my kids.
00:19:29
I didn't shoot the person who I wanted to have another one with. What would the police believe?
00:19:35
Tom's story that the shooting was a suicide? Or Ashley's parents' story that he'd shot their daughter in a fit of rage?
00:19:44
Coming up, Ashley's family is outraged by the investigation's final report. It was incomplete. It was inconsistent. No follow-up. It was unbelievable.
00:19:57
Then, a new investigation turns up a new witness. I'm going to start crying because it's the catalyst for opening everything up.
00:20:04
I finally have someone who's taken it seriously. Ashley Fallis, 28 years old, wife and mother of three, was dead.
00:20:24
The gunshot wound in her head, unsurvivable. It was suicide, said her husband Tom.
00:20:31
I didn't shoot my wife. I didn't, I didn't do this. It was murder, said her parents.
00:20:39
I had three grandkids that I dearly, dearly loved that I knew in my heart that Tom had just killed their mother.
00:20:50
The news of Ashley's death spread quickly the morning after the party. I didn't understand what was happening and why, because everything was fine at that night.
00:21:01
As much confusing as anything. Very confusing. She was happy. She didn't seem suicidal.
00:21:06
Andrea, new friend, co-worker, drinking buddy at the party, couldn't shake a feeling.
00:21:13
I don't feel like she would have taken her life. Tom was the only other person that was there.
00:21:18
So if it wasn't her, I had to be him. Right. But for all their middle-of-the-night questions, the police did not arrest Tom, nor charge him with anything.
00:21:27
What were they telling you along the way? Oh, that they were investigating it. At Ashley's funeral, Tom was one of the speakers.
00:21:34
Ashley didn't have much patience. And what he said wasn't the sort of thing people expected to hear.
00:21:42
She goes, I don't care when you do it, where you do it. I want it now. It was an unusual and frankly not very emotional eulogy
00:21:50
for reasons only Tom might understand. But her parents were furious. When he had that opportunity to speak and share about
00:22:00
the woman he so-called loved and called his eternal wife, all he did was degrade her.
00:22:12
What was it like to hear that? It was shocking. It was unbelievable. As the days turned into weeks and Tom remained free,
00:22:23
Ashley's parents became convinced that something about the investigation was not right.
00:22:28
Joel and I sat down and said, look, if for some crazy reason she walked in the house and shot herself
00:22:35
and they can show that. We will accept it and support Tom. We didn't feel like that was, you know, the case.
00:22:42
They weren't alone. Remember, on the night it happened, former Deputy Brian Spencer saw Tom roaming around freely
00:22:49
with blood and other potential evidence all over him. Police 101, a very basic thing.
00:22:55
Any scene that you respond to, you want to treat it as the highest level of what it could possibly be.
00:23:02
So he would be a suspect. And he needed to be preserved. He needed to be controlled.
00:23:07
But none of that was done at the scene. Pretty soon, Ashley's parents began to suspect there was a cover-up to protect Tom.
00:23:15
Perhaps the so-called blue wall of silence, looking out for a fellow law enforcement officer.
00:23:22
It's a hell of an accusation to make, though. It is. It is strong, but that is how we feel.
00:23:28
Mind you, the Evans Police Department strongly disagreed. Both the coroner and the crime scene investigator issued reports
00:23:35
concluding Ashley's death was indeed suicide. And remember, Tom told the police she'd expressed suicidal thoughts before.
00:23:42
And she had two close relatives who'd taken their own lives. And investigators found prescription psychotropic drugs in Ashley's purse and nightstand,
00:23:52
which Tom told them she'd quit cold turkey without medical supervision, when she learned she was pregnant.
00:24:00
And so, two months after Ashley's death, her parents got the news they feared. Police ruled her death a suicide. Case closed.
00:24:11
It made me angry. It made me angry because I knew, I knew that he shot her. I knew that Ashley wouldn't take her own life.
00:24:23
Once the case closed and we got the police report, we realized they didn't do anything.
00:24:30
So tell me more about the police report and what you didn't like about it. It was incomplete. It was inconsistent.
00:24:37
It could have been written by a high school student. No follow-up. It was unbelievable.
00:24:44
The Evans Police Department declined to speak with Dateline on camera, but said this about the allegations against them.
00:24:50
The investigation we conducted was thorough and complete. A conclusion of suicide was determined after an exhaustive review
00:24:57
an analysis of all evidence, physical, forensic, and testimonial, by all of the five agencies involved.
00:25:04
As for Ashley's parents, there was nothing more either of them could do, apparently.
00:25:09
And two years went by, during which Tom moved to Indiana with the kids and enrolled at a local university.
00:25:16
And I said to him, Tom, murderers always move away. It was important to Ashley's parents to remain close to those three kids,
00:25:25
so they fought for grandparents' rights, and tried, they said, to be civil with Tom.
00:25:29
But they also told anybody who'd listened that they believed their daughter had been murdered,
00:25:35
like a local reporter. And he said, do you mind if I start looking into this? And I said, Joel, and I said, no, go ahead, start looking into it.
00:25:43
And it didn't take him much. The reporter asked around, talked to neighbors, and asked the Evans Police Department to comment on what he'd heard.
00:25:53
And before you knew it, the chief announced, Ashley's case would be reopened. I extend my sincere sympathy to the family of Ashley Fallis for their loss
00:26:03
and for the revisited grief that can accompany the reopening of a difficult case such as this one.
00:26:10
I start crying because it's the catalyst for opening everything up. I finally have someone who's taken it seriously.
00:26:17
Denver's Fox 31 aired the startling discoveries that prompted the new investigation.
00:26:22
In particular, a neighbor, who was only 15 at the time, said he heard Tom admit to shooting Ashley.
00:26:31
It's pretty hard to forget hearing somebody confess their murder and then getting away with it.
00:26:36
To prevent any suggestion of taint or cover-up, the case was turned over to the nearby Fort Collins Police Department.
00:26:44
For the next seven months, officers talked to witnesses, both old and new, and hired experts to re-examine forensic evidence.
00:26:51
and when their work was done, Will County D.A. Michael Rourke decided to assemble a grand jury.
00:26:59
What I want to do is I want to put all of that information, as much as we can gather, and almost use it as a test run.
00:27:05
And they said? And they indicted him. And I got the phone call that they indicted him.
00:27:10
But I just started crying. Tom Fallis was arrested in Indiana, charged with second-degree murder,
00:27:17
and brought back to Colorado to stand trial. Ashley's parents were finally optimistic.
00:27:25
I believe that they will find him guilty of marrying our daughter. I believe that's going to happen.
00:27:32
Have you decided to believe it or do you really believe it? I really believe it.
00:27:37
Coming up, a powerful one-two punch from the prosecution. I heard him saying, oh my God, what have I done?
00:27:44
She said, I could hear her screaming, get off me, get off me. Case closed? Far from it.
00:27:51
When Dateline continues. Four years after Ashley Fallis' death, her husband Tom was on trial for murder.
00:28:11
Dan Grossman of NBC's Denver affiliate KUSA was in the courtroom for opening statements.
00:28:17
The room was packed. You have Ashley parents who were there a lot of family members aunts uncles even just people from the public who were interested in this case The prosecution allegation was perfectly clear Tom Fallis argued with his wife and in a fit of rage shot and killed her
00:28:36
At the conclusion of this case, after you've received all of the evidence, you will be convinced beyond a reason without that it is him who pulled the trigger.
00:28:45
Prosecution witnesses said Ashley was in high spirits at her New Year's Eve party,
00:28:49
not at all suicidal. She was happy the whole night, laughing, smiling. She was dancing with her children, interacting with all the guests.
00:29:00
Tom, though? Ashley's uncle John testified about Tom's sudden blow-up when he discovered Ashley asked him for a joint.
00:29:08
And I was sort of taken back by it because everything was fun that night, and then all of a sudden, boom.
00:29:14
So I was just like, whoa. A neighbor said Ashley told her how Tom got physical with her.
00:29:19
She told me how he had pushed her around before. He had never hit her, but he was physical in pushing her.
00:29:28
D.A. Rourke wanted the jury to hear that Tom had a hot temper, that he was volatile.
00:29:33
Anger would have been the most obvious motive. Simply lost his temper. Anger. Gun nearby, bang.
00:29:39
Right. To prove it, the witness. Ear witness, you could say. Nick Glover, the neighbor whose story was reported on television and helped reopen the case.
00:29:51
I heard him saying, oh my God, what have I done? Oh my God, what have I done? Nick was 15 at the time.
00:29:57
He said he remembered crouching down inside his house under an open window, listening to Tom speak to people in his driveway.
00:30:06
You can hear one of them, I do not know who it was, say what? What do you mean? and he proceeded to say, I shot my wife.
00:30:15
Nick said he knew it was Tom. He could see him out the window. How certain are you that the voice you're hearing
00:30:22
is Tom Fallis' voice? By 100%. There was more. Nick's mom, Kathy Glover, testified that
00:30:29
on the night of the shooting, she got a strange phone call from a teenage neighbor
00:30:34
around 1 a.m. She said, please tell me you called the police. And I said, no, I didn't. Why?
00:30:39
And she said, because your neighbor just shot his wife. And I said, what? And she said, I could hear her screaming, get off me, get off me.
00:30:50
Powerful evidence. And then that neighbor testified. But, uh-oh. Do you recall telling Kathy Glover in a phone conversation that same early morning,
00:31:03
I heard her screaming, get off me, get off me. I do not. She was 16 and drinking that night, she said, so that might explain her faulty memory.
00:31:15
Do you recall telling Officer Croson that you heard a female yelling, get off of me, get off of me?
00:31:21
I do not. Did you expect that from her? Yeah. It didn't surprise me. It hurt you, though.
00:31:27
It hurt. But I thought that when you have a police officer who interviews her within an hour,
00:31:33
hour and a half of this shooting, and she, as clear as day, is saying, these are the things I heard from my back window, whether she had been drinking that night or not.
00:31:40
To me, that's the most believable version of events. So, a hiccup, perhaps. But then there was the crime scene.
00:31:50
Remember, the coroner and the CSI officer said at the time that the scene screamed suicide.
00:31:56
But this prosecution witness? My name is Jonathan W. Priest. Priest is a former homicide detective and forensic consultant
00:32:04
who used a miniature model of the phallus bedroom to show Ashley's position. So she has to be here and then bent down so that she'll fit into this trajectory area.
00:32:14
He was convinced that if Ashley shot herself, there would be more blood on the floor and surrounding surfaces,
00:32:20
not just this one carpet stain. We have indications of bleeding, but the type of injury that we're talking about is going to bleed a lot.
00:32:31
and that's not the kind of stain I would expect to see if that's what was occurring.
00:32:36
Something is keeping that blood from reaching that area. And he believed that something was Tom Fallis.
00:32:43
Remember, his clothing was drenched with blood and the priest concluded Tom and Ashley must have been in close contact with the gun went off Using the prosecutor he suggested there was a struggle when the shot was fired I can keep blood staining from getting onto the wall or onto the cabinet
00:33:02
and I can lower her, continuing to bleed, onto my shirt to where I get her in this position.
00:33:10
The prosecution rested its case. What possible defense could there be? Well, for a start, this.
00:33:20
I have so much pain on the inside, I can no longer take it. A letter. And what a letter it was.
00:33:28
Coming up, a troubled marriage or a troubled young woman? What kind of mental health issues did you observe Ashley Fowles to be going through?
00:33:37
Mood swings. Impulsive behaviors. and the verdict. It can't be an easy thing for a juror
00:34:02
imagining a moment he or she didn't see and deciding what must have happened. Did Tom Fallis kill his wife Ashley in a fit of violent temper or what?
00:34:17
Tom Fallis did not kill his wife and mother of their three children. Ashley Fallis committed suicide.
00:34:29
Remember how the prosecution talked of Ashley's happy frame of mind? That, Ashley, was a kind of lie, said the defense.
00:34:38
Ashley Fallis was a beautiful woman, but she had a terrible pain inside. She was mentally ill.
00:34:52
The defense put one of Ashley's close friends on the stand. What did you know of Ashley having a mental illness?
00:34:58
I knew that she was on medications. We spoke pretty in-depth about that. But even with medications, the friend testified, Ashley had trouble controlling her emotions.
00:35:09
What kind of mental health issues did you observe Ashley Fowles to be going through?
00:35:15
Depression, mood swings, impulsive behaviors. In fact, the defense argued Ashley was so depressed the summer before she died, she wrote this letter to Tom.
00:35:30
I have so much pain on the inside I can no longer take it. I'm sorry to do this to you and the kids, but I find myself not even liking my children.
00:35:40
Every day is a chore with them and you. I have to pretend to be happy. I have to pretend to be someone I am not.
00:35:49
Please make sure you raise the kids to continue to go to the school we have chosen.
00:35:54
I do love them. I just can't take this life any longer. Please make sure you let them know every day that I do love them.
00:36:02
And this was not their fault. Suicide expert Dr. Michael Allen studied the letter as well as Ashley's medical records
00:36:10
and testified about his review. Do you have an opinion in this case about whether or not Ashley Fallis was a high risk to commit suicide on January 1, 2012?
00:36:21
Yes. My opinion is that she had many, many risk factors and warning signs. Remember, detectives had learned years before that Ashley had a family history of suicide.
00:36:33
Both her maternal uncle and her grandmother took their own lives. And that, said Dr. Allen, put Ashley at a higher risk for doing the same thing.
00:36:43
Two close family members who had died by suicide would suggest a genetic propensity for suicide.
00:36:53
The defense argued that on New Year's Eve 2011, it was the miscarriage that broke her will to go on.
00:37:01
That she spent the night masking her pain with alcohol. That she planned to dull it further with marijuana after the party.
00:37:09
And that's why Tom was upset. She was vulnerable. He was concerned about her He didn want her to add marijuana to this toxic system that was developing inside of Ashley
00:37:26
Phallis. The defense conceded Ashley and Tom quarreled that night, but insisted it never got
00:37:32
physical. Those scratches on Tom's chest, the ones the prosecutors believed were proof of a struggle?
00:37:38
DNA tests never found any evidence to support that. You did not find any of Ashley Phallis'
00:37:44
DNA, cellular material, on those swabs from Tom's chest, correct? That is correct.
00:37:51
The defense reminded jurors that Tom told the police why he had the scratches, that he'd
00:37:56
done a little manscaping to spice up his marriage. He had texts and photos to prove it.
00:38:02
There's Tom Fallis when he has hair on his chest, all the way to the left. And on December 17th, 2011, he texted Ashley.
00:38:12
there you have it you get your way so here it is thought you might like it so the scratches said
00:38:19
the defense were because it was itchy and that's all as for the so-called witnesses said the defense
00:38:26
totally unreliable the one changed her story on the stand and the other just months after the
00:38:33
shooting young nick glover went camping of all things with tom the very man he said he heard
00:38:40
confessed to shooting Ashley Fallis. At no time during the camping trip with Tom Fallis did you
00:38:47
ever tell anybody that you were uncomfortable being there with Tom Fallis? I do not recall.
00:38:53
Who to believe? For example, there wasn't one, but two prosecution crime scene analysts.
00:39:01
This one, you've already heard, believed it was murder. But this one? Most people that shoot
00:39:07
somebody in an act of rage, they don't stop with one shot. Dan Gillum was the crime scene expert from the first investigation of Ashley's death.
00:39:18
Using a defense attorney about the same height as Ashley, he demonstrated how difficult it
00:39:23
would have been for someone as tall as Tom to have shot Ashley at an angle that matched
00:39:28
the bullet's trajectory. First of all, is that an unnatural position for another person to be holding the gun in
00:39:34
that manner? It is for me. Okay. And Mr. Fallis is six feet tall. How tall are you?
00:39:40
I'm six feet as well. Okay. And the gun was Ashley's. The shooting happened in arm's reach of where it was usually stored, said the defense.
00:39:48
After examining all the ballistic and blood spatter evidence, Gillum just didn't believe the shooting was murder.
00:39:55
I believe that the story that Mr. Fallis gave is consistent with the evidence found at the scene.
00:40:02
In other words, he thought it was suicide. So, what happened in that moment after midnight?
00:40:11
How would a juror decide? Upon reaching a verdict, you will inform the bailiff who will in turn notify me.
00:40:18
Reporter Dan Grossman settled in for a bit of a wait. This is almost a three-week trial. There's a lot of evidence.
00:40:24
You thought that you were looking at coming back the next day to hear the verdict.
00:40:29
But, no. Less than four hours later, a verdict. We, the jury, find the defendant, Thomas Fallis, not guilty of murder in the second degree
00:40:39
and all lesser included offenses signed by the jury foreperson. Not guilty, not murder.
00:40:47
After four long years of living under a cloud of suspicion, Tom Fallis was acquitted of all charges.
00:40:53
He stayed straight-faced. his defense attorney, Iris Itan, was very emotional. But Ashley's parents, they left the courtroom fairly quickly.
00:41:05
What about Ashley's family? Can they just accept this and go on? I don't think they'll ever accept it.
00:41:10
To say that they were distraught would be an understatement. They, I think, truly believe that Tom Fallis killed their daughter,
00:41:19
and they are never going to let that go. An idea once so deeply ingrained, true or not, will not go away.
00:41:28
And Tom Fallis and his children make a life as best they can. That's all for now. I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.