00:00:00
My parents always told me that monsters don't exist. I can tell you with absolute certainty that is 110% false.
00:00:24
He is a monster. A wife and mother killed in her own home. I get a phone call from a screaming, irrational voice on the other end.
00:00:35
I said, is it Rachel? And I said, what do you mean? Somebody came into her house and murdered her.
00:00:40
Who murdered her? Police discover Rachel had a complicated love life. She said, I've fallen hopelessly in love with you.
00:00:49
You were married to somebody else. I wanted to get out of that marriage as soon as possible.
00:00:52
Was there an even bigger secret? Buried in this box. We're realizing, wait, there was a former wife.
00:01:00
We finally come around this turn. The whole side of the mountain's on fire. You're no bushido! You're no bushido!
00:01:08
Marriage, money, and murder. Some say more than one. When people say, I know how you feel,
00:01:16
you have no idea how I feel. I don't want you to know how I feel because no one should ever feel this way.
00:01:24
The night forest was profoundly dark. Below its thick canopy of trees, even the meager moonlight was shot out.
00:01:44
As the driver rushed too fast down the twisting, stomach-churning track inches from yawning, inky-black depths, desperate to save the passenger's life,
00:01:54
What were they doing up here, so far from civilization, from safety? And what answers did the fire consume?
00:02:04
As one of them was launched on a path as dark and twisted as the mountain road itself,
00:02:10
one evil begetting another, and another, until... This whole story is a mixture of murder and blood and failings and grace and heaven and God,
00:02:21
and there's some real craziness to it. But, to begin. 2,500 miles west of that remote mountain trail in Georgia is one of the more civilized places on earth.
00:02:38
Napa, California, world-famous wineries, Michelin-starred restaurants. Here lived a beautiful woman who loved four admiring men.
00:02:47
Her father, the prominent artist. Her husband, the ex-fighter pilot and pharmaceutical executive.
00:02:54
Her lover, the handyman, former Marine and firearms expert. And her first boyfriend, the would-be impressionist painter.
00:03:04
His name is Tim Tarrington. And she, the woman at the center of all that happened, was Rachel.
00:03:11
Rachel Hatfield. So, Rachel. Tell me about her. Oh, s***. I'm sorry. We're starting, huh?
00:03:21
Well, just whatever. Okay. Start again. Oh, yeah. What did that do to you when I said that?
00:03:29
My heart just went boom. The subject of Rachel, as you can plainly see, is painful for Tim Charrington,
00:03:35
a pain that might lessen if he'd only learned to forget. But all he can do is remember, like the night they first met.
00:03:42
It was a July night party, and she was dancing. And I said, wow, I'm going to meet that girl.
00:03:50
How old were you? I was 18, and I think she was 17. Oh, wow. Coming over here. Love drunk teens.
00:03:57
They set up house together. That's Tim during those giddy years, rarely serious,
00:04:02
looking like a character from the movie Dazed and Confused. And there's Rachel, unconsciously glamorous,
00:04:08
like some movie star in her own romantic comedy, with a plot that was all too familiar.
00:04:15
Aspiring artists waiting for their break. Could she see Making a Life as a painter?
00:04:22
Yeah, she could. Rachel could picture it because she had seen it happen. Her own father, Don Hatfield, made a big name for himself
00:04:29
painting the romantic, bucolic beach scenes that for years have graced living rooms around the country.
00:04:36
You may have seen his How to Paint courses on YouTube. This is called, for me, it's called Aiming Your Shot.
00:04:44
Rare is the artist who, like Don, could comfortably raise four kids in the Napa Valley.
00:04:49
Welcome back in, Ray. But though many are called, few are chosen. Tim's artistic hopes were disappointed.
00:04:57
It wasn't happening. It wasn't happening. So he and Rachel lowered their sights and hustled up any work, like murals,
00:05:05
that might help cover the rent. We're, you know, doing murals, and that's all the income we had.
00:05:13
Murals doesn't pay all that well. No, it doesn't pay much at all. She was undergirding and supporting
00:05:19
and loving and directing Tim. Don Hatfield thought his daughter would outgrow Tim.
00:05:26
After all, Rachel, unlike Tim, buckled down and went to college. You know, graduates at top of her class at Sonoma State,
00:05:33
recruited by Deloitte and Touche, and they started her out at 80K. We want you. No, I want to do a little business of my own, you know.
00:05:40
And she and Tim would run around and do stuff. Paint murals. Yeah. Were they any good?
00:05:46
Not really. But she loved him nonetheless. 14 years this went on. Rachel wanted to get married have kids I haven asked her to marry me yet Did you want to have kids I did I did I did but I just wasn there yet you know what I saying
00:06:06
Well, it's an old story, isn't it? Tim was blindsided by what happened next. Rachel met another man, someone who was everything Tim was not.
00:06:17
Todd Winkler, focused, disciplined, a former F-16 fighter pilot who was on track to be a corporate leader.
00:06:24
Tim scrambled. And I went and bought a ring real quick to propose to her, and I did.
00:06:32
It was too late by then, of course. Rachel turned him down and announced her engagement to Todd.
00:06:39
It was really hard, you know, because the love of my life was leaving me for some guy that had a good job and a house and a boat and a nice car.
00:06:49
Tim, to me, was Rachel's soulmate. It was nothing but loving and kind to her. We were both 21.
00:06:56
Hard to watch, said Rachel's closest friend, Shannon Thurman. She called me when she broke up with him and said, you know, we're done.
00:07:03
I want to have a family. He's not ready to have a family. And so, you know, we're done.
00:07:09
And then literally like two months later, she called me and said, you know, you need to be here in two days. I'm getting married.
00:07:16
And I was like, oh, great, you guys made up. And she was like, no, we didn't make up.
00:07:20
You know, it's this other guy, his name is Todd, and you need to be here in two days.
00:07:27
Tim didn't go to the wedding, couldn't handle it, went to a bar to escape it. No idea the wedding party would swoop in to his bar for a round of toasts.
00:07:36
It was hard, man, watching your girl on this big guy with her hot pink dress on, and he was carrying her.
00:07:43
He's a guy that's got it going on, and she's a pretty girl, and they look like a great couple.
00:07:47
I just, I mean, I can't imagine what that would be like. I just can't. Yeah, it's hard.
00:07:56
To be the guy who gets dumped is bad. It's bad. I quit paying, you know, as soon as I found out she married Todd.
00:08:08
And I just had no energy. I had no oomph. I had no inspiration. I had given up. So, what does this broken-hearted love story have to do with a fiery mountain crash?
00:08:26
More than you could possibly imagine. In my mind, this was not an accident. Our friend was murdered. I truly believe that.
00:08:38
A married woman's complicated love life. One of Rachel's lovers is gone, but not forgotten.
00:08:45
I thought maybe, you know, later on down the road we can get together again and share life again.
00:08:51
And there's a new lover on the horizon. I couldn't get out of my mind. History, for all we may try to slip its inconvenient grip as a sticky business,
00:09:16
rarely is done with us as we would choose to be with it. We make debts. We must pay.
00:09:25
Rachel Hatfield turned her life as if on a dime, left her past behind and embraced an existence
00:09:31
that was everything it wasn't with old boyfriend Tim. When she married Todd Winkler,
00:09:36
the ex-fighter pilot turned corporate executive, she also married into a very different lifestyle.
00:09:42
There were private airplanes and boats and motorcycles, a big house in the development east of Sacramento
00:09:48
called an air park, Cessnas in garages, Piper Cubs on the curb. Tim Charrington versus Todd Winkler?
00:09:56
No contest, said her dad, Don Hatfield. The guy's an Air Force Academy graduate.
00:10:02
He's successful in business. He's a family man. He's, you know, from the Midwest.
00:10:07
He's got to be great. Good, solid upper middle class guy. Yeah, I know. And he's got a plane.
00:10:12
Planes and boats and, you know, all over the place. What Tim the starving artist could offer beyond love and loyalty was a lot of nothing.
00:10:20
Todd, on the other hand. Went to Orlando with him, to Disney World. And he was picking up the bill for this stuff?
00:10:27
Yeah, most of the time, yeah. Don had no way of knowing that Tim was, for a time, still in Rachel's life, sort of.
00:10:37
You didn't lose touch completely? No, we really kept in touch. Why would they do that?
00:10:43
Maybe because marriage, her marriage, Rachel led Tim to believe, wasn't all apple pie and ice cream.
00:10:50
Because she wanted to share with me what was going on. What did she tell you? She shared with me that Todd had taken her credit cards and maxed them all out and bought a plane and just put her in debt for like $45,000.
00:11:03
Whoa. I was like, whoa. Aren't you freaking out? She said, yeah, but he'll take care of it.
00:11:10
Which sounded less like complaining than maybe boasting. Tim, after all, could barely qualify for credit at all.
00:11:18
Eventually, being on the outside looking in was just too hard. Because I couldn't take it no more.
00:11:24
You know, it was getting harder and harder. So he asked her to stop calling him.
00:11:29
He had to move on, start painting again, forget her. Though, as he admitted to us, he wasn't very successful.
00:11:36
I thought, you know, maybe later on down the road we can get together again and share life again.
00:11:45
Wishful thinking, of course. Tim simply failed to understand that Rachel's life with husband Todd was getting more exciting
00:11:52
by the day. When Todd company sent him to live briefly in Australia he invited Rachel dad to visit and paid his way Every night after work boom we were going to Cirque du Soleil to comedy clubs to dinners
00:12:06
I mean, it was a big, it was a six-week party down there. But it was back home in the air park where the Winkler's social life blossomed.
00:12:14
Gosh, I have all kinds of things from Oktoberfest in October where the neighbors get together,
00:12:19
Christmas parties, Easter, Valentine's Day parties. Ice cream social and paper airplanes.
00:12:27
These were the neighbors, Rich and Linda Johnson, Linna and Marion Cockrell. Todd had one airplane in the hangar and one in the driveway.
00:12:36
They loved having an ex-fighter pilot for a neighbor. Todd was always, I mean, he was just a genuinely interested guy.
00:12:44
He would make eye contact with you. He always wanted to know about my job. What sort of cases are you working on?
00:12:49
What kind of law do you practice? I had actually kind of looked at Todd as kind of a guy's guy.
00:12:55
You enjoyed their company? We did. Enjoyed Todd a little more than Rachel, maybe.
00:13:01
I knew her less well than I knew Todd, I feel. I feel like we were both in the same place in our lives, but sort of moving in different circles.
00:13:12
She wasn't one of those people you immediately were attracted to, or what? No, and I don't. I really liked her, but she always seemed a little bit distant.
00:13:23
Very polite, very friendly, but a little bit distant. Want to go over there? Yeah.
00:13:28
Go over there. By 2009, Rachel and Todd had two little daughters, Eva and Ariel.
00:13:34
He always seemed very involved and very engaged with the kids. And to me, always seemed to be trying to help Rachel and give her a break.
00:13:42
Rachel and Todd to us were like the perfect little family. They're both very proactive parents, loving parents, caring parents,
00:13:51
as well to each other, a couple. They seem like the perfect couple. And in our experience, we saw Todd more on a social level with the kids than we saw Rachel.
00:14:05
Not every day, mind you, Todd landed a lucrative job with an international pharmaceutical company,
00:14:12
grew expense accounts soft on his desk-bound track toward what he called a C-suite, as in CEO.
00:14:21
The only catch was his office was a long drive away in the San Francisco Bay Area,
00:14:26
and not wanting to uproot his family, Todd got an apartment in town, returning home to the air park for the weekends,
00:14:33
which meant, of course, that Rachel was now anchored to home and to toddlers Monday through Friday,
00:14:39
and was soon quite restless. So she put her kids into daycare and got a full-time job managing the airpark.
00:14:47
How was she as a mother, by the way? Oh, she was okay, I guess. Was that harsh? Dawn, you should know, has firmly rooted religious beliefs.
00:14:57
I tried to lead all of my children to the love of Jesus Christ. It was an article of Dawn's brand of faith.
00:15:04
A mother should be at home with her kids. I was really pretty frustrated that she had them over in daycare and that she was working full time.
00:15:14
I didn't like it. But of course, it wasn't the only thing he didn't like about Rachel's job.
00:15:21
There was also him. The first thought I had was, you know, wow, what a beautiful woman.
00:15:28
And I still remember what she was wearing. I remember the way her hair was. His name? James White.
00:15:34
former Marine, gun enthusiast, air park handyman. She was just the most perfectly nice, most beautiful woman I've ever met.
00:15:48
I couldn't get her out of my mind. Intoxicated by a married woman. Well, no good can come of that.
00:16:00
The attraction was mutual, and the fact they were both married was just one problem.
00:16:06
Another was soon to arrive. How does she feel about carrying Todd's baby? Service in the military, as so many Americans have come to know,
00:16:29
can form a person. as it did James White. I was a Marine for life. It never leaves you.
00:16:39
Once a Marine, always a Marine, they say. And James White loved everything about the Corps.
00:16:46
I miss the Marine Corps very much. Though not so much his next job as a Mississippi Deputy Sheriff.
00:16:53
What was it you didn't like about it? I don't like seeing human suffering on a day-to-day basis.
00:16:58
So, after a failed marriage and with his young daughter in tow, he moved back to the place he started out, Northern California.
00:17:07
That little girl, Caitlin White, is all grown up now. We're more best friends than father and daughter.
00:17:13
We fight like siblings, and we're just, we're more focused on having fun and not really caring about what other people think.
00:17:24
James and Caitlin set up house together here in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada mountains,
00:17:29
coincidentally just a few miles from Rachel and Todd Winkler's air park. James started a handyman business and, again, pure coincidence, got some jobs at the air park.
00:17:41
He also started a website called AmmoSmith.com, not so much about guns as about the craft of creating custom ammunition.
00:17:50
We have an automatic pistol, the shoes-rimmed revolver cartridge. Now that was his life in the spring of 2010 A nicely very little business a second marriage that was not going terribly well Oh and he had a secret mad crush on the beautiful young woman who managed the air park Rachel Winkler
00:18:13
And one day she called me into her office. This is in June, beginning of June of 2010.
00:18:19
She said, have a seat. I said, okay. I thought I was in trouble. and she leaned over from her chair and she grabbed my hand and said james i got something i really
00:18:26
need to tell you i thought i was like you're fired no she said i've fallen hopelessly in love with
00:18:34
you and i don't know what to do about it what was it like to hear that it was a huge relief
00:18:39
relief yeah because you were in love i was already in love with her at the time but i couldn't tell her i didn't feel that i should tell her you know i wouldn't know how
00:18:50
she would react. I'd rather have her as my friend than have her as nothing at all.
00:18:59
So, having left artist Tim to marry ex-fighter pilot Todd, Rachel now launched into an affair
00:19:06
with ex-Marine James. This, by the way, wasn't one of those sneak off into a closet and steal a
00:19:14
kiss kind of affairs. With Todd living and working in the San Francisco Bay Area during the week,
00:19:20
James and Rachel were together almost constantly. We tried to spend as much time as possible we could together.
00:19:27
What did it feel like when you did? I felt like we were family. I felt like we were one.
00:19:32
One heartbeat. You know, our hearts were intertwined together like... I can't describe.
00:19:41
Indescribable love. I never loved someone so intensely in my life. Their children were soon in on the secret.
00:19:48
Caitlin was beguiled by Rachel. You could be talking to her like we're talking, and she would make you feel like the most important human being on this earth.
00:19:56
How did that make you feel? Special, loved. I could open up to her. If Todd suspected anything, he didn't let on.
00:20:09
But Rachel's dad, Don, began to get a queasy feeling during his visits to the air park.
00:20:15
Tell me what you thought about him at the time. He came across as this Christian guy.
00:20:20
You know, he's helping Rachel. He's helping her around the airport. And okay, fine.
00:20:25
After about the second time, I said, you know, is this guy trying to bed you or what's going on?
00:20:29
And she says, he'd like to, but it's not happening. There were whispers around the neighborhood, too.
00:20:37
People do notice things. I think we suspected. Suspected what? That something was going on?
00:20:43
That maybe something was going on. Because you saw the two of them together a lot?
00:20:47
She and Jane? I didn't see him as a couple, you know, outwardly as a couple, even though you'd see him together.
00:20:54
But Rachel and James had more than Todd and Don and the neighbors to worry about.
00:20:59
You were married to somebody else. I was. What did you do about that? What did you think about that? How troublesome was that for you?
00:21:06
I wanted to get out of that marriage as soon as possible because I wanted to be with Rachel.
00:21:12
So you told your wife? No. My wife discovered us. And then we separated. You will perhaps not be surprised
00:21:21
to hear that James' wife, angry and betrayed, made a phone call to Todd Winkler,
00:21:29
who begged Rachel end it with James. She, in a rush of guilt and shame, agreed. She tried to call it off, and I tried to call it off.
00:21:38
We couldn't stay apart from each other more than two days before we went crazy for each other.
00:21:41
How would you try to call it off? What would you do? She would say, I need to work it out with my husband.
00:21:48
And I'd say, I need to work it out with my wife. We can't talk to each other. Two days later, she'd text me.
00:21:53
She'd say, I love you and I miss you. I'd say, I love you and I miss you too. We had a real strong spiritual bond.
00:22:02
And then all lovesick, they'd sneak off to see each other or leave longing messages on the phone, like this one from Rachel.
00:22:11
One of the great things when you're in love with somebody is that those feelings come to the surface more.
00:22:18
Your feelings about work, about your heart, about your spirit, about everything.
00:22:24
And we can share those with each other, okay? And I love you. Take care. Bye. During their heart-to-hearts, Rachel complained that her Todd was not so perfect as people seemed to think.
00:22:41
Did she lay it on a little thick for the sake of her other man? Wouldn't be surprising, of course.
00:22:47
Anyway, James relayed to us what he said she told him. That Todd was stingy, emotionally distant.
00:22:54
That he was so devious he actually faked having cancer twice to avoid deadlines at work.
00:23:01
That on a business trip to Amsterdam, he feigned some sort of catatonic state the day he had a presentation due.
00:23:08
and worse, as James related Rachel's story, Todd talked about staging a serious car wreck
00:23:15
as a pretext for suing his own company and collecting a big settlement. Now, all this may have just been trash talk
00:23:23
about the husband whose mere existence was an impediment to their happiness, but wrapped up in the fog of their love,
00:23:30
they began talking about running away from it all, together. And then, it was just about a year into their affair.
00:23:38
Uh-oh. She was pregnant with Todd's baby. So did Rachel and James end it then? Why, no, they did not.
00:23:52
What did it do to your relationship? Brought us closer. She said to me, who in her right mind
00:24:00
Want to take on a woman with two toddlers and an infant. I said I would. Without hesitation.
00:24:08
She started crying and so did I. How did she feel about carrying Todd's baby? She said that the life in her was a gift from God.
00:24:19
No matter who the father was, she was going to love that baby no matter what. Because half that baby was her.
00:24:24
Sure, of course. And I told her I would love that boy and her daughters just like they're my own.
00:24:30
But wait a minute. It was, after all, a husband. Todd was not about to take this, lying down.
00:24:37
And sure enough, he recruited a powerful ally. One tense and anxious day, they braced themselves
00:24:44
and set out to confront his wife's lover. And James White was ready for them. I had a 9mm around me, and I know how to use it extremely well.
00:24:54
Witness to a showdown between an angry husband and his wife's pistol-packing lover.
00:25:05
I see these two men walking up the driveway, and I was like, oh my god, what are they doing here?
00:25:15
And what was about to happen? Todd Winkler, distressed by his wife's infidelity,
00:25:35
found an unlikely ally as he prepared to confront her lover, James White. But in this case, Rachel's dad, Don Hatfield, was only too happy to help.
00:25:45
He did not approve of his daughter's behavior, just too much like his own once was.
00:25:51
and Don was a guy who'd been carrying his guilt like a cross for years. I tried to lead all of my children to the love of Jesus Christ.
00:26:00
There was only one major obstacle to that ever occurring in a way that I would be happy with,
00:26:07
and that was my hypocrisy. What do you mean? Hmm? Your hypocrisy? My hypocrisy. Chasing women.
00:26:15
Ah. Blowing my marriage. As Don tells it, women found his role as an ascendant artist quite appealing.
00:26:23
Never mind, he was a married father of four. And that kind of thing destroyed, literally destroyed my family.
00:26:31
By the time Rachel was in middle school, Don's string of affairs led to a home-shattering divorce.
00:26:37
I think that the obliteration of the nuclear family had a profound effect on Rachel.
00:26:44
Now, he feared, the apple hadn't fallen far from the tree. His daughter, Rachel, was in the middle of an affair herself, and it was putting her marriage at risk.
00:26:54
Todd had been calling me. What am I going to do? How am I going to save my marriage?
00:26:58
I said, Todd, have you just told him straight up to stay away from your wife until this thing is worked out?
00:27:05
He said, no. I said, well, have you thought about that? He said, well, not until right now.
00:27:10
Sounds like a good idea. Will you come with me? Yeah, I'll go with you. and so we drove over there.
00:27:21
James's daughter Caitlin, 16 then, sounded the alarm as Rachel's worried father and betrayed husband
00:27:27
pulled up at the entrance to James's isolated mountain property. We just got done shooting
00:27:32
and I just hear this car roll up. I was like, wow, that sounds like Rachel. And I see these two men walking up the driveway
00:27:38
and I was like, oh my God. what are they doing here? And then I ran out. I'm like, Dad, Todd's here. And so is John. He goes,
00:27:50
all right, let's get this over with. And I grabbed the nine, or I didn't grab the nine, I grabbed the
00:27:56
M4. Caitlin is talking about the guns she had at the ready, a nine millimeter pistol and an M4 rifle.
00:28:04
And James, he had a pistol holstered in the small of his back as he walked out to greet Todd, Don.
00:28:11
I had a 9mm around me, and I know how to use it extremely well. Here is James' memory of a confrontation so tense it sounds almost surreal.
00:28:23
As the two men approached the house, he said, they hid behind Todd and Rachel's children.
00:28:29
He had Ariel in his arms, using her as a human shield. And Don had Alex in his arms, hiding on the other side of the car.
00:28:37
We're afraid that you're going to shoot them. Perhaps. I can't remember whether or not Todd actually went to the door with the kid or I went to the door or whatever.
00:28:47
He was a human shield. He was going to stop the bullets, right? That's a little scary.
00:28:51
Yeah, it is scary. Todd was holding Ariel. Don was holding Alex. And Todd came up and he looked just a wreck.
00:28:59
Todd confronted me. He said, Rachel and I aren't divorced yet. And I would appreciate it if you would stay away from her.
00:29:04
And? No. You said no. I said no. There was a pause. if something was going to happen this would be the moment and then he turns to me and he goes
00:29:16
hi caitlin i was like get off this property and suddenly it was over todd and don and the kids
00:29:23
got back into the land cruiser and drove off what was the feeling like as this was going out
00:29:30
no the feeling for me was god i hope that this clears the air i think i said you know he's asking
00:29:36
him to stay away. So maybe he'll stay away and maybe they can figure out what to do.
00:29:41
Was it a civilized conversation? Yes. Yes. They didn't yell at each other? No. Didn't stare daggers at each other?
00:29:47
Nothing. Zippo. I didn't like the fact that here's a marriage in trouble and there's guys
00:29:53
will prey on that If he a gentleman he says I wait in the wings And if if this flies fine But you know he didn
00:30:05
No, apparently nothing could keep the lovers apart. James emailed Rachel. Hey, my love, I miss you something awfully bad.
00:30:14
I've been crying on and off since Sunday. I'm dying inside. My heart is shattered.
00:30:21
I love you endlessly. My sweet love. No, this wasn't over. Not the affair. Not the marriage either.
00:30:31
And not the confrontation. Something was coming. Watch out. 911, what's your emergency?
00:30:40
Calling to report a fatality. Where did this occur? It's in the Cameron Park Airpark.
00:30:49
Who had been killed? I get a phone call from a screaming, irrational voice on the other end.
00:30:55
And who was the killer? Oh, so peaceful in the air park that last Sunday, February 2012.
00:31:18
Todd and Rachel Winkler's marital issues did not noticeably ruffle the surface of normal suburban life.
00:31:24
A neighbor bumped into Todd that afternoon. He stopped and talked to us for a couple of minutes and wished us well and kept going.
00:31:34
He was pushing the two strollers with all three kids, and he didn't look particularly cheerful.
00:31:39
Todd had no way of knowing that Sunday afternoon that Rachel was back at James' Mountain House,
00:31:45
double-checking her divorce application. She finished the paperwork, and she says,
00:31:50
I'm filing, I'm going to fax him the next morning. You're continuing with the relationship.
00:31:54
She is filling out divorce papers. He's trying to block her. She's determined to do it.
00:31:58
She turned to me that day. She says, you know what, James? Whether you're in the picture or not,
00:32:02
I'm divorcing Todd. I want out. Whether you're in the picture or not, but was there some doubt about that?
00:32:08
No. She said the reason why she wants to be with me is because she wanted to be with me,
00:32:12
not because she had to be with me. I'm trying to imagine what you were feeling like.
00:32:15
I was elated. We were finally going to be able to start the life together we've talked about and dreamed about and wanted together for so long.
00:32:25
Rachel headed home to tell Todd they were history, that she was leaving him for the man she loved.
00:32:32
Evening fell. It was Sunday night. No one who drove past the Winkler home in the gathering dark
00:32:39
would have noticed anything untoward. But come Monday morning, It was a day unlike any the airpark community had ever seen.
00:32:48
911, what's your emergency? Good morning, I'm calling to report a fatality. Where did this occur?
00:32:55
It's in the Cameron Park Airpark. My understanding it was a domestic. It was just so surreal.
00:33:01
It almost, it seemed like a dream. What was going on? The neighbors, watching anxiously from their windows, didn't know, of course.
00:33:08
I was in my yard and saw the sheriff's department pulling into the neighbor next door,
00:33:13
between our house and the Winkler's house and taking kind of tactical positions,
00:33:17
donning flak jackets and pulling AR-15s. There were five sheriffs in the backyard
00:33:24
with their guns drawn facing Todd's house. What happened next? Floored Marion Cockerell.
00:33:31
And I saw Todd walking backwards across the street. Stop right there. Turn around.
00:33:39
Put your hands on top of your head. Drop down to your knees. Keep your hand on top of your head, you understand?
00:33:43
Yes, I do. Who else is inside the house? There's no one else inside the house. Where's your wife?
00:33:47
My wife is inside the house. She said nobody else was inside, though. My wife is dead.
00:33:52
How could it be? Rachel Winkler was just 37 years old, with those three little children to whom she meant the whole world.
00:34:01
Where is your wife? She's in... When you enter the house, you turn to the right,
00:34:07
the first bedroom on your right. And you're sure she's dead? I'm positive. How can you be? How are you sure?
00:34:14
No pulse, no breathing. Amid the chaos, frantic calls, one of the neighbors reached Rachel's father.
00:34:20
And I get a phone call from a screaming, irrational voice on the other end. I said, is it Rachel? Yes, it's Rachel.
00:34:27
I said, I have a question for you. Is there a yellow ribbon around the property? Yes.
00:34:32
Is there a big white van in front of the house? Yes. Don was in the middle of moving.
00:34:40
The movers tried to calm him down. And the guy says, we don't know that she's dead.
00:34:44
I said, count on it. He killed her. And I got there, and, you know, she was gone.
00:34:48
He was right to begin with. Rachel was dead. The horrific news spread. I got a call from a friend, and I said, campy.
00:34:59
And the next thing I knew, I woke up on the floor. You fainted. I completely blacked out, hit the floor.
00:35:07
So I called the sheriff's department. And asked them if they knew what was going on.
00:35:14
And they said, just stay right where you're at. James' daughter, Caitlin, got a message at school.
00:35:22
I walk outside and I call a family friend and he goes, are you sitting down? I think you need to sit down, Caitlin.
00:35:30
I was like, what's going on? And all I remember is just dropping to the ground. Rachel's friend Shannon couldn't believe what she read online.
00:35:41
I found out through Facebook. I was scrolling and saw someone post something, Rip Rachel,
00:35:49
and I was like, what the hell is going on? So then I called her younger brother,
00:35:53
and he said somebody came into her house and murdered her And I said what do you mean Somebody came into her house and murdered her What had happened in that house
00:36:06
An eyewitness account from Todd. I thought, oh my God, I want to get the children,
00:36:11
get the children out here. And what does this box have to do with a long ago fire and death on a dark mountain?
00:36:25
Stop right there. Turn around. Put your hands on top of your head. Drop down to your knees. Keep your hand on top of your head, you understand me?
00:36:39
Yes, I do. The scene that played out in front of the Todd and Rachel Winkler home in the air park that Monday morning, February 27, 2012,
00:36:48
grew more bizarre by the moment. As neighbor Marion Cockra watched the police surround Todd,
00:36:53
he saw something quite incomprehensible. They handcuffed him and took him off, and he didn't know what was going on.
00:37:01
Todd? Under arrest? Charged with murder for killing Rachel? What about her lover, the man with all the guns?
00:37:08
No, it was Todd in handcuffs. The investigators disappeared into the house and found a bloody crime scene
00:37:18
and Rachel Winkler dead in her baby's bedroom. They found the couple's three young children safe and sound across the street at a neighbor's house.
00:37:28
Todd had dropped them off there before the police arrived. Soon, Todd himself was sitting in an interview room at the sheriff's department,
00:37:36
where he admitted, yes, he killed Rachel, but he said he had no choice. And then he told the police a harrowing story of rage and violence and self-defense.
00:37:48
The trouble began the night before, Sunday night, he said, as he was preparing to leave early the next morning for work.
00:37:55
Rachel told him straight out she was leaving him for James. She'd come back to the arms of James White.
00:38:04
And then a few hours later, 3.30 Monday morning, when Todd went into the baby's room where Rachel had taken to sleeping,
00:38:10
they argued bitterly about custody of the children. I said, I'm not going to agree to you having the kids up here
00:38:20
and I'm not going to fight you on this. And she said, you know, I want to have my boyfriend get rid of you.
00:38:34
Her boyfriend is a big gun collector. As Todd told it, when Rachel said that, when she threatened to send James White to get rid of him,
00:38:44
whatever that meant, he overreacted and punched Rachel. Todd said he tried to apologize.
00:39:08
But then he said Rachel turned around and attacked him with a deadly weapon. And I got a hold of them.
00:39:20
We had a struggle on the bed and rolled off into the bed. And I got into this struggle over the scissors.
00:39:29
I took some cuts just on my hands trying to get them away from her. They wrestled on the bedroom floor, he said.
00:39:38
Just a couple of feet from the crib where seven-month-old Alex was sleeping. And overweight and out of shape, said Todd.
00:39:47
He was fighting for his life with his much fitter wife. It was a long, long, long protracted struggle.
00:39:54
I don't know how long, but it was a long time. She's a very strong girl, extremely strong girl.
00:40:02
And then she had me on bottom, and she was on time. I mean, went back and forth between bottom and top in this struggle over the scissors.
00:40:12
Then he said he finally overpowered her, got control of those scissors. I was able to get him turned around onto her and give her some jab.
00:40:21
She was... She was... She was injured at this point, but probably not seriously.
00:40:35
I poked her in the eye really hard and got her to break free. He retreated, he said, as quick as he could.
00:40:42
I got up and got out of the room and ran to my car. I got to my car and thought, get out of here.
00:40:51
I thought, oh my God, get the children, get the children out of here. His two daughters were in their room, but baby Alex was with the wounded Rachel.
00:40:59
Standing there in the garage, he said, he made a decision. He had to protect his children.
00:41:05
He would go back in and rescue them from Rachel. I grabbed my motorcycle jacket at that point, put it on, sift it up.
00:41:12
It's got pads over here for breaking down the door. and I rushed into the room. She must have been waiting, said Todd, to pounce.
00:41:22
He was, he told the police, soon in a fight to the death to save his own life. I tripped and fell forward when I rushed into the room.
00:41:30
She kicked me in the face and then we got into another subsequent struggle on the floor.
00:41:37
and once I started to get the upper hand, I just pushed the scissors in as far as I could.
00:41:54
And where was that do you recall In a third Uh In her throat I don know how long Very long time Okay and why did you hold her there like that with the scissors in
00:42:08
I knew if I let go. I mean, she still had a hand on the scissors. I was also fearing for, you know, she was a killer kind of situation.
00:42:20
Eventually, Todd got to his feet. He prepared a bottle for crying Alex, he said, and he worried.
00:42:27
And I just started just pacing around the house just now. By and by, Ariel and Eva woke up.
00:42:39
Todd kept them out of the room where their mom lay dead. Then he said he cleaned up the house as well as he could.
00:42:45
And at 1026 a.m., seven hours after Rachel died, He phoned a lawyer friend and asked him to inform the authorities.
00:42:55
Tell me exactly what you heard from your neighbor. What I'm willing to tell you is that I'm an attorney.
00:43:01
I received a call notifying me of the situation. About the same time, 10.30 a.m., Todd took his children to the neighbor's house.
00:43:08
I said there's been a... I didn't tell him Rachel was dead. I said we have a very serious situation across the street.
00:43:17
Can you please watch the kids? Murder investigations are, of course, based on more than just witness statements.
00:43:23
The CSI team rushed over to Todd and Rachel's house. And Assistant DA Lisette Suter joined them as they searched and documented the interior of a house that was strangely chaotic.
00:43:37
What did it look like? The house is well manicured, minus the fact that there's this yellow crime scene tape up.
00:43:43
And then you walk through that and you walk into the doors and the house is in complete disarray.
00:43:50
Kitchen is completely undone. Baseboards missing all over the place. The house is not put together at all.
00:43:59
Such an odd place. In the garage that doubled as a hanger, investigators found Todd's Mustang, Rachel's SUV, a boat, a BMW motorcycle, and parts of a plane Todd was refurbishing.
00:44:12
And back inside the house, in the master bedroom, in a nightstand, they found something else, too.
00:44:20
Something quite unexpected. This blue box. Inside, ashes. What? At the bottom of the box was a label that simply said,
00:44:33
Cremated Remains of Catherine Lynn Winkler. And now suddenly there were two mysteries to solve.
00:44:40
What really happened in the Winkler baby's bloodstained bedroom? And more than a decade and 2,000 miles away,
00:44:48
what was the ugly truth that burned on the mountainside in Georgia? Someone was keeping secrets.
00:44:59
Big secrets. We're realizing, wait, there was a former wife? And that was just the beginning.
00:45:10
When Todd Winkler was arrested for killing Rachel, he claimed it was self-defense.
00:45:25
He told the cops she came after him with those scissors. He had to protect his children and save himself,
00:45:31
even if it meant a duel to the death. It is a fellow killer to be killed kind of situation.
00:45:38
Prosecutor Lisette Suter listened carefully to Todd's version of events and was skeptical.
00:45:44
That's her job, of course. Still, no one else in Todd's house saw what happened, so there was no one to contradict his story.
00:45:53
But then the investigators found that box with ashes in it, and the label on the box said Catherine Lynn Winkler.
00:46:01
We're realizing, wait, there was a former wife? Oh, yes, there was. Todd Winkler had been married before, and clearly his ex-wife was dead.
00:46:11
So what happened to her? No choice, decided Prosecutor Suter, she would have to find out.
00:46:18
And that's when she set out to follow a trail that led to a man in Georgia named Gerald Johnson,
00:46:26
a judge now, but back in 1999, a rookie detective. It really shocked me that I was getting a call from California about a case that I had worked in our little gentle town there in White County.
00:46:39
Had you forgotten all about that case? No, sir. I actually, over the years, I've thought about that case many times.
00:46:45
The case, an auto accident in the fall of 99, an accident that killed the first Mrs. Winkler, Kathy.
00:46:54
My father called me that night and told me that Kathy was no longer with us. What was that like for you?
00:47:03
It hurts. It still hurts. So many years later, Charles Carlisle still smarts from the loss of his big sister Kathy.
00:47:12
Just never got over it. But then, Kathy was also his mentor, his protector, perhaps his only true friend.
00:47:20
They grew up on MacDill Air Force Base near Tampa, Florida. Charles, painfully shy.
00:47:26
Kathy, outgoing, strikingly attractive, popular. Tonya Van Adder and Julie Lynn Cox were school chums.
00:47:35
They remember what a knockout she was, but that there was more to her than just that.
00:47:41
She could have her choice of young men. She was beautiful, inside and out. It wasn't just her exterior beauty.
00:47:48
She was a beautiful girl, but she just had such a sweet, kind, caring personality that
00:47:52
was attractive to everybody. It was a small miracle, perhaps, that she turned out so well, given what was
00:48:00
demanded of her, said her friends. Her mother left when they were young. Her grandmother lived with her for a while,
00:48:06
but she was the caretaker of her siblings. She had a younger sister and younger brother,
00:48:10
and Kathy pretty much mothered them and cared for them. She definitely was the mom.
00:48:17
Except on weekends, when the school chums remember sneaking around the base to get a glimpse of the true stars among the young men there.
00:48:27
No surprise, it was the macho fighter pilots. The man in the uniform. Yes, that uniform.
00:48:33
The man in the uniform. Definitely. The jumper suit. Yes. Very hot. Kathy and I would always joke and say,
00:48:39
do you think you're going to marry a pilot? Wouldn't that be so cool? It's like Top Gun.
00:48:43
Marry a pilot. And of course, she ended up marrying one. Wasn't a direct route, mind you.
00:48:48
First, in her early 20s, Kathy struck up a serious relationship with a pilot who,
00:48:53
in the end, just couldn't seem to commit. And so, just like Rachel, years later in Napa, California,
00:49:02
Kathy was a young woman on the rebound when she met fighter pilot Todd. Where the first one didn't work out, or perhaps maybe it didn't work to the way that you wanted it to,
00:49:11
maybe she felt like this was what she needed to do, and Todd came into the picture.
00:49:16
I think having that pilot probably maybe is what caused her to marry Todd. Patterns.
00:49:23
That time, too, Todd was ready to commit. Right away. How long did they date before they got married?
00:49:31
I wouldn't say it was a very long time at all. They got married within weeks of dating.
00:49:36
She appeared to be happy, so I didn't question that. She had married her pilot, and so I thought, you know, her fairy tale is coming true.
00:49:44
The Air Force sent Todd to Japan soon after the wedding. It was an exhilarating time for Kathy.
00:49:51
Getting married, heading off to live in an exotic place. Kathy was excited to move to Japan, and she was going to be an English teacher.
00:50:00
And later, after Todd left the Air Force, Kathy's friends remember how she was there for him
00:50:04
as he tried to figure out what to do next. She was very nurturing in the fact that she was supporting him
00:50:10
in whatever different career he was going to choose. It was a difficult time for Todd.
00:50:15
We did spend Thanksgiving with them one year, and Todd had put on a lot of weight.
00:50:20
and I know that he wasn't working and he was depressed. But Todd always had a knack for making money
00:50:26
and he figured it out, got into the booming Wi-Fi business and pretty soon Kathy and Todd moved into a big lakeside house in Georgia
00:50:35
with a boat and fancy cars and of course an airplane. Kathy, always so nurturing, told her friend she was ready to take the next step.
00:50:46
I remember Kathy calling me and telling me that they were living in Georgia and that she was excited about it and that she wanted to have children.
00:50:54
So I was excited for her because I can see her with little kids. But nine years into what looked like a happy marriage, children had yet to arrive.
00:51:06
And now we know because of what was in that blue box, they never would. Time to find out what happened.
00:51:14
Who knew that the discovery in that box would bring investigators all the way across the country
00:51:20
to the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Georgia, to a campsite high on a hill. Here was a lonely place that had kept its secret long enough.
00:51:37
We finally come around this turn, the whole side of the mountain's on fire. A mysterious death and suspicion.
00:51:45
It just didn't add up. White County, Georgia. It's beautiful. Just nature at its best.
00:52:04
This is where the Blue Ridge Mountains begin. And it's sweet here. It's quite lovely.
00:52:08
It's beautiful. A person can find what really matters up here, said Mike Hodnett and Woody DePue.
00:52:15
Up here so far from the raucous urban world, our weekend steeped in the peace and beauty of a natural cathedral.
00:52:24
We ride our mountain bikes, go sit in the river, hike, go rappelling. Most of the time you're just, you're out there by yourself and you make your own rules.
00:52:33
And at night? You can go up to the top of the mountain and you can see a lot of stars you didn't know were there.
00:52:39
But down the sides of the mountain, under a thick canopy of leaves... Many, many nights it's just pitch black.
00:52:46
This is the place, these the conditions, that California Prosecutor Lisette Souter needed to understand.
00:52:52
It was September 26, 1999, one of those pitch black nights. The night Mike and Woody lived through one of the strangest experiences of their lives.
00:53:04
Mike and Woody were asleep in separate tents around a common campfire. At both, same moment, were suddenly startled awake.
00:53:12
I was sleeping in my tent, and I heard somebody shouting from the road about 100 yards away,
00:53:18
help, help, help, my wife is dead. This is the middle of the night? It's the middle of the night.
00:53:23
And then I kind of just laid there, and I was like, no, I didn't just hear that.
00:53:28
And then I heard it again. They got up fast, and out of the black night... some strange man come walking into their campsite going,
00:53:35
oh, help, help me, my wife is dead. The stranger was emotional, distraught, told them he and his wife had been camping
00:53:43
a few miles further up the narrow mountain road. He said that he had been stung by a bee
00:53:48
and that his wife was rushing him to the hospital and he was laying in the back of the truck He then told us that his wife lost control of the vehicle Then the pickup truck went over the edge and tumbled down the ridge he told them And then he was thrown out of the back bed of the truck
00:54:06
It just threw him out, and then he was able to walk away. He said it crashed at the bottom, burst into flames, with his wife still inside.
00:54:17
The man looked disheveled, but okay. He wanted to call 911, but told them he didn't have a cell phone with him.
00:54:25
And he wanted to try to find his wife, he told them. Woody and Mike told the stranger he could ride in the bed of their pickup truck
00:54:32
while they drove up the twisting track looking for the accident site. I kept asking, like, where's the wreck? Where's the wreck?
00:54:39
And then after that went on, you know, 20 or 30, 40 seconds, you know, going around different turns and stuff, we finally come around this turn,
00:54:50
and the whole side of the mountain's on fire. And obviously we knew we were there.
00:54:54
Looked like several acres of forest were on fire. Did it look like it was possible anybody could be alive down there?
00:55:02
No. No. Just the same. Woody and Mike climbed down the steep incline as far as they could.
00:55:08
I don't see how anybody could have survived that wreck, the cliff, the fire, but I'm still hopeful.
00:55:15
I've got to do something. But there was no getting near the truck and no sign of a survivor.
00:55:22
And then the firefighters came, and the EMTs, and of course the cops, and they too heard the husband's bizarre tale.
00:55:30
And they also learned his name was Todd Winkler. In their report, they wrote that when they encountered Todd,
00:55:37
he was calling out for his wife Kathy over and over again. Kathy, Kathy. As if he was hoping she'd come walking out of that burning forest.
00:55:46
The patrol deputies called in the investigators, which is how Gerald Johnson, a brand new detective at the time,
00:55:53
found himself deep in the Georgia woods early that autumn morning. So what happened up there on the hill was,
00:56:00
well, you can describe to me as best you understood at the time what had happened.
00:56:04
Sometime during the night, he had gotten up, according to his statement, to go outside to use the restroom.
00:56:12
And as he came back to the tent, he realized that he had been bitten by something
00:56:16
or was having some type of reaction that his throat was closing up. Sort of anaphylactic shock type reaction.
00:56:22
That's what I described it as. And she takes him out to this Toyota pickup, if I remember correctly.
00:56:30
He's crawling on his hands and knees at this point and having all these symptoms of some type of allergic reaction.
00:56:38
Johnson mostly just observed, he said, as the Georgia Bureau of Investigation looked into what happened,
00:56:44
but took no action. And eventually the coroner ruled Kathy's death an accident. Then the life insurance company did the same.
00:56:53
And as the more than half-million-dollar policy on Kathy's life was a double indemnity,
00:56:59
it paid double in the case of an accident, Todd got close to $1.2 million. And the case was closed.
00:57:07
But for the heartbreak, it was Julie Lynn who told Tanya what happened. And she said,
00:57:13
Tanya, Kathy's dead. She's not alive anymore. She died. I remember falling to the ground and I said, what do you mean she's dead?
00:57:31
Kathy's friend Julie Lynn felt not just for herself, but for Todd too. I wanted to console him and just let him know that we were there for him, supporting him.
00:57:42
anything we could do for him. And he never returned any of my calls. Tanya? Tanya tried to call him too.
00:57:51
Different reason. It just didn't add up. My phone call was strictly to figure out
00:57:55
and to pick his brain and ask questions. Because by then, Tanya was a cop herself
00:58:01
who knew a little something about suspicious behavior. Did I think he was going to answer that phone?
00:58:07
No. And let me tell you, I tried that phone number numerous times. And after about a month of calling it repeatedly, the phone number was disconnected.
00:58:16
She didn't get anywhere now. But sometimes, maybe with a little help from a curious prosecutor, you get a do-over.
00:58:26
So as the years went by, you thought about it? Oh, yes, sir. Bothered you? Yes. So that must have made that call that you got from California all the more remarkable.
00:58:38
When I realized what they were asking me about, yes, sir, I thought, oh, my goodness, what in the world is going on with this case?
00:58:49
The more we read, the more we realized that this was not an accident. So many questions about that long-ago case, starting with, why was Kathy even camping?
00:58:59
Was it camping? Kathy was not a camper. Once, when outsiders came to these North Georgia mountains and valleys,
00:59:20
it was to make a movie called Deliverance. This time, the visitors were California detectives.
00:59:26
Here to find out exactly what happened on this mountain path on a dark night more than a decade ago.
00:59:33
We got all those police reports. Out in California, 15 years later, Prosecutor Lisette Souter was convinced
00:59:40
for the sake of her own case, she had to find out what really happened up here on this isolated mountain road in September 1999.
00:59:49
What is very important about the Georgia case in our case is it goes to his intent in the Rachel case And before long she knew this was going to be explosive The Georgia case could be her best evidence in the here and now in California
01:00:08
to show that Todd Winkler was perfectly capable of spousal murder because, she soon believed, he had done it before.
01:00:17
The more we read, the more we realized that this was not an accident. Todd's behavior up here on the mountain, said Prosecutor Suter, was deeply suspect.
01:00:27
For one thing, his stories just kept changing with each telling. Like the one about where he was sitting in the truck as it headed down the mountain trail,
01:00:35
in the passenger seat holding Kathy's hand as he told the police, or back in the bed of the truck as the campers insisted he told them.
01:00:44
And when the truck went off the road... Did he describe being thrown out of the vehicle?
01:00:49
Well, not to us, but there was another interview that was done earlier where I think he described to someone as a twisting and turning motion.
01:00:57
But in our interview, what I recall him saying is that when he came to himself, he was laying on the ground outside the vehicle.
01:01:05
There was a huge fire and he didn't know where his wife was. So that he didn't remember the accident at all in your interview.
01:01:14
Right. But apparently he didn't in some other interview. And that's correct. There were differing stories, too, about what sort of bug supposedly bit him,
01:01:24
supposedly causing an allergic reaction so bad he had to ask Kathy to rush him down the mountain to a hospital.
01:01:31
And yet when the cops asked to see the bug bite... He didn't know where the bug bite was. Didn't know what bit him.
01:01:37
Didn't know where it was? No, sir. Something serious enough to give him an allergic reaction that doesn't present anywhere is a bit odd.
01:01:46
And that was a big question in my mind. Todd told the cops back then he'd had a history of allergic reactions,
01:01:53
always carried an EpiPen for emergencies, yet didn't take that to the wilderness that weekend.
01:02:00
Did that seem strange to you, that he'd go camping without an EpiPen if he was subject to this sort of thing?
01:02:05
It seemed strange to me that we were spending so much time talking about bug bites.
01:02:09
It was almost as if we were trying to steer away from the real issue, which was a fatality crash involving his wife.
01:02:17
It also seemed strange, he said, that by the time the campers saw Todd, he displayed no evidence of an allergic reaction.
01:02:24
Of course, Lisette Suter and her people interviewed Mike and Woody, too. And they told her, as they told us,
01:02:31
that they never forgot how strangely phony Todd seemed when he arrived at their campsite that night.
01:02:38
He was kind of play-sobbing, I would say. It was some horrible acting going on. Was it believable?
01:02:46
He also wondered why on a warm southern night was Todd dressed in several layers of heavy clothing.
01:02:53
Was he protecting himself from a fall he knew he was going to cause? He had a lot of extra clothing on, but I remember he also had a toboggan hat on.
01:03:02
The kind you pull down over your ears. And I'm standing there in a t-shirt, shorts, and flip-flops.
01:03:07
Also, why did the accident happen on the one spot in the whole drive that offered a long straight drop hundreds of feet into a deep ravine?
01:03:17
The steepest cliff possible on that road. Why did their Toyota pickup erupt into flames?
01:03:23
That might happen in the movies, but rarely in real life. Why did it look like the fire had been burning for a long time?
01:03:30
It was the whole side of the mountain. It was a big mountain. It had to have been burning an hour or two.
01:03:36
I would think. Probably closer to two. Curiosities. Why would he bring her up here to the very top of the mountain to go camping?
01:03:44
It's an hour's drive over a rutted track to the other campers farther down the hill.
01:03:50
According to Kathy's family, she didn't like camping at all. So why would he bring her to the most remote possible place?
01:03:57
No one camps up there unless you want to be really secluded. And that, said Kathy's brother, was not something she would have wanted.
01:04:08
Did she like to go camping? She'd rather be in a hotel any day over at a tent than my sister.
01:04:17
Puzzled Kathy's friends, too. I was at camping? Kathy was not a camper. And there was this.
01:04:24
I recall him at some point, Mr. Winkler saying, Do you think I killed my wife? Is that a question an innocent man would ask, Johnson wondered.
01:04:35
And when the investigator responded, Johnson remembered thinking Todd's behavior seemed off, inappropriate.
01:04:43
If I remember correctly, Special Agent Roberts says, did you? And then at that point, he became very emotional.
01:04:51
You know, oh, I can't believe. And just his body language and his demeanor was just so over the top.
01:04:59
But, though they may have had their suspicions back in 1999, suspicion alone didn't make the death of Kathy Winkler
01:05:07
anything but what it was called at the time, an accident. Insurance companies investigated and paid out
01:05:13
because they felt that it was a real accident, and the authorities there couldn't show that it wasn't a real accident.
01:05:20
So, why was it worth you looking at it again? Well, we knew a lot more about Todd Winkler at this point.
01:05:27
We knew a lot more about how he goes about getting what he wants. The more she learned about Kathy Winkler's death, the more it seemed to her that Todd must have planned it all.
01:05:42
Just as the evidence here in California was telling her that the killing of Rachel Winkler more than a decade later was a case of history, Todd Winkler's history, repeating itself.
01:05:53
but if she had some crusading idea of finding justice in that old case and using it to solidify her own here in California She have to persuade a judge first
01:06:08
Disorder in the court. You're no casino! You're no casino! Once a long time ago, this part of California was the epicenter of the gold rush.
01:06:36
Back then, as legend has it at least, there was no wait for justice. You committed a crime. The punishment was meted out then and there.
01:06:44
But not now. For more than two years after the bloody confrontation in the Winkler's nursery,
01:06:50
Todd waited in jail to be tried for his wife Rachel's murder. And I just started just pacing around the house just saying, God, I just don't want to do anything.
01:07:06
For those two years, Todd maintained, as he had from the very beginning, that he killed Rachel only to save his own wife, to save himself and his children.
01:07:16
From jail, he and his family fought a losing battle with Rachel's father, Don Hatfield, who won custody of those children.
01:07:23
and here began atoning for the sins of his youth by devoting his life to three little kids,
01:07:30
Eva, Ariel, and Alex. Oh, that's the baby brother. It was after all that that they held the trial.
01:07:40
Prosecutor Lisette Souter intended to portray Todd as a manipulative and devious man
01:07:45
who murdered not one wife, but two. That is, if she could persuade a California judge
01:07:52
to allow an old Georgia case to be dusted off and brought back to life. I felt confident that I had the law behind me on that,
01:08:00
and I submitted my brief, and I submitted the legal arguments that supported that.
01:08:06
And she won. And so, September of 2014, when Todd Winkler went on trial charged with the first-degree murder of his second wife, Rachel,
01:08:16
the set suitor could use the Georgia story about first-wife Kathy's death 15 years earlier against him.
01:08:24
And the defense? Dismissed the Georgia case out of hand. Irrelevant, said Todd's attorney.
01:08:31
Kathy Winkler's death was thoroughly investigated, he said, and was not ruled a murder because it was not a murder.
01:08:40
There's no evidence of anything other than an accident. Todd's attorney was able to explain away the things that had raised suspicion.
01:08:47
Kathy's family was wrong, said the defense. She loved camping. A ranger who saw them making their dinner way up in this remote spot so far from any other living soul said they seemed happy.
01:08:59
And the insurance money, remember that? That wasn't motive, just business as usual for a pair of upper-middle-class professionals.
01:09:08
In addition to the insurance policy of about 1.1 that Kathy had at the time of her death on her own life,
01:09:15
he had 1.2 million on his own life. No. Kathy and Todd were a young, awkwardly mobile couple.
01:09:21
Life insurance was cheap, easy to get. They both had it. Anyway, Todd loved Kathy. Why else would he keep her ashes all these years?
01:09:31
Kathy's death said the defense had nothing whatever to do with the event for which Todd was on trial,
01:09:37
the death of Rachel Winkler. And he wasn't guilty in this case either. This is not a murder case, ladies and gentlemen.
01:09:43
This is a self-defense case, or at most, it's a voluntary manslaughter case. There were two good reasons to believe that, said the defense.
01:09:59
Reason one, self-defense. As Todd told the police that very first day, He was a good guy in a bad situation, said his attorney.
01:10:13
He worked hard and long hours to support Rachel. He wanted to make her happy. He was a good dad.
01:10:20
And for that, she cheated on him, threatened him, and then attacked with those scissors.
01:10:24
Of course, by that point, Todd told the police, she was a very unstable woman. Started drinking, started binge drinking.
01:10:31
I was afraid for the children. She was just spinning into this mental cycle of self-destruction.
01:10:39
And then Todd's defense revealed this little gem. She signed up for California Sweetheart, which is an adult connection, kind of a, you can judge for yourselves what it is.
01:10:51
Married to a man she'd grown to hate, in an affair with a man she was maybe thinking of cheating on, said the defense.
01:10:59
She was conflicted, said Todd's attorney. She was telling people she was afraid of Todd, and yet she sure didn't act like it here.
01:11:08
Todd and Rachel looked happy. Compare it with this photograph taken in Las Vegas, just a few days before Rachel died.
01:11:16
But there was something else, said Todd's attorney. And it was reason number two that Rachel's death was not murder.
01:11:23
And that was that his client had a psychotic breakdown when Rachel attacked him.
01:11:27
His ability to understand what he was doing was diminished. Why should a jury believe that?
01:11:33
Well, as you'll remember, Rachel herself described Todd as unstable at times. and now the defense presented evidence of what they said was his history of psychotic episodes.
01:11:44
The first one happened in Asia something like 20 years earlier when Todd was married to Kathy
01:11:49
and was flying with the Fighting Samurai Squadron. He was caught shoplifting from a base PX.
01:11:56
He claimed amnesia. So the Air Force sent him... psychiatric tests. But then it got even more bizarre, and Kathy called her friend Tanya.
01:12:07
She telephoned me saying, I'm in Hawaii. Todd had a mental breakdown, and so he's in a psychiatric
01:12:15
facility. She had said to me that he escaped and was in the wooded area in Hawaii for a week or two,
01:12:24
and when he finally came out of the woods, he said that he was a samurai warrior.
01:12:29
Back then, after months of psychiatric evaluation, Todd was diagnosed with dissociative disorder,
01:12:35
a neurosis that warped his view of reality. Not exactly what the Air Force wanted in a fighter pilot.
01:12:41
And because of events and determinations by the Air Force psychiatrists, he was retired medically with a 50% disability.
01:12:55
And there was that incident in Amsterdam, remember? Rachel told James about it. It happened just before he was due to make an important presentation at a conference.
01:13:05
That time he appeared to black out, became catatonic, ended up in the hospital, where they found nothing wrong with him, and released him.
01:13:13
Rachel told James he faked the episode. But here at the trial, a defense psychiatrist testified that Todd suffered from real mental issues,
01:13:22
dissociative disorder, conversion disorder, which meant he could be violent if he felt he was under attack.
01:13:30
And that awful morning, first he told police she threatened to sick her well-armed boyfriend on him.
01:13:36
And she said, you know, I want to have my boyfriend get rid of you. And then, she's coming at me with a V of scissors.
01:13:48
Rachel's dad, Don, and self-described soulmate James watched as the defense argued that Todd had no choice but to kill the woman they so loved.
01:13:58
His state of mind is what you really need to pay careful attention to here. He knows that she'll kill him.
01:14:07
He knows that if he stops, if he doesn't end it right then, that it could end him.
01:14:14
All very sad, said the defense, but not murder. And what would Prosecutor Souter say about that?
01:14:21
Simple. All that psychiatric stuff, she said, was fakery. Todd Winkler may have had or feigned some disorder that got him out of the Air Force, she said,
01:14:32
but he killed Rachel, and it was murder deliberate and planned, she said, committed by a man practiced at getting away with things.
01:14:41
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. This is a case about a mastermind, a manipulator, a murderer.
01:14:48
However, this is a case about Todd Winkler and how he brutally murdered Rachel Marie
01:14:54
Winkler, his wife, mother of his three small children. Todd Winkler did not have to fend off a scissor wife said Prosecutor Souter so it wasn self And Rachel death could not be blamed on any mental condition either Any more than the death of another Mrs Winkler in those dark woods so long ago
01:15:17
But as she began to tell that part of the story, watch what happened. She's found burned to death down a steep embankment where the car went.
01:15:28
The car and she burned. And the defendant is very fine with just a few minor scratches on him.
01:15:35
You are not samurai! Stop! You do not speak truth! You only want to destroy! You are no Bushido!
01:15:47
You are no Bushido! Bayliss and his lawyer struggled to restrain Todd. It looked like the whole trial would be over.
01:15:59
Whatever happens, somebody had already made up her mind. I was told that monsters don't exist.
01:16:07
My parents always told me that. I can tell you with absolute certainty that is 110% false.
01:16:15
He is a monster. She's found burned to death down a steep embankment. Just as the prosecutor was laying out her case against Todd Winkler and the killing of his wife Rachel,
01:16:37
a sudden, inexplicable outburst from Todd. You are not samurai! Stop! You do not speak truth!
01:16:49
You only want to destroy! You are no Bushido! You are no Bushido! Bushido? In Japanese, the way of the warrior, the honor-based code of conduct of a samurai.
01:17:01
Why was Todd Winkler raving about it now? Was this another psychotic episode? Stop. Stop.
01:17:11
Of course, the trial came to a screeching halt. A mistrial loomed. But once order was restored, the judge allowed the prosecutor to continue.
01:17:23
As I was saying, the defendant's former wife, Kathy Winkler, went on a camping trip back on September 26th of 1999
01:17:31
with this defendant. She died in a fiery crash. The only witness to the crime was, in fact, this defendant.
01:17:40
Were there parallels? You bet there were, said Prosecutor Souter. The deaths of Kathy and Rachel
01:17:46
were both cold-blooded, calculated killings. He's had now two wives where he has been the one
01:17:53
who has been the only witness to a crime. But, she said, based on what investigators found,
01:18:00
The events at 3 o'clock in the morning in the California air park were not so hard to determine, and she prepared the jury.
01:18:07
What happened that night was horrific. 1. Todd opened Rachel's laptop and found the divorce documents
01:18:16
she been working on with her boyfriend James That laptop disappeared from its usual place in the Winkler home Number two he grabbed the scissors from a craft box which was kept on a shelf right above the
01:18:28
computer. And three, I believe he took a pair of scissors and he went in that room with the intent
01:18:36
to kill her. He attacked her while she was sleeping, stabbed her repeatedly in the face and the neck
01:18:42
area and I believe at that point he thought he had killed her and he left her for dead.
01:18:48
Then, said the prosecutor, as Todd prepared to leave the house, he saw a light had been turned
01:18:53
on in the baby's room. So that's when he then goes, gets his motorcycle jacket on for padding,
01:19:01
for protection, bangs in the door, finds her in that corner. Cowering. Cowering.
01:19:11
Try to save her own life. Correct. They knew that Rachel spent some time after the first attack holding her baby.
01:19:18
Baby Alex's onesie was examined. And you know that there are drip blood, like being dropped blood up on top of that onesie.
01:19:30
That's how we know that Rachel was holding that baby. Then Todd came back. She's in the corner there.
01:19:39
She kicks at him. didn't stop him. He bear crawls up her body. He takes those scissors and this ex-fighter pilot
01:19:47
jams them into her neck and he sits there and lays there on top of her while she slowly dies.
01:19:53
After that, for seven hours, Todd cleaned up, said the prosecutor, then took his kids to the
01:19:59
neighbor's house. And then after dropping the kids at the neighbor's, but before the cops arrived,
01:20:05
He took the time to cut his hands to make it look as if he'd been attacked by Rachel.
01:20:11
How did they know the cuts were self-inflicted? The neighbor said his hands weren't cut when he dropped off the kids.
01:20:18
And then the prosecutor told the jury about the ashes, Kathy Winkler's ashes, which Rachel discovered months before she was killed.
01:20:28
And learned how there had been a crash and he had no injuries and she had died. Rachel was upset by this
01:20:38
and said, well, is this how I'm going to turn out? And this defendant's reply was,
01:20:43
well, you're not going to get in my way, are you? Rachel knew she was in danger, said Prosecutor Souter,
01:20:49
as a doomed young woman had already told her closest friends and family. And Rachel explained that this defendant said to Rachel,
01:20:56
if you divorce me, you will end up like my last wife. She did. After 13 days of testimony, the jury got the case.
01:21:08
They were out one day. We the jury impaneled in the above entitled action by the defendant Todd Allen Winkler,
01:21:16
guilty of the crime of first-degree murder. No outburst this time, no breakdown.
01:21:21
The former fighter pilot sat quietly and listened. He got 26 years to life. It was over for Todd But not for anyone else Not really As James White daughter Caitlin told us I was told that monsters don exist
01:21:39
My parents always told me that. And after going through that trial and seeing what I had to see,
01:21:45
I can tell you with absolute certainty that that is 110% false. He is a monster.
01:21:53
And Rachel's men? we weren't surprised to hear that James has his own idea of what justice might be.
01:22:01
Did you have any thoughts about what would happen if the justice system didn't look after Todd in a way that seemed reasonable to you?
01:22:11
He would have been dealt with. By whom? Me. You know, they could have put you in prison for life.
01:22:18
It would have been a one-way mission. He and I are both going to go down together.
01:22:22
I'm not going to shoot him. I'm going to kill him with my two bare hands. I'm going to do to him what he did to Rachel.
01:22:31
Tim Charrington, the man who failed to commit and then watched the love of his life go on to her terrible end,
01:22:38
has his own way of taking revenge, mostly on himself. Kind of a tragic love story from your point of view.
01:22:45
It is, it is. I mean, this is a woman you could have spent the rest of your life with.
01:22:49
Very, very easily could. Yes, I should have pulled the trigger when I had that chance, you know.
01:22:54
I blew it. I didn't, you know, give her the ring earlier. Well, you're still paying for it, aren't you?
01:22:59
Yeah, yes, I am, yeah. That's a tough one. Different kind of thinking across the country.
01:23:09
Among the friends of that other Mrs. Winkler, the one whose death on a lonely mountain road is still officially labeled accident.
01:23:17
I mean, this is a beautiful woman who gave so much, was so nurturing and caring.
01:23:23
I don't feel like there's been justice for Kathy. I think about Kathy's death all the time.
01:23:28
About whether she could somehow have done more to prevent a second death, the murder of Rachel Winkler.
01:23:35
My heart breaks for those children. I wish I could hug them all and tell them I'm so sorry that I didn't press harder
01:23:47
to make them open this case or be that strong person that I was. I apologize. And someday, said Don Hatfield,
01:23:59
he'll find the words to tell the story to Rachel's children, Ariel, Alex, and Eva.
01:24:06
This whole story is a mixture of murder and blood and failings and grace and Jesus and heaven and God, and there's some real craziness to it.
01:24:16
But that's the character of my life and some of Rachel's life, and it's just kind of life in general.
01:24:25
In the meantime, he said, he's trying to be the kind of parent he wasn't with his own children, but is now for Rachel.
01:24:35
I believe it's my destiny to raise them. I intend to do that, you know, with God's help.