00:00:00
I have a lot of guilt still in me. It makes me sick how I could do something like that. I am the responsible one. A working mom, new at the office. She loved
00:00:15
her job and really loved her handsome young boss. The thing that I never wanted to face was the hurt that I was gonna cause. A passionate nine-to-five affair.
00:00:27
The problem, she was married, and so was he. I grabbed his face and I was like, you know what, I love you.
00:00:35
I'm not going anywhere. Just tell me what's happening. Cheating husbands, scheming wives, being unfaithful to your spouse isn't a crime, is it?
00:00:44
That would come next. It was just like every emotion possible all in one second.
00:00:52
I went, oh my God. My God. Murder in the dark. Who was behind it? And who would pay?
00:01:00
When you see him on the video, he's armed and ready. Two couples, two families, and the single moment that shattered it all.
00:01:08
I knew one day that this was all gonna come out. I'm Lester Holt and this is Dateline.
00:01:15
Here's Keith Morrison. Look at this place now So ordinary With its pharmacy, its grocery store
00:01:26
Its carefully tended parking places So alike to suburban strip malls From Bismarck to Bakersfield
00:01:32
But that night That cold night of heat Gathered here, sweet, terrifying Doomed For the longest time
00:01:45
I couldn't go anywhere because I'm thinking everybody's looking at me. This is the story of two married couples,
00:01:57
of the advice they can offer others now that it's too late for them. I think if I could tell them anything,
00:02:03
it would be, put your family first. But of course, that's not what happened. And this parking lot?
00:02:13
There'll be a body here before we're done. Careful when you stir the hot pot of desire.
00:02:27
The place is Meridian, Idaho, little brother to bigger Boise here in the foothills of the majestic Rockies.
00:02:34
This is where they got to their perfect place, the end of their rainbow. It was 2006, and luck was on their side.
00:02:42
They had just moved from Southern California, and they were happy. They were fulfilled at work.
00:02:47
They had two beautiful children. They had everything they ever wanted. They were Rob and Candy Hall,
00:02:53
one of those charmed couples who'd fallen in love at first sight, in their case, first sight meant admiring each other in the gym.
00:03:01
We were out, I think, that weekend, and then we never stopped. What was it about that relationship?
00:03:08
What was it about him that you liked somebody that was so good? We just connected instantly.
00:03:13
By the time Rob and Candy moved to Idaho, they'd been together for years, had two teenage daughters.
00:03:19
Rob landed an excellent job as a computer specialist at the Ada County Sheriff's Office,
00:03:24
specializing in vehicle locators inside squad cars. He loved every minute of his job.
00:03:32
And as if it was a sign that this is where they belong, Candy's career as a paralegal took off, too.
00:03:38
She was a natural, could and did sell her confidence and skills to anybody who walked in the door.
00:03:44
It didn't hurt that she was pretty. No, it didn't. And her co-worker, Sophia Serna, idolized Candy.
00:03:53
You became close. Oh, we became very close. She was like a mother to me. Yes, it was all just about perfect.
00:04:01
And then, who knows why these things happen exactly. They just do. And no one imagined, why would they, how this thing was going to end.
00:04:12
About eight months into his new job, Rob started traveling for work. Nothing unusual about that, of course.
00:04:18
But soon, he seemed to be staying away from home a little longer than he really had to.
00:04:23
Started snapping at her, too, Candy said, about little things. Not like the old Rob at all.
00:04:30
So, at this point, you begin to suspect something? Yeah, I start thinking, what is going on?
00:04:35
Why are you acting like this? And then one night, after a late flight in from California,
00:04:41
Rob lay down beside his wife in bed, and it all came tumbling out. He just started to cry, and he said, I'm having an affair.
00:04:52
And I laid my head on his chest, and I said, Rob, please, just fix it. You didn't get upset? You didn't yell? You didn't scream? You didn't cry? You didn't do anything?
00:05:06
That's what shocked him. You know, the typical response is, get the hell out of here.
00:05:11
You throw the clothes out the window. Oh, no. The last person on this planet that you would think to have an affair would be Robert.
00:05:21
But of course, it was devastating, crippling. Every day she went to work and every day Sophia saw her friend turn herself inside out and just seemed to wither.
00:05:32
I watched her go through misery. sobbing in her hands daily and just trying to figure out what this woman had that she didn't.
00:05:42
Did she still love him? Yes, dearly. And wanted the marriage to continue in spite of the affair?
00:05:48
Yes, she did. She didn want to believe in her head that he found something in this woman that wasn in Candy Well he felt bad about it agreed to go through counseling with candy but after he confessed to you and you said fix it he didn He didn know what he wanted Come on no I mean
00:06:08
he wanted to keep going with the affair, that's what he wanted. I for sure told him to stop.
00:06:12
Stop right now or I'll stamp my foot and hold my breath. Yeah. And he kept doing it. Yeah,
00:06:17
it was my fault. He had a void because of me. That's what I was thinking. What do you think
00:06:22
the void might have been or what did you think the void? I just was boring. Boring old Candy Hall,
00:06:29
rejected, apparently unlovable, and nearly 40. And then one day at work, Candy was introduced to a
00:06:37
recent law school graduate who was looking to staff his new office. A boyishly handsome, smart as a
00:06:43
a cocky young lawyer. His name was Emmett Corrigan. My friend, she said, Emmett, you've got to meet Candy.
00:06:53
I mean, she's just as passionate and aggressive as you are, and she would be great for you.
00:06:59
And something suddenly lifted in Candy Hall. By the time those words had left her friend's mouth,
00:07:06
Candy knew. She just knew. When we come back, Candy Hall has a decision to make, and it will have consequences she never intended.
00:07:20
Deadly ones. The text popped up and Rob read it. Rob was, why are you texting my wife?
00:07:40
In Boise, Idaho, inside this law office in the fall of 2010, was a paralegal whose charmed life was falling apart.
00:07:48
Candy Hall was an unhappy woman. Her marriage was dying or dead. Her 40th birthday was bearing down like a Chinese bullet train.
00:07:57
But then one day, it got worse. Candy's boss told her she was also unemployed. My husband's had an affair.
00:08:06
Now my attorney, who I work for, has fired me. Yeah, pretty low. Such problems. And then there was him.
00:08:18
Emmett Corrigan fixed everything. He was handsome and he thought she was gorgeous.
00:08:24
And of course, he hired her right away for his new law office. And, well, you know what came next.
00:08:31
Soon there were racy emails, spicy text messages. I would like to be put on that pedestal.
00:08:39
Emmett made me feel that way. It was pretty much of an ego boost for me. And she really wasn't trying to get back at her husband, said Candy.
00:08:46
At least not consciously. I was thinking about me. And only me. You know what? It made me feel good.
00:08:54
It made me feel like I was on top of the world. Sitting here now, is Candy still thinking only of Candy?
00:09:02
Perhaps as you hear the rest of the story, you can be the judge of that. Anyway, back then there were a few hitches in Candy's newfound fantasy life.
00:09:12
To start with, Emmett Corrigan was also married and lived in this quiet cul-de-sac just a couple of miles from Candy
00:09:18
with this woman, his wife, Ashley. He was just a guy that everybody wanted to be around.
00:09:27
Enthusiastic, full of energy. Sometimes too much energy, but that's kind of one of the things I loved about him.
00:09:35
Just like Candy and Rob, Ashley and Emmett met in a gym. Theirs was in college in Utah, 2003.
00:09:43
Also inseparable from that moment on. And they certainly made a striking young couple.
00:09:49
They were married after just six months together. Made their vows before God and the church in the LDS temple.
00:09:55
And? We both were like, you know what? I think I'm ready to be a parent. First came twin girls, followed soon by a son and then another daughter.
00:10:05
He loved being a dad just as much as I loved being a mom. In the winter, they went skiing and sledding.
00:10:12
In the summer, they camped and swam at the lake they so loved. They made memories.
00:10:17
Ashley never doubted this was how their life was supposed to be. She was pregnant with her fifth child
00:10:24
when her ambitious husband opened his law office that fall of 2010 and made the fateful decision to hire a paralegal named Candy Hall.
00:10:34
Not that he had any idea. He was Celia's fate, of course. And he more than his wife, Ashley, understood his private motivations.
00:10:44
Did you suspect she was involved with Emmett? With Emmett? Yeah. No. Why? The way he described her was an older woman who he looked up to in a motherly way.
00:10:55
He said, she just believes in me. She thinks I'm going to be this great lawyer. And you saw her and she was an older woman.
00:11:02
She was almost 40 and I was 28. So I don't, it wasn't something that I felt like a competition of, I guess.
00:11:10
But for the many reasons that plainly escaped those who aren't seated smack on the hot stove of desire themselves,
00:11:17
Emmett and Candy thought otherwise. Oh, they tried to keep their hands off each other for a little while, said their co-workers,
00:11:23
but if they believed they were hiding their obvious infatuation, their suddenly messy hair, their hastily rearranged clothes,
00:11:31
they were only fooling themselves. I noticed a significant change in her attitude.
00:11:37
Went from being depressed about what Rob had done to happy, you know. Springing her step again.
00:11:45
Oh, yeah. Such timing. Now that Rob seemed to want to fix their marriage, Candy became a study in pretense.
00:11:52
Honesty took a holiday. I was living a lie Being in an affair is just living one big lie You lie about everything Yes And she lied to herself too
00:12:06
You were thinking of you and he together striding across the bow of the Titanic.
00:12:11
This is going to be it for you for... ever. Yes. Then one night, a couple of months into the affair,
00:12:18
events suddenly ticked measurably toward their deadly conclusion. Around bedtime, Candy received a text from Emmett and couldn't hide it.
00:12:28
The text popped up and Rob read it and it said, I wish I was there with you tonight.
00:12:35
What did he say? He was angry. He just, Candy, what is this? And I said, I don't know.
00:12:40
So he calls Emmett. Rob was, why are you texting my wife at this time of night? Emmett's answer.
00:12:49
Two minutes later, he showed up at Rob's house. They talked like dueling lovers out on the sidewalk.
00:12:55
Then Rob came back inside. Rob tossed my phone up on our bed and he said, you win.
00:13:02
I can't compete. He's young. He's a good looking guy. He's an attorney. You make him a lot of money.
00:13:11
What good am I? And he was just devastated. Now you've got yourself a pretty complicated life at this stage.
00:13:19
Yeah. Of course, that February 2011, Emmett's life was complicated too. Ashley could see how stressed he was, didn't understand it.
00:13:30
That or why he seemed to avoid coming home. There was one time when my son asked me if he lived with us anymore.
00:13:41
And later in the bedroom, he was like, what's that all about? And I was just like, well, we miss you.
00:13:46
And he just kind of yelled and screamed and left. Ashley thought maybe it was her fault.
00:13:54
She went to marriage counseling. Emmett refused to go. I had felt really pushed away and was trying to find an answer
00:14:02
and tried to surprise him by cleaning out his car and found a weird envelope. Weird envelope?
00:14:08
Just an envelope that was some sort of pill. I researched online and one of the side effects was problems with intimacy and sexuality.
00:14:21
I thought maybe if he was doing that, that could explain why he didn't necessarily want me.
00:14:28
Did you take it personally, too, though? You want to be everything that they want.
00:14:34
So it was hard not to take personal. Especially when Emmett, who'd been working out more and more,
00:14:40
announced he was going to a fitness competition in Ohio on their wedding anniversary.
00:14:47
What did that feel like? Lonely. he called and said happy anniversary I'll call you later but didn't call back
00:14:53
and the night before he came home my um oldest son who was he just turned four was screaming one night for probably two hours my dad's gonna die my dad's gonna die he's gonna die
00:15:09
and I just held him tried calling him but he never answered his phone it was a very strange weekend
00:15:16
strange strange is not a big enough word to describe what was about to happen coming up i literally was like please do not leave and he said no i'm i'm leaving a secret
00:15:35
meeting at walgreens and something will go horribly wrong i said no i'm not doing this
00:15:41
He's like, oh, we are doing this. When Dateline continues. It was the 11th of March, 2011.
00:16:01
This was it. The big event. D-Day, you could say. It was early evening. Cold as the sun went down the meridian.
00:16:10
cold and bleak. And in two homes in particular, it was very bleak indeed. Candy Hall arrived home from work
00:16:18
to find her husband Rob packing boxes to leave. What other reason could there be?
00:16:25
I know we were probably coming down to the wire. You're having the kind of unfair fights
00:16:30
that married couples have all the time. They betray each other with abandon and then wonder why it doesn't work out.
00:16:37
The thing that I never wanted to face was the hurt that I was going to cause on so many people. I knew one day that this was all
00:16:50
going to come out, but the way that it usually ends up. Well, now you can only look back and
00:16:56
wish it had turned out that way. Around the same time across town, perhaps two miles away,
00:17:02
Ashley Corrigan had just made the mistake of telling her husband Emmett that in her desperate
00:17:07
state of worry, she'd asked her family members to pray for them. He said, your family, I hate your
00:17:15
family. I could beat your brother up. I could kill all of you. But I grabbed his face and I was like,
00:17:20
you know what? I love you. I'm not going anywhere. I don't care what it is. Just tell me what's
00:17:27
happening. And I don't know, I felt like that was the last chance and he didn't take it. He didn't
00:17:32
He didn't open up about anything. That night, though, a trusted family member who'd agreed to help counsel the couple called.
00:17:41
And Emmett answered the phone. He went back into our bedroom. And I could hear everything he was saying because the baby monitor was on.
00:17:48
The hard part then was not a word he said was true. What was he saying? I think she might be sleeping with this person She says I the worst father ever And just things that I know I had never done So when he walked out I flipped the baby monitor off
00:18:06
And I said, oh, how did it go? It went good. He thinks you're as crazy as I do. And I said, oh, OK, well, do I get a turn?
00:18:15
He said, I don't care what you do, but you're not using my phone. And Emile said, hey, I'm going to run to Walgreens and I'll be right back.
00:18:23
I put the phone down and I literally was like, Emmett, please do not leave. And he said, no, I'm leaving.
00:18:31
Do you must have felt like your life was flying apart and you didn't know what to do?
00:18:34
I kind of felt like, okay, maybe this is the grand finale. But he needed a wake-up call.
00:18:39
He did. He needed a wake-up call. Careful what you wish for. Getting late now. Very dark.
00:18:46
Over at the hall house, Candy had been talking to her husband, Rob. Maybe he shouldn't move out.
00:18:52
Maybe they should try to fix their marriage, make it work somehow. And then, right in the middle of that, she suddenly told him she had an errand to run.
00:19:00
Couldn't wait. Guess where? I said, I need to go to Walgreens. I'm just going to go through the drive-thru.
00:19:07
I said, I'll be right back. Here's Candy's explanation for the way the meeting with her lover was arranged.
00:19:13
As I was pulling out of the back of my driveway, Emmett texted me and said, hey, what are you doing?
00:19:19
I said, I'm going to Walgreens. He goes, I was just there. Hey, meet me there. And then what happened next?
00:19:27
You can watch it yourself right here on surveillance tape. I go to Walgreens, go through the drive-thru,
00:19:35
and I pull around and I park my car. And then he pulls up and I get in his truck and we go to Fred Meyer.
00:19:41
Here they are again, getting gas at Fred Meyer when Emmett opened the truck's rear door.
00:19:47
He pulls out all these prescription bottles. I said, what are you taking? He said, well, if you don't want to grow a penis, don't take it.
00:19:56
And then he got back in the truck and we drove off. From there, Candy and Abbott pulled into a secluded spot and had sex under a streetlight.
00:20:05
And that's where they were, tangled up in each other, when Candy's phone rang. Her daughter, coming home from a date, had seen her car in that parking lot.
00:20:15
She said, Mom, why is your car at Walgreens? I called Dad. I go, all right. Okay, I'll be home in a minute.
00:20:25
Too late, because now the wind was up. Rob, the unfaithful husband, had to know.
00:20:31
Now he was the aggrieved spouse. And sure enough, as Candy talked to her daughter, here he was in his pickup truck,
00:20:38
come to Walgreens to look for his wife. Phone call from Rob. He goes, are you with Emmett?
00:20:44
and I go, took a deep breath, and I said, yep, I am. Emmett looks over at me, and he takes the phone away from me,
00:20:56
and he goes, yeah, what's up, chief? And he says, yeah, wait right there. We'll be right there.
00:21:03
You wait right there. And that's when I said, no, knock it off. We're not doing this.
00:21:08
And he's like, oh, we are doing this. There are moments in life when big choices are made.
00:21:15
This was not a good one. Coming up, a late night rendezvous turns deadly crime. And I went, oh my God, I'll never forget, ever.
00:21:40
Here at a Walgreens drugstore in Meridian, Idaho, just before 10 p.m. on a Friday night in March 2011,
00:21:52
time was up. Devil wanted his due. Robert Hall was a man on a mission. As you can see on these store surveillance videos,
00:22:00
Rob parked his pickup truck, went through the front door, roamed the beauty and cosmetic aisles.
00:22:05
He was looking for his wife, Candy, who, of course, was also in a pickup truck. With her lover, Emmett.
00:22:13
Here you can see Rob leaving the store, looking at Candy's parked BMW. Then, strangely, getting back into his own pickup truck, pulling out and then re-parking it on the other side of Candy's car.
00:22:25
Curiously, his door now just out of range of the store surveillance camera. This is when he made that phone call, the one in which Candy confessed she'd been with her boss, Emmett Corrigan.
00:22:35
And he said to Rob, what's up, chief? and here was Emmett's truck speeding through the parking lot.
00:22:41
Still time to stop this if wiser heads had been in charge. But they weren't. Nothing wise about what's coming.
00:22:49
I see Rob in his truck and he has just this look on his face like, oh man. And I get out of the truck.
00:23:00
Then Emmett gets out and then Rob gets out and walks over to us. this is just the sort of moment in which a person might have wanted to cool the overheated atmosphere
00:23:10
control the spitting anger might have chosen words carefully that is not what happened
00:23:19
rob is standing next to me and he's like what are you doing out with my wife at 10 o'clock at night
00:23:25
and emmett said rob she don't want to be with you anymore okay she's done i mean really rob
00:23:33
What did you make last year? Maybe $40,000? Candy, what did we make last week? $27,000 last week in one week, Rob. That's how much I make. You don't make anything.
00:23:43
Nasty, of course. Arrogant. Like a thoughtless young buck who needed to be reminded of something.
00:23:50
Rob said, well, what about your kids and your wife? She just had a baby. They're at home waiting for you.
00:23:57
And you're out with my wife. And at that time, And his eyes got huge and he pushed himself off of his truck and went over to Rob and pushed Rob very hard on his chest.
00:24:10
And then the climax, the confrontation that had been building for weeks. That's when I said, enough, that's enough. You get in your truck and Rob, we got to go.
00:24:22
And as I was walking in my car, another car came by and I had to stop. And at that point, I hear pop, pop, pop.
00:24:31
I didn't know what it was. I didn't know if that car just backfired. I had no idea.
00:24:37
And I stopped going, like, what was that? And all I see in my peripheral vision right here is Rob covered in blood, like someone poured a can of red blood all over him.
00:24:53
And I went, oh. Frantically, Candy's fingers somehow found the numbers. 911. The pistol went flying somehow.
00:25:05
No one disputes that. There it was, lying on the pavement between two men. Both shot.
00:25:13
One alive. One dying. And Candy Hall entered that twilight zone where memories are made that can't ever be erased.
00:25:21
Though, as you and the police department and lawyers and a judge will soon see, they can certainly be amended.
00:25:30
What we know for sure is that she rushed to the prostrate body of one of those two men.
00:25:36
I gave him a kiss on his cheek, and I'll never forget, ever. But he took that last, you know, deep.
00:25:46
It was very surreal. It was just turning gray here. to hear, to hear. I didn't have much time to think of much
00:25:55
other than thinking to myself, oh my God, he's dead. But which one? And what just happened?
00:26:08
A tragic lapse in judgment? A thoughtless but unintended crime of passion? Or was it murder in the first degree?
00:26:21
Ashley Corrigan did not go to sleep after her angry husband announced he was going to the Walgreens drugstore
00:26:40
in Meridian, Idaho. So she was up at one in the morning when the police came. Emmett was dead, they told her.
00:26:48
killed by his lover's husband and Ashley entered a twilight zone of her own. It was like the ultimate humiliation.
00:26:58
It was, not only is your husband gone, but you know that marriage you were trying so hard to save?
00:27:04
Here's all the answers of why it was going wrong. But now you don't have a marriage to save anymore.
00:27:10
It was just like every emotion possible. Like I went through a divorce and a death all in one second.
00:27:16
Bizarre. and then I had to get prepared to tell my kids. And what story do you tell little kids?
00:27:23
Well, there's been an accident, and your daddy's spirit's left his body, so he's not going to be on the earth with you anymore.
00:27:30
They all just kind of stared at me like, what are we supposed to do now? What now, indeed?
00:27:39
At that very moment, a few miles away, Rob Hall was in a hospital bed, recovering from a grazing gunshot wound to his head.
00:27:47
The result, police said, of a botched suicide attempt. After, Rob put two bullets from his semi-automatic pistol into Emmett Corrigan.
00:27:56
One in his heart. One in his head. And over at the Meridian police station, Candy Hall, her clothes still covered in blood,
00:28:06
was telling the first of several different versions of what happened in the parking lot.
00:28:11
quite unprepared of course for the public torrent about to come down on her head suddenly you thrust into the public eye big time yes as a Jezebel as woman who is at the center of a tawdry love triangle What is that like for you
00:28:31
It's scary. For the longest time, I couldn't go to the grocery store. I couldn't go anywhere because I'm thinking, everybody's looking at me. Everybody knows who I am.
00:28:45
Everybody knows what I did. Yes, but it did happen, and I own it. Here's something else that happened.
00:28:53
Although on the night of the shooting, Candy rushed to kiss her dying lover, she rather soon was back in her husband's corner as his chief supporter,
00:29:02
especially when Robert Hall was charred with premeditated first-degree murder. We felt that the evidence supported that he planned to go to that Walgreens
00:29:14
and do exactly what he did when he got there. This was no sudden crime of passion, said the prosecutors,
00:29:21
Idaho Deputy Attorneys General Jessica Lorello and Jason Spillman. This is a case of a man hunting down his wife's paramour
00:29:30
and waiting for 17 minutes to have the opportunity to kill him. Ms. Lorello. Thank you, Robin.
00:29:36
In fact, as they made their case for the jury, prosecutors portrayed Rob as an angry man,
00:29:42
furious about his wife's affair. A man who called Emmett's law office repeatedly to berate Candy so loudly that others heard it all.
00:29:53
Statements such as, you're a whore and why are you with him? And the night of the shooting?
00:30:01
Prosecutors played those surveillance tapes from Walgreens, showing Rob arriving at the drugstore 17 minutes before the confrontation,
00:30:08
walking through the aisles looking for Candy, all the while with a pistol, not the one he usually carried,
00:30:15
but the one Candy gave him, tucked in his pocket. Then the jury saw Emmett and Candy arrive in the parking lot.
00:30:22
And eight minutes later, heard Candy's 911 call after shots were fired. Oh my God! Oh my God!
00:30:29
What happened? What happened? What happened? The prosecutor said the sequence of the shots told the story.
00:30:37
Two quick shots, a pause, and then one more. Our theory all along was that Rob Hall had executed Emmett Corrigan with two successive shots, turned to face his wife, attempted to commit suicide with a third shot.
00:30:57
A theory backed up by forensics. The shots were fired from close range, two or three feet.
00:31:03
There was a heavy concentration of gunshot residue on only Robert Hall's hands and only one man's DNA on the trigger guard.
00:31:11
The DNA matched that of Mr. Hall. I think that Rob Hall went to the Walgreens in order to confront Emmett Corrigan, that he took a loaded gun.
00:31:25
And Rob decided that was his opportunity to get his candy back by killing Emmett.
00:31:33
Why did he talk to Emmett for eight minutes before he fired? The store was closing, said the prosecutor.
00:31:41
People were going home. I think he waited until there were no eyewitnesses, and he executed Emmett Corrigan.
00:31:48
A neat and tidy theory agreed the defense, but completely wrong. This fight was started by Emmett Corrigan.
00:32:00
Rob was a nice guy, said the defense, and it was Emmett who was out of control. Emmett who kept amphetamines and steroids in his pickup truck.
00:32:10
Drugs with serious side effects, said a defense expert. He had hyper irritability as well as impulsiveness, his explosive temper.
00:32:20
What really happened? Rob didn't testify. A doctor backed his claim that because of his head wound, he simply couldn't remember.
00:32:28
So the defense offered a theory that Emmett started the fight. Then the gun fell on the ground.
00:32:33
Emmett grabbed it, shot Rob. Then during the pause, Rob got hold of the gun and fired back in self-defense.
00:32:39
And the courtroom came to a halt. Every head turned when a star witness took the stand to support that theory Would you please state and spell your name for the record Sure Candy Hall
00:32:53
Candy, who repeated the story on the stand, that she told us of Emmett pushing Rob,
00:32:58
Emmett becoming enraged, of hearing the two men scuffle as she walked away before she heard, but did not see, the shooting.
00:33:07
The only problem? She told the police a very different story the night it happened.
00:33:13
You told Detective Miller that night that you did not see or hear a physical altercation.
00:33:18
Isn't that right? I don't know. In fact, Candy changed her story about so many things,
00:33:24
all helpful to Rob's case. I'm trying to clarify that your story has changed after speaking with your husband.
00:33:35
Things were remembered after talking to my husband. In fact, later, the judge made a comment
00:33:40
outside the jury's presence. He said in all of his 30-some years on the bench, he'd never seen a witness so thoroughly discredited.
00:33:52
But before she left the witness stand, Candy expressed her love and sorrow for the man she cheated on, yet still loved.
00:34:01
He knew, and he still knows in his heart, that I've never stopped loving him. You still stop loving someone.
00:34:08
and watching it all Emmett's wife Ashley you watched as Candy testified what was that like
00:34:19
it's hard to hear her stand up there and tell her husband how sorry she was and how much she loved him
00:34:25
because ultimately it was because of them that I didn't get that chance and Rob Hall's version of events
00:34:35
he's about to tell you The very first time he has spoken of this. But first, it's up to the jury to determine the wages of sin.
00:34:46
Coming up. I wish I had never gone there that night. A husband with a stunning story to tell.
00:34:54
The last thing I remember was the gun pointed at my head. But whose story will the jury believe?
00:34:59
Once he had everything he wanted before he and his wife scratched the itch of wanting more.
00:35:14
And now a jury was about to tell Robert Hall whether for the rest of his life he'd have anything at all.
00:35:21
We have a small advantage over the jury. Hall did not testify, but he talked to us.
00:35:27
His first ever interview. To tell us he was sorry about what happened? Yes, that.
00:35:33
But also to tell us that it wasn't his fault. The notion that I brought a gun there to gun down Emmett Corrigan.
00:35:43
I didn't bring a gun there to gun down Emmett Corrigan. Hall's version? That despite what you've heard, he did not even know for sure that Emmett was having an affair with Candy.
00:35:55
that in the parking lot Emmett was the aggressor pulled him down from behind by the hood of his sweatshirt.
00:36:02
I don't think I made four steps before I was ripped off my feet. When I hit the ground, the first thing I thought was my cell phone hit the ground.
00:36:11
And I looked over and it was my gun. He reached down, grabbed my gun, and we just struggled over it.
00:36:18
The last thing I remember was the gun pointed at my head. and the feeling of being hit upside the head with a baseball bat.
00:36:28
And I remember seeing everything black and gray. And that's all I remember until Sunday in the hospital.
00:36:38
In that moment of extreme anger and passion, crazy things happened. And you're asking us to believe that the crazy thing that happened started when you got shot.
00:36:51
Yeah. And he pulled the trigger. Yeah. And then you must have taken the gun and fired two shots at him.
00:36:57
Yeah. Of course he had a hole through his heart and one in his head, which sound for all the world when you hear that, like those were targeted shots.
00:37:06
Is it possible you shot him and then decided you were going to shoot yourself No absolutely not I never been suicidal The jury did hear the defense case of course
00:37:18
Just not Robert's version of it. But it was enough for a verdict. Is Robert Dean Hall guilty or not guilty of first-degree murder?
00:37:27
Not guilty. Not guilty. Hearts rose and fell. But then, not so fast. Is Robert Dean Hall guilty or not guilty of second-degree murder?
00:37:38
Guilty. Guilty of murder. Not premeditation per se, but of an intent to kill and a disregard for human life.
00:37:48
Rob Hall looked like he'd been punched in the stomach. Tears sprained to his eyes.
00:37:55
Hall was sentenced to 30 years in prison. He'll be eligible for parole in the year 2028, just before his 60th birthday.
00:38:04
So as we sit here now, having been convicted of intentional murder, you're still not taking responsibility for it as that.
00:38:15
As murder, no. You're saying the architect of this tragedy is more Emmett Corrigan than you.
00:38:25
Absolutely. Yes. And so you, sitting in prison for the next God knows how many years, are as much a victim as anybody else.
00:38:36
It's devastating. I wish that I'd never gone there that night to get my wife. Or if you went, that somehow you're, like, not taking your gun along.
00:38:51
I think that. I do the what if game on that. And then I think, you know, what if he would have pounded my face into the cement and not stopped?
00:39:02
And then people would say, well, why didn't he have his gun with him? And thus, you encountered one of the elements of classic tragedy.
00:39:11
The thing you buy to protect yourself is a thing you use to destroy yourself. Yeah.
00:39:16
Another thing to contemplate in your jail cell late at night. Yeah. He also thinks about his two daughters, whose lives, graduations, triumphs, marriages, children he may never witness.
00:39:34
Two girls who, at the age of 18 and 14 back then, suddenly found themselves left without either parent in the home.
00:39:42
Because of a final twist to this story of betrayal and retribution, Rob's wife Candy was sent to prison herself.
00:39:51
Because of the killing? No. She pleaded guilty to charges of grand theft for embezzling some $30,000 from the attorney for whom she worked before Emmett Corrigan.
00:40:03
She served 18 months for that. Before she went to prison, she talked to us about regret.
00:40:11
I have a lot of guilt still in me, a lot. And it has to do with my kids and his kids.
00:40:17
And it makes me sick how I could do something like that. I'm the responsible one.
00:40:25
And it's something that I don't know are they going to ever be able to get through that.
00:40:29
I mean, hopefully one day I can prove to them that it was just a mistake. In the years since, Ashley has remarried
00:40:39
and has become an author, blogger, and speaker with a message to stand strong and faithful.
00:40:47
I think there's thousands of people in this country that come to those crossroads
00:40:52
and don't know what to do. But I think if I could tell them anything, it would be,
00:40:59
put your family first. I guess I would like to say to Rob, Rob, he had five kids.
00:41:07
Couldn't this have been something you pictured as you held up the gun and targeted it at his head and his heart?
00:41:16
Once in Meridian, Idaho, were two happy, successful families. wasn't quite enough for some of them.
00:41:24
And the wreckage is forever.