00:00:00
Total shock and disbelief. I mean, this is not happening. Am I having a nightmare?
00:00:07
It was so sudden. Please leave my wife and death and buy it. I almost go nuts! That moment is ingrained in my memory. Time stood still.
00:00:16
A wife and mom collapsed and gone. And I go to run to her and she's cold. Her death baffled the experts. A heart attack, a seizure. Could it have even been her new tan?
00:00:29
It was the first time Chad got in a spray tan and she passed away a few hours later.
00:00:36
Finally, investigators had an answer. This mystery, they said, was murder. We were in complete shock.
00:00:44
Curious evidence. Suspicious markings on her neck. Strange behavior. He went from hysterical to calm.
00:00:53
The trial had everything. Exploding emotions. A secret affair. Did you have an affair?
00:01:00
Yes, and my husband is well aware of it. Even an identical twin. Five years of suspicion comes down to one moment.
00:01:08
We did jury. I don't think that anyone can imagine what it's like to love someone so much and then be charged with their murder.
00:01:17
It's unfathomable. Keith Morrison reports on a cliffhanger of a case. In an instant.
00:01:24
The story, when it hit the news, sounded almost crazy. Killed by a spray tan. Claiming his wife died after an allergic reaction to her spray tan.
00:01:35
Husband accused of murdering his wife tries to blame her death on a fatal reaction to a simple spray tan.
00:01:40
And thus a myth was born. The case of the spray tan defense. What a headline. That was a strange tale.
00:01:48
It was true that a spray tan did briefly play a role at the heart of what sounded like murder.
00:01:54
but the real story? Headlines don't always sell it, do they? The true story of what happened here in Miami
00:02:01
was far more troubling, tragic, and bizarre than any headline. And it all happened so fast.
00:02:09
Business was good. Beautiful house. Great friends. And then it changes in an instant.
00:02:16
Like that. Like that. To begin with, there was Aventura. A brand new town, an upscale suburb actually, with clipped green lawns and trophy boats that skirts the northern fringe of Miami.
00:02:31
And among the founding families in this clean new place was the Kaufman clan. Migrants a generation ago from up north in New York, Jerry Kaufman came first.
00:02:40
We are, we're four brothers, lots of children and grandchildren. The family's been very close for generations.
00:02:51
and pretty soon aventura was a magnet for a big and ever bigger kaufman family including these two the twins adam and seth kaufman jerry's nephews identical like two halves
00:03:04
of one person seth tried to explain it by describing the day adam cut his finger we're
00:03:09
both screaming and uh and my mom said seth why are you crying hysterically and i said because it
00:03:15
hurts and it was adam's finger um so i truly do believe that we feel each other's pain
00:03:22
They were teachers first. Big teachers for little kids. We both started teaching pre-K because there were no jobs available at the time.
00:03:31
I'm trying to imagine you with four-year-olds. Kind of like kindergarten cop, you know, Arnold Schwarzenegger.
00:03:37
But it was a lot of fun. It was a lot of fun and also very rewarding. But teaching didn't pay the bills.
00:03:44
So they joined the family business, real estate development. Though, frankly, they looked more like wrestlers or bar bouncers, big, burly, athletic men.
00:03:53
And it turned out, suckers for love. She was my soulmate. She was my soulmate. We had an instant connection.
00:04:02
Adam fell first for a remarkable young woman named Eleonora, though everybody called her Lena.
00:04:08
She'd been everywhere, had Lena. Russian roots, grew up in Israel, came to America, met Adam at work, and quickly decided that he was the twin for her.
00:04:17
And he? I knew right away that this was the girl I wanted to spend the rest of my life with.
00:04:22
What did she do for you? She is absolutely spectacularly beautiful. She's a head turner.
00:04:32
She's got class. And, you know, you have this poor schlub from New York. You meet a woman like this.
00:04:39
You know, you've got to jump on that opportunity. So I did my best, and something worked.
00:04:45
So what would people see when they saw you? Lena walking down the street, do you?
00:04:49
Happy. It was the happiest time of my life. I had everything I ever wanted in a woman.
00:05:00
Caring, loving, giving. She was my best friend. They got married in March 2000. Before long, they had a girl and a boy.
00:05:10
A nice house and a gated community. A big extended family they saw all the time.
00:05:15
And as Adam's mother Elaine saw it, a remarkably happy and untroubled relationship.
00:05:21
There was just so much harmony in that marriage. He absolutely adored her and she adored him.
00:05:27
And she would tell me all the time, you know, he's so cute, Mom. If I said, you know, Lena,
00:05:33
the guys want to go out tonight and grab a drink or go get a steak. No problem. Go.
00:05:40
There was never an argument about me spending time with my friends. There's really nothing I would have changed
00:05:46
about our relationship, nothing. Then it was Seth's turn. And here comes this Brazilian girl who is loud.
00:05:55
That was Raquel and Seth was smitten Adam and Lena too the four of them became inseparable We traveled together On the weekends we were together Restaurants everything family events It was the four of us
00:06:10
Yeah. It's like you had a sister, too. Yes. Yeah. Really did. I mean, we truly talked about and enjoyed everything together. Everything.
00:06:20
And it had to be that way because Adam and Seth, they're so close. So you get the picture.
00:06:30
It was a sweet spot in life. Too sweet, too perfect to last. It was November 6, 2007.
00:06:37
Seth and Raquel were getting married in 10 days. Lena was to be a bridesmaid, and so she got herself her first ever spray tan to look her best in the dress.
00:06:45
Just hours after that is when it all came crashing down in an instant. And this big happy family suddenly plunged into a very dark place.
00:06:56
It was a little after six the next morning, said Adam Kaufman, when he woke up and realized Lena wasn't next to him in bed.
00:07:03
He walked into the bathroom, he said. And there she was. And I go to run to her, and it's just in slow motion as I'm going to her.
00:07:12
And I touch her, and she's cold. I'm screaming, Lena, Lena, wake up, wake up. That's when he made that frantic call to 911.
00:07:20
He was hysterical. A million things are going through my mind and all I'm focused on is getting her help.
00:07:50
The 911 operator tried to instruct him in CPR, but it wasn't working. 23 minutes went by that way.
00:07:58
You know how at times in your life, seconds feel like minutes? This felt like hours.
00:08:07
Then the medics finally arrived, chewed Adam out of the way, started working on Lena.
00:08:12
Adam phoned his twin brother, Seth. Adam was on the other end of the line, frantically screaming my name.
00:08:20
Get over here quick. Lena's not breathing. Seth and fiancé Raquel raced over to the house as EMTs tried to intubate Lena, pushed and prodded,
00:08:29
and did everything they could to coax life back into her body. And Adam is pacing back and forth and screaming,
00:08:35
Oh my God, oh my God, oh my God, my kids, my kids. And he's saying to me, please go to my kids, please go to my kids.
00:08:43
Raquel got the baby from the crib and went into the four-year-old's room. She was on the floor playing with her toys,
00:08:49
and she looked at me, she said, did mommy ask you to come baby sit me because she wasn't feeling well?
00:08:56
And I said, yes, baby. Lena was being rushed out of the house and to the hospital,
00:09:01
but they could not save her. And Adam was a mess, destroyed. What on earth had happened to Lena?
00:09:09
And the big question, did someone close make it happen? When we come back, you know where this is going.
00:09:18
A husband now under suspicion. The whole scene together for Fire Rescue was like, this is not adding up.
00:09:25
When In An Instant continues. You immediately feel that you've lost half of you, your soul, your heart.
00:09:48
I couldn't believe that that was true. Adam Kaufman insisted he had no idea what killed Lena.
00:09:55
She was so active, seemed so healthy. How could a 33-year-old go to the bathroom at night and just drop dead?
00:10:04
Didn't make sense to the EMTs either. Something didn't look right. Which is why Detective Anthony Angulo was called in
00:10:12
to take a closer look at this medical mystery. He'd never investigated a homicide before,
00:10:17
but could this perhaps be his first? Even a rookie knows a husband is always a potential suspect
00:10:24
when a wife drops dead. And certain things about Adam's story that morning seemed off.
00:10:30
I mean, you know, the whole scene together for fire rescue was like, this is not adding up.
00:10:36
And it wouldn't to Chief Assistant State Attorney Kathleen Hogue either. For starters, Adam said he'd been asleep in bed
00:10:43
just before finding Lena. But some of the first responders said they saw Adam fully dressed when they arrived.
00:10:50
Well, nobody sleeps dressed. Even down to the fact that at the hospital itself, one of the officers recognized that he had cologne on and he had his watch on.
00:11:02
As if he had been out all night or something. Or at least up. Another officer reported the hood of Adam's car parked in the garage felt warm to the touch,
00:11:11
as if he'd just been driving it. Being warm kind of really lends it to being driven.
00:11:18
And when the detective looked in the bedroom, did his eyes deceive him? Or was one side of the bed undisturbed, as if it hadn't been slept in?
00:11:27
So what was Adam's story about how he found his wife in the bathroom again? Turns out it was a little unclear.
00:11:36
He told the first captain that he went into the bathroom and saw her slumped over the toilet.
00:11:43
after that he made a statement where he said that she was slumped over the magazine rack the other
00:11:50
way yes strange isn that what guilty people do change their stories but more than anything it was something on lena body that just might tell what happened to her Some nasty looking bruises on her neck those and other signs of trauma
00:12:06
suggested that Lena's death wasn't from natural causes. It looked like she'd been strangled.
00:12:12
Something has happened which has cut off the air supply and created a pressure such that
00:12:17
you get these, you know, marks in your eyes. When somebody has caused their airway to be closed.
00:12:24
In other words, it doesn't happen just by itself. Not usually. So the picture coming together was not of an unexplained innocent death, said the prosecutor,
00:12:35
but the story, perhaps, of a husband who came home after a night out and suddenly snapped.
00:12:41
That panic on the 911 call could be the sound of a man realizing he had just done the unthinkable.
00:12:48
It could also be that this man ended up strangling his wife, all right, freaked out over what he did didn't necessarily mean to do it but you know it happened because
00:13:00
he's twice her size and a whole lot stronger than she is and whatever set him off set him off
00:13:06
but did they arrest him no that if it happened at all would have to wait for an autopsy report
00:13:14
hard evidence and so 10 days after lena's death when seth and raquel went ahead with their wedding
00:13:21
police were paying attention. In Judaism in particular, we celebrate life before death.
00:13:31
Adam was there, made a speech, even cracked a few jokes about his brother. And he just wanted for his brother, his twin brother,
00:13:40
to have somewhat of a good time at his wedding. But looked out another way. It seemed to the police somehow suspicious.
00:13:51
As it did win a couple of months after Lena's death, Adam seemed to be dating again.
00:13:58
So they kept an eye on him and waited for the medical examiner to issue his autopsy report.
00:14:03
Waited for months, a year, longer. This was not like some slick Miami TV show. Bureaucracies don't move so fast in real life.
00:14:13
But then it was April 2009. Quite suddenly, decision day. Coming up, was Lena Kaufman murdered?
00:14:25
They pointed out suspicious markings on her neck. Or is there another explanation?
00:14:31
Something to do with that spray tan? Has the FDA received complaints of seizures by people who have undergone spray tan?
00:14:39
Yes. When Dateline continues. 17 months after that desperate November morning and Adam Kaufman claimed he was still in the dark
00:14:59
no clue, he said, as to how his Lena died. He said dozens of calls to the Miami Medical Examiner's Office
00:15:06
went unanswered. So finally, he called the State Board of Examiners to complain.
00:15:12
A very nice guy said, Ms. Kaufman, I will look into it, take care of it, get back to you as soon as possible.
00:15:19
And the very next day, there was a ruling on the cause of Lena's death. But no one told Adam.
00:15:26
Not yet. It was a week later, a sultry Tuesday evening. Adam was working at a new ice cream shop he and his brother opened
00:15:34
during those boom-to-bust real estate days for developers. In walk, police, and that was not uncommon.
00:15:41
Police always frequent our shop. And I look back down, and I see red dots on my shirt.
00:15:49
All over my shirt. I look back up, and then I see about 15 police officers, SWAT officers, in this door.
00:15:58
And I see them, there he is, and they're pointing at me. I'm like, me? And they jump over the counter, throw me down to the ground, and I'm like, what's going on?
00:16:08
In walks a gentleman, plainclothes, comes up to me and says, leans down while I'm on the floor and says, remember me?
00:16:16
It was Detective Anthony Angulo asking the question. the investigator who'd poked around the house the morning Lena died,
00:16:24
among the first who'd been suspicious of Adam's story. He says, I don't want you to say a word, real nasty.
00:16:31
He said, you're under arrest for the murder of your wife. Again, time froze. And I said, are you kidding?
00:16:43
Total shock and disbelief and awe. I mean, this is not happening. This is a joke.
00:16:47
This is a nightmare. Am I having a nightmare? The medical examiner had ruled the cause of Lena's death was mechanical asphyxiation.
00:16:57
That she'd been choked to death by a person. And now Adam was being charged with second-degree murder.
00:17:03
They took him to the Dade County Jail, locked him away. I'm thinking to myself, this is a mistake.
00:17:09
This can't be happening. But it was happening. Days turned to weeks, weeks to months.
00:17:15
Reality sank in. Adam was accused of murder. What was your level of confidence or the lack of it as you sat in jail waiting?
00:17:25
I was sitting in jail saying, okay, when are they going to realize what happened?
00:17:29
They're going to find out the cause of death. They're going to find it and then that's going to release me.
00:17:34
I was waiting for that. It didn't come. For the past year and a half, the children had no mother.
00:17:40
Now they had no father. Finally, after Adam had been in jail three months his attorneys arranged a bond hearing
00:17:47
And as so often happens in Florida it turned into a mini-trial The state finally presenting its evidence against Adam
00:17:54
Had this big strong man the only other adult in the house when Lena died strangled his wife to death then lied to cover it up The state played that 911 call in a courtroom packed with Adam family
00:18:10
many of whom were hearing it for the first time. As the tape continued to play, one family member couldn't take it and passed out.
00:18:21
There's a nurse attending, so I think you should proceed. This was raw stuff, seldom seen in stodgy Miami courtroom.
00:18:30
That occurred on the following day. The first witness was Detective Angulo, who revealed he'd been investigating Adam ever since that very first morning.
00:18:40
I examined the body. Present were a couple of other officers. They pointed out suspicious markings on her neck.
00:18:48
And there was something else. I did observe what I believe to be petechial hemorrhaging in the eye and the actual eyelids.
00:18:55
And what indication, if any, does the presence of petechia in someone's eyes or eyelids suggest to you?
00:19:00
Asphyxiation. Asphyxiation, death by suffocation. Detective Angulov said he was sure he'd gotten his man,
00:19:07
had been suspicious since he talked to Adam at the hospital. He seemed upset at one point, then the other minute he was very angry.
00:19:15
I could see his jaw muscles clench. He's obviously disturbed, but it was strange going from being upset to angry.
00:19:26
And where had Adam Kaufman been earlier that night? Not sleeping, investigators thought.
00:19:33
Remember, his side of the bed looked to them undisturbed. But on Lena's side, there were unusual smudges.
00:19:41
The staining appears to be on the actual pillow itself and just below the pillow where the body would lie.
00:19:47
They were stains from the spray tan Lena got the previous evening when she wanted to look her best for Seth Kaufman's wedding 10 days later.
00:19:56
Defense attorneys seized on that evidence and perhaps without intending to made their case famous overnight.
00:20:03
They called in an expert named Dr. Ronald Wright, the former chief medical examiner in Miami-Dade County.
00:20:09
In your investigation, has the FDA received complaints of seizures by people who have undergone spray tan?
00:20:17
Yes. Do you believe that the spray tan material should have been investigated for potentially
00:20:25
causing an allergic reaction? Oh, sure. I mean, we don't know exactly what happened to Mrs. Coffman.
00:20:32
We know that she collapsed, we know she asphyxiated, but we don't know why any of that happened,
00:20:38
and certainly there's a real possibility that that could have been caused by this exposure
00:20:46
to the tanner, she's got it all over her hands. It certainly raises the possibility of an allergic
00:20:51
reaction caused by that. She gets her first spray tan the night before she passes away.
00:20:56
Why not investigate it? Stranger things have happened. It would be negligent on our part not
00:21:03
to do that. It was certainly negligent on their part not to test it. It became known far and wide
00:21:08
as the spray tan defense. But the idea that Lena's death might have been caused by an allergic reaction
00:21:16
one more ridicule than serious consideration. It was almost comical. But they had a point.
00:21:22
I mean, it was never tested, right? To see whether or not there was some possibility that that could have caused it.
00:21:27
Actually, there was some testing done just for the heck of it after that, but even the doctor that they put on the stand couldn't ascribe to that theory.
00:21:37
I mean, I guess it sounded sexy, but it really wasn't feasible. The judge was not persuaded either.
00:21:42
Adam would stay in jail, no bond. His family was devastated. Twin brother Seth left in tears.
00:21:52
But shortly after that hearing, in one of those rare moments, the judge had a change of heart.
00:21:57
It was just after Father's Day. The judge said, he used the term, I had a catharsis.
00:22:05
He said, I'm going to let this boy go home to his kids. It was a great day. except Adam would have to wear an electronic ankle monitor
00:22:16
a stark reminder he was not a free man and the real trial was yet to come When we come back, evidence about marks on Lena Kaufman's neck and torso
00:22:29
marks her best friend says she didn't see the night before when Lena showed off her new tan
00:22:35
You said that she took off her jacket? Yes she did Was she nude underneath her jacket?
00:22:39
Yes she was Did you notice any marks on her body at all? No. When In An Instant continues.
00:22:57
Four and a half years after he buried his wife, Lena, came the day of reckoning for Adam Kaufman.
00:23:03
Here he was, charged with second-degree murder, accused of killing her in the bathroom of their Avatura, Florida home.
00:23:10
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you have been selected and sworn as the jury to try the state of Florida versus Adam Kaufman.
00:23:18
As he had been since Lena's death, Adam was surrounded by his protective family, including his identical twin, Seth.
00:23:26
The family was terrified. Adam was facing up to life in prison if convicted. I was really worried because bottom line is that
00:23:35
the fate of my twin brother rests in the hands of 12 people I don't know. Dade County Assistant Prosecutor Joe Mansfield
00:23:44
methodically laid out the state's case for the jury. There was, he argued, only one possible way
00:23:50
to explain Lena's death. Lena Kaufman died as a result of mechanical asphyxiation to her neck.
00:23:56
And the defendant, her husband, is the one that did it. That ultimate evidence would be scientific, medical, said the prosecutor.
00:24:07
But he wanted jurors to keep in mind the obvious. Adam Kaufman was the only adult home at the time of Lena's death,
00:24:14
giving him the opportunity to kill her. And with his bodybuilder's strength, the wherewithal, too.
00:24:21
On top of that, Adam couldn't keep his story straight, said Prosecutor Mansfield.
00:24:25
Version one came from the 911 call. when Adam said he found Lena on the floor. She's not breathing?
00:24:32
No, I don't know what happened. She's on the floor. But a fire rescue lieutenant said Adam told him he found Lena somewhere else in the bathroom.
00:24:41
He told me word for word that she found her slumped over the toilet. And he indicated that if she was vomiting, kneeled in front of the toilet
00:24:50
with her head down in front of the toilet. But later at the hospital, said that same EMT,
00:24:56
he overheard Adam saying something else entirely. Why is it that you took note of that third version?
00:25:01
I took note of it because it was completely different from the other story he had told me.
00:25:05
This time he mentioned the patient being slumped over a magazine rack. Chief Assistant State Attorney Kathleen Hogue supervised the case.
00:25:13
She wanted jurors to know about Adam's puzzling behavior that morning and called a firefighter to the stand.
00:25:19
He went from hysterical to calm. his demeanor or his emotions fluctuated? Yes, ma'am.
00:25:29
From hysterical to calm? Yes, ma'am. And there were those other unusual things, said the first responders,
00:25:35
that they just couldn't help but notice, like how they'd seen Adam Kaufman dressed.
00:25:41
Not at all like someone who said he'd just woke up. It stood out for me that Mr. Kaufman was completely dressed.
00:25:47
And if he was just doing CPR, how does he have shoes, clothes on and why is she completely naked? It just didn't sit right. It didn't seem normal.
00:25:57
If, as Adam said, he'd been home all night, why was the front of his Mercedes warm to the touch?
00:26:03
I put my hand on the hood and I felt that it was extremely warm. And of course there were those
00:26:09
marks on Lena's neck and torso. They were fresh, said the prosecutor. They weren't there the evening
00:26:15
before when she showed her best friend her spray-on tan. You said that she took off her jacket?
00:26:20
Yes, she did. Was she nude underneath her jacket? Yes, she was. Did you notice any marks on her body at all?
00:26:26
No. An Aventura police officer gave a stark description of the indentations he observed on Lena's neck.
00:26:34
And it was just consistent, consistent with fingertip-sized marks. And they called a witness who'd been key to the investigation that morning,
00:26:42
crime scene investigator Anna Howell. She testified about what she saw on Lena's hands.
00:26:47
The nail polish on Eleanor Plotkin's middle finger and index finger are chipped.
00:26:54
Were those chipped nails evidence of a struggle that morning? And then prosecutors presented the man they considered the most important witness of all,
00:27:02
the senior medical examiner who determined Lena's cause of death. What would be the manner of death?
00:27:07
Homicide. And why would it be a homicide, Dr. Heimer? This mechanical asphyxiation could only occur at the hands of somebody else.
00:27:16
Somebody else? Yes, somebody else. And just to be sure there was no doubt Lena was murdered,
00:27:22
the prosecution provided evidence she couldn't have died of something like, say, heart failure.
00:27:27
They called the plastic surgeon who gave her an EKG before giving her breast implants
00:27:30
just four months before her death. She was a normal, healthy patient. Prosecutors wanted to prove that Adam wasn't all that distraught after the loss of his wife.
00:27:41
So they called a woman he dated two months after her death. You made a comment about his wedding ring.
00:27:47
I did. I asked him if he was married. He said that his wife had passed. And I said, so when do you think you're going to be ready to take that off?
00:27:57
At some point, did you guys become intimate? Yes. But as the state's case began to wind down, prosecutors could have no idea what would stick with the jury.
00:28:08
Any more than they knew that their star CSI witness was about to blow up on them.
00:28:15
Isn't it true, ma'am, that you previously had an intimate sexual relationship with Detective Angelo?
00:28:21
Coming up, fireworks from a witness and from the victim's mother. Are you accusing me of advice?
00:28:28
And is the prosecution's case about to completely unravel when Dateline continues?
00:28:34
Biased, incompetent, flawed. The way Adam Kaufman attorneys saw it prosecutors had put on a great show for the defense You will hear that this is a prosecution in search of a crime An innocent man has been falsely charged with a crime that did not occur which he did not commit
00:29:07
No crime at all, said defense attorney Bill Mathewman. Certainly not murder. The defense's claim?
00:29:14
That Lena blacked out, collapsed, fell neck first onto a magazine rack, a freak set of mishaps that cut off her airflow and caused her death.
00:29:23
A theory he could have proven easily, said Attorney Matthewman, if it hadn't been for incompetent investigators.
00:29:31
For starters, he said, lead detective Anthony Angulo ordered this detective, Anna Howell,
00:29:36
to disregard a key piece of evidence at the scene. Detective Angulo specifically told you not to take those items of evidence,
00:29:43
those magazines, into custody. Is that right? Right. The magazines in that rack said the defense were the key to the mystery.
00:29:50
They would have proven that Lena fell there because they would have been stained by her fresh spray on tan.
00:29:57
I think the failure to collect the magazines in and of itself could constitute reasonable doubt.
00:30:03
You never fail to take in to custody evidence. In fact, said Adams lawyers, the police were so determined to prove this was a murder, they misread the scene entirely.
00:30:15
These photographs prior to... Like, for example, when Howell told the court she found chipped polish on Lena's nails.
00:30:23
The nail polish on Eleanor Plotkin's middle finger and index finger are chipped.
00:30:28
The detective's suggestion? That Lena's husband attacked her and she fought for her life.
00:30:36
But the defense hired its own crime scene expert to look at that tiny bathroom space.
00:30:40
Did you find any signs of a struggle inside the house? I found nothing that would indicate anything like that.
00:30:51
But to be fair, said the defense, Howell wasn't the only one who screwed up that morning.
00:30:57
I put my hand on the hood, and I felt that it was extremely warm. A police officer said the hood of Adam's car was warm to the touch.
00:31:06
But the defense answered, of course the car hood was warm. It was locked in a garage on a hot Miami night.
00:31:12
Evidence of nothing. Mr. Coffin was completely dressed. Prosecutors, said the defense, tried the same tact with those emergency workers.
00:31:20
They said Adam didn't seem to them like a man who just rolled out of bed to find his wife unconscious.
00:31:25
They insisted he was fully clothed. And yet, that's not what the very first responder on the scene witnessed.
00:31:32
I saw a man on top of a woman attempting what looked like CPR. What was the man wearing when you entered the room?
00:31:39
At that time, he was wearing boxers and a t-shirt. What those others likely saw, said the defense, was Adam's identical twin who arrived at the house perfectly dressed minutes after that 911 call ended.
00:31:52
I had no reason to change my opinion whatsoever. It's an incidental. But what really stuck in the craw of Adam's lawyers was that medical examiner who ruled Lena's death a homicide.
00:32:02
Why did it take him a year and a half to call it that? Because, they said, he was pressured into it by police.
00:32:10
On cross-examination, co-counsel Al Millian ripped into the doctor. Detective Anthony Angulo and Aventure have been pushing you to rule in a homicide. Isn't that true?
00:32:23
That's not true, counselor, and you know it. And the defense used Lena's autopsy photos to make the case for its own theory, that she died accidentally.
00:32:32
There are these marks on the undersurface of the chin. These match the spines of the magazine in terms of a contact mark.
00:32:41
This former medical examiner testified for the defense that the pressure on her neck would have clearly blocked her airflow, killing her.
00:32:48
But it was why the defense said Lena collapsed. That was the real shocker. These cells should not be here.
00:32:55
The doctor said he took apart Lena's heart and found scarring. This is active focal myocarditis.
00:33:03
Scarring of the heart that the state medical examiner never found. Heart disease.
00:33:08
The doctor explained to a riveted courtroom that Lena likely had no idea just how sick she was
00:33:14
until her heart suddenly gave out that morning. The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.
00:33:20
I do. And then, just for good measure, the defense called someone else with star power to the stand.
00:33:27
In congestive heart failure and all that. Dr. Michael Bodden, the former New York City medical examiner and frequent medical expert in high-profile murder cases,
00:33:36
reviewed Lena's autopsy file and said to him there was no question about it. There was no murder. She died of natural causes.
00:33:45
Even Lena own mother said she tried to tell detectives that her daughter had suffered frequent fainting spells before her death that it might indeed have been an accident but they wouldn listen How many calls were made to the detective trying to reach him
00:34:00
My son, my ex-husband, and myself, I had to call there too. I assume it was about 25 calls, maybe more.
00:34:09
It was something you rarely see. A grieving mother defending the man accused of killing her daughter.
00:34:15
She said Adam was and is like a son to her. We are very close and usual, even more closer than before.
00:34:23
Frieda, do you love Adam? Like my own son. And it has happened a number of times during this trial.
00:34:30
A state witness wound up winning points for the defense. Adam's so-called love interest, for example.
00:34:37
Well, it wasn't quite like that. Yes, they dated for a while, but Adam wasn't going to get deeply involved, she learned.
00:34:45
Adam wasn't emotionally available, which he always made very clear from the very start.
00:34:51
Finally, one last loose end. Remember CSI, Anna Howell? Earlier she testified that she, a married woman, had only a working relationship with lead detective Angulo.
00:35:03
When you've been off duty, you've socialized with Detective Angulo? No, sir. No?
00:35:10
But the very next day, she was called back to the stand and had to admit she hadn't told the truth.
00:35:16
You knew you had misrepresented your relationship to this jury on the stand under oath.
00:35:20
Isn't that true, ma'am? Yes or no? It wasn't part of the case. Yes or no, ma'am?
00:35:23
Is that true? Yes. Thank you. In fact, the two had had an affair. Are you married?
00:35:30
Yes. Did you have an affair with Detective Angula? Yes, and my husband is well aware of it, sir.
00:35:35
and I am happily married and I don't have any issues with that any longer. And she said the old affair never affected her work.
00:35:44
And with that, she stormed out of the courtroom. To the defense, it was clear they said that she and Angula were in cahoots
00:35:51
and that a man who wanted so badly to prove Adam a killer, the detective who never took the stand in this trial, could not be trusted.
00:36:00
In his closing, the lawyer said it was Adam who was the real victim. at a lousy police investigation.
00:36:08
They bungle this investigation beyond recognition to Adam's detriment, causing the false charges to be lodged against him in this case.
00:36:17
But it was one person the court didn't hear from who may be battered most, Adam Kaufman.
00:36:23
He opted not to take the stand in his defense, but he wanted to speak to us. The problem with this case comes down to one word.
00:36:34
Investigation. A rookie detective working his first homicide. A fellow in the medical examiner's office not doing a thorough autopsy.
00:36:44
Ms. Eisman has two beautiful grandchildren. More infuriating, he said, was the prosecutor's claim that Lena's mother was only standing by him so he'd let her see her grandchildren.
00:36:56
The joy of her life. That outraged Lena's mother. You think she's going to go against him?
00:37:02
Are you abusing me in Christ? One of the prosecutors in his closing went after your family
00:37:08
and basically said that your mother-in-law was a captive of your family, could do nothing to express her real opinion
00:37:16
because otherwise she'd be left out in the cold. How dare he go after Lena's mother?
00:37:23
Lena's mother who bravely came into that courthouse and stood up for the son-in-law
00:37:32
that's charged with second-degree murder of her daughter. His mother-in-law's show of loyalty was striking
00:37:39
but would it be enough to impress the jurors and save Adam? Coming up... I know I have the truth on my side.
00:37:49
No evidence of a strangulation. The proof is there. We did jury in Miami-Dade County, Florida.
00:37:56
When in an instant continues. Nearly five years had passed since Lena Kaufman's death.
00:38:13
And now her husband, Adam, was about to learn his fate at the Miami courthouse. Two possibilities now.
00:38:20
an immediate handcuffed escort to spend up to the rest of his life in prison for instant and permanent freedom in the arms of his family.
00:38:29
I had my entire family there with support. That's why I was able to walk into that courtroom every day holding my head up high
00:38:37
because I know I have the truth on my side. But Prosecutor Kathleen Hogue believed her side had presented the real truth
00:38:44
that Adam had choked Lena to death after an argument early that morning at their home No evidence of a strangulation The proof is there It didn happen by her by itself Now Adam and his twin brother Seth and the family all watched in anticipation as the judge
00:39:02
sent the jury in to deliberate. The jury may retire. I just wanted a fair trial because I knew once all the evidence was presented that there's
00:39:12
no way that 12 people can sit there. I don't care who you are. They were gone. They were out of the room.
00:39:16
You couldn't do anything about it. Nothing you can do about it. Jurors Ryan O'Donnell and Bernard Jennings said they were ready for the task ahead.
00:39:23
Jennings is a court-certified mediator, making him a natural choice to be their foreman.
00:39:28
Did you call for a vote right away? No, not initially when we went in the room. We took time to go through each piece of evidence and deliberate, deliberate.
00:39:35
Here, with permission of the court, is the actual jury room, where we could see how they literally weighed the evidence.
00:39:43
I drew three scales on the chalkboard. to the far right will be broken of innocent,
00:39:48
and to the far left, broken as guilty. And he said, you have to fit in one of these positions.
00:39:52
So we tried to fit everything in that to come up with a decision. They paid close attention to the conflicting testimony
00:39:58
from those different medical examiners. But more than anything, the jurors were determined
00:40:03
to listen to that 911 call one more time, very carefully. It's much easier to hear that, you know,
00:40:10
within the confines of a juror room when there's 12 of us hauling around a laptop.
00:40:13
You know, it had been a month since we last listened to that 911 call, so I think it was imperative that we got a chance to hear it again.
00:40:19
Please, my wife, who's that from? Bye. I don't know what's going on. And when they listened, they said, they heard a man who wasn't changing his stories, but was simply beside himself and utterly confused.
00:40:31
You know, obviously, when you first hear it in the openings, he said, I don't know what's going on over and over again.
00:40:37
When we listen to it during the end in the jury room, you think, man, this is just a terrified man that really has no idea what's going on.
00:40:43
And after eight hours of deliberation, they had reached their verdict. We, the jury in Miami-Dade County, Florida, on this fifth day of June, 2012, find as follows.
00:40:55
The defendant is not guilty, so say we all. Adams' family and friends burst with emotion.
00:41:01
So what was that like? I'll tell you, I didn't hear her reading it. I put my head down and all I could think about were Lena and my kids.
00:41:14
I hear not guilty. And I hear crying in the back. That's it? That's it? It's over?
00:41:20
It's over? And it's over? It's over? Finality. Later, Adam and Seth posed for pictures holding the jury charge sheet with those words he'd longed to hear.
00:41:32
Not guilty. The very words Miami prosecutors had dreaded. They'd spent a huge amount of resources on this case and lost.
00:41:41
And the jury foreman told us he believed the case should not have gone to trial at all.
00:41:47
Why did the state bring this case to trial when there's such evidence that said, no, don't do this.
00:41:54
Adam Kaufman is innocent. He's not not guilty. Adam Kaufman is innocent. I don't apologize for the case. I'm not going to.
00:42:01
But you believe a murderer has gotten away with it. Hey, he's not the first one. He won't be the last.
00:42:05
Look, that guy, he paid for a lot of money for a defense, and he got it, and he's a very lucky man.
00:42:15
Given what he's been through, lucky might not be the word Adam would use. Still, he says he's not angry, not bitter.
00:42:23
I can only move forward. I can't move backwards. I can only move forward and do the right things for my family, my children, myself.
00:42:32
and as for the team that tried to put him away the discovery that the people who were
00:42:38
who were looking for evidence against you had been actually having an affair and maybe couldn't be relied on to tell the truth
00:42:45
that's right what was that like? poetic justice? things happen for a reason I'm a firm believer of that
00:42:53
and Lena Spirit was definitely with us during this trial and she was watching over it
00:42:58
Lena he will always remember lena he said and the love he lost in one instant that november morning
00:43:08
where do you put her now she's with me every day every day you know there's not a day that goes by
00:43:18
that i don't think about her the kids think about her she'll always have a place in my heart we have
00:43:23
pictures of her all over the home. Our wedding photos are just pictures of her. So the children will never forget who their mother was.
00:43:33
That is. And she's still a very big part of their lives. Every day. That's all for now.
00:43:43
I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.