00:00:00
I can't believe that your baby's lying there, lifeless. She was everything to me. She was so sweet to everybody.
00:00:09
State troopers said Bonnie had died in a hiking accident. They said she fell off a cliff. Her mother said they were wrong.
00:00:22
I'm screaming to them, these are defensive wounds. No witnesses, no weapon, nothing left behind but a stranger's DNA.
00:00:31
No longer have some accidental death. This was a homicide. They had no suspect, but for years her mother kept fighting to find Bonnie's killer.
00:00:40
Bonnie's mother continues her own crusade. Then, after more than a decade of searching, a phone call.
00:00:47
They just got information. It was a match. Can we get a conviction on just the DNA?
00:00:53
And there was something else, something about Bonnie herself. It was almost like she knew something.
00:01:11
Good evening and welcome to Dateline. I'm Lester Holt. We often see headlines about DNA evidence exonerating the innocent.
00:01:19
It seems we hear less about how DNA is used to track down the guilty. In the story, a sample found on a murdered young woman was sent to the national database.
00:01:30
Twelve years after she was killed, it turned up a match. One profile out of five million, matching a man thousands of miles away.
00:01:40
But in this case, prosecutors would need more than DNA to convict a killer. Here's Keith Morrison.
00:01:49
Many years ago, late on a September night, a family in Anchorage, Alaska, got a knock on the door.
00:01:56
It was one of those eerie feelings instantly when someone knocks on the door at 10 o'clock at night, and they asked to speak to my dad.
00:02:04
It was 1994. Samantha was 12, her brother Adam 13. They huddled on the staircase overlooking the front door.
00:02:11
I heard my dad collapse and scream, no, not Bonnie. And I just remember thinking, God, please let her be in the hospital and let her be okay.
00:02:21
Bonnie was elder sister. Bonnie Craig, 18 years old. I remember my dad dropping to his knees crying on the front deck.
00:02:30
And that was about the first time I've ever seen that happen. Their mother, Karen, was on vacation, was on a sailboat off the coast of Florida, four time zones away.
00:02:39
It was 2 a.m. when she docked, got the news. Bonnie would not be okay. Alaska State troopers had called and said that Bonnie had died in a hiking accident.
00:02:52
And you're thinking, they're nuts. What's going on? Why? Why would you say something like that?
00:02:58
But it was true. At least that Bonnie was dead. It was a hiker who found her body floating in McHugh Creek, a few miles from Anchorage.
00:03:09
But first, they didn't know who it was, no ID on the body. Alaska State Troopers finally figured it out from the class ring she was wearing.
00:03:19
But Karen could not take it in. Not Bonnie, her model child, her conscientious college freshman, who she knew was going to school that day.
00:03:28
not hiking miles and miles from home and the university. None of it made sense. She didn't drive, so how did she get out there?
00:03:39
Somebody would have had to be with her, and she would not have missed school. She absolutely did not go out there on her own.
00:03:48
In fact, Bonnie's sister heard her get up that morning at 5 a.m. and set out on her 45-minute walk through the pre-dawn dark
00:03:56
to catch the bus that would take her to her 7 a.m. class at the university. She usually didn't return home till about 10 p.m.,
00:04:03
packing most of her classes into a few days because she had a job at Sam's Club.
00:04:08
She was incredibly responsible. Responsible and nurturing toward her younger siblings,
00:04:15
in part because their parents, Mother Karen and Stepfather Gary, had divorced a couple of years earlier.
00:04:21
She just liked to help us make all the right decisions, and I looked up to her. Another brother, Jason, was two years older than Bonnie.
00:04:30
I tell my kids this all the time. You can decide in the morning when you get up.
00:04:34
You can have a good day or a bad day. And she would always choose to have a good day.
00:04:39
She was incredible. One of those people that as soon as you start talking to her,
00:04:44
you're instantly attracted to her personality. In high school, they used to call her Tigger
00:04:49
because she was just bouncy and fun and so sweet to everybody. She was involved in sports. She was coaching the kids with swimming.
00:04:59
She started students against drunk driving. She was the very first girl to be on the wrestling team at Surface High School.
00:05:09
Bonnie had a serious boyfriend, Cameron, who had left that summer to start college at the University of California.
00:05:17
She used to record herself singing and talking to him and send him cassette tapes.
00:05:22
She was crazy about them, yes. They were madly in love. And now suddenly Bonnie Craig was dead.
00:05:32
At least, that's what her mother Karen had been told. But as she flew home to Alaska, she struggled with denial.
00:05:39
I believed flying back that as I got there, she might even be at the airport saying,
00:05:45
Mom, I'm sorry, it wasn't me. It's all just been a terrible mistake. But no, Bonnie was not at the airport to meet Karen.
00:05:55
Her body was at the funeral home I only got to see her face It just incredibly sad and you think oh my God it is her
00:06:08
You can't believe that your baby's lying there, cold and lifeless. The next day, Karen saw her baby again, saw more than her face,
00:06:19
and noticed something that seemed to confirm what she already believed. It wasn't a hiking accident.
00:06:26
She called the Alaska State Troopers. Her knuckles were broken. So I'm on the phone screaming to them, saying,
00:06:34
No, you've got to get back. You've got to take more pictures. These are defensive wounds.
00:06:39
Look again at Bonnie's body, she demanded. Look harder. What happened to Bonnie Craig that September day, screamed Karen, was murder.
00:06:50
When we come back, Bonnie's mother faces not just grief, But guilt. I think my mom felt very responsible.
00:06:57
Like I caused this. I caused this, you know. They killed Bonnie because of something I did.
00:07:03
Was her child's death revenge? When Dateline continues. In the autumn of 1994, a suffocating grief descended in Anchorage, Alaska.
00:07:22
and settled on the home of 18-year-old Bonnie Craig. It was a very bad night. It was tough. It was really tough.
00:07:30
I guess you just don't know what to do after that. How to channel your emotions.
00:07:35
We're all devastated. Once she arrived home, Bonnie's mother, Karen, jumped into action.
00:07:39
Had to find the truth about Bonnie's death. And seemed equipped to do so. She was an Anchorage Reserve police officer and before that a local TV reporter.
00:07:49
She told her media friends it was murder. The troopers didn't know what they were doing.
00:07:54
She even included Samantha in this interview. She wouldn't have taken it from a stranger for sure.
00:08:00
There was nothing accidental about it. But initially, it did look like an accidental fall to one of the troopers,
00:08:06
the one who happened to have been the first to talk to Karen. But the others saw the evidence and thought, murder.
00:08:14
One trooper at the crime scene was Tim Hunyer, now retired. One thing that was strange to us, we did find one drop of blood on a leaf at the top of the cliff.
00:08:24
One drop of blood. One drop of blood. Which was found by Trooper Robert Beatty, also now retired.
00:08:32
I was on my hands and knees just kind of looking and came across that drop of blood.
00:08:37
We got blood up here, did he tell you that? How big was this drop of blood? About the size of an eraser head, really.
00:08:43
And the interesting part about that was that it was a drop that had fallen straight down.
00:08:51
Indicating to the troopers that she'd been hurt somehow before she got anywhere near the edge of the cliff.
00:08:57
With it being, you know, five, six feet away from the cliff's edge, it was real apparent to me that, you know, we no longer have some accidental death.
00:09:08
This was a homicide. But because there was no sign of a struggle at the crime scene,
00:09:15
no weapon, nothing more left behind, it was obvious this would be hard to solve.
00:09:22
So, though eventually they told Karen they agreed with her, Bonnie had been murdered,
00:09:26
they wanted her to keep that information secret. Fat chance. By then, Karen was telling anyone who would listen what she thought,
00:09:36
and she was not about to stop. So, you spoiled it for them. Yeah, I got in trouble constantly for me getting involved in the investigation and also...
00:09:51
Opening your big mouth to the media. Yeah. She was troubled by something else, too.
00:09:56
Her reserve work with the Anchorage Police Department. Was Bonnie the victim of a revenge killing?
00:10:03
I was doing undercover work, doing drug buys. and we had done this major bust just beforehand.
00:10:12
So in a position to make some people pretty mad at you. Right. I think my mom felt very responsible.
00:10:19
Like I caused this. I caused this. They killed Bonnie because of something I did.
00:10:25
She took that as it was her fault. And so, therefore, she had to... Figure it out.
00:10:32
Had to solve the crime. caught up in a whirl of guilt about her own possible role
00:10:37
and a growing anger about what she perceived as an inept investigation by the troopers,
00:10:44
Karen began a campaign to keep Bonnie's case in the public eye. We started handing out flyers.
00:10:52
We got bumper stickers made. We started building up a reward. We had bus signs driving all around town.
00:11:01
The first one said, who killed Bonnie? and continued doing interviews. Somebody out there knows what's happened,
00:11:09
and we desperately need to hear from them. Oh, and there were lots of tips which went nowhere
00:11:16
and only ate up the trooper's precious time. They resisted Karen's efforts to insert herself into the case
00:11:22
and told her as little as possible, didn't tell her, for example, about that drop of Bonnie's blood at the top of the cliff.
00:11:29
She was very demanding. I think she felt with her police background she should be privy to all the information we had.
00:11:37
Oh, man. The troopers hated me because I just kept pushing and pushing. I wasn't about to give up.
00:11:45
I was so fearful that things were being missed. Tension grew. Troopers rarely returned Karen calls which compounded her belief the investigators didn know what they were doing Unwilling to believe and unaware that they were doing a lot We talking to all Bonnie friends people she went to school with people she worked with
00:12:07
anybody that had any connection at all with Bonnie. We walked the same route Bonnie walked that day to see if anybody was around,
00:12:14
you know, talk to the paper girl, talk to, you know, people we saw jogging on the street.
00:12:18
We would ride the bus, you know, for a week straight just to talk to all the people on the bus.
00:12:23
For a week? Yeah. to see if they saw anything, see if they heard anything. And nobody heard anything?
00:12:29
No, no one saw, no one can remember seeing Bonnie that day. Winter came. Karen, consumed by grief, rage, guilt about her undercover drug work,
00:12:39
was now a single-minded crusader for Bonnie. Nothing else mattered. Nothing at all.
00:12:45
It's unbelievable. You know, as a mother, I abandoned my kids and just started looking for a killer.
00:12:58
And it was months before the troopers gave Karen the rest of the news about what happened to Bonnie in the last minutes of her life.
00:13:08
Coming up, as investigators began looking for possible suspects, they looked first close to home.
00:13:16
I remember just straight up asking him, Dad, did you kill Bonnie? When Dateline continues.
00:13:29
It was a standoff, tense and unpleasant. Karen, the grieving mother, furious at a team of state troopers she did not trust,
00:13:36
determined to find out herself who murdered her bright, beautiful Bonnie, versus detectives who in turn did not trust her,
00:13:44
and so told her little about what they knew and what they were learning. But they eventually let her see the autopsy report,
00:13:53
and that's when Karen saw a dozen or so brutal head wounds. That's also when the medical examiner told her about one extremely important piece of news,
00:14:02
horrifying, but potentially useful. Bonnie had been raped as well. And as awful as that was, it left one sliver of hope.
00:14:13
The killer left behind his DNA. Match it, and they'd solve the case. So, who was it?
00:14:22
It couldn't have been the boyfriend, Cameron. He was down in California going to college.
00:14:27
Troopers said they looked at Karen's work as a reserve undercover police officer
00:14:30
and determined the men in those drug buys were not involved either. But there was one man, very close with opportunity,
00:14:38
who returned home to Anchorage from an out-of-town trip just the night before the murder.
00:14:43
Bonnie's stepfather, Karen's ex-husband, Samantha's dad. And I remember that being a really unsure, really scary feeling.
00:14:52
In my mind, it didn't make sense. My dad is not and never has been a violent man.
00:14:57
And so I remember just straight up asking him, Dad, did you kill Bonnie? Do you remember the look on his face when you asked him?
00:15:03
He was devastated. He was completely devastated. But I just needed to hear it from him
00:15:09
because there was so much uncertainty in my life. at that point. There's so much confusion that to be able to have him tell me when he was tucking me
00:15:20
in bed was all I needed. The DNA spoke too. He was eliminated. But someone did it. Troopers set
00:15:29
about collecting DNA from every man who might have crossed Bonnie's path the day she was murdered,
00:15:34
including some men who worked with her at Sam's Club. We had information that there was one
00:15:39
employee there who Bonnie complained to her supervisor about. Evidently this individual got
00:15:46
Bonnie's phone number off the Sam's Club computer and would call her. He was doing a little stalking.
00:15:52
That threw the red flag up right away. DNA cleared him. They moved on to a second young man at Sam's
00:15:58
Club whose behavior seemed suspicious. They had a meeting at Sam's Club that morning that she
00:16:04
was murdered. And this individual, he did not sign into the meeting. You went and checked him out?
00:16:10
We checked him out, come to find out that he was at the meeting. He didn't sign in. Others saw him
00:16:15
there. We still got his DNA and he was cleared. Then there was a student attended an English class
00:16:21
with Bonnie, threw up all kinds of red flags. That is, once the teacher read his class journal.
00:16:27
I met with her, and she showed me his journal that was filled with anger. There was a reference that September 28th was going to be a rough day, and that he was going to be put to a test.
00:16:44
That was the day she was killed. Yeah. And there was a reference to die. You could see that he was very angry and troubled.
00:16:56
He wasn't in class that day. And he came to her later on the afternoon, soaking wet and reeking of aftershave.
00:17:08
And he handed in his paper. And she felt like he was nervous at the time. All the signs pointing toward guilt.
00:17:18
And then he was also at the scene when they were recovering her body. That very day.
00:17:25
Yeah. One of the looky-loos, as they say. Yeah. Which is often the case with somebody.
00:17:31
If they've killed someone, they'll go back and look at the investigation. Right.
00:17:34
So what did you think when you heard that? I thought, this is it, you know. I remember instantly thinking, well, Bonnie had pepper spray.
00:17:43
I wonder if she pepper sprayed him. And that's why he had to mask it with cologne.
00:17:48
It sounded very suspicious to us, you know. So right away, you know, we're just talking about that, jumping on that.
00:17:53
and find a guy But the DNA eliminated him too Or so the troopers told Carrie When they said no the DNA didn match and he has an alibi
00:18:06
his stepmom said he slept in that day. Did you buy that? No, absolutely not. I said, what if there was two people?
00:18:15
It didn't have to be his DNA. Yeah. He could have been involved and it was somebody else's DNA.
00:18:22
Did you make some noise about that? Absolutely. but then months went by and years no match no justice for bonnie no peace for karen for the
00:18:35
troopers and then it was 1998 four years since bonnie's murder the troopers still working the
00:18:41
case when one of them zeroed in on the former city bus driver and he would fill in for the
00:18:49
regular driver on bonnie's bus route and we just found out some strange strange things about this
00:18:54
guy. He had several reports about him trying to pick up young girls. One of them was the
00:19:01
daughter of another bus driver. I mean, I'm talking 14-year-old girls. Oh, boy. He was
00:19:07
a substitute teacher, but got fired for some of the things he was staying in his classes.
00:19:12
Apropos of young girls. Yes, and he left the area and moved down to California. The troopers went looking and found him in Davis, California.
00:19:20
We flew down there to try to talk to him. Could this be him? The man who raped and murdered Bonnie?
00:19:26
Could the hunt finally be over? They got his DNA. It came back that he was the individual involved in Bonnie's death, or that he had sex with her.
00:19:34
Everyone was happy. Everyone was ecstatic. You got your guy. We got our guy. Finally, they had their man.
00:19:42
But, what is it they say? Don't count your chickens. When we come back, you'd think it would be all over if the DNA matched.
00:19:51
but it was not to be. You think, wow, this is the guy. Then the bomb hit. The bomb.
00:19:59
When Dateline continues. All that was left in the family now, in the years after Bonnie's murder,
00:20:14
was the collecting of memories of bits of things that reminded them of how good she was,
00:20:20
how thoughtful. Like a school paper, Bonnie was to have turned in the day she died.
00:20:25
She'd read it to her sister the night before. It was an English exercise, said Samantha, in which Bonnie wrote about saying goodbye.
00:20:33
Saying goodbye to her friend Katie, who had died in a vehicle accident. Saying goodbye to her dad, her biological father, who was never really a part of her life.
00:20:43
Saying goodbye to Cameron as he went away to college. It was almost like she knew something.
00:20:48
Something was broken in the family. Could never be fixed, of course. But then there was this news, huge news, that the DNA matched a one-time bus driver who'd moved down to Davis, California.
00:21:00
The troopers called Karen as soon as the result came in. You get excited and you think, wow, this is...
00:21:07
This is the guy. Yeah. Then the bomb hit. The bomb? The bomb. They had some new DNA system out. They retested it and turned out it wasn't him.
00:21:17
Ouch. No one could believe it. Back at square one. Back at square one. You know, then dealing with Karen again.
00:21:24
Karen ramped up her campaign to keep Bonnie's case in the public eye. Bonnie's mother, Karen Campbell, continues her own crusade to find her daughter's killer.
00:21:32
She remains unsatisfied with the investigation. The attention brought in tips. Troopers eventually tested more than 100 DNA samples.
00:21:42
And nothing came of it but frustration. The case grew cold, as cold as some of the winter nights.
00:21:50
And four years became six, eight, ten. The case faded from the public spotlight.
00:21:57
And so around Thanksgiving 2006, 12 years after the murder, when Trooper Hunyer answered the phone one day...
00:22:03
I couldn't believe it. The director of the state crime lab contacted me and said that they just got information
00:22:10
that there was a match to the CODIS system. on a semen sample for Bonnie Craig. They got him.
00:22:20
Or the system did. CODIS is short for Combined DNA Index System. It's a national database of DNA profiles
00:22:29
created by federal, state, and local crime labs. And CODIS got a hit. Gave us a real good day.
00:22:36
Everybody was happy. The match was in New Hampshire, of all places. A man who did imprison for armed robbery back in early 2003.
00:22:43
but nobody got around to entering his DNA into CODIS until late 2006. They got a hit the first time. It was wrong.
00:22:52
So Trooper Hunyer flew to New Hampshire to meet the man behind the match. His name was Kenneth Dion.
00:22:59
Hunyer had never heard of him. Hey, my name's Tim Hunyer. Hey, Tim, I'm just letting you check.
00:23:05
Their Q&A session was taped. Okay, when did you get into Alaska? It was in the 90s sometime.
00:23:12
And I just started talking to him about his life, where he grew up, where he went to school, how he got up into Alaska.
00:23:20
So you didn't jump right in and say, we know you killed this girl. No, just try to gain some rapport with him.
00:23:26
Basically, we smoked and joked for a while. Did you get to travel to the state quite a bit?
00:23:32
A little bit. I went up to Natalie a couple of times with friends from the military.
00:23:36
I've been to Mary Pelties a few times. I like it down there. Found out he was a fifth degree black belt, martial arts.
00:23:42
He was ranked number 10 in the world in the fighting competition. Wow. He liked to brawl in bars, he said.
00:23:49
Carried martial arts weapons in his car, including nunchucks. That was his thing. He loved it.
00:23:56
He loved the adventure. He was married at the time of Bonnie's murder. but later got divorced.
00:24:01
That's the first thing I've always screwed up in my life, is that marriage right there.
00:24:06
I love it to death, yeah. I told you all this stuff. Yes. If Kenneth Dion knew why an Alaska state trooper
00:24:12
would fly 4,500 miles just to talk to him, he didn't show it. He was civil. He answered all the questions.
00:24:20
Just like, you know, we're friends. For some reason, I got a bad memory. I forget things.
00:24:26
Faces, I'll remember. I'll forget your name. I've already forgotten your name. Well, that's Tim.
00:24:31
Tim? Yeah, I'm sorry. No problem at all. He told me that after he got up here in the Army, he got into cocaine.
00:24:37
He started using drugs, and then everything went downhill. He was basically kicked out of the Army,
00:24:45
and the cocaine became really a big part of his life, and he did some armed robberies to support the cocaine habit.
00:24:53
He was in and out of prison in Alaska, and then in 1996, two years after Bonnie's murder,
00:24:58
he moved back to New Hampshire, where he got in trouble again. And now, here he was answering Trooper Hunyer's next question.
00:25:07
Did he follow the news when he was up in Alaska? Oh, yeah, all the time. Did you ever meet someone called Bonnie or anything like that?
00:25:15
It was a pretty high-profile case. I can't recall. I can't remember. Hunyer tried to jog Dion's memory.
00:25:23
And I took out Bonnie's picture and showed it to him. Then something curious happened.
00:25:27
The man who said he remembered faces insisted he didn't recognize Bonnie. But Trooper Hunyard was watching his body language.
00:25:35
His legs started twitching, and we just kept glancing at him. Might he have met her even once, the trooper asked?
00:25:42
18 years old? Hell no. My wife would have killed me. Then he got right to the point.
00:25:52
And a sad thing about it, later on that day, her body was found at McHugh Creek.
00:25:57
Whoa, whoa, whoa. What are you trying to say? Well, like I said, I'm just down here investigating your name has come up.
00:26:04
You know, like hundreds of names. Why would my name come up? That's what I'm trying to figure out.
00:26:09
What do you think? Oh, I thought we had our man. Troopers looked up some of Kenneth Dion's New Hampshire girlfriends.
00:26:15
One said he casually mentioned he could kill someone and get away with it. And she just thought he's blowing smoke, you know.
00:26:22
Then he also told her that, you know, I can't go back to Alaska because it's something I've done.
00:26:26
She never asked him about that. But she told the troopers they might want to talk to her sister.
00:26:33
And the sister told us, yeah, you know, he told me that he can't go back to Alaska because he killed somebody.
00:26:39
Coming up, Bonnie's family learns investigators have made an arrest. I'm immediately so fearful.
00:26:47
Can we get a conviction on just the DNA? When Dateline continues. Strange how big events in life can arrive when you least expect them.
00:27:07
Karen was on vacation again, a remote island in the Philippines. An email arrived from Trooper Hunyer.
00:27:14
Call me, it said. I tried calling him and I kept getting disconnected. But finally, they had a conversation long enough for Karen to learn one thing.
00:27:25
one amazing fact. A DNA match. After 12 years, they had the man they believe murdered her daughter, Bonnie.
00:27:34
And there on that island, Karen felt afraid. You would expect that I would be thrilled,
00:27:40
and no, I'm immediately so fearful that, oh my gosh, now we know who's done it. Are we going to get him convicted?
00:27:50
A few months later, in 2007, Kenneth Dion was indicted and extradited to Alaska.
00:27:56
Karen's anxiety only grew. I didn't trust the investigation. Is the evidence still there?
00:28:04
The investigators, the witnesses. Can we get a conviction on just the DNA? And to make it worse,
00:28:11
dozens of pretrial hearings dragged on four more years. It's unbelievably long and painful.
00:28:18
Everything's like the day that she was murdered. It like having everything ripped open again The trial finally started in May 2011 She has 11 linear lacerations in the back of the skull
00:28:34
It was Paul Maiovis' first trial as Alaska's assistant attorney general in charge of cold case homicides.
00:28:40
And he was worried. I went into it with a heavy heart. I knew that it was going to be a very difficult task.
00:28:46
That's because the DNA taken from Kenneth Dion did not prove he raped and killed Bonnie.
00:28:51
Only that sex took place between them. And beyond the DNA, the prosecutor had little to connect Dion to the murder.
00:28:59
There was no weapon, no motive, no witness to the crime. We not only had to establish that Kenneth Dion was the killer,
00:29:07
but we also had to disprove that it was an accident and prove that she had been murdered and she didn't fall off the cliff.
00:29:13
His co-counsel, Jenna Grunstein, was a 13-year-old Anchorage schoolgirl when Bonnie was murdered.
00:29:19
I remember very vividly how much this impacted the community. Everyone's sense of security when you know that somebody was kind of literally snatched off the street.
00:29:30
In Anchorage, they were under intense pressure. The courtroom was packed, standing room only.
00:29:35
And then on the second day of the trial, a new problem. The defense attorney told the jury in his opening statement that the initial investigation at BQ Creek was inadequate,
00:29:45
And in fact, the crime scene video was missing and had been for years, confirming Karen's
00:29:52
worst fears about the troopers. It just made us sick. Which made the news that came the next day all the more shocking.
00:30:00
Out of the blue, somebody at the Alaska State Troopers office found the crime scene tape.
00:30:07
Good news? Well, you'd think. But... My concern was that it threatened the trial itself.
00:30:14
We immediately took a recess at a five-day break in trial. The amazing discovery of the long-lost videotape could very well be grounds for a mistrial,
00:30:24
because the defense got it after the start of the trial. For five days, the prosecutors researched case law,
00:30:30
marshaled their arguments, and worried about yet more delays in the trial. But then, good news.
00:30:37
The defense attorney decided he would not request a mistrial. And back in court, prosecutors played the crime scene tape.
00:30:44
The public's first chance to see what investigators did the day of the murder. I recall prior to playing the tape my dread on, boy, what's the family going to feel.
00:30:57
It was Trooper Beatty who took the stand when the video rolled. You know, this is the first time they've seen their daughter in this horrible position, dead, floating in the water.
00:31:08
Unbelievable. Unbelievable. I couldn't start crying, but I made myself watch everything.
00:31:15
And as she did, the most amazing thing happened. Now, you would think that for a mother to watch something like that would just be horrifying.
00:31:28
It would. It was healing. Healing? Healing to me because I knew then that for 17 years that I had known that they did do the investigation.
00:31:42
They did take care and were very competent at the scene. For all those years, she accused the troopers of being incompetent at the crime scene.
00:31:55
And she was wrong. And they were down on their knees looking for evidence. They were in the water looking for a weapon.
00:32:07
It must have changed everything for you. It did. It's a big revelation for her. It was. It was.
00:32:12
I went out as he walked out of the courtroom. I gave him a hug and told him thank you.
00:32:21
Seventeen years of anger and tension just popped like that. Pretty much. Within a few minutes.
00:32:28
But the prosecution's problem remained. Could Bonnie have picked up Dion's DNA from consensual sex?
00:32:35
Only solution, let Bonnie's own character speak for her. I haven't come across anybody else that spent her age and had the level of maturity that she had.
00:32:45
Party girl she was not. She clearly was not a party girl. What more she was seriously in love with her boyfriend Cameron It was just clear from every aspect that they were completely in love with each other And all these 17 years later even in court Cameron was grieving still
00:33:04
I loved her. So, deep in love. But also far too busy, said the prosecutors, to sneak off for some secret tryst.
00:33:19
She was working, she was in school, she didn't have time. And why Kenneth Dion? He was a married man with a newborn, a cocaine problem, and a vastly different life.
00:33:30
They came from two completely different worlds, and there was no reason for the two of them to have mixed together.
00:33:35
Anyway, said the prosecutors, there was physical evidence of rape. Her pants were smeared with grass stains.
00:33:41
One of the buttons was undone. She didn't drive, and the place she was killed was miles away.
00:33:47
Someone must have taken her there. There, where investigators found that one telling drop of blood on a leaf near the top of the cliff.
00:33:57
This is what really showed that she was injured before she went off the cliff, which establishes that she had been beaten and it was a murder and it wasn't an accident.
00:34:05
In fact, the state's forensic pathologist testified Bonnie's wounds were not consistent with an accidental fall.
00:34:10
She had 11 blunt force wounds on her skull, but no injuries on her face and few on her torso.
00:34:18
He said no blood indicating an accidental fall was ever found on any rocks. This is a no-brainer.
00:34:25
We have his sperm in Bonnie Craig. There's no dispute about this. This was no accident of the prosecution.
00:34:33
It was rape and murder. Unless, as the defense attorney was about to suggest, maybe Bonnie Craig had a few secrets of her own.
00:34:43
It was consensual sex. How many people had a different side to them that was different than what family and friends knew?
00:34:52
Coming up, the case for the defense. You're saying this young woman had a different side?
00:34:57
I'm saying that that's a definite possibility. Would the jury buy it when Dateline continues?
00:35:04
When Bonnie Craig's raped and beaten body was found face down in a creek outside of Anchorage, Alaska,
00:35:18
it was September 1994, and Kenneth Dion was a 25-year-old cocaine addict on the way down, a long criminal spiral.
00:35:27
At the time of the trial, he was 41, entering middle age and potentially facing 124 years in prison for rape and murder.
00:35:37
Was Bonnie murdered? No. She died accidentally. But not if defense attorney Andrew Lambert could help it.
00:35:45
Bonnie accidentally fell off the cliff and died. After having consensual sex with your client?
00:35:50
Not necessarily that day. Could have been a couple of days before. It could have been.
00:35:56
And that was the essence of it, the defense of Kenneth Dion, that he and Bonnie had consensual sex.
00:36:02
And a few days later, she just happened to die in a hiking accident. No provable connection between the two events, said the defense.
00:36:10
While Dion told Trooper Hunnyer a few years earlier he had never met Bonnie, his attorney was now saying the opposite, though offering no evidence of how or when they'd met.
00:36:21
But after all, it was the prosecutor's job to prove rape, not his, to prove otherwise.
00:36:26
And attorney Lambert scoffed at the prosecutor's argument that Bonnie was too busy and too in love with her boyfriend to have had a sexual fling on the side.
00:36:34
You've interviewed thousands and thousands of people. And how many of them were really good people that had found out had cheated on their spouse, had cheated on their boyfriend, and nobody knew.
00:36:44
how many people had a different side to them that was different than what family and friends knew.
00:36:51
And you're saying this young woman had a different side? I'm saying that that's a definite possibility.
00:36:55
But it would probably be a lot harder to believe it of this particular young woman than most other people.
00:37:04
But you never know. Maybe if she met him, got to know him initially, she found him somewhat charming and was maybe enthralled with him.
00:37:12
and then she never gets to know the history of who he is. Is that what he said happened?
00:37:17
Well, you know I can't answer that because that attorney privilege In any case Bonnie death was consistent with an accidental fall his defense expert testified When a body tumbles we don know how it tumbles Injuries can occur in
00:37:30
microseconds and not leave blood on the rocks. What's more, the defense attorney pointed out,
00:37:36
not one person could place Kenneth Dion with Bonnie or at the creek that day. There's no
00:37:41
witnesses to say that they saw Ken and Bonnie together that day. There were no witnesses
00:37:48
placing him near her along her route. The case went to the jury in mid-June. It wasn't out for long.
00:37:56
Karen and the family were on their way to do a TV interview and... As I'm pulling up to the interview,
00:38:03
I see the cameraman and the reporter taking off and they circle around and they say,
00:38:07
The jury's back! The jury deliberated so fast, just several hours, they thought it had to be guilty.
00:38:14
It was incredibly exciting because we knew that it was going to happen. We're just dying to hear the words.
00:38:23
And we did it. We, the jury, find the defendant, Kenneth Dion, guilty of murder in the first degree as charged in count one of the indictment.
00:38:30
Praise God. Sweet victory. It was like the weight of the world was lifted off our shoulders.
00:38:39
He's guilty. Amazing. Amazing. Ken Dion did not kill Bonnie Craig and did not rape her.
00:38:45
Are you telling me that you believe your client is innocent? I am. You don't think he committed this crime?
00:38:52
I don't. We're asking for the maximum sentence. At the sentencing in October 2011,
00:38:58
as the prosecutor argued for 124 years the maximum sentence and no chance at parole because Dion hadn't shown any sign of remorse.
00:39:06
Mr. Dion, as the family has pointed out, has never taken responsibility for what he's done.
00:39:11
And I never will because I didn't do it. And that answers your question, Judge. Nothing further.
00:39:17
Kenneth Dion, as if on cue, denied it all. The judge gave him the maximum, but also the chance at parole when he's about 80.
00:39:27
Is it possible he actually didn't remember doing it? I struggle with that. Is it possible that his protestations are sincere in that he had an episode in his life that he has either blocked out or for some reason can't recall based on what was, you know,
00:39:44
happening in his life at that time. Cocaine puts holes in your brain, as they say. It does.
00:39:48
Amazing, though, isn't it? This is a man who got away with murder for a long time and would have
00:39:53
completely scot-free if it hadn't been somebody put the DNA into CODIS. It's really remarkable.
00:40:01
Which became, it turned out, the subject of Karen's new campaign at the time. She joined the Alaska
00:40:07
State Troopers and other law enforcement agencies trying to persuade every state to enter DNA into
00:40:13
CODIS, the national data bank, upon arrest. After her push for a change in Alaska, the state now
00:40:19
enters a suspect's DNA when he or she is arrested for a felony, just as it records mugshots and
00:40:25
fingerprints. More than 30 states now have laws in place to take DNA from arrestees. We need all of
00:40:32
them to collect it. DNA doesn't lie. You get to the truth so much sooner. It saves money. It saves
00:40:38
lives. Samantha channeled her grief. She became a 911 operator. 911, what's the location of the
00:40:46
emergency? So when you have someone on the other end of the line who's calling in because they just
00:40:50
found out that somebody had died and they need to know what happened, I feel that pain. I know that
00:40:56
pain. But as for Bonnie's older brother, Jason, his mission became more personal. It changes the way
00:41:04
I raise my kids. I spend more time to make sure that they're understanding why things are done
00:41:10
in certain ways or what builds character, what really is important in life. Sounds to me like
00:41:15
you're trying to grow some more bonnies. Maybe. You miss her a lot, don't you? Did the ache ever go away?
00:41:28
No. She was kind to everybody and that's why it was so shocking that anybody could harm her
00:41:36
because she would never harm anybody. She was such a sweetheart. That's all for now.
00:41:43
I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.