00:00:00
It's a murder mystery. You've got a wealthy family. It's something for everybody.
00:00:07
There is a club of people consumed by trying to figure out what happened. I've never seen anything like it.
00:00:17
Almost everywhere Robert Durst went, mystery followed. A missing wife. Everything about this reeked of murder.
00:00:25
A murdered best friend. A dead neighbor. It's hard to understand. Now, the stories you haven't heard as those who knew Robert Durst best speak out.
00:00:37
I hope and I pray that when all this is done, we all get answers. And hear his own account of his strange life.
00:00:46
The reclusive millionaire spent much of his time on the road. So where was he? What was he doing?
00:00:53
Who was he with? What is a guy of his wealth doing? hanging out at a homeless shelter soup kitchen.
00:01:01
For decades, suspicions, questions, raised anew on the series The Jinx. Will there finally be answers?
00:01:10
Bob didn't kill Susan Berman. The twisted trail of Robert Durst and the mystery that haunts a mother.
00:01:18
Karen, where are you? He's definitely in the mix. He is in the mix. I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.
00:01:27
Here's Keith Morrison with Robert Durst, The Lost Years. There is a letter written decades ago.
00:01:42
A prophecy? Perhaps. A warning, certainly. A doctor writing about a very troubled 10-year-old boy suffering from hostility issues.
00:01:57
sufficient to produce a personality decomposition and possibly even schizophrenia.
00:02:04
The troubled little boy? His name is well known. Robert Durst. By now you've heard the bizarre saga.
00:02:19
The multimillionaire scion of a New York real estate empire. The disappeared wife.
00:02:24
The dead friend. The dismembered neighbor. He's been the subject of several Dateline episodes,
00:02:30
and the star, though not in the way he intended, of HBO's The Jinx. But do you, does anyone, know the truth about Robert Durst?
00:02:42
The story behind the story? The trail we followed, the revelations we encountered,
00:02:48
the personal account he wrote and we were given, which have led us into a very weird place.
00:02:54
The Lost Years of the Infamous Robert Durst. The tale is like quicksand. It sucks you in.
00:03:03
Bob is endlessly fascinating and always surprises me. He was certainly elusive, mercurial, sometimes desperate, always in motion.
00:03:15
We'd track him, his descent, his strange detour off the road, off the grid. A life that no one, not even his family or close friends, could fathom.
00:03:27
He has a good heart inside. I really think so. We begin with two people who knew and loved the man they called Bobby,
00:03:38
godfather of their son, close friend of more than 40 years, long before the rest of the world heard of him.
00:03:45
And when did you meet him? We went to high school together. Stuart and Emily Altman spoke to us after Durst was arrested.
00:03:55
There's still a side of Bob that's not a monster. You know, he has a heart, but it's caused me a great deal of conflict
00:04:03
and I can't get my head around is whatever happened to Bob. It's hard. The Altman shared personal photos and the story of Bob they've lived and breathed,
00:04:16
Starting with the family disaster that tormented him. His mom committed suicide when he was seven years old,
00:04:23
and it was a devastating experience for Bob. Compounded by Bob's strained relationships with his brother Douglas and his father Seymour,
00:04:37
but then in the 1970s, Stewart introduced Bob to a young woman, and this whole twisted tale was set in motion.
00:04:44
I was living on East 52nd Street on the second floor, and Kathy was living on the third floor, and Bob owned the building.
00:04:54
He used to come and collect the rent. Kathy was Kathy McCormick, Stuart's young and beautiful upstairs neighbor.
00:05:04
He was like Prince Charming and a princess. Kathy was the love of his life. But it didn't last.
00:05:14
A few years later, the Albans watched their prince and princess grow apart. She became more independent. It wasn't the fairytale anymore.
00:05:26
No. In fact, Kathy's brother Jim told us it was more like a horror movie. There's a dark side of Bob that, you know, was fairly well camouflaged when they were first, you know, going out and getting married.
00:05:39
but it escalated ultimately into psychological abuse, economic abuse, and physical abuse.
00:05:46
Remember that doctor's letter warning that the 10-year-old Bob suffered from severe hostility issues?
00:05:53
Kathy gave a copy to her friends including Ellen Strauss Evidence she said just in case Kathy warned all of us that if anything ever happened look to Bob Bob did it
00:06:05
Don't let him get away with it. And then, in 1982, Kathy Durst disappeared. How did he take it?
00:06:16
It's Bob. You know, he asked if we had seen her, if we heard anything, if we knew anything.
00:06:23
But they didn't. No one did. Bob was typically almost detached in his demeanor. You know, almost, I don't know nothing, I don't know anything.
00:06:38
From the outset, Bob denied any involvement in Kathy's disappearance. At the time, he was careful to distance himself from investigators.
00:06:46
New York Times reporter Charles Bagley has covered the Durst real estate empire for more than three decades.
00:06:52
And when Kathy vanished, said Bagley, Bob's protective friend, Susan Berman, a name you've probably heard of,
00:07:00
became his unofficial spokesperson. And Susan would call back and say, well, Bob's, you know, really not feeling right right now.
00:07:10
I'm going to handle a lot of this. Bob himself was pretty much incommunicado then,
00:07:17
but we have obtained this, his own account, his version of things, which he wrote later.
00:07:24
Here's what he wrote about Kathy's disappearance. After my wife Kathy left, my compulsive use of alcohol, drugs, and food
00:07:32
changed from an infrequent problem to a daily event. He didn't come in to work for about two years.
00:07:41
Later, when Bob began showing up at work again, sporadically, he wasn't anything like a buttoned-up executive.
00:07:50
He enjoyed smoking pot in a social situation, burping and farting, because it disturbed people, you know, and he liked to watch their reactions.
00:08:00
Right. So these stories about misbehaving, peeing in a wastebasket or something.
00:08:05
It was peeing in a wastebasket and all of that. It gave pause to the family. And it was no great surprise.
00:08:14
when the family patriarch Seymour Durst chose Bob's younger brother, Douglas, to run the family business.
00:08:21
Did he really think up until the point where Douglas was picked that he had a shot at it?
00:08:26
He was groomed for it. That was supposed to be his job. He was upset. It had a devastating effect on Bob.
00:08:37
And that is when the little-known and reclusive Bob Durst went off on his own to embark on a strange new life.
00:08:44
What we wanted to know is how and why trouble seemed to be his traveling companion.
00:08:53
When we return, more mysteries and more questions for Robert Durst. And a peek at his new life on the Lost Coast.
00:09:02
I think he wanted to be a cross-dresser, and maybe he was experimenting with it.
00:09:07
Do you know what I mean? Hanging out at a homeless shelter soup kitchen. Wait a minute.
00:09:13
He bought a house. He hangs out at a home on Sheldon? They call this place the Lost Coast, an almost mystical corner of Northern California,
00:09:34
where Bob Durst came to, what, get lost himself? It was 1995, after he was dumped from the company, 13 years after Kathy disappeared.
00:09:46
Bob walked into the office of local real estate broker Gene Davenport. He told me he was a writer for the Wall Street Journal.
00:09:53
He said he wanted to have a place of ocean view. Bob forked over nearly $400,000 in cash for a big family house in the town of Trinidad,
00:10:03
overlooking the Pacific, where he lived like a hermit. nobody really seemed around he never really had contact or didn't really have any best friends
00:10:13
in that personal account of his he explained why i hated to have more than a brief conversation
00:10:22
with someone because i immediately found myself being asked what do you do the true answer was nothing i live off the family estate
00:10:30
which was true enough but he wasn't exactly idle either said author Matt Birkbeck
00:10:38
who followed the Durst case for over 15 years and wrote a book about it called A Deadly Secret
00:10:45
Bob Durst was buying other properties he said but some of his choices didn't seem to make sense
00:10:52
these aren't just homes we're talking storage facilities and P.O. boxes You mean he'd buy one storage place or something?
00:11:01
He'd have an address, and the address turned out to be a storage facility. And what's he doing with all these different storage facilities?
00:11:06
The main town near Trinidad is Eureka, where we discovered Bob spent quite a bit of time in a second-hand clothing store, primarily for women.
00:11:16
I think he wanted to be a cross-dresser, and maybe he was experimenting with it.
00:11:21
Do you know what I mean? He always came alone, said shopkeeper Kate King. He would buy something pretty plain like this, you know, nothing real, you know, so it wasn't outstanding.
00:11:35
And then he would get a skirt, you know, and try to match it up, you know, and most of the time he couldn't.
00:11:42
So I would try and help him match. Kay had seen her share of cross-dressers, but there was something different about this one.
00:11:52
He wanted to be somebody else besides Robert Dersh which might explain another untold story of those years an odd and so far unexplained habit of frequenting Eureka seedy side
00:12:07
Hanging out at a, it was a homeless shelter soup kitchen. Wait a minute. He bought a house.
00:12:15
He hangs out at a homeless shelter? He's hanging out at a homeless shelter. But, said Charles Bagley, he was also restless.
00:12:23
He was in constant motion, whether he was here in Texas or California or in Europe.
00:12:33
Or Los Angeles, where he'd look in on Susan Berman, who you'll remember spoke for him after Kathy disappeared,
00:12:39
and was now trying to make it as a Hollywood screenwriter. She and Bobby, I always felt, were very tight.
00:12:47
This is Susan Berman's friend, Kim Lankford. She was very protective of Bobby. Susan lived in a slightly run-down cottage in L.A.'s Benedict Canyon,
00:13:01
and occasionally Bob would stop by, but soon he'd be gone again, sometimes flying back to Trinidad where he'd question his shuttle driver, Ross Vitale.
00:13:12
He would kind of specifically ask questions about, has the sheriff's department been out here? You seen anything going on?
00:13:20
And in 1997, while Bob lived here, something did happen. A local teenager named Karen Mitchell vanished after leaving a women's shoe store
00:13:30
that later Bob was known to frequent. By the year 2000, the case was cold. But that, of course, is when across the country in New York,
00:13:41
another case was suddenly hot again. The investigation into the disappearance of Bob's wife, Kathy,
00:13:47
reopened by Westchester County DA Janine Pirro, who later became a TV host on Fox News Channel.
00:13:54
I had an instinct. Everything about this reeked of murder. We had evidence that she was battered by him,
00:14:01
which she has since confirmed. It was clear to me that he killed her. The investigation was supposed to be top secret.
00:14:09
But as we know, Bob Durst found out. Yeah, he seemed worried. He did. And then one of Kathy's friends, you've met her, Ellen Strauss, offered the cops a tip.
00:14:23
I begged the police to interview his best friend, Susan Berman. I showed them all my research.
00:14:30
I felt Susan Berman was the key. Always did. And the police did plan on interviewing Susan Berman.
00:14:38
The problem was, they just waited a little too long. Coming up, did Susan ever tell you that she was afraid of Robert?
00:14:52
She did tell me she was fearful of him. My first thought was, why didn't they listen to me?
00:14:58
What were they waiting for? Godot? When Dateline continues. By the autumn of 2000, Westchester County's reinvestigation of the missing millionaire's
00:15:17
wife, Kathy Durst, had been chugging quietly for months. When the story broke, Durst found himself in the media glare again.
00:15:25
It had been 18 years since Kathy disappeared. and public opinion, he wrote, turned against him unlike before.
00:15:34
In 1982, the tone of the publicity was of a scandal about a rich schmuck who had a terrible marriage.
00:15:41
People did not distance themselves from me because of it. In 2000, I was a murderer who everyone disliked.
00:15:49
Of course, Susan Berman had kept the bad press at bay back in 82, and now investigators wanted to talk to her.
00:15:57
And what did Bob do then? He got married. Not to Susan Berman, but to New York real estate broker Deborah Cheriton.
00:16:06
That wasn't a marriage made in heaven. That was clearly a marriage of convenience in that this is Bobby Durst saying,
00:16:14
in the event I'm arrested, I have someone to bail me out and to handle my affairs.
00:16:20
Well, of course, that's just an opinion. Maybe it was a love match. But it did come with spousal privilege, which meant Deborah didn't have to talk to the cops about her new wealthy husband.
00:16:32
She also reported he got access to a substantial share of his money. Deborah doesn't do anything unless Deborah benefits.
00:16:39
That's a character reference I'm not sure I'd want to have. She is a savvy businesswoman.
00:16:47
Meanwhile, out in Hollywood, Susan Berman was struggling to make it as a screenwriter.
00:16:53
Things weren't quite going as well as she would have liked with her career. For years, Susan had relied on Bob for help, and he responded, sometimes with big checks.
00:17:05
Two at least were $25,000. There was some macabre kind of kooky energy that went on between them.
00:17:15
We got some unique insight from a woman who claimed she was Susan Berman's closest confidant and therapist and psychic.
00:17:22
Her name is Barbara Stabiner, and she told us she knows what Susan was thinking.
00:17:27
In fact, she gave the police many hours of her recorded conversations with Susan,
00:17:33
in which, during those last months of 2000, according to Barbara, Susan grew increasingly worried.
00:17:40
Did Susan ever tell you that she was afraid of Robert? She did tell me she was fearful of him because I had the feeling she felt afraid of him because she was afraid he would withdraw any help But it was more than that said the psychic Susan was afraid of Bob she said because she knew too much
00:18:05
She knew his secrets. Towards the end of her life, she was very agitated with him.
00:18:13
Would he save her? Susan didn't know, said Barbara. And then, just before Christmas 2000, she said,
00:18:21
Susan let her know that Bob was on the way, with money. He said, I'll bring it. And that's what happened.
00:18:31
But I can't prove it. L.A. cops have long suspected Bob did go to Susan's house in L.A.,
00:18:38
but not to bring her more money, to prevent her from talking, ever. We do know from flight records and Bob's own personal account
00:18:47
that he did go to California. Christmas 2000, Robert Durst was on the move again.
00:18:53
In late December, he flew here to Eureka, California. He had owned a house in this area for several years, but had recently sold it.
00:19:03
He wasn't coming to stay here. He got a car, got inside it, pointed south. In Bob Durso's own personal account, he notes a visit to Garberville, 600 miles from Los Angeles.
00:19:16
After that, we can't follow his trail. We do know that late on December 22nd or early the 23rd,
00:19:24
Susan Berman was murdered by a bullet to the back of her head at her home in L.A.
00:19:28
And on the 23rd, flight records confirmed Bob took off from San Francisco on the Red Eye to New York.
00:19:36
And soon after, this letter, postmarked December 23rd, showed up at the Beverly Hills PD.
00:19:44
I call it the cadaver note. Oh yes, the famous note directing police to her body, a note likely written by her killer.
00:19:52
Word of Susan Berman's murder traveled fast. It was like, oh my God. I mean, and my first thought was, why didn't they listen to me?
00:20:03
They did not interview Susan Berman in a timely manner. What were they waiting for? Godot?
00:20:09
Bob skipped Susan Berman's memorial service, and a few weeks later he surfaced in Galveston, Texas.
00:20:17
Another good place to get lost. Except, of course, trouble eventually found him there.
00:20:24
A killing, a dismemberment, and an unforgettable acquittal. We all know the story, but not this version.
00:20:36
Coming up. Did Robert Durst rehearse telling the truth? His wife and friend smuggled a little cassette tape recorder into the jail.
00:20:46
He would then discuss with them whether or not he sounded believable with the story that he was telling.
00:20:51
At the end of the highway to Galveston, Texas, is a road sign. Mile zero, it says, this is where Bob Durst went to vanish.
00:21:14
He had actually moved here just weeks before Susan Berman's murder, and initially he was not a suspect.
00:21:19
but he took pains to keep himself hidden as he told his friends the Alderman's. Nobody would be looking for a Robert Thurston, a $300 a month apartment under an assumed name.
00:21:31
The name of an old high school classmate named Dorothy Siner. Although in his log he wrote he didn't like wearing a wig.
00:21:40
It itched, it got in my eyes unless it was on tight which made my head sweat. But the version Bob told over the years believes author Matt Birkbeck doesn't tell the real story.
00:21:54
Certainly not the famous killing of his elderly neighbor, Morris Black, or Bob's activities in Galveston than elsewhere.
00:22:02
It was really strange, you know, him in black palling around in Galveston amongst the homeless.
00:22:07
So what is a guy of his wealth and his family's influence doing, stealing identities?
00:22:16
In fact, in the spring of 2001, at the same time as he, as Dorothy Siner, was living in Galveston,
00:22:23
he rented another room in New Orleans under the name Diane Wynn. We found the place and his old landlord, Michael Ogden.
00:22:33
He was wearing a blouse with small brassiere, a wig. He lived on the top floor, and the neighbors often saw him wearing women's clothing.
00:22:44
He wasn't a drag queen. He was just in disguise. And then he'd fly off somewhere else, New York, California, Connecticut,
00:22:56
always returning, as he carefully noted in his personal account, to that down-market apartment in Galveston,
00:23:04
where, in September 2001, he shot Morris Black, accidentally and in self-defense, he claimed,
00:23:11
and then dismembered the man and threw his body parts into Galveston Bay. Here's how Durst described it.
00:23:19
Jack Daniels. Marijuana. Bought bow saw. Bow saw not deep enough. Returned for bigger bow saw. Could not use saw.
00:23:29
Went back, first looked at electric saws, bought axe, did it. But Matt Birkbeck believes Bob's claims about the killing were attempts after the fact
00:23:41
to sanitize what the evidence suggests was a brutal murder. It makes no sense. And if you look at the autopsy report, it shows that Morris had been beaten severely
00:23:51
in the upper torso and even perhaps suffered a heart attack. So obviously something else was going on.
00:24:00
After his arrest, Bob called his friends the Altmans and tried to explain what happened.
00:24:06
He said he went to the Fugue State. It was an out-of-body experience. It's hard to understand.
00:24:14
Charged with murder, Bob Durst also called his new wife, Deborah Cheriton, who helped arrange $300,000 in cash for bail,
00:24:23
which he promptly skipped, got a car and traveled the country, sometimes using Morris Black's ID.
00:24:32
It was weeks later when they finally caught him, shoplifting in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania.
00:24:39
Well, more than $38,000 in cash was in his car. The Altmans visited him in jail.
00:24:48
You know, I asked him how he was doing, and he said, you know, not great. he talked about how he pretty much was going to do maybe suicide by cop.
00:24:58
But Bob, of course, didn't pull that particular trigger and was sent back to Texas for trial,
00:25:04
where his Houston attorney, Dick DeGarren, devised the defense that beat the murder charge.
00:25:09
It was a simple case of a struggle over a gun, and the gun went off. If it truly was self-defense,
00:25:16
then what happened after the killing doesn't change that. Bob wasn't so confident he'd get off.
00:25:27
In fact, he asked his friends the Altmans to help him learn more about what life behind bars would be like for him.
00:25:34
He thought that if we got to know the ins and outs, that maybe it would be easy for him once he was on the inside.
00:25:41
He worried about how he'd hear his favorite music, for example. He was trying to find out if maybe there was a radio station he could buy,
00:25:49
so that if he were in jail, he could have music that he liked. Bob knew his chances of acquittal depended in large part on winning the jury's sympathy.
00:25:59
So for that, he went on a crash diet. Bob was trying to use every way within his power to look frail when he was on trial in Galveston.
00:26:10
He also went to considerable trouble to practice his testimony, as presiding judge Susan Chris learned later from recordings taped in the jail.
00:26:18
He had his wife and friend smuggled a little cassette tape recorder into the jail.
00:26:25
He would practice his testimony, sneak the tapes back to them, and then discuss with them whether or not he sounded believable with the story that he was telling.
00:26:36
Will the defendant please rise? The Altman said Bob was convinced, 99.9% certain, that he'd be convicted.
00:26:43
Will the jury find the defendant, Robert Durst, not guilty? The jury took five days to save him from 25 years to life in prison.
00:26:58
Though he later served a little time in federal prison for skipping bail and dismembering Morris Black.
00:27:04
But by 2005, he was a free man again. Now the only person who could catch Bob Durst was Bob Durst.
00:27:13
Coming up, caught off camera and seemingly off guard on the jinx, did Robert Durst confess?
00:27:23
Why did he give that interview? How do you be able to show he's not a horrible person?
00:27:29
When Dateline continues. Houston, 2010 The story of Robert Durst took a most unlikely turn.
00:27:48
The mess in Galveston long behind him, he had settled into this luxury high-rise.
00:27:53
Mark Thusen was the condo board president. Mr. Durst was mostly disheveled. It didn't look like his hair was capped.
00:28:01
It was messy. He looked like a street bomb. He was 67 by then and seemed to have done away with his cross-dressing.
00:28:12
Might have lived out his days in quiet if eccentric isolation. But then the Durst story went Hollywood.
00:28:20
A movie called All Good Things was released based on Robert Durst's life, played by Ryan Gosling.
00:28:30
It was directed by filmmaker Andrew Jarecki. Bob liked that movie and that why he got involved with Jarecki I think It was to offer his side of the story that Bob sat for two long interviews with Jarecki for what would eventually become the HBO series called The Jinx
00:28:48
I begged him not to do it. I begged him not to do it. Why he did it, only Bob knows.
00:28:54
What did he think he would get out of it? How did he be able to show that he's not a monster, he's not a horrible person?
00:29:02
Bob watched The Jinx at the same time as everybody else did. And according to Jarecki, the filmmakers had given evidence to the authorities two years before the show aired.
00:29:14
Which to Bob's attorney, Dick DeGarren, meant the show was far from objective reporting.
00:29:20
They edited probably 50 or more hours down into a few minutes. And I think the editing job was designed to make him look bad.
00:29:30
but it was a simple comparison of handwriting samples that on its own seemed to condemn Robert Durst.
00:29:37
It was episode 5 of the Jinx series in which a letter he admitted sending to Susan Berman
00:29:43
was compared to the infamous cadaver note her presumed killer sent the cops. Soon after seeing that episode
00:29:52
Bob packed up and left Houston but the cops were monitoring his cell phone and eventually tracked him to the J.W. Marriott Hotel in New Orleans.
00:30:03
So now two FBI agents show up at the hotel and they're talking to the clerk. Well, do you have anyone booked here under the name of Dorothy Siner?
00:30:14
No. They go through ten other aliases. No. No. No. Damn. Where is he? They turn around and there's Bob walking in the lobby headed for the elevators.
00:30:31
Later, they accompanied him to his room. And ultimately they turn up cash, a gun and some pot.
00:30:40
So Bob Durst was booked for possession of a handgun and marijuana in Louisiana and also arrested for the murder of Susan Berman in Los Angeles.
00:30:50
And the very next day, the final episode of The Jinx aired, featuring the now infamous off-camera bathroom...
00:31:00
What was it? A confession? I killed him all. Of course. Few people knew this then.
00:31:18
The documentary edited Durst's hot mic moment manipulating two sentences together
00:31:23
that were not actually spoken as one. Durst's friend certainly had no idea. What did you think of what you saw?
00:31:31
Oh, God. I just looked at Stuart and he looked at me and we were speechless for a really long time
00:31:37
and then I burst into tears because it just, like, it was like a knife. after his arrest a package arrived for him at that new orleans hotel the police opened it
00:31:50
there were a pair of shoes in it and 117 000 in cash so he was definitely getting ready for
00:31:59
something pair of shoes and money that's that's kind of what you need isn't it that's right
00:32:04
and attorney degeron stepped in again this time he acknowledged because of bob's trip to new
00:32:11
Orleans. Getting him out of jail might not be so easy. I acknowledged early on the chance of him
00:32:18
making bail right now. The chances are slim and none, and Slim just left town. Robert Durst pleaded
00:32:26
guilty to illegal gun possession. He was sentenced to seven years in federal prison.
00:32:34
But as for the Susan Berman case, attorney Dick DeGarren insisted Bob had nothing to do with her
00:32:39
murder. The trial got underway in March 2020, but was postponed because of the coronavirus pandemic.
00:32:48
It resumed 14 months later, with DeGuerrand continuing his battle against a tough deputy
00:32:54
DA named John Lewin. A frail Robert Durst testified from his wheelchair, and under questioning by Lewin, made this stunning admission.
00:33:09
hypothetical. I did not kill Susan Berman. But if I had, I would lie about it. In September 2021 a jury found Robert Durst guilty of first murder He was sentenced to life without parole
00:33:29
Two months later, a grand jury in New York indicted him for the death of his first wife, Kathleen Durst.
00:33:36
But a jury would never hear that case. In January 2022, Robert Durst died in a California hospital while serving his life sentence.
00:33:47
He was 78. And in a final twist, John Lewin, the prosecutor in the Berman case, said that because Durst was appealing that verdict at the time of his death under California law,
00:34:01
his conviction will be vacated. Robert Durst may be gone, but the mysteries remain.
00:34:13
Coming up, a missing teenager. Karen, where are you? Investigators wonder, is there a link?
00:34:25
Robert Durst is a person of interest in this case. Of all the places Robert Durst wandered, this was not just a favorite,
00:34:44
but now the setting of a lingering mystery, California's lost coast. In 1997, a pretty teenager named Karen Mitchell was helping out at her Aunt Annie Casper's shoe store.
00:34:58
I did not ever meet Robert Durst, but my manager, she said she remembered him because he just dressed as a woman.
00:35:09
Karen might well have met Robert Durst, said Aunt Annie. She often helped Eureka's homeless population, people among whom Bob was known to mingle.
00:35:19
We can't know for sure, but we do know she was in Bob's neighborhood more than once.
00:35:26
Karen used to go to Trinidad on the bus. I mean, they could have met. It's definitely a possibility.
00:35:32
She liked unusual people. She liked to pick their brain and talk to them. The day she vanished, Karen left the shoe store to walk to her job at a nearby daycare center,
00:35:45
where she'd arranged to have Annie pick her up after work. and as I came down, I had this weird feeling like something was off.
00:35:53
It was. Karen never made it to work. Her mother, Mary Casper, lived in Los Angeles.
00:36:00
No forgetting what that phone call was like. We drove from Southern California up here,
00:36:07
and I remember hanging flyers at the rest stops with my daughter. I'd just be like, this is not happening right now.
00:36:16
How could this be? Karen, where are you? A massive search produced no sign of her, though there was one curious lead.
00:36:29
A witness who said he saw a young woman get into a car with an older man on this busy Eureka Road.
00:36:37
The witness worked with a police artist to produce this, but nothing much came of it, at least not back then.
00:36:43
Years passed, and then Matt Birkbeck, who authored a book on Durst called A Deadly Secret,
00:36:49
got a tip from some independent investigators also working the case, a possible connection.
00:36:56
There were credit card records that placed Durst in the Eureka area the day that this girl disappeared.
00:37:02
The transaction was just up the coast in Trinidad, maybe 20 minutes or so by car,
00:37:07
from that spot where the witness saw a girl picked up on the road in Eureka. And then, before the trial in Galveston,
00:37:16
Birkbeck heard this. I have a really good source that was close to the defense team.
00:37:21
And I was told that Durst, he was extremely concerned about Karen Mitchell and was so concerned, he thought he was going to get charged.
00:37:27
Durst brought this up on his own with his defense attorney? Yes. And Dick DeGarren apparently said to him,
00:37:32
Bobby, let's worry about one case at a time. Not true, said Dick DeGarren. I've never had any concern about it.
00:37:39
Did Bob? No. But when Durst was arrested in New Orleans, the case was reborn. Andy Mills was the Eureka police chief at the time.
00:37:52
Robert Durst is a person of interest in this case. He's definitely in the mix. He is in the mix.
00:37:57
Someone that we will consider as part of our larger investigation The chief was not alone The FBI and the Humboldt County DA were investigating a possible Bob Durst connection too However Durst was not the only person of interest
00:38:14
There were five others. The evidence, the circumstantial evidence, is just not there
00:38:20
at this point. That old composite sketch, for example, could this be Robert Durst? The chief
00:38:27
isn't quite sure it's particularly accurate. Looks very similar. Were you impressed by the similarities?
00:38:34
I'm impressed by the similarities, but my questions are being able to recognize somebody
00:38:39
in a very small space and window and then being able to recount that in a description
00:38:45
that's pretty precise. That sketch? Ridiculous, said Durst's attorney, Dick DeGarren.
00:38:52
I know Bob pretty well. That doesn't look anything like him. It looks like Mr. Potato Head.
00:38:57
So, who was that witness of 18 years ago? Would he still remember? The cops hadn't spoken to him recently, so we found him.
00:39:08
Riding his tractor in the green hills above Eureka. Randy Gomes, an army vet and local carpenter.
00:39:17
Did he remember? I looked right at him because I was yelling at him. Yelling at him because that guy cut him off
00:39:24
when he stopped his car to pick up a teenage girl. You know, and I eyeballed him all the way around as I was coming around the car.
00:39:33
Gomes insisted the girl got into the car willingly as if she knew the man. So now, 18 years later, we showed Gomes his sketch and a picture of Robert Durst.
00:39:44
What is your gut reaction when you see those two photographs together? I believe that's the man that I saw.
00:39:51
So how sure are you you got it right? I'm positive. In my heart, I know I have it right.
00:39:56
and Gomes was fairly certain he said the girl who got in the car looked like a photo the police showed him
00:40:03
of Karen Mitchell but it was her because she we made eye contact but issues there's no proof
00:40:15
that it was Karen Mitchell who got into the car and Bob Durs' eyes were not blue
00:40:22
and said Chief Mills Gomes didn't come forward till months after the incident. What we don't want to do is just take something that's, you know, sensational
00:40:33
and plug that person into the midst of an investigation that may or may not have anything to do with him.
00:40:39
But the investigation continues. And some, like Birkbeck, believe there may be more.
00:40:46
I've never said definitively that he was a serial killer. What I said was that there's so much out there about him
00:40:53
that clearly there's something going on here and that law enforcement needs to look into it.
00:40:59
And thankfully, they are doing it now. Waste of time, said Dick DeGarren. Well, there's no evidence.
00:41:08
And to think, you know, they have to have a theory that he's some kind of serial killer.
00:41:14
He's not a serial killer. But the notion of Robert Durst as a serial killer has come up.
00:41:19
It sells magazines. It sells books. that causes people to turn on their TVs. A long-missing wife, a dismembered neighbor, a murdered friend.
00:41:33
This is how Robert Durst is defined now. Where did it all go wrong? All that power, privilege, money?
00:41:42
It's been decades since the doctor warned Bob's hostility issues could lead to personality decomposition.
00:41:49
Is that what happened? To his friends Emily and Stuart Altman Bobby Durst was a good person
00:41:59
and loyal friend for more than 40 years Though Emily, painful as it was worried that Bobby Durst may have been
00:42:10
the friend she never knew after all I can't understand harming a human being, okay?
00:42:18
Doesn't make sense to me I don't know if I could forgive that and I wish I could
00:42:24
and I'm struggling with that I don't know I don't know That's all for now I'm Lester Holt
00:42:37
Thanks for joining us