00:00:00
My mother called and says, Michelle's dead. How is that possible? A young mother found brutally murdered.
00:00:11
Her little girl left to wander in her mother's blood. Police had a suspect, and they say he had a motive.
00:00:18
We had an intimate relationship. We ended up having sex. But could they prove he was the killer?
00:00:25
It was a circumstantial case. Except for that witness, the girl who left those footprints.
00:00:31
We will never know what Cassidy saw and what she didn't see. Maybe she couldn't tell detectives who the killer was, but maybe she didn't have to.
00:00:41
The fact that Cassidy was spared, would that mean anything to a jury? The person that killed the mother cared about Cassidy.
00:00:49
And now, a stunning twist in the case. I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline. Here's Keith Morrison with Silent Witness.
00:01:01
I think I paused for a second. I had to take a deep breath. And just the reality of what was going on sank in.
00:01:10
Those who saw the footprints will not forget them. They were tiny. And they were bloody.
00:01:18
I had to get my composure to finish searching this house to make sure there was nobody else in the house.
00:01:24
It was the 3rd of November 2006, early afternoon. Deputy Scott Earp of the Wake County Sheriff's Department had been dispatched to a quiet and leafy neighborhood called Enchanted Oaks, the outskirts of Raleigh, North Carolina.
00:01:38
Here because of the 911 call from this place, on Birchleaf Drive. I think my sister's dead.
00:01:44
Here, tell me what happened, ma'am. I have no idea. Oh my God. The caller was Meredith Fisher.
00:01:49
her. She had just discovered, on the floor of the master bedroom, the savagely beaten
00:01:54
body of her elder sister, 29-year-old Michelle Young, a woman who, in death, was about to
00:02:01
be famous. Listen to me, ma'am. I'm going to tell you what to do, but you need to come down so we
00:02:06
can help her. You said there's blood everywhere? Yes. Listen to me, ma'am. I'm listening.
00:02:10
Is she breathing? I don't think so. Have you checked? Michelle, she's cold. Okay.
00:02:19
As she spoke, Meredith was cradling her two-and-a-half-year-old niece, Cassidy, who had crawled out from under the bedclothes on her parents' bed, just feet from where her mother lay.
00:02:28
Cassidy's voice, chattering to her aunt, was caught in the recorded call. Had Cassidy witnessed the murder? Awakened, alone, to find this?
00:02:41
You know, you just picture a small child walking around in his blood and tracking it across the hallway over into the bathroom.
00:02:50
By now, Wake County investigators were descending on the house, and having secured the crime scene, Earp's job was done.
00:02:57
But on his way out, he saw Cassidy again. She was still in her pink pajamas, still in Meredith's arms.
00:03:05
He asked Meredith a question. I looked over the child. I didn't see any blood, so I asked her,
00:03:10
did you clean the child? And her response was no. I thought it was kind of odd, because I was expecting her to say yes, I guess.
00:03:17
Somebody did. Yeah, somebody did. But who? Was it the same person who murdered the little girl's mother?
00:03:25
On this November day, all they had were questions. Sergeant Richard Spivey of the Wake County Sheriff's Office probably knows the case better than anyone.
00:03:34
I mean, this was just a brutal, vicious beating. There was a lot of time and energy invested into this assault.
00:03:41
Why do you say a lot of time and energy? I think the medical examiner told us there was over 30 blows with some sort of a blunt object.
00:03:50
So detectives started investigating the victim and everyone else around her. Michelle Young was born and raised on Long Island, New York.
00:04:01
She was smiling all the time, and she was the life of the party. Stacia Grossman knew her from childhood.
00:04:07
She didn't like being the center of attention, but she liked creating a great atmosphere for everyone to have a good time.
00:04:13
Michelle was a cheerleader in high school and a straight-A student. Jennifer Powers felt drawn to her.
00:04:20
She had this kind of bookworm assigned to her where she was very studious and goal-oriented.
00:04:26
I mean, she was also just a great person to be around, a fun, happy spirit, and someone that I wanted to spend a lot of time with.
00:04:35
Lots of people did. And when she chose a college far from home, North Carolina State,
00:04:40
She was soon surrounded again by an admiring group of women friends, best friends, buddies.
00:04:46
Fiona Childs was her sorority big sister. There's this one picture, and it's like it just came out beautiful,
00:04:54
and we liked it because we thought we kind of looked like Charlie's Angels pose without intentionally doing that.
00:05:02
It was sometime in 2001 when friends started hearing about Michelle's new guy. A fellow student named Jason Young heard how he'd grown up in the North Carolina mountains,
00:05:11
how he loved to camp, how he was a life of tailgate parties. Michelle fell hard and fast.
00:05:18
They seemed like a good couple. He was different from other men that she dated in the past.
00:05:23
He wasn't as serious about a career as she was. He was a little bit less sophisticated than Michelle was, but she seemed to be very happy with him.
00:05:31
Michelle and Jason married in October 2003. The day after the wedding, they shared their big secret.
00:05:40
Michelle was pregnant. Their daughter Cassidy was born early the next year. I love you, Mommy.
00:05:47
I love you too, Cassidy. And when she came along, it was love at first sight. I love you Mommy Oh oh Yay Michelle was an enthusiastic mother Huh Huh Huh Huh
00:06:07
By all accounts, Jason was a good dad. He was a great playmate. He knew how to sit on the floor and play with his daughter, you know.
00:06:18
The Youngs moved into the big fine house on Birchleaf in 2005. Both of them worked.
00:06:24
He a salesman. She a financial specialist. In the summer of 2006, Michelle got pregnant again.
00:06:31
They kept the news to themselves, but it was clear something good was happening.
00:06:36
The comment he said to me was, he's excited to have another baby. Not implying that she was pregnant, but that he was excited at the prospect of it.
00:06:46
But just a few months later, Michelle was dead. Jason was 170 miles away in Virginia on a business trip the night of the murder.
00:06:55
He heard the news the next afternoon and returned to Raleigh. Stacia Grossman got word from her mother.
00:07:01
My mother called and says, Michelle's dead. And I said, Michelle who? Some celebrity? Like, what are you talking about?
00:07:10
Like, what do you mean? Like, how is that possible? What happened? The very questions that Wake County investigators were asking themselves.
00:07:19
When we come back, a security camera provides a critical clue. It's not what it caught on tape, it's what it missed.
00:07:27
And why? There was a camera there that had been unplugged. Who had something to hide?
00:07:46
The facts were stark and ugly. One night in November 2006, while her husband was away on business,
00:07:52
Michelle Young was attacked in her own bedroom and brutally beaten to death. Her body discovered the next day by her sister, Meredith,
00:08:00
along with her two-and-a-half-year-old daughter, Cassidy, who'd been left to wander in her blood.
00:08:06
For the investigators who set out to find her killer, no way to get those little footprints out of their minds.
00:08:12
Sergeant Richard Spivey, lead investigator. Those of us that work in law enforcement, this is our profession, but we're also parents.
00:08:20
That certainly strikes a different note with you when you see something like that.
00:08:25
Michelle's husband, Jason, a medical software salesman, was 170 miles away the night of the murder.
00:08:30
Even so, investigators had to look at him. We know that he was the last person to talk to Michelle that night,
00:08:37
and he was also the reason why she was found. He called Meredith Fisher to go to the house.
00:08:42
Jason Young's business trip that night was routine. Security tape showed him getting gas about 7.30 p.m. as he left Raleigh.
00:08:51
Two hours later, he was seen on tape at a Cracker Barrel restaurant in Greensboro.
00:08:55
Later, he checked into this Hampton Inn in Hillsville, Virginia. This is him, front desk, about 11 p.m.
00:09:01
And him again at midnight. He also made a phone call around midnight, and that was the last time anybody heard from Jason Young
00:09:10
Until he made another call at 7.40 the next morning. A normal person would look at this and say,
00:09:15
he was 170 miles away. He's got an alibi. That sounds like a great distance, you know.
00:09:22
But 170 miles you can get between the crime scene and the hotel in about two and a half hours.
00:09:29
Perhaps, but there were curious anomalies at the crime scene. Couldn't explain them.
00:09:34
A jewelry box was missing two drawers. So was it a bungled burglary? Then there were footprints near the body that seemed to eliminate Jason.
00:09:43
An obvious print on a pillow was a size 10th, but Jason wore a size 12th. But this was weird. There was another partial footprint.
00:09:52
It defied easy identification, so they began calling in shoe experts. And now they wondered, were there two attackers?
00:10:01
Of course, investigators discovered early on that Michelle and Jason's marriage was strained.
00:10:05
and in the last weeks of Michelle's life, things were not good. At our friend Shelly's wedding, he was so drunk.
00:10:13
I'm just really out of it. When we got to the wedding, our friends were letting us know
00:10:22
that Michelle and Jason were fighting and they were referring to it as World War III.
00:10:30
Jennifer Powers told investigators about another fight that October. Michelle wanted her mother to stay with them for the holidays.
00:10:37
And Jason, who had a tense relationship with his mother-in-law, wanted to limit her stay.
00:10:43
And said so in an email, along with another nugget. He wrote, Our marriage has seen better days, and I don't see it trending up.
00:10:51
And I remember that really striking a chord with me, because I didn't know that their marriage had seen better days.
00:10:58
So, of course, investigators wanted to interview Jason Young. maybe he could tell them something.
00:11:05
But he refused to talk to them. He talked to the lawyer and then under the advice of counsel
00:11:14
he declined to speak with us at all. Didn't ask about it? Didn't ask how his wife died?
00:11:19
No. Perhaps, investigators thought, that business trip deserved a second look. So they went to the hotel,
00:11:28
poked around, and discovered some odd activities that night in a stairwell near an exit.
00:11:34
There was a camera there that had been unplugged. Really? Yes. It was one of the side exits of the hotel.
00:11:41
One of the, like I said, the fire stairs that go down to the first floor. Was there any other tampering down there?
00:11:47
Well, the door that was adjacent to where this camera was located, that door also had been propped open that night.
00:11:54
How do you know that? And the gentleman that was working as the clerk that night found a rock that had been placed in the door to keep the door from closing Well then they plugged the camera back in so it now working again
00:12:07
And at about 6.35 that morning, suddenly that camera's pointing straight at the ceiling.
00:12:13
Same camera? Same camera. And it's tampered with yet again. If that was Jason Young's work, is it possible he did make the 340-mile round trip?
00:12:24
Could he have killed his wife and cleaned up his daughter all in seven and a half hours without ever being seen?
00:12:31
To find out, investigators played a hunch. They visited every gas station along the route, showed Jason's photo, talked to the night clerks,
00:12:40
and came across a woman named Gracie Doms in a tiny place called King, North Carolina.
00:12:48
She took one look at that photograph and recognized it instantly. He was the foul-mouthed customer, she said, who came storming into the store to complain that the pumps were locked.
00:13:00
And what time was it? 5.30 a.m., morning of the murder. There was actually an altercation between the two of them.
00:13:08
So you have a reason why she would remember him as opposed to any other customer that may have just happened into the store.
00:13:15
If that attendant was right, investigators may have undercut Jason's alibi. Still, it wasn't enough.
00:13:23
So they plotted ahead. Painstaking work took time. And then, years after the murder, they finally got a match for that partial footprint.
00:13:34
The State Bureau of Investigation and the FBI were able to eventually identify that shoe
00:13:38
as a hush puppy orbital shoe. And it was a size 12, which was the same size that he wore.
00:13:44
Throughout the investigation, Jason steadfastly maintained his silence. And rather than face a legal battle where he'd be asked some tough questions, Spivey said,
00:13:54
he even gave Michelle's family custody of his daughter. Everyone that we spoke with, all of them talked about how much he loved Cassidy
00:14:01
and what a great dad he was to just turn over primary custody. That was very surprising.
00:14:08
Investigators had heard enough. They believed they had a case, circumstantial, but a case.
00:14:15
And three years after Michelle Young's body was found on the bedroom floor, Jason Young was charged with her murder.
00:14:24
Investigators and prosecutors knew that very little pointed directly toward Jason Young,
00:14:30
but so far, nothing pointed away. Coming up, the case against Jason Young as an alleged killer and as a cheating husband.
00:14:42
We had an intimate relationship for the two days that he was there. He ended up having sex.
00:14:48
He never settled down. When Dateline continues. Jason Young went on trial for the murder of his pregnant wife, Michelle, in June 2011.
00:15:09
By then, he'd spent 18 months in a jail cell. The guy who lived for tailgates, the guy who loved to party, that guy was long gone.
00:15:17
Prosecutor Becky Holt opened for the state. The defendant had a plan. His plan was to murder his wife. His plan was to get away with it.
00:15:27
With no murder weapon found, the prosecution's case was built on that partial shoe print.
00:15:32
They knew now that Jason once owned a pair of hush puppies like these that matched the print.
00:15:37
They were now missing. They also told jurors about that early morning visit to the gas station and the suspicious activity at the hotel.
00:15:44
But the thrust of their case was this. Jason Young was trying in the most violent possible way to get out of a troubled marriage.
00:15:52
Were you aware of tensions in that marriage? Yeah, I was well aware. Meredith Fisher, Michelle's sister, lived near the couple and for a period was Cassidy's nanny.
00:16:05
As the young's fights intensified, she took on the role of a marriage counselor, too.
00:16:10
What would you say were the main issues? Michelle's main issues were Jason being more responsible, understanding her more,
00:16:19
and his main concern was their lack of sex life. Prosecutors called friends to the stand to paint a picture of a marriage that was unraveling,
00:16:29
out loud and in public. Jason made it very well known that, you know, he was upset about the lack of sex in the relationship.
00:16:39
And at parties, said Fiona Childs, Jason's X-rated tricks were famously over the top.
00:16:45
I never observed it myself. I would just hear about it and, you know, he would expose himself and do what he thought was these funny tricks.
00:16:55
And I was always just rather embarrassed for Michelle. He never settled down. It was as if he was still living the single life.
00:17:04
He never bought into the marriage and what all that meant. In October 2006, when Michelle was four months pregnant,
00:17:13
Jason became deeply involved with another woman. And not just any woman. Michelle Money was one of Michelle Young's close friends from college,
00:17:26
one of those Charlie's Angels. In early October, days before his third wedding anniversary,
00:17:32
Jason flew to Florida to see Michelle Money. She testified they both knew it was wrong.
00:17:38
We basically just hung out at the house, and we had an intimate relationship for the two days that he was there.
00:17:48
Jason was crazy about her, his friend Josh Olton said. He basically told me that he thought he was in love with her.
00:17:54
Michelle mother Linda Fisher testified that in the final weeks of Michelle life she could see the toll the failing marriage was taking on her pregnant daughter She had her head on my lap and she was lying out and I was stroking her hair and she was empty
00:18:24
And what did she tell you? Things weren't working out with Jason. Two days before she was murdered, Michelle phoned her sister Meredith to report yet another blow-up with Jason.
00:18:35
She was just, I've had it. She said that, you know, more than one time. I just, I can't do this anymore.
00:18:44
Jason was telling one of his close friends the same thing. And prosecutors said just days before Michelle was murdered,
00:18:52
he indulged in one last transgression. A casual hookup with an old friend named Carol Ann Sowerby
00:18:59
in his own living room. Michelle was away at the time. Cassidy was put down to bed
00:19:06
and had a couple drinks, just were talking. We ended up having sex. But divorce was apparently not an option for Jason.
00:19:29
He had made a statement at one time that he was afraid that if he ever got a divorce,
00:19:34
that Michelle would take Cassidy and move back to New York. And did he indicate to you that he would have some concerns about ever being able to see Cassidy again?
00:19:41
Correct. Still, one big question remained. Was a good-time guy like Jason Young even capable of murder?
00:19:50
Genevieve Cargo was engaged to Jason in 1999, before he met Michelle. And she took the stand to testify about a fight they'd had over Jason's excessive drinking.
00:20:01
He became agitated. He said something to the effect of, if I'm going to make such a terrible husband, then give me my ring back.
00:20:10
Did you give it to the defendant? No. He began trying to pull the ring off and it wouldn't come off.
00:20:18
He was throwing me from one bed to the other and jumping on me with all his weight
00:20:23
and pinning my arms, both of them, behind me. Prosecutors hoped to convince the jury it all added up to a motive for murder.
00:20:33
So how would the defense counterattack? With a witness who could refute every charge.
00:20:39
Coming up... Jason Young finally breaks his silence as he takes the stand to testify.
00:20:48
Did you kill your wife, Michelle? No, sir. Were you there when it happened? No, sir.
00:21:05
What the prosecution didn't tell you... There's an art to the business of criminal defense.
00:21:11
And it would take a true artist to repaint the prosecution's dark portrait of Jason Young.
00:21:17
So, what could defense attorney Mike Klinkeson do? Well, to begin with, as he told the jury, he agreed with the prosecution.
00:21:26
Jason Young was not a good husband. He acted at times like an immature jerk. But that does not make him a killer.
00:21:35
The defense was not about to make any more concessions, mind you. That jewelry box in the bedroom, there was DNA on it.
00:21:42
Didn't match either Michelle or Jason. The suspicious activity at the hotel? There was a fingerprint on that camera, and it wasn't Jason Young's.
00:21:52
And there wasn't any forensic evidence that tied Jason to the crime scene. And there was no blood in his car.
00:21:59
It was not a scratch on him. Ladies and gentlemen, Jason Lynn Young did not murder his wife.
00:22:07
He did not murder their unborn son. And this case has not been solved. Who better to make that argument than Jason Young himself?
00:22:17
But so far, remember, he had never said a word to anyone about that November night and almost five years silence.
00:22:26
It's always a big decision for defense attorneys whether or not to call their clients.
00:22:30
Beth Karras is a former prosecutor and legal analyst. She covered the trial. This is a case that really begged for Jason Young to testify.
00:22:38
Finally, after all this time. Right, and if he's truly innocent, get on the stand and tell the story.
00:22:43
We call Jason Young. With his mother sitting in the front row, Jason Young prepared to do just that.
00:22:51
Defense attorney Brian Collins hit it hard off the top. Did you kill your wife, Michelle?
00:22:56
No, sir. Were you there when it happened? No, sir. But what about Jason's missing hush puppies that match the partial shoe print?
00:23:04
He no longer owned them, he said. Are those the shoes that you had on on November the 2nd?
00:23:09
No, sir. They were all ratty, he said. Told Michelle to give them to Goodwill. And as for the night of the murder, after he checked into the hotel, Jason testified,
00:23:19
he left his room twice, the first time to get a power cord for his laptop. I was going over the sales call that I had the next day.
00:23:29
The second trip, he testified, was to smoke a cigar. I had to go outside to smoke a cigar.
00:23:35
And I also wanted to look at some sports schedules and some standings, and so I wanted to see if I could pick up the USA Today as well.
00:23:45
That newspaper run explained why he was seen at the front desk he's at around midnight.
00:23:50
So between the time you smoked the cigar and went back upstairs and went to sleep,
00:23:55
did you leave that room until the next morning? No, sir. Next morning, after his sale...
00:24:00
Paul, Jason testified, he realized he'd left some eBay printouts sitting on the computer printer at home.
00:24:06
They showed purses. He was thinking of buying one for Michelle as a belated anniversary present.
00:24:12
And I realized I didn't bring those papers. Why was it important to you that somebody get those papers?
00:24:18
Because I wanted it to be a surprise. I was surprised that Michelle means so much more than anything.
00:24:24
So around noon, November 3rd, he called his sister-in-law, Meredith, from the car to ask if she'd go to the house.
00:24:30
and get those eBay papers. Friday, November 3rd. He left Meredith a voicemail. If you could give me a huge favor and go over there
00:24:38
and see if you can find it, see me on the computer. Then he headed to his mother's place in the mountains nearby.
00:24:45
And it was there he testified hours later that he learned Michelle had been murdered.
00:24:50
I just fell. I broke on the inside. I just broke and I didn't believe it. Family members drove him back to Raleigh.
00:25:04
During the drive, he said his friends called. Ryan and Josh had said that the investigators were asking really ugly questions
00:25:15
and pointing their finger at me and doing things like that. And they said, you don't need to talk to anybody.
00:25:20
You need to get a lawyer before you talk to anybody. And then the explanation for his long silence.
00:25:29
The lawyer that I got after talking with him, he actually advised me to not go talk to the police.
00:25:35
Did you take that advice? Yes, sir, I did. Did he also tell you not to talk to anybody about it?
00:25:41
That's actually exactly what he said. He said don't talk to anybody about anything.
00:25:45
The defense also addressed the motives prosecutors had laid out that Jason wanted to escape a bad marriage
00:25:51
and keep custody of Cassidy and spend time with his new love. Did you have any designs in your own mind of leaving Michelle Young for Michelle Monty?
00:26:03
No, sir. Describe why not. I think we both knew it was wrong. I don't think we either one dreamed that it would ever be found out.
00:26:16
Pushing me around. As for that violent episode with his ex-fiance, Jason had an explanation.
00:26:21
for it. Did you throw her around on the bed like she said? No, sir. What I did was wrong. I did pin
00:26:28
her down and I took the ring. Okay. What was your level of intoxication at that time? I was very
00:26:36
intoxicated, but I don't feel like that's an excuse for what I did. And they questioned him
00:26:41
about the most important woman in his life. Did you want to stay married to Michelle? Yes, I did.
00:26:47
I wanted to have another baby and I wanted the family to grow. He also explained why he gave up custody of his daughter without a fight.
00:26:57
Were you able to afford a lawyer for a full-blown custody battle? No, sir, I had due to the media and some of the internet website.
00:27:11
The job that I had, I lost it. His testimony lasted three hours. Jason Young was a very good witness.
00:27:20
He understood what he had to do when he was on the stand. So he didn't come off as contrived or phony,
00:27:28
like he had put this together very carefully in order to account for all the evidence that they had.
00:27:33
He had access to police reports, all the discovery. He knew the state's vulnerabilities,
00:27:41
and so he could arguably tailor his testimony to fit with an innocent explanation.
00:27:51
How did Jason Young do? Twelve jurors were about to decide. Coming up, the prosecutor gets her chance
00:28:00
to go one-on-one with Jason Young. And it isn't pretty. Were you working on your marriage?
00:28:06
When you were having sex with Caroline Sowerby in your home? When Dateline continues.
00:28:14
It was riveting almost five years of silence about his wife murder I went back to my room. Broken here in this courtroom.
00:28:33
I loved Cassidy and I loved Michelle. And that he went to murder his wife. Now prosecutor Becky Holt began pulling apart a story she had just heard for the first time.
00:28:43
Were you working on your marriage when you were having sex with Caroline Sowerby in your home?
00:28:48
less than two weeks before your wife was murdered? No, ma'am, that was not the way to work on a marriage.
00:28:55
That was very detrimental. Were you working on your marriage when you called Michelle Money?
00:29:00
Michelle and I confided a lot in each other, and we talked about my issues with my wife,
00:29:07
and she talked about her issues with her husband. So is the answer yes when you had an affair with Michelle Money
00:29:14
that you were working on your marriage? No, ma'am. Having the sexual intercourse and having the intimacy was very detrimental to that.
00:29:22
The cross-examination lasted a full hour, and the next day, the case went to the jury.
00:29:27
Retired to the jury deliberation room. It soon became clear jurors were having trouble.
00:29:33
I've indicated that y'all have not yet reached a unanimous decision. The jurors were split six to six.
00:29:39
The judge sent them back to try to make it unanimous. Watch everybody else remain. Let the jurors leave first. Thank you.
00:29:43
But hours later, they were back, and courtroom 3C was still. It appears that they are hopelessly deadlocked at this point.
00:29:54
Eight jurors had voted for acquittal. Four voted guilty. Judge Stevens declared a mistrial.
00:30:01
Was serious consideration given to dropping the case? I think there was serious consideration as to, is there more we can do?
00:30:10
So the prosecutors decided they would try again, but this time with the one thing they didn't have the first time, Jason's own story.
00:30:21
The second trial began in February 2012. This time, Howard Cummings led the prosecution, hoping to use Jason's own words to convict him.
00:30:30
Put your left hand on the Bible and raise your right hand. But first, prosecutors called that night clerk at the gas station, Gracie,
00:30:37
who remembered Jason complaining about the locked pumps. When he came in to pay, he started cussing and raising cane.
00:30:47
And what time did this happen? That was about 5, 5.30 in the morning. A time when Jason said he was at the hotel.
00:30:55
20 next witness. Then prosecutors had new witnesses and new testimony. They wanted jurors to hear about Cassidy, whose bloody footprints they contended made her a silent witness to murder.
00:31:08
When I got to Cassidy, I said, what are you doing? Daycare worker Ashley Pometier took the stand.
00:31:14
I noticed what she was doing. She told jurors she watched Cassidy playing alone, days after her mother was murdered.
00:31:21
She had the chair and the doll in her hand together, and then the mommy doll in the other hand.
00:31:27
and she just hit him. As unsettling as it was, the prosecutors wanted jurors to know
00:31:35
the killer had left a silent witness behind, a witness he would never harm. The fact that Cassidy was spared,
00:31:45
did that mean anything to you or would that mean anything to a jury? Certainly. It meant that the person that killed the mother,
00:31:53
we felt, cared about Cassidy. I do. Thank you. Fiona Childs took the stand. Prosecutors pressed her about a life insurance policy Jason arranged.
00:32:03
It did raise a red flag to me. And Michelle had questioned. That she brought up specifically her life insurance.
00:32:10
She brought it up several times asking me, didn't I think that a million dollars was too much and did they really need that?
00:32:17
After Michelle died, Fiona found out the true amount of the policy was actually four million dollars.
00:32:22
I was just, like, in total shock. Like, that is incredibly excessive. And prosecutors also told the jury about civil lawsuits against Jason brought by Michelle's mother and sister.
00:32:36
One was a wrongful death case filed in 2008, a year before he was charged with murder.
00:32:41
Over the defense objection court clerk Lauren Freeman testified about that lawsuit There is an alleged paragraph paragraph 6 again reading verbatim from the record In the early morning hours of November 3rd 2006 Jason Young brutally murdered Michelle
00:32:58
Young at their residence. Freeman went on to testify that Jason never responded to the
00:33:03
allegations, and that led to a default judgment against him. That judgment said Jason killed his
00:33:10
wife. A default judgment does not mean the facts alleged in the civil complaint are true.
00:33:16
It does not mean he's guilty. And the judge at the criminal trial told the jury that and his
00:33:22
instructions. However, when you hear the statement, Jason Young brutally murdered his wife, but that
00:33:30
doesn't mean he's guilty, folks. Hello, you know. And the prosecutor made sure the jury heard just
00:33:38
who signed that ruling. I'm reading from this judgment, which is signed actually by Judge Stevens.
00:33:44
Judge Stevens, the very judge sitting before them in this trial. The jury hearing it, it's just something that's going to carry a lot of weight.
00:33:54
This is the complaint that was filed in December seeking custody of Cassidy. Prosecutors also called the attorney involved in that custody case over her daughter Cassidy.
00:34:05
and those same allegations were repeated yet again. The jury heard several times through these two civil complaints
00:34:14
that Jason Young brutally murdered Michelle Fisher Young. But the headline act came when prosecutors played Jason Young's entire testimony
00:34:24
from the first trial. I wanted her to have that. And began to rip it apart. I don't remember.
00:34:31
Prosecutors tried to show that Jason's call to Meredith to pick up those eBay printouts
00:34:36
was merely a ploy to get her to discover the body and find Cassidy. Why else would he print an eBay auction ad and leave it on the printer
00:34:44
and then hit the road where he couldn't bid during the actual auction? They called Sergeant Spivey to the stand.
00:34:51
That auction was going to end 8 o'clock p.m. Eastern Standard Time. And what day was that?
00:34:57
That was on November 2, 2006. just hours before the murder. Now prosecutors tried to prove Jason lied about his reasons for leaving the hotel room.
00:35:08
I didn't pull the door all the way to the room. In his original testimony, he told the court he left the first time to get a power cord for his laptop.
00:35:15
Why was it that you wanted to look on your laptop? I was going over the sales call that I had the next day.
00:35:22
But Special Agent Mike Smith took the stand to say Young didn't use his laptop for work that night.
00:35:29
It's an internet site dedicated to sports. Jason said he went out a second time to smoke a cigar.
00:35:37
But prosecutors contended Jason was a fierce anti-smoker. And the weather that night was freezing, windy.
00:35:45
Can you tell me whether or not there was ever any substantial outerwear that the defendant either had in his luggage or was wearing?
00:35:52
No, so there was, I think, a suit jacket. Okay. That was the only outerwear that I'm aware of.
00:35:59
Jason chose not to testify this time, but the defense fought back, of course. They argued the gas station attendant's memory couldn't be trusted because of a childhood brain injury.
00:36:09
I've had memory problems since I was six because I've been through a lot with myself and my kids and my ex-husband.
00:36:19
The defense also argued the case really wasn't solved, that there was no physical evidence to prove Jason was the killer.
00:36:26
that he would never have had time to make that trip and commit murder, that he didn't have the mindset of a killer.
00:36:34
And that cigar? They showed that Jason Young actually owned a humidor, and he'd once made a purchase at a cigar store.
00:36:41
You have ample evidence before you that Jason Young is not guilty. And then it was over again.
00:36:47
And time for another jury to consider whether Jason Young would go to jail or walk out of court a free man.
00:36:56
Coming up, the verdict, take two. With a jury by unanimous verdict, find the defendant, Jason Lynn Young, to be.
00:37:18
For more than five years Michelle Young family and friends had been waiting for answers
00:37:23
Who killed their pretty pregnant Michelle? Many thought they knew. It was him. You know, I didn't know all the evidence.
00:37:30
I didn't know half the things I know now, but I felt that way. One jury failed to decide.
00:37:36
And now attorneys were making their final arguments to a second jury. Be mad at him.
00:37:41
Hate him if you want to. But when you look at the physical evidence in this case, it does not match up.
00:37:47
It does not match up to Jason having killed his wife and unborn son. Thirty blows? That's not from a stranger.
00:37:57
That is a mad, mad domestic abuser. Soon that jury was behind closed doors in the Wake County Superior Court.
00:38:09
After two days, they were back. with a verdict. With a jury by unanimous verdict,
00:38:15
find the defendant Jason Lynn Young to be guilty of first-degree murder of Michelle Young.
00:38:19
Guilty. First-degree murder. Jason Young didn't flinch. Behind him, his mother was equally stoic.
00:38:27
On the other side of the court, Michelle Young's bereaved mother and sister wept.
00:38:33
Fiona, at home, got the news from a friend. She said he's guilty. I was like, what?
00:38:41
What? Jason Young received a life sentence. Chose not to address the court. Even as the bailiffs led him away, he remained expressionless.
00:38:55
The prosecutors were, they told us, relieved. It was very emotional to have family members there who you've been working with for five and a half years.
00:39:07
And they finally have justice, you know. You know, we've been telling them for years, just trust. Just trust that it'll be the right result.
00:39:17
But was it? A year and a half ticked by, and then this. Attorneys for Jason Young demanding a new trial, saying the trial that led to his conviction had significant errors.
00:39:29
December 2013, Jason Young's new attorney launched his appeal. Who is the killer? Is Jason Young the person responsible for Ms. Young's death?
00:39:41
And, you know, it seems fundamentally unfair. What was fundamentally unfair? Remember, during the trial the attorney pointed out,
00:39:49
the prosecution introduced testimony about those civil cases against Jason brought by Michelle's family.
00:39:56
They accused Jason of murder. Jason Young brutally murdered Michelle Young. The defendant brutally murdered Michelle Marie Fisher Young.
00:40:05
Way out of bounds, said the attorney. The jury should not have been allowed to hear about any of that.
00:40:11
Outside the court, Michelle's sister Meredith predicted the appeal would be thrown out.
00:40:15
And the jury came to the right verdict, and we're confident it'll stay. But she was wrong.
00:40:21
A Raleigh man is getting a third trial in the death of his pregnant wife. In April 2014, the judges ruled unanimously that testimony about those civil cases prejudiced the jury.
00:40:33
And they took particular exception to the fact the prosecutor was allowed to tell the jurors it was their trial judge who signed the civil judgment against Jason, which said that he killed his wife.
00:40:44
In fact, said the appeals court, introducing evidence about the civil cases was a violation of North Carolina law.
00:40:51
And that law says you cannot use a civil complaint, a civil allegation as proof in a criminal case.
00:40:58
But a year later, the state Supreme Court reversed the appeals court decision. And in 2017, Jason Young made yet another attempt to get a third trial.
00:41:07
This time on grounds his defense team was ineffective. It was also denied. I love you, Mommy.
00:41:13
I love you too, Cassidy. But children know little of the arcane world of motions and appeals.
00:41:19
For Cassidy, her father, her mother, are snatches of memory ever farther away. That's all for now. I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.