00:00:01
Jane, it's your kind of day out there. The Dateline team is gathering. Really? Tell me.
00:00:06
Low humidity, totally sunny, glorious. It's time for the morning meeting. They managed to get the daughter to basically turn against the mother.
00:00:15
It does appear to be random from what we know, but they did have an arrest in that case.
00:00:20
I think it's a great idea. Thanks for being on top of it. Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly.
00:00:26
I'm Andrea Canning. It's July 24th, and here's what's on our docket. In Colorado, surprising testimony at the trial of a dentist accused of poisoning his wife's protein shakes.
00:00:39
James said he ordered the potassium cyanide as part of a game of chicken that he had with Angela.
00:00:44
And 30 years after a double murder in a Wisconsin farmhouse, investigators uncover a personal connection between the victims and their alleged killer.
00:00:53
Prosecutors are saying that Tony killed Tana and her boyfriend Tim out of some kind of emotional breakdown that was brought on by this drunken rage.
00:01:03
But before all that, we're heading to a Boise courthouse for the sentencing of Brian Koberger
00:01:07
and the culmination of a case that has gripped the nation. Earlier this month, Brian Koberger caught everyone off guard by taking a plea deal,
00:01:18
admitting his guilt in the savage murders of four University of Idaho students in 2022.
00:01:24
Kaylee Gonzalez, Madison Mogan, Ethan Chapin, and Zanna Kornodel. The agreement allowed him to avoid a lengthy trial, the death penalty, and any explanation of his motive.
00:01:36
All right, this is the state of Idaho versus Brian Koberger, defendant as president in custody.
00:01:41
Koberger's sentencing took place on Wednesday, and it was the first time the families of the students Koberger stabbed to death had a chance to speak directly to him.
00:01:51
Their anguish and anger was on full display. This is Olivia, Kaylee Gonzalez's sister.
00:01:57
I won't stand here and give you what you want. I won't offer you tears. I won't offer you trembling.
00:02:03
Disappointments like you thrive on pain, on fear, and on the illusion of power. And I won't feed your beast.
00:02:11
Instead, I will call you what you are. Sociopath. Psychopath. Murderer. Dateline producer Shane Bishop, who has followed this case since day one, joins us now. Hey, Shane.
00:02:24
Hi, Andrea. So, Shane, set the scene in the courtroom for us. Who was there? Who was speaking? This was such a big day for so many people.
00:02:35
Yeah, I think the word I'd use would be a tinderbox. I mean, there was high emotion everywhere, obviously, after two and a half years of waiting for answers in this case.
00:02:42
People started lining up the day before for a chance to wait through the night for one of the very limited seats in the courtroom.
00:02:47
The two roommates who survived were the first people to talk. One of them, Bethany Funk, asked a friend to read her statement for her.
00:02:56
I woke up around seven with a terrible toothache, so I called my dad, who is a dentist. He told me
00:03:02
to take Advil, so I did, and I went back to sleep. This is the first time we've heard any explanation
00:03:07
why the roommates didn't call 911 earlier. The murder took place around 4.20 a.m. The 911
00:03:14
one call wasn't placed until noon. I was still out of it and still didn't know what happened.
00:03:20
If I had known, I of course would have called 911 right away. I still carry so much regret and guilt
00:03:26
for not knowing what had happened and not calling right away, even though I understand it wouldn't
00:03:32
have changed anything, not even if the paramedics had been right outside the door. And Bethany Funk
00:03:37
talked about the lasting impact that night has had on her. I slept in my parents' room for almost
00:03:44
a year. I made them double lock every door and still check everywhere in the room just in case
00:03:49
someone was hiding. And I still check my room every night and I double lock it. I have not slept
00:03:55
through a single night since this happened. I constantly wake up in panics, terrified.
00:04:00
Someone is breaking in or someone is here to hurt me, or I'm about to lose someone else that I love.
00:04:06
The fear never really leaves. um all right that is really hard to hear we also heard shane from the other roommate who survived
00:04:16
next is dylan mortenson she was in tears as she read her statement she came face to face with
00:04:21
coberger in that house um although she didn't mention that specifically did she no she didn't
00:04:28
and dylan's probably had the hardest road to hold the two survivors he actually spoke to her
00:04:33
after the murders. People call me strong. They say I'm a survivor. But they don't see what my new reality looks like.
00:04:42
They don't see the panic attacks, the hypervigilance, the exhaustion, the way I scan every room I enter,
00:04:50
the way I flinch at sudden sounds. They don't know how heavy it is to carry so much pain
00:04:57
and still be expected to keep going, and that's because of him. he still parts of me i may never get back
00:05:05
he stole that he took the version of me who didn't constantly ask what if it happens again
00:05:11
what if next time i don't survive it's just heartbreaking for a 19 20 year old kid you know yeah and we heard statement after
00:05:26
overstatement from family members. They had different things that they wanted to get across.
00:05:34
Steve Gonsalves, Kaylee's dad, is a really intense human being. Anybody who's followed the case knows
00:05:39
that. And throughout this case, he's been the most outspoken of all the victim's parents. And so there
00:05:44
was a lot of anticipation to see what he would do. And when his name was called, Steve got up and made
00:05:48
what I thought was a real power move. He turned the podium away from facing the judge and turned
00:05:53
straight to face the defendant to address him directly Today we are here to finish what you started Today you lost control
00:06:07
Today, we are here to prove to the world that you picked the wrong families. The wrong state, the wrong police officers, the wrong community. In time, you will be nothing
00:06:21
but two initials forgotten to the wind, no visitors, nothing more than initials on an
00:06:27
otherwise unmarked tombstone. In addition to Steve, Olivia, Kaylee's big sister,
00:06:34
called Kohlberger a loser among a lot of other things actually, and she did something brilliant
00:06:38
and very calculated, I thought. Back when Kohlberger was a graduate student pursuing
00:06:42
his master's degree at DeSales University before he moved west to Washington State,
00:06:47
he'd put out a research project asking criminals about their feelings and how they prepared for
00:06:52
their crimes and olivia gonsalves turned some of his own questions on coberger where is the murder
00:06:58
weapon the clothes you wore that night what did you bring into the house with you what was the
00:07:04
second weapon you used on kaylee what were kaylee's last words please describe in detail
00:07:13
the level of anxiety you must have felt when you heard the bear cat pull up to your family home
00:07:19
on December 30, 2022. If you were really smart, do you think you'd be here right now?
00:07:27
There is a name for your condition, though. Your inflated ego just didn't allow you to see it.
00:07:32
Wannabe. You act like no one could ever understand your mind, but the truth is you're basic.
00:07:39
No one is scared of you today. No one is intimidated by you. No one is impressed by you.
00:07:46
No one thinks that you are important. You want the truth? Here's the one you'll hate the most.
00:07:53
If you hadn't attacked them in their sleep, in the middle of the night, like a pedophile,
00:07:59
Kaylee would have kicked your ass. Thank you. Thank you. you know shane at times there was applause in the courtroom sobs very emotional but coberger
00:08:15
you know didn't share seemingly in any of that emotion looking very blank he looked directly at
00:08:23
those who were speaking the only time i saw him look around the courtroom was when the gallery
00:08:27
burst out in applause after olivia gonzalez's very pointed remarks to him otherwise his eyes
00:08:33
did not wander. And as far as speaking, when the judge asked him if he wanted to make any kind of
00:08:37
statement, he said only three words. I respectfully decline. There was no surprise when it came to the
00:08:43
sentencing, though, right? We knew what was going to happen. There wasn't. I believe that although
00:08:47
the judge wasn't bound by the plea deal, he did stick to it. And as part of that plea, Koberger
00:08:52
agreed to four consecutive life sentences and 10 years for burglary. So what happens to Brian
00:08:58
Koberger now, does he stay in Idaho? He's such a high-profile inmate. Well, there's really little doubt that he'll be sent to Idaho's toughest prison. It's called the
00:09:07
Maximum Security Institution. It houses death row. There are 400 men there. It houses, you know,
00:09:13
as the saying goes, those who don't play nice with others in prison. It's doubtful he'll have
00:09:18
any contact with anyone but staff for months. I don't have any information about protective custody,
00:09:22
but I'm sure he'll be pretty isolated. Let's come back to the motive. This is one of the
00:09:30
most disappointing parts for people is that they felt like if you're going to give him this plea
00:09:34
agreement, he should have had to give in some explanation of why he did what he did, which he
00:09:39
didn't. And he also didn't do it at the sentencing hearing. What are you hearing on that?
00:09:45
Well, Judge Hitler touched on this before he handed down the sentence. He said the crimes
00:09:48
may just be unexplainable. And by insisting we understand why he did this, we're giving
00:09:55
Kohlberger control. And it's time to end that. In my view, the time has now come to end Mr.
00:10:00
Kohlberger's 15 minutes of fame. It's time that he'd be consigned to the ignominy and isolation
00:10:07
of perpetual incarceration. I've been saying for a long time that we need to get comfortable with
00:10:11
the idea that we'll never know exactly why Kohlberger committed these crimes. I do believe
00:10:17
my sources who told me they believe Kohlberger wanted to be a famous serial killer. I mean,
00:10:21
don't they all want to be famous or infamous? The families, you know, they want to make sure
00:10:25
that their loved ones are not lost in all the, you know, the circus of this and all the speculation.
00:10:31
So many of the families said their last act to honor the victims they lost, the family members
00:10:36
they lost is simple, just to live. My true final act of love was to continue on without them,
00:10:42
for them. Of course, we wish all of the families and friends the best as they go forward and try
00:10:49
to heal from this. Thank you, Shane. Thanks, Andrea. Coming up, it's week two in the murder trial of Colorado dentist James Craig. We'll tell you what
00:11:03
the woman he was having an affair with had to say when she took the stand. As the prosecution's case against dentist James Craig unfolds in an Arapahoe County courtroom,
00:11:20
there has been no shortage of emotional witnesses and stunning details. Craig is accused of killing his wife Angela in March 2023 by poisoning her with potassium cyanide
00:11:32
and tetrahydrosoline, a common ingredient found in eye drops. The prosecution has been methodically laying out its case against Craig, who has pleaded not guilty
00:11:42
including blockbuster testimony from his former business partner, two of his six children,
00:11:47
and a woman he was having an affair with. Dateline producer Michelle Madigan has been in court and
00:11:52
joins us with the latest Michelle welcome back Hi Andrea Okay so two of Craig daughters have taken the stand They are not being identified publicly because of an order from the judge but you saw them really struggle during questioning
00:12:05
when you were in the courtroom, Michelle. We did, Andrea. The first daughter to testify was
00:12:10
James and Angela's oldest daughter. She recently graduated from college, and she was tearful almost
00:12:16
from the moment she took the stand. She choked up just at the question of what her mother's name
00:12:21
was. Michelle, you know, I know that sometimes when we do dateline interviews, friends and family,
00:12:27
they choke up right out of the gate in the interview. It's hard. It is. And it's happened a number of times in this trial. You just can see the hurt and the
00:12:37
reality that's setting in for these people who loved Angela. Yeah, it shows how much they loved her. So the defense has contended that Angela was depressed
00:12:46
when she died and took her own life. But the testimony from Craig's oldest daughter
00:12:51
seemed to push back against that, right? Yes, she said that there were a lot of things
00:12:56
that Angela was looking forward to. She wanted to become a grandmother and she said the two had planned to fix up a house together
00:13:03
and Angela would send her house listings. Her daughter also testified that when Angela became sick,
00:13:09
she didn't know what was wrong with her and she really wanted to get out of the hospital,
00:13:13
saying she needed to get back to her girls. And, you know, when the defense cross-examined her about Angela's mental health, her daughter maintained that her mother struggled like anyone else, but she did not have a mental illness.
00:13:27
The other daughter who testified, Michelle, she was living at home at the time when Angela died.
00:13:32
She was asked about a mysterious phone call between her and her dad. This was so interesting. She said that James calls after he's been arrested from jail, and he asked her to bail out another inmate saying that this inmate would have important information. And she did it. She went to the jail, paid this inmate's bail, and he handed her a letter from her father.
00:13:57
And the letter asked her to create a deep fake video of Angela saying she had asked James to order the poison.
00:14:05
It gave her the directions to make the video, buy a burner laptop, adjust the metadata, and make these purchases on the dark web.
00:14:15
Unbelievable. And just to clarify, she didn't go forward with it, and she handed everything over to law enforcement.
00:14:22
Again, so strange. Michelle, we heard from James Craig's former business partner who played a key role at the beginning of this case.
00:14:30
Yes, this testimony was from Dr. Ryan Redfern. He was also a dentist. He met James during dental school. He and his wife, Michelle, who also testified, were friends with James and Angela. And when Angela became ill, Ryan was on his way to visit her in the hospital.
00:14:47
And he gets this call from the office manager that had discovered a cyanide package had been delivered to the office.
00:14:56
And so he is the person who pulled a nurse aside to let them know about it. And he also told Angela's brother about the cyanide.
00:15:05
So that set off alarm bells, obviously, in the hospital. Then he testified about a conversation that he and his wife had with James.
00:15:13
and James is saying, Ryan, what have you done? And Ryan eventually asked him, was it true?
00:15:21
What is this for? And James said he ordered the potassium cyanide as part of a game of chicken that he had with Angela,
00:15:28
who he said was suicidal and unable to obtain it for herself, but that he had ordered the cyanide for her at her request.
00:15:37
Michelle, we talked last week about the fact that it was an open secret. James Craig was cheating on his wife with multiple women
00:15:42
And this week, we heard from one of the most anticipated witnesses in this trial, the woman James Craig was seeing when Angela died.
00:15:50
Yes, her name is Dr. Karen Kane. She's an orthodontist based in Texas. And the prosecution had her lay out how she met James and how the affair started.
00:16:00
They met in February 2023, so just about a month before Angela died. It was a conference in Las Vegas, and they struck up a conversation waiting in line to go to dinner.
00:16:10
And she said that as she was talking to him about her divorce and her faith, she really opened up to him because he also described himself as in the same situation at the end of a hard divorce.
00:16:23
And this relationship continued after the conference. That's right. She said they texted and had phone calls.
00:16:29
And during those, he said Angela and he'd been separated. He was living in his own apartment.
00:16:34
She said James also talked about Angela's illness. And in March, Dr. Cain actually came to Colorado while Angela was ill. They had dinner a couple of times while she was in the hospital. And then even after she passed away, he came and took her to dinner. And in fact, he left her hotel at midnight. And two hours later, she gets a knock on the door from a detective telling her that James had been arrested.
00:17:01
Oh my, that's a lot. So Karen was just completely in the dark about everything. She was.
00:17:08
The prosecution is really pointing to her as motive. He was intending to be with her, and that's why he wanted to commit this alleged murder.
00:17:18
Dr. Kane testified that she and James talked about being together in the long term.
00:17:22
They didn't talk about logistics, but they did talk about their feelings, and this was a very swift love affair.
00:17:28
Yeah, and the prosecution spent a lot of time reading through James Craig's and Dr. Cain's texts while she was on the stand. Was that to further bolster their idea of what the motive was?
00:17:41
It was. I mean, they exchanged 4,000 text messages and we got to hear some of them.
00:17:46
And during the time that Angela was in the hospital, James is writing to Dr. Cain and
00:17:51
texting and saying quote she still thinks I did this to her and quote just for the record I will never drug you in case that was something you were ever worried about Okay It has been quite the interesting trial so far and there still more to come
00:18:05
Michelle, and I know you'll be there. So we look forward to catching up with you again
00:18:09
as this progresses. Thank you. My pleasure. Coming up, a traffic stop cracks open a 30-year-old cold case in Wisconsin.
00:18:25
33 years ago, a Wapaka County Sheriff's Detective responded to a call at a house on Butternut Road
00:18:33
in the small town of Royalton, Wisconsin. In the bedroom, he found two people and a dog stabbed to death.
00:18:41
But no one was arrested until three years ago. Tony Hayes, who lived just under two miles from that house on Butternut Road in 1992,
00:18:50
was charged with two counts of first-degree murder. But prosecutors say the connection between him and the victims was much deeper than how close they lived to each other.
00:18:59
Hayes pleaded not guilty to the charges, and late last week, a jury was seated in his trial.
00:19:05
Dateline producer Marissa Meyer is in the courtroom, and she has stepped out to the parking lot to tell us how investigators say they cracked this case and what the defense is saying they got wrong.
00:19:15
Marissa, welcome back to the podcast. Thank you so much for having me. Marissa, first of all, tell us, who are these victims?
00:19:22
So the victims in this case are Tana Togstead, who was 23 at the time, and her boyfriend,
00:19:27
Tim Mumbrew. He was 34. And according to Tana's best friend, they had been dating for about six
00:19:33
months. So what is the prosecution alleging happened that night in March 1992? The prosecution
00:19:40
is painting a picture of a pretty brutal murder. They haven't been clear on the exact sequence of
00:19:47
events, but they're alleging that Tony Hayes showed up to Tana's house drunk, got into a
00:19:53
scuffle with Tana's boyfriend. During that scuffle, he punched Tana. She was knocked out and he
00:19:59
repeatedly stabbed Tim. And according to the investigator's complaint, once Tana came to,
00:20:05
Tony allegedly stabbed and killed her. Semen was found like on top of her legs. And in the midst of
00:20:12
this, Tana's dog, Scruffy, was killed as well. What is the prosecution saying is the motive here?
00:20:17
Why would he do that? So they're saying that the motive in this case is a personal one,
00:20:22
that Tony's dad died in a snowmobiling accident when Tony was about seven, so years and years
00:20:28
before the murder. And Tana's father was there during this accident. So prosecutors are saying
00:20:35
that Tony killed Tana and her boyfriend Tim out of anger and some kind of emotional breakdown that
00:20:42
was brought on by this drunken rage. What led investigators to Tony Hayes after all this time?
00:20:48
Because Marissa, so much time passed. So what we know so far is that the case got a fresh look in
00:20:53
2015 when a special agent with the Wisconsin DOJ was assigned to look into it. And a lot of the
00:21:00
evidence from the scene was preserved, even though back in 1992, no one was talking about
00:21:05
DNA testing or DNA. And one of the key pieces that was preserved was semen that was collected
00:21:10
from Tana's body. So over the years, they would try to match the sample to CODIS, didn't find a
00:21:16
match. And then through a seven-year investigation, law enforcement landed on Tony. And they set up
00:21:23
this traffic stop in 2022 to get a DNA sample from him. And according to prosecutors, that DNA sample
00:21:31
was a match to the DNA that was found at the scene. The defense has strongly criticized the traffic
00:21:36
stop in all of this. Walk us through what they're alleging there, the defense. Right. So they're
00:21:43
saying in July 2022, a state agent and a Wisconsin state trooper pulled Tony over for not having a
00:21:51
front license plate on his truck. So then the trooper gives Tony a pen, a clipboard, and this
00:21:57
warning ticket and convinces Tony to sign this traffic citation. The investigators say that they
00:22:04
DNA tested the pen, the clipboard, and the ticket, and they say that it was a match to the semen that
00:22:11
was found on Tana's body. Wow, so this is like a twist on giving the suspect a water bottle or
00:22:17
taking their McDonald's from them. Exactly. But when it comes to the DNA results,
00:22:22
the defense is really saying not so fast with it. They're saying that these DNA results are
00:22:28
unreliable, that most of the DNA evidence in the case was used up by the year 2000 from what they're
00:22:36
saying is destructive testing. And so they're saying these DNA profiles that investigators came
00:22:43
up with were created with insufficient evidence. And they're also saying that this DNA test
00:22:49
should have had a warrant, right? Yes. Yes. They're saying that it's an illegal DNA test,
00:22:56
as you said, conducted without a warrant and without consent. There was a huge moment after Hayes was arrested in 2022, a month after that traffic stop.
00:23:06
he ends up confessing to the murders? He does. He does. He says that he was blackout drunk the night of the murders.
00:23:16
There's holes in his memory and holes in his story. You know, he doesn't remember if he brought a knife to Tana's house or if he picked up a knife at Tana's house.
00:23:26
During the interrogation, which is quite lengthy, investigators asked him, So why didn't you come forward after this brutal crime? And he said something along the lines of,
00:23:39
I didn't want to make it seem like I had planned this. And that after when he'd seen these news
00:23:46
reports about the murders, he said something along the lines of like, oh my goodness, what did I do?
00:23:53
Yeah, except he used some bad language. Yes. Some worse language than oh my goodness. Yes. As we know,
00:24:00
though he's now on trial, saying he didn't do it. So why would he have confessed? What's the
00:24:05
defense saying? The defense is saying that this is a coerced confession, that the investigators
00:24:12
lied repeatedly to Tony, that they interrogated him for seven hours, that they used these
00:24:18
techniques that really elicited a false confession in this case. The defense is saying jurors can't
00:24:24
trust the DNA analysis or the confession. So what are they saying actually happened then?
00:24:29
What is their theory? So they are saying that the person who perpetrated these murders is Tony's uncle,
00:24:36
who actually passed away in 1995. But according to the defense, this uncle was psychotic, had been known to kill dogs.
00:24:46
And even though this relative had been ruled out as a suspect early on, the defense is saying that investigators didn't take the evidence against him seriously enough.
00:24:56
This story takes yet another twist. They exhume the uncle's body back in June? Yes, they do. So the state exhumes the body. They DNA test the uncle's DNA against the DNA found on
00:25:12
Tana's body, and they say it is not a match. But the judge has said that the jury is not going to
00:25:18
hear that the uncle's body was exhumed, that these DNA results did not match back to him.
00:25:24
But it seems at least for now, the uncle will be mentioned as an alternate suspect in this trial.
00:25:31
All right So Marissa the trial is expected to take what another month or so Yes So there lots of testimony lots of witnesses to come Okay Very interesting case Marissa Thank you so much
00:25:41
Thank you so much, Andrea. That's it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly. To get ad-free listening for all our
00:25:49
podcasts, subscribe to Dateline Premium. And if you want to send us a message about any of the
00:25:55
cases we cover on the podcast, or you have questions for the Dateline team, You can reach us on social at Dateline NBC or call us at 212-413-5252.
00:26:08
Coming up this Friday on Dateline, Josh has a classic episode. A man dies mysteriously in his brand new apartment.
00:26:15
His girlfriend says he shot himself. His parents refuse to believe it. I concluded that there must have been an intruder in the house that shot Jonathan.
00:26:24
Watch Behind Door 813 this Friday on NBC at 9, 8 central. Thanks for listening. Bryson Barnes is head of audio production.
00:26:56
Paul Ryan is executive producer and Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline.
00:27:01
See everybody as we go. Bye-bye.