00:00:00
It's going to be really hot, right? Pretty hot today and really hot tomorrow. It's the start of another workday for the Dateline team.
00:00:07
The prosecutor speaking out was on Nightly last night, was on Today Today. Our producers are catching up on breaking crime news.
00:00:15
Somebody killed them and somebody's on the run. Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly.
00:00:22
I'm Andrea Canning. It's July 31st and here's what's on our docket. An old story that's come roaring back into the news.
00:00:30
the Epstein files, and what convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell might have to say now.
00:00:36
Obviously, she doesn't want to say something that could land her in worse trouble than she's already in.
00:00:40
In Arizona, newly revealed evidence in the case of a 16-year-old beaten to death after a house party.
00:00:46
It's a crime that has galvanized a community. Some of the accused are part of a group called the Gilbert Goons.
00:00:52
A lot of these kids were high school students being attacked by their classmates.
00:00:57
But before all that, the trial of Colorado dentist James Craig, accused of poisoning his wife Angela, came to a swift conclusion.
00:01:08
Over the last three weeks, the prosecution argued that James Craig poisoned his wife Angela with potassium cyanide and tetrahydrosaline, a chemical found in eyedrops.
00:01:19
He pleaded not guilty to murder and to charges that he attempted to launch a murder-for-hire plot from behind bars.
00:01:26
Throughout the trial, Craig's defense has maintained that Angela took her own life.
00:01:30
And on Monday, the defense rested without calling a single witness. Both sides made their closing arguments on Tuesday, and then the case was in the hands of the jury.
00:01:39
I went to Colorado and was on the scene as the verdict came down. But first, Dateline producer Michelle Madigan is back to tell us about the final days of the trial.
00:01:47
Michelle, thanks for joining us. Hi, Andrea. Okay, Michelle, so let's back up to the end of the prosecution's case.
00:01:54
They had pointed to Craig's numerous infidelities as motive, and they played video from surveillance cameras around the couple's home.
00:02:01
So jurors got to see for themselves what the relationship between husband and wife was like.
00:02:06
The family had eight cameras in their home, and the investigators reviewed over 1,000 hours of this footage from mid-February to March of 2023 when Angela died.
00:02:17
and the prosecution then called their lead detective, Bobby Joe Olson, back to the stand
00:02:23
to walk the jurors through this video. There was one camera in the kitchen that recorded
00:02:29
audio and video, and it just captures these conversations at the time that the couple had.
00:02:36
So definitely an insight into their relationship that we don't often get to see in cases like this.
00:02:42
Usually we hear from people, but we don't actually see it. What did these videos show?
00:02:48
So some of the clips were just everyday conversations. They were navigating fights between kids, what they want for breakfast, talking about needing to go to the dentist, things like that.
00:02:58
But then there's this footage that the prosecution argued was more sinister. This was a clip that showed James in the kitchen microwaving something and mixing a drink.
00:03:08
and there was a cup with a pink lid that becomes eventually a piece of evidence because then 40
00:03:14
minutes later, Angela's seen in the video drinking from it. We know a few hours later, Angela texted
00:03:21
James Craig. She wasn't feeling well. So they're trying to use this video to bring it all together.
00:03:27
So the defense got a chance to cross-examine the lead detective. What happened there?
00:03:31
So this was key to their case, right? Even before the cross-examination, the defense
00:03:36
was pointing out that the clips that they were showing to the jurors skipped around and that
00:03:41
there were time lapses and we're not getting the full picture of what happened with this family.
00:03:48
You know, on cross, they also argue that a huge amount of media attention on the case
00:03:52
received right from the beginning could have compromised their investigation. They talk about these blinders that the detective had and that the investigation had going into this
00:04:03
case. The defense then spent time going through some entries of Angela's actual journal, which
00:04:10
her sister had given to investigators. They read passages where she described feeling alone,
00:04:16
unloved, and hopeless, seemingly pointing to her state of mind in the years prior to her death.
00:04:23
The prosecution also walked through a timeline for the case, a timeline that was created by James Craig, and he actually called it timeline in his phone.
00:04:33
He did. This was a note that was found in his iPhone called Timeline. And prosecutors believe this is his first written statement about what he says happened to Angela.
00:04:45
In it, he admits to multiple affairs. He says he asked for divorce. He then writes that Angela said she did not want a divorce and that she was going to end her life.
00:04:56
And he agreed to help her research poisons and purchase some, including the eyedrops.
00:05:02
So in his writings, Craig was saying basically that he went along with it, but that it was all Angela's idea?
00:05:10
That's right. In the note, he said that they agreed he would prepare the dosages for her, but that she would take them herself.
00:05:19
And that they agreed that they needed to put on a show that they were still a happy couple.
00:05:24
Okay, so the defense, when it was their turn, they didn't call any witnesses and rested immediately.
00:05:30
You know, we see that from time to time. It happens when the defense feels like they can try the case through cross-examination.
00:05:38
And that's what they did here. I mean, they cross-examined most of the prosecution's almost 50 witnesses. We were curious if Dr. Craig would take the stand, but he did not.
00:05:50
All right So both sides then had their opportunity to make their closing arguments What did each side focus on The prosecution from the beginning said Angela Craig was innocent She had no part in her death They painted the picture of James Craig as someone
00:06:08
who was constantly cheating on his wife, but did not want the divorce because of his financial
00:06:13
situation and the public image. This guy didn't want the reputational consequences associated with
00:06:20
divorce. He didn't want to be the guy who left the mother of his six children to go out and chase
00:06:25
other women. He didn't want that. Much better to be the grieving widower. Get the sympathy.
00:06:33
The prosecutor also walked through the evidence surrounding Craig's research into the poisons and
00:06:39
those purchases he made. And he argued that in order to agree with this defense contention
00:06:46
that Angela was suicidal, the jurors would have to believe that Angela chose to die a slow, painful
00:06:53
death. He spent 10 days killing Angela Craig. And he could have stopped on day one or day two
00:07:04
or day 10. He kept going. Kept going right until the end. The defense, in their closings, they
00:07:14
actually tried to use that video from the house to their advantage? They did. They said, yes,
00:07:21
there's still love between James and Angela. You can see the love and the tenderness and the
00:07:27
kindness and just some of these hours and hours of video in the home. You can see acts of kindness,
00:07:38
of intimacy, of love, of affection. But they wanted the jury to look at this couple
00:07:47
as a broken couple. She said the text messages show that this couple, while loving,
00:07:53
was also broken because, and they said this, he was a cheater. You know what they proved? They proved beyond a reasonable doubt that this guy was a pretty
00:08:03
crappy husband. He cheated on his wife constantly. They did. They proved beyond a reasonable doubt
00:08:10
that he was not faithful. But this idea that somehow this was some sort of motive,
00:08:19
sadly, it was nothing new. Been going on for years. All of a sudden, it's a motive?
00:08:27
23 years later? It's a motive? After closing arguments, James Craig's fate was in the hands of the jury.
00:08:37
And on Wednesday afternoon, I was in court as they came back with a verdict. We, the jury, unanimously and beyond a reasonable doubt,
00:08:44
find the defendant, James Craig, guilty of murder in the first degree. The jury found James Craig guilty of first-degree murder,
00:08:52
as well as guilty on all of the other charges relating to the murder for hire and tampering
00:08:57
with evidence schemes he plotted from behind bars. After the verdict was read and a brief recess,
00:09:03
the judge went right into the sentencing phase. Something that was unusual, the jurors were
00:09:08
invited into the courtroom to watch, and it seemed most of them, if not all, accepted that invitation.
00:09:14
Angela's family during this phase had the chance to speak. Most of her siblings got up to the podium
00:09:21
as well as two of her six children. Here is her daughter, Miriam. I was supposed to be able to trust my dad.
00:09:30
He was supposed to be my hero, and instead he'll forever be the villain in my book.
00:09:36
At times, James Craig became visibly emotional, sobbing in the courtroom. When the judge asked if he wanted to speak, he, his family, and his legal team all declined.
00:09:48
Then the judge read the sentence, life in prison without the possibility of parole,
00:09:53
as well as a sentence of over 30 plus additional years for the other charges. Dr. Craig unleashed a path of destruction as wide as a tornado and just as devastating.
00:10:05
Damage to his children, damage to Angela's family, damage to his own family. none of the individuals that are here in the courtroom
00:10:18
before the court today will ever be the same. With that, the case against James Craig came to a conclusion.
00:10:25
It has been a riveting trial, and I'll be staying on the story for a future Dateline episode,
00:10:29
so stay tuned. Up next, in a Phoenix suburb that's been terrorized by teen violence,
00:10:36
one victim's parents make an emotional statement in court. The town of Gilbert, Arizona, used to be written about as one of the safest places to raise a family in the country.
00:10:53
That all changed in October 2023. 911 emergency. Hey, I'm at a party. A bunch of people I hear with jumped my friend and he's knocked out on the ground.
00:11:03
16-year-old Preston Lord was viciously beaten by a gang of young people. He died from his injuries a few days later.
00:11:11
Seven people, most of them teenagers, were charged with his murder, and suddenly Gilbert was in the headlines for a very different reason,
00:11:18
as a place where teens were attacking other teens. In the past year, the case against Preston's alleged attackers has inched closer towards trial,
00:11:28
closely watched by a community searching for answers. Recently, they got some, as police interviews with witnesses were played in open court for the first time.
00:11:36
phoenix-based dateline field producer britney morris is here to tell us what she learned hey
00:11:40
britney hi andrea good to talk to you remind our listeners britney what happened to preston lord
00:11:47
according to some police reports that i've read preston lord and his friends they were at an out
00:11:52
of control house party on halloween weekend and they were trying to leave when approached by a group of boys they did not know One of those boys stole a gold chain from the neck of Preston friend
00:12:05
And it's at this point when things started to escalate, Preston and his friends began to run away.
00:12:10
But Preston stumbled during his escape, was beaten to the ground, and left for dead.
00:12:16
Several months later, Preston's alleged attackers, they were arrested, and they all pleaded not guilty at that time.
00:12:22
It just breaks my heart for Preston's family. This is just so senseless. And it's gotten a lot of attention. And for more than just Preston's case.
00:12:32
So prior to Preston's death, teens were being ambushed in parking lots, parks, and outside fast food restaurants.
00:12:41
And a lot of these kids were high school students being attacked by their classmates.
00:12:46
One group in particular got a lot of attention for these attacks. They called themselves and were known by their victims as the Gilbert Goons.
00:12:56
I spoke to one victim who was beaten by a group of kids he believes are part of the Gilbert Goons.
00:13:04
He suffered a concussion and later decided to move out of the country to finish high school safely.
00:13:10
Another teen told me he was punched in the back of the head with brass knuckles because he would not give an attacker his car keys.
00:13:18
Most of the attacks were filmed by the assailants themselves and posted on social media to a lot of fanfare.
00:13:25
Were any of these self-described Gilbert goons involved in Preston's death? The defendants have not come forward and identified as a Gilbert goon, at least not since their arrest.
00:13:35
What we do know is that witnesses and tipsters told police that some of Preston's alleged attackers are known Gilbert goons.
00:13:43
Bring us up to speed on Preston's murder case. Sure. In March this year, one of seven defendants, William Owen Hines, pleaded guilty to a reduced charge of manslaughter and was sentenced to 12 years in prison for that charge.
00:13:57
Preston Lord's parents had very strong words for Hines at his sentencing hearing. Here's Preston's dad, Nick.
00:14:05
The tragic and senseless violence that took my son's life has devastated our family in ways words cannot fully capture.
00:14:13
I have no words of forgiveness to offer. And Preston's mom told the judge that her son would have been graduating soon from high school.
00:14:21
One day I had a happy and healthy 16-year-old son, and the next day I saw him lifeless in a hospital bed.
00:14:27
The family told us that this moment felt like a step forward, but at the same time there are still six defendants left to go, and now that trial won't happen until January next year.
00:14:38
The reason for that is the defendant's attorneys filed for an extension citing the immense amount of evidence in this case.
00:14:46
There are more than 2,000 pages to be read and as many as 600 digital files that they are still in the process of reviewing.
00:14:54
Some video clips from that mountain of evidence were shown at a recent hearing. What did everyone see?
00:15:00
It was a very stunning day in the courtroom. For the first time, we saw some clips from police interviews.
00:15:06
One witness is on tape telling the police that one of the defendants by the name of Talon Renner approached Preston Lord at that party.
00:15:15
Talon Renner was like, like walking behind me like this. The witness then demonstrated for the officer how he says this defendant allegedly punched Preston in the head.
00:15:27
He like steps up beside him like this and punches him like that. And then I saw him begin to go down, and I saw people just running all over.
00:15:36
Everybody was running towards it. All I know for sure, like God, was that Talon Renner punch checker on Saturday.
00:15:43
They threw the first punch on the person. It's worth repeating that Talon Renner pleaded not guilty in this case.
00:15:49
Brittany, you talked about the one teenager. He's been sentenced to 12 years in prison.
00:15:52
The other six defendants, presumably they're facing a lot of prison time if convicted.
00:16:00
Has that had an effect on the kind of violence that led up to Preston's death? It doesn't appear that way.
00:16:07
Over the last year, I've met with several people actively working to tackle the problem with teen violence.
00:16:13
And those same people tell me that the violence is still very much there. I was sent a video showing a fight from earlier this month involving several girls,
00:16:23
some just 15 and 16 years old, attacking each other in the same parking lot where many of the alleged Gilbert Goons attacks took place.
00:16:31
Why is the violence not being curbed then with such a spotlight on this? It's definitely an ongoing conversation.
00:16:38
Preston's law was passed. This is an Arizona state law a couple of months ago. And what it does is it strengthens penalties for group attacks, right?
00:16:46
So any group of three or more assailants attacking a single victim faces a felony offense.
00:16:52
And it is the state's hope that this sends a message to people who are instigating this violence.
00:16:59
There are huge ramifications. Yeah, that is progress. Brittany, thank you so much for this update.
00:17:05
Thank you so much, Andrea. Coming up, Ghislaine Maxwell, who was convicted of sex trafficking young women for Jeffrey Epstein, has been talking to federal prosecutors.
00:17:14
What could she have to say now? One of the biggest names in true crime is back in the news.
00:17:27
Jeffrey Epstein, disgraced New York financier who took his own life in 2019 while awaiting trial on federal sex trafficking charges.
00:17:36
Prosecutors said he operated a sex trafficking ring targeting vulnerable young women and underage girls.
00:17:42
And there have long been questions about what kind of secrets Epstein may have taken to the grave.
00:17:48
recently both politicians and some members of the public have been demanding that the doj
00:17:54
release documents related to epstein case but epstein name isn the only one back in the news Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell was Epstein longtime
00:18:06
friend and accomplice. She was arrested after his death and in 2021 convicted of sex trafficking
00:18:12
charges. She's serving a 20-year prison sentence. Last week, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche
00:18:18
sat down with her for nine hours of interviews over the course of two days. Here to bring us
00:18:24
All the updates is NBC News national law enforcement and intelligence correspondent Tom Winter, who has been covering the case for years.
00:18:31
Tom, thank you for coming back on the podcast. Of course, it's great to be here and unfortunately discussing still what is such a sad and difficult and delicate case.
00:18:42
Tom, give us a quick refresher on Ghislaine Maxwell. Who is she and how is she tied to Jeffrey Epstein?
00:18:48
Well, Ghislaine Maxwell is a socialite and a major figure in the Palm Beach circles in London and Europe for a long time.
00:18:58
And Maxwell eventually met Jeffrey Epstein through social circles, and the two of them started spending time together.
00:19:04
They were involved in a romantic relationship together that's just based on people that we've talked to that have known them for a long time,
00:19:10
and also from information that was elicited at eventually her criminal trial. What she was convicted of is that effectively starting in the 1990s and carrying on into the mid-2000s is basically being a recruiter for Jeffrey Epstein of young girls, girls under the age of 18, who she was involved in what federal prosecutors describe, which is sex trafficking.
00:19:35
She would go out and meet young girls, and then they would engage in what's called grooming,
00:19:41
the idea of getting somebody who's underage in a position where they would accept sexual contact with adult individuals.
00:19:51
In fact, Epstein accuser Virginia Giuffre, who has since died by suicide, spoke to Savannah Guthrie in a Dateline special about Gillian recruiting her.
00:20:00
Let's take a listen to that. My dad worked at Mar-a-Lago, which was so cool. And he said, you know what?
00:20:06
I can get you a summer job there. I was a locker room attendant in the spa area.
00:20:11
I get approached by this beautiful, well-spoken, well-mannered woman with an English accent from
00:20:18
proper. And she says, I know this older gentleman who's looking for a traveling masseuse.
00:20:25
He's super rich. He flies around everywhere. Did she say her name? She told me her name was Ghislaine Maxwell.
00:20:31
Virginia also told Savannah this. Ghislaine was doing the same things that she asked me to do for him while touching me in my private areas as well.
00:20:42
Yeah, so I mean, the allegations here are not just that she recruited Virginia Joffrey, but in fact that she participated in some of the abuse.
00:20:50
Jeffrey Epstein, Tom, has been back in the news recently after calls to release the Epstein files.
00:20:56
There's so much curiosity. First of all, what do people even mean when they talk about these Epstein files?
00:21:02
Is this just like a dossier of men's names? I mean, it's like you're imagining what would be in it, right?
00:21:11
It's thousands of pages. So the Epstein files are a couple of different things. One, there's the Palm Beach Police Department in Florida, which initiated this investigation.
00:21:19
Think of that as column A. Column B are the federal files. So that's the FBI interview reports, the evidence that they were able to get, the flight records that they have. There are other people that flew on Epstein's plane, that they were powerful people, Hollywood people, former President Bill Clinton, current President Donald Trump. Column three are all the files that have come out in civil litigation.
00:21:40
So those are kind of the three columns, if you will, that make up the, quote, Epstein files.
00:21:46
But the Epstein files that we really haven't seen are the federal investigative files.
00:21:50
So that's what people have been calling for. That's what they wanted to see. And as the calls to release the file get louder and louder, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche,
00:21:59
he requested a meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell. He did. And it's extraordinary that the Deputy Attorney General of the United States
00:22:07
would request a meeting like this. And the reason why I say that is I cannot recall a time in my 10 plus year career of focusing exclusively on law enforcement and these high profile investigations where the deputy attorney general interviewed anybody.
00:22:22
I mean, this is this is the boss is the number two of the Justice Department. Typically, Andrea would get maybe an email summary.
00:22:28
And there were other questions about who was in the room. I mean, would Blanche be the sole witness if, in fact, her statements could be used in a future proceeding?
00:22:35
All sorts of technical legal stuff. But it's raised those issues. So this meeting, Tom, took place over two days at a federal courthouse in Florida. Curious minds want to know, do we have any idea what Deputy A.G. Blanche asked her about?
00:22:50
Well, those curious minds include myself, the reporter, and we are trying to get some more information as far as what went on there.
00:22:56
Maxwell's own attorney has said that she was asked a number of different names of probably 100 names came up in the course of their discussion, whether or not they got into any sort of specific details about crimes.
00:23:08
It is our reporting that she was given some use immunity. So basically for the purposes of what they asked her for, she had some immunity.
00:23:15
So obviously she doesn't want to say something that could land her in worse trouble than she's already in.
00:23:20
And federal prosecutors, they, you know, have concerns about Ghislaine Maxwell's credibility.
00:23:27
That is an understatement. It was part of the original indictment. She was charged with two counts of perjury for lying in a 2016 deposition.
00:23:34
Prosecutors repeatedly pointed out the times that she, they believe, was not truthful with them.
00:23:40
I mean, let's just go back to the day of her arrest. She bought a house in New Hampshire under a fake name.
00:23:45
The FBI, they said, come out. We've got an arrest warrant for you. She tries to hide on them. And then they find her cell phone wrapped in tinfoil in an effort to, they think, avoid some sort of surveillance or detection. So at every turn, they raised serious concerns.
00:24:00
their minds about her credibility. And so ultimately, do you think we'll see more
00:24:03
transparency with the Epstein files? Do you think we're going to know what's in there and hear some
00:24:10
names? I mean, that's all anyone talks about, right? You know, we keep hearing names and names,
00:24:14
and you're so right. It's what everybody talks about. Who's in there? What are the names? What's
00:24:18
going on? Donald Trump said this week, look, do you think if my name was in there in a criminal way
00:24:23
that it wouldn't have come out already? I think at this point, given the time that we would have
00:24:29
heard from somebody who would have presented credible allegations that either Bill Clinton,
00:24:34
Donald Trump, anybody who's involved in this, that they would have said, look, I was forced to have
00:24:39
sex with this high profile person and I was under the age of 18. That obviously makes it a crime.
00:24:44
We have not heard that so far. So we could get a lot more names, but it doesn't necessarily mean
00:24:50
that there's something there. Okay. Well, we know that you are on top of it, Tom. We appreciate it.
00:24:56
Thank you, Andrea. That's it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly. To get ad-free listening for all our podcasts, subscribe to Dateline Premium.
00:25:06
Coming up this Friday on Dateline, my story about a beloved teacher murdered in her own home while members of her family slept.
00:25:13
How could you not hear your wife screaming if she's being attacked? Sounds crazy.
00:25:18
Watch The Footprint at the Lake this Friday at 9, 8 central on NBC. Thanks for listening.
00:25:24
Dateline True Crime Weekly is produced by Frannie Kelly, Katie Ferguson, and Brittany Morris
00:25:29
Our associate producers are Carson Cummins, Caroline Casey and Kim Flores Gaynor
00:25:35
Our senior producer is Allison Orr Production and fact-checking help by Terry Dickerson, Veronica Mazzaca
00:25:41
is our digital producer, Rick Kwan is our sound designer, original music by Jesse McGinty, Bryson Barnes
00:25:48
is head of audio production, Paul Ryan is executive producer, and Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline
00:25:54
Stay cool, everybody. Bye-bye.