00:00:00
How are you? Good. Last week of summer, though. Yes. I mean, not technically, but effectively.
00:00:06
It's time for Dateline's morning meeting. Our editorial team is discussing breaking crime news.
00:00:11
He had been following her, and she was completely unaware. They might still be in one year, and tomorrow she has a hearing on her other case.
00:00:18
They waited months before they realized she was really missing. Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly.
00:00:25
I'm Blaine Alexander, filling in today for Andrea Canning. It's August 28th, and here's what's on our docket.
00:00:32
In Northern California, after giving a bizarre press conference about his missing wife,
00:00:38
her husband is arrested for her murder. It's the first time in Shasta County history they're trying to get someone for a murder charge with no body.
00:00:45
In Dateline Roundup, the kayaker who faked his own death faces sentencing, and rap star Cardi B appears in a Los Angeles courtroom as a civil defendant.
00:00:55
will bring you the latest on what she had to say in her own defense. She really doubled down on it being just a verbal altercation, nothing physical.
00:01:04
Plus, you've seen investigators asking suspects for DNA samples in Dateline episodes.
00:01:09
A former prosecutor breaks down why this is often detectives' best tool, but it's not always foolproof.
00:01:16
DNA cannot be the only thing you're walking into the courtroom with. But before all of that, at the murder trial of Florida grandmother Donna Adelson,
00:01:25
one of the most anticipated witnesses takes the stand, her oldest son. Nearly two years after she was arrested, Donna Adelson's trial is now in its second week.
00:01:38
The 75-year-old grandmother is charged with helping to orchestrate the 2014 killing
00:01:43
of her daughter Wendy's ex-husband, FSU professor Dan Markell. Markell was shot in the head by two hitmen in his driveway,
00:01:51
and four people have already been convicted for their roles in the crime, including Donna's son, Charlie.
00:01:57
Donna Adelson has pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder, conspiracy, and solicitation.
00:02:03
In its opening statement, the prosecution laid out what they said was Donna's motive
00:02:08
to get Dan Markell out of the way so that Wendy could move their children closer to her parents.
00:02:13
The defendant said that she would never, never, never give up and never stopped fighting for Wendy and the boys to be relocated to Miami.
00:02:26
And she never did. The defense then countered that there is no direct proof that Donna Adelson was ever involved.
00:02:32
This case is really a lot about theory and motive and not evidence. This week, as testimony ramped up, the dynamics of the Adelson family took center stage.
00:02:45
Daughter Wendy and Rob, the Adelson's son, who is estranged from the family, both took the stand.
00:02:51
Dateline producer Brad Davis was in the courtroom as their dramatic testimony unfolded
00:02:56
and is here now to break down everything that happened in that testimony. Brad, thanks so much for joining us.
00:03:02
Oh, glad to be here. This is certainly a lot to talk about. So let's jump right in.
00:03:06
Okay, so Wendy took the stand first. Now, what's notable about this, this is her fourth time testifying in six years.
00:03:13
When we heard her on the stand, I mean, what was her demeanor like? What were some of the things that she said?
00:03:18
Yeah, I mean, she's very poised on the stand and she's a lawyer herself. So she really knows what to say and how to be careful when she speaks.
00:03:28
And the prosecution explained to the jury that she was testifying under state subpoena
00:03:33
and that she had a form of what's called use immunity, where what she said on the stand
00:03:39
could not be used against her later in a court of law. But that doesn't mean that she can't be later prosecuted related to this case.
00:03:46
The prosecution wanted her to help paint a picture of her family. And they wanted to show that Donna Adelson was deeply involved in the divorce proceedings.
00:03:56
You know, all the motions going back and forth. And they also wanted to show, right, how much Donna apparently disliked Dan.
00:04:03
Yeah, they went through all of these documents, all these emails, all these texts from Donna to Wendy.
00:04:08
And you get a lot of like really nasty comments that Donna makes about Dan Markell, her former son-in-law at that point.
00:04:15
Did your mom ever call Dan Markell any disparaging names around this time frame?
00:04:21
She did. Okay. Including piece of shit? Yes. Asshole? Yes. A narcissist? Yes. A bully?
00:04:30
Yes. A bastard? Yes. So certainly the prosecution painted one picture of everything.
00:04:38
But when it came time for cross-examination, how did Donna's defense team try to counter the prosecution's case here?
00:04:44
Yeah, the defense portrays Donna as a very loving mother and a very loving mother-in-law that she really had no animus.
00:04:53
She would do things for Dan. She would help with the kids, help him out with the kids, even as Wendy and Dan were divorced.
00:05:00
You testified that your mother hated Danny at the time that he was killed, but the week before he died, your mother was babysitting for Danny, wasn't she?
00:05:10
Yes. And in fact, she actually made him banana bread, specifically the way he liked it, right?
00:05:17
It was his favorite. Without nuts, but with chocolate chips. That's right. The next witness in all of this was someone that a lot of people have been waiting to hear from for quite a long time, and that's the third Adelson sibling, Rob.
00:05:30
Now, he has never testified at any of the earlier trials, so this is really the first time we're hearing from him.
00:05:34
But before we get to his testimony, Brad, just kind of tell us a little bit about Rob.
00:05:38
Yeah, Rob Adelson is the oldest of the three Adelson kids. He is an ENT, an ear, nose, and throat doctor, and he lives up in New York.
00:05:49
He does not live anywhere near Florida where the Adelsons have lived. You could tell he was very nervous on the stand He tried to look really not at Donna not at anyone in the courtroom I mean he was very careful to just focus on the prosecutor when he was talking
00:06:06
I'm curious, what was the mood in the courtroom while he was testifying? Yeah, I mean, when Rob was testifying, you could sort of hear a pen drop because this is someone
00:06:13
that we have never heard from in this case, you know, someone who has really been very reluctant
00:06:17
to speak to media or anything. And we're finally hearing him. And the jury, you know,
00:06:22
seemed very wrapped with attention as he was speaking. Let's talk about the picture that Rob
00:06:27
painted of the Adelson household growing up. Yeah, he talks about his family, that basically
00:06:33
his mom, Donna, was really in control of a lot of things and she would get involved in her kids'
00:06:38
lives to an extent that, you know, was maybe to him unhealthy at times. Based on your personal
00:06:44
observations throughout your life of your parents and of your siblings, who is the leader in the
00:06:51
family? Who tends to run the show? I think my mom. Would you describe Donna Adelson's personality
00:06:58
as being more controlling or more laid back? I think more on the controlling side. Rob said
00:07:05
Charlie to him is sort of the middle child who's sort of the ne'er-do-well. Wendy is the youngest.
00:07:11
You know, she's the one that Donna has to take care of and make sure she's all okay. And of course,
00:07:16
the prosecution asked Rob about Donna's relationship with Dan Markell. What did Rob
00:07:21
have to say about the interaction between those two? On the stand, Rob said initially it seemed
00:07:26
like everything that Donna had no issues with Dan. But as the divorce began and got underway,
00:07:32
she got really angry with Dan. And how did Donna Adelson feel about Dan Markell in 2014?
00:07:39
I mean, she hated him. And Rob was also asked about his interactions with his mother surrounding Dan Markell's death.
00:07:49
He said that she was the one who essentially broke the news to him. Yeah, that's right.
00:07:53
I mean, he said he got a call from her that right when it happened and he was in shock.
00:07:59
He couldn't believe what had happened. But he said his mother was not that emotional on the phone speaking with him.
00:08:06
She had said, you know, I don't care. It doesn't concern me. Was that out of character for her to not be curious and not be asking some questions?
00:08:13
Yeah, I mean, it was an unsolved murder of my former brother-in-law, someone that we all know very well.
00:08:21
If it was some neighborhood gossip, people would be interested. This was national interest, and nobody had any curiosity about who did this to Danny.
00:08:32
And Brad, this is certainly interesting. there was one portion in there where Rob testified that Donna told him not to talk to law enforcement?
00:08:39
Yeah. Rob said that the FBI came to talk with him up in New York, and he obliged and told them what he could, and then he got a call from his mother.
00:08:49
Did you let her know that you already had talked to law enforcement? Yeah, I said I already did.
00:08:54
What did she say to that? She said, oh, well, you don't know anything anyway. You don't know anything anyway?
00:08:59
Correct. And then the prosecution moved forward a bit to May of 2016. That's when the two hitmen were arrested.
00:09:06
This was a very compelling piece of testimony. Brad, what did Rob have to say about what happened next?
00:09:12
Yeah, he said that he was truly shocked when he heard that they were arrested and made.
00:09:16
And so he was like waiting for his parents to call him to say, you know, that these arrests and he didn't hear from them.
00:09:22
But he knew he was going to talk to them two days later because his anniversary was coming up.
00:09:26
So his mother did call and they talked about, you know, little things, small talk, and they never brought up these arrests.
00:09:34
So I finally broached the topic and said, you know, they found the guy. They arrested someone who killed Danny.
00:09:40
You know, there's no response. And I said it, you know, at least two or three times.
00:09:44
And her response was, you know, I've got to go. And then did she hang up the phone after that?
00:09:49
Yes. Other than, you know, her reaching out for happy birthdays, happy anniversaries, that kind of thing.
00:09:55
Was that the last conversation? you had with her? That was the last time I spoke to her. Okay, that's all. Thank you. We know that
00:10:01
the prosecution is continuing to present their case. And of course, we will keep having you back
00:10:05
on, Brad, to break down every twist and turn that comes out of the courtroom. Thank you so much.
00:10:11
Glad to be here. Thank you. Coming up, after a mother of four disappeared in Redding, California,
00:10:17
her sisters urged police to take a closer look at her husband. Now, there's been an arrest in the case.
00:10:26
In March, Tyler McCain stood in front of reporters at the Shasta County Sheriff's Office
00:10:39
and talked about his wife, Nikki. She'd been missing for almost a year. We miss you.
00:10:44
I don't really know what to say. I haven't been in the public, guys. I'm just here in support.
00:10:50
So anything that I can do, I want to do that. The people in that room knew that there was something Tyler wasn't saying.
00:10:57
Before Nikki disappeared, her husband, Tyler, had been indicted on four counts of domestic violence for allegedly assaulting her.
00:11:05
Charges that had been dropped by the prosecutor after Nikki vanished, leading to protests outside of the county courthouse.
00:11:12
Justice for Nikki is what we're looking for, and that's what we shall receive. Nikki's three sisters took it upon themselves to keep attention on her case,
00:11:21
including by talking to Dateline last summer for our online series, Missing in America.
00:11:26
I know that there are a lot of people who know something, but maybe they just might be afraid to say something.
00:11:33
And then, late last week, the family finally got some answers. Even without finding Nikki's body, the Shasta County DA charged Tyler McCain with his wife's murder.
00:11:44
Action News Now reporter Blake Mayfield has been following this case closely. He joins us now to tell us how prosecutors got to an indictment here and what they're revealing to the public about this investigation.
00:11:55
Blake thank you so much for joining us We so glad to have you today Yeah thank you for having me I want to start by just talking about who Nikki was Our digital team did a really great interview with her sisters but tell us a little bit about what her life was like in Reading
00:12:08
She was born and raised in Reading, Reading lifer, if you will. Homemaker, had four kids, 39 years old when she disappeared.
00:12:15
Now, according to her sisters and the DA's account of the county's investigation, the marriage started getting violent around 2020.
00:12:23
Tyler was arrested for domestic violence in 2023. So, Blake, what do we know about that incident?
00:12:29
In the sheriff's complaint, the reporting officer said that when he met Nikki at Mercy Hospital, she had two black eyes and other injuries to her head and face.
00:12:37
She had told the officer that Tyler had come home extremely agitated. It was not making any sense.
00:12:42
He held her down, taped her ankles and wrists together, put tape over her mouth, proceeded to be right and hit her for three hours after that.
00:12:50
Three hours? pretty pretty rough pretty violent stuff um nikki had told the officer there at mercy that tyler had
00:12:57
done this type of thing before but it never been that bad never to that extent um tyler told the
00:13:02
officer he didn't strike nikki in any way he told the officer that he thought she got in a fight with
00:13:07
another woman and that's why she had the marks and the black guys and all that um he pleaded not
00:13:11
guilty to the felony charges and he was scheduled to go to court on june 3rd and that's actually
00:13:15
just a little over two weeks after Nikki disappeared. Wow. Those are, I mean, we just need to pause and say
00:13:22
those are some heavy allegations against Tyler that she made. Her sisters told us that Tyler had been asking Nikki
00:13:31
to recant some of those allegations against him. She told us she was very upset because what he did was ambushed her with his attorney
00:13:39
and tried to get her to tell his attorney that none of that happened and she made it up.
00:13:44
The press release that the Shasta County DA put out last week references these alleged efforts by Tyler, saying, quote,
00:13:52
Detectives also determined that Tyler McCain made multiple attempts to dissuade Nikki from testifying in connection with a domestic violence incident.
00:14:01
What do we know about that? I mean, is there any evidence? I know that she did not ask the county to drop the charges against Tyler.
00:14:07
And Dateline has reached out to both Tyler McCain and his attorney. we've not yet heard back from either of them. But Blake, what do we know about the investigation
00:14:16
into Nikki's disappearance? Yeah, until last week, investigators and the district attorney's office
00:14:21
never said publicly that they suspected foul play or that Tyler was even an official suspect.
00:14:26
They did appear to have him on their radar from the get-go. The couple's house was searched just
00:14:31
a couple days after she went missing. Investigators found a firearm, a large capacity magazine,
00:14:37
ammunition. There was a protective order against him related to prior felony domestic violence
00:14:43
charges to where he wasn't supposed to have anything like a large capacity magazine.
00:14:47
So he got a charge for that one. The week after that, he forged Nikki's signature to cash an IRS
00:14:53
refund check. And that's all we knew about the investigation. Was there anything that they found
00:14:57
that pointed to possible violence toward Nikki? Any evidence to that effect? Yeah, so this is all new information from the DA's office.
00:15:05
We had no idea of any of these details until last week. Nikki's Chevy Avalanche was found about a week after she was last heard from.
00:15:13
And authorities say they smell an overwhelming odor of decomposition. The truck bed had a white sheet with bloodstains on it.
00:15:20
Investigators did confirm that the blood on the sheet was Nikki's. And they confirmed the primary source of the rest of the DNA in that car was indeed Tyler's.
00:15:27
So that was a part of the investigation as early as May of last year. in April of this year, Tyler was pulled over for throwing things out of the window of his truck.
00:15:37
And one of the things that authorities found was actually Nikki's driver's license that had been
00:15:41
partially burned. There's one more thing here, Blake, that was kind of buried in the DA's press
00:15:47
release, but it is a very striking and notable detail. Tyler, according to the DA's office,
00:15:54
actually admitted to killing Nikki at some point. Yeah. Yeah. That's what she said in her press
00:15:58
conference, she said that a confidential informant told detectives that Tyler admitted to killing
00:16:04
Nikki. So that could have been over a year ago. It could have been three months ago. It could have
00:16:08
been in March. But just to kind of punctuate it, I mean, that is a major update. Very, very much so.
00:16:12
It's something I didn't expect to hear. I'm curious, Blake, during her press conference,
00:16:16
did she at all mention or address this kind of growing public frustration with just how long
00:16:23
it's taken to bring an indictment in this case? DA Stephanie Bridget said this last week. It's
00:16:27
the first time in Shasta County history they're trying to get someone for a murder charge with
00:16:31
no body. The DA pointed out that her office and law enforcement partners have been gathering
00:16:36
evidence since May of last year. She is going to bring back all the charges she dismissed last July
00:16:41
against Tyler now. It may have appeared that McCain had gotten away with domestic violence
00:16:47
charges, and I understand your frustration at that time. But as you can see, we filed an
00:16:52
enhancement to the murder charge for murder with intent to prevent testimony. It is our belief
00:16:58
that Tyler McCain murdered his wife, Nikki McCain, to prevent her from testifying in the domestic
00:17:05
violence case. Yeah, so this enhancement actually changes the sentence that he'd be facing
00:17:09
significantly. He's now looking at life without parole, and he also cannot get out on bail while
00:17:14
waiting for his trial to start. He entered a plea of not guilty at his arraignment. You were there
00:17:19
in the courtroom that day. What was the mood like there? What was Tyler's demeanor when he
00:17:24
entered that not guilty plea? Full courtroom. You know what it's going to be. It's one of the most
00:17:27
high-profile cases, not only in Shasta County, but it feels like. I mean, I'm talking to Dateline.
00:17:32
Truthfully, I didn't really get a good look at him. His attorney did a really good job of standing
00:17:35
in front of him. Well, Blake, it is a very disturbing case. Thank you so much for joining
00:17:41
us to break it all down. And I appreciate you guys having me on. If you or someone you know
00:17:45
is experiencing domestic violence, you can always call the National Domestic Violence Hotline.
00:17:50
That number is 1 or visit the website thehotline for more resources Up next it time for Dateline Roundup Rapper Cardi B is on civil trial in California for an alleged assault
00:18:07
And what happened to the Wisconsin man who faked his own death to start a new life in Europe?
00:18:13
We've got an update. Plus, when investigators collect suspects' DNA, we'll tell you what you need to know.
00:18:25
Hi, everyone. Welcome back. Joining us this week for our roundup is Dateline Digital producer,
00:18:36
Veronica Mazzaca. Veronica, hi. Hi, Blaine. Veronica, thanks so much for joining us today.
00:18:41
We certainly have a lot to break down. So first to start, we're heading to Wisconsin for an update
00:18:46
in the case of Ryan Borgwart, the married father of three, who authorities say faked his own death
00:18:52
last year by pretending to drown while kayaking in a local lake. Now, after searching the lake for
00:18:58
weeks, police found Borgwart alive and well in Eastern Europe, where they say that he went to
00:19:03
meet a woman that he'd met online. This is really quite a twisted case, Veronica. So what's the
00:19:09
latest here? Yeah, so Borgwart voluntarily returned to the U.S. last December. He was taken into
00:19:15
custody and then he was charged with obstructing an officer. The allegation is that once police
00:19:21
discovered Borgwart was alive and made contact with him, they say he deliberately misled them
00:19:26
about his location by using a VPN while browsing the internet, thereby obstructing their investigation.
00:19:32
Borgwart was finally sentenced on Tuesday after pleading guilty to that charge. And what kind of a sentence did he receive?
00:19:40
The judge sentenced Borgwart to 89 days in county jail, one day for each of the days Borgwart's whereabouts were unknown by law enforcement.
00:19:48
89 days in jail. So that's the legal penalty. I'm curious, Veronica, what became of his marriage?
00:19:54
What happened with his family that he deceived all this time? So when he returned to the U.S., his wife did file for divorce.
00:20:03
For our next story, let's move out to California, where we switch gears and we focus on a civil trial instead of a criminal one.
00:20:09
And it involves a name that many of us are familiar with, rapper Cardi B, whose legal name is Belcaliz Almanzar.
00:20:15
She's on trial this week for allegedly assaulting a female security guard inside a Beverly Hills medical building in 2018.
00:20:22
So what is the plaintiff saying happened here? So the plaintiff, Imani Ellis, took the stand Monday.
00:20:30
She claimed that she was conducting routine rounds as a security guard when she saw Cardi B exit an elevator outside of an obstetrician's office.
00:20:38
She testified that she said, wow, that's Cardi B, after which she alleges Cardi B got in her face and accused her of spreading the news of the rapper's pregnancy, which was a secret at the time, via her phone.
00:20:50
She says that Cardi B yelled obscenities at her, cut her cheek with her fingernail, and then spit on her.
00:20:56
Now, Cardi's lawyer is actually presenting a completely different story in his opening, though, right?
00:21:01
Yes. So Cardi B's lawyer, Peter Anderson, said that the rapper caught Ellis filming and photographing her.
00:21:07
He does admit that his client used strong language and yelled, but never touched Ellis.
00:21:12
You know, I think a lot of us are wondering, what does Cardi B have to say about all of this?
00:21:17
Veronica, we actually heard from her on Tuesday. Yeah, so she really doubled down on it being just a verbal altercation, nothing physical.
00:21:25
When you say there was a verbal altercation. Yes. Do you know what the word altercation means?
00:21:31
Like a conflict. Like a fight, right? Yeah, it was like a verbal fight, but it didn't get physical.
00:21:37
at all. When I'm talking to you now, are we having a verbal altercation? We haven't, we'll say,
00:21:45
a debate. A lot of people know Cardi B for her personality. It sounds like it was coming out on
00:21:52
the stand there too. And finally, we're diving into some updates in the case of Ghislaine Maxwell,
00:21:59
convicted sex trafficker and former girlfriend of also convicted sex trafficker and disgraced
00:22:05
New York financier Jeffrey Epstein. As I'm sure many of our listeners will remember, last month,
00:22:10
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche sat down with Maxwell in a rather unprecedented interview
00:22:16
and questioned her about Epstein's crimes as well as her own. And last week, the DOJ released the
00:22:22
audio and transcripts of that two-day interview. So, Veronica, a lot of people, of course, have
00:22:27
been talking about this. What is the key takeaway that you've garnered from the release of this
00:22:31
audio. So as we know, there's been a lot of buzz about a possible black book or client list that
00:22:39
allegedly has the names of powerful individuals that Epstein trafficked young girls to. But
00:22:45
according to Maxwell, that list doesn't actually exist. And Ghislaine Maxwell also answered some
00:22:50
questions about her own involvement. There's a ton of writing and a ton of, I guess, testimony as
00:22:56
well, but also public reporting about how the recruiting was a very aggressive effort
00:23:02
that you were a part of, that he was a part of, and others, to try to find more and more
00:23:07
masseuses. Is that true, and what role did you have in that? That is partially true.
00:23:15
Okay. So it is true that I found masseuses, and in my effort to find them, I would go to massage
00:23:22
spas, like legitimate spas. And one of Epstein and Maxwell's most vocal accusers was a woman named Virginia Roberts
00:23:31
Giuffre. She claims to have been recruited by Maxwell at President Trump's spa in Mar-a-Lago more
00:23:37
than two decades ago. Giuffre died by suicide earlier this year, and now her family had a very strong reaction
00:23:44
to the release of those tapes. Veronica, what did they have to say about this? Yeah, so they said that they were, quote, outraged by the release of the audio and transcripts
00:23:54
as it gives Maxwell a quote, platform to rewrite history. They said, transcripts directly contradict the conviction Maxwell got for child sex trafficking.
00:24:04
It had to have just been difficult for them to hear this and almost kind of relive all of this
00:24:09
so soon after her death. And there is more news, Veronica, about Jufre this week as well.
00:24:15
That's right. We learned that she was writing a memoir at the time of her death,
00:24:18
and it will be released posthumously in October. It's called Nobody's Girl. I'm sure a lot of people will be very interested to read that book.
00:24:28
All right, Veronica, thank you so much for your expertise as always. We appreciate you.
00:24:32
Thank you. You've seen it time and again on Dateline, the moment when law enforcement asks someone to give a sample of their DNA.
00:24:42
Matching that sample to DNA left at the crime scene can make or break an investigation.
00:24:48
But DNA isn't always collected at the police station. Take the recent case of Tony Hayes.
00:24:53
He was accused and acquitted of a 33-year-old double murder after investigators took a sample of his DNA from a pen that he used while at a traffic stop, which was a point of contention during his trial.
00:25:06
It made us here at Dateline want to find out more about the collection of DNA, how it works, what the process looks like, when it's allowed, and just any other nuances when it comes to this topic.
00:25:17
So joining us now is former prosecutor Melba Pearson. She's the chair of the American Bar Association's Criminal Justice Section.
00:25:24
Melba, thanks so much for joining us today. It's great to have you. Melba M.: Thank you so much for having me.
00:25:28
Really looking forward to the discussion. Me too. So Melba, let's talk about actually getting DNA from a potential suspect.
00:25:35
Usually we talk about gathering DNA through a cheek swab or hair Is there specific training for that Yeah so officers definitely have that as part of their training They know the basics on how to collect DNA right So that important to note But in terms of how DNA can be obtained first off consent
00:25:53
So the police officer, the detective asks you, hi, can I have a sample of your DNA?
00:25:58
We're trying to eliminate people in this particular investigation. And you can say yes or no.
00:26:04
If you say yes, moves forward. If you say no, now it's up to the detective to go and get a warrant.
00:26:11
Now, other ways that DNA could be obtained if you are convicted of a crime. And it varies by state, but as a general premise, you will be swabbed for your DNA,
00:26:21
even if you're not going to prison. But also, the way that has been very interesting in terms of a lot of discussion is the discarded DNA.
00:26:31
Because once you throw something out, the courts have very clearly said it's no longer yours.
00:26:36
So if you take a sip from a water bottle and then you chuck it in the garbage, law enforcement can come right behind you, pick up that bottle, bag it, the whole thing, take it to the lab, have it tested, and then that could be used as a sample against maybe an existing sample in a particular case.
00:26:53
And then the last way that DNA can come into play is the whole idea of genetic genealogy.
00:27:00
And so you upload your DNA sample to 23andMe, Ancestry.com, whatever the case may be,
00:27:07
law enforcement may be able to get access to that database through the use of a warrant.
00:27:13
And if there a match then what they looking at is this may be someone who is related to the target of this investigation so let try to figure out is this a cousin Is this a brother Is this a sister And you backtrack from there
00:27:27
So Melba, before we go any further, let's just kind of level set here, because I do think that
00:27:31
it's easy to look at, you know, cases where DNA is involved and just say, okay, great, we got DNA.
00:27:37
It's a match. Boom. The case is solved. This person's going to prison. But it's not always
00:27:42
that cut and dry? Yes, absolutely. So there's so many different permutations in terms of how this
00:27:47
can go, right? There's a scenario where it could be a mixture. So you can't tell conclusively,
00:27:54
you know, it might be two or three different people that are involved in that one sample,
00:28:00
we call those contributors, it could be more than one contributor to that particular sample.
00:28:04
That doesn't exactly necessarily give you clarity on who the person is that committed the crime. So
00:28:09
there's that. Also, you can have DNA, and it can be from a consensual encounter. So, for instance,
00:28:17
we've seen many times in so many cases, especially involving a sexual assault, where the person who
00:28:24
might be the main suspect, their DNA is found on the victim. And they're like, listen, we had a
00:28:30
consensual encounter earlier that day, an hour before. And when I left the person, they were
00:28:35
fine. They were still alive. How do you get around that argument, right? So while DNA is great in
00:28:42
terms of identification purposes, DNA cannot be the only thing you're walking into the courtroom
00:28:48
with. This is such a fascinating discussion. We could go on and on. Melba Pearson, chair of ABA's
00:28:53
criminal justice section Thank you so much for joining us today I really appreciate it Thank you for having me Blaine And that it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly To get ad listening for all of our podcasts subscribe to Dateline Premium
00:29:09
Coming up this Friday on Dateline, we have a classic Andrea Canning episode. When young mother Kelsey Barrett went missing on Thanksgiving Day 2018, investigators relied on a witness to piece together the mystery of her disappearance.
00:29:23
Was there any blood on the TV? Do you remember? Yeah, there was blood on the TV.
00:29:26
There's blood on the chairs. There's blood on the table. But was she just a witness or something more?
00:29:33
Watch Devil's Bargain this Friday at 9, 8 Central. And just a reminder before you go,
00:29:39
the first of its kind Dateline Live event is happening Sunday, September 28th in Nashville.
00:29:45
I'll be there along with Josh, Keith, Andrea, Dennis, and Lester, and we would love for you to join us.
00:29:52
There will be onstage panels, audience Q&As, and a VIP reception. Tickets are on sale now at datelinenbc.com slash event.
00:30:00
You can also find a link in the description of this episode. We'd love to see you there.
00:30:04
Thanks so much for listening. Dateline True Crime Weekly is produced by Frannie Kelly and Katie Ferguson.
00:30:10
Our associate producers are Carson Cummins and Caroline Casey. Our senior producer is Liz Brown Kurloff.
00:30:17
Production and fact-checking help by Terry Dickerson and Georgina DiNardo. Veronica Mazzica is our digital producer.
00:30:23
Rick Kwan is our sound designer. Original music by Jesse McGinty. Bryson Barnes is head of audio production.
00:30:31
Paul Ryan is executive producer. And Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline.
00:30:36
All right. Thanks, everybody.