Search Captions & Ask AI

Did He Actually Fail the Polygraph?? #crimejunkie #truecrime

February 02, 2026 / 01:52

This episode discusses the disappearance of Nikki and the investigation surrounding her fiancé Bobby. Key topics include Bobby's polygraph results, his alibi, and police suspicions.

During the investigation, police asked Bobby to take a polygraph test regarding Nikki's disappearance. He reportedly failed a key question about his involvement, although Bobby later claimed the question was misphrased.

Bobby stated that he felt partially responsible for Nikki's disappearance. He provided an alibi, claiming he was with a cousin at a mall getting fitted for wedding tuxes before returning home to meet Nikki.

The episode raises questions about Bobby's credibility and the lack of physical evidence linking him to any crime, leaving him in a gray area as a person of interest.

TLDR

Bobby's polygraph failure raises questions about Nikki's disappearance.

Episode

1:52
00:00:00
Now, like I said, this is all happening over the first few days of Nikki coming up missing. And when police start
00:00:05
getting more involved, they look at what Bobby's been doing and they become suspicious of his actions, too. So, they
00:00:12
ask him to come in and take a polygraph. Now, when he does, police say that he failed an important question, one along
00:00:21
the lines of, "Did you have anything to do with or know anything about Nikki's disappearance?"
00:00:27
His response was no, but according to the polygraph, it said that's a lie. Now, later on, Bobby came out and said
00:00:34
that is not what or how they asked him. He said that the way the question was phrased was something more like, "Do you
00:00:41
feel responsible for her going missing?" And he said like, "Well, how would any man not feel partially responsible for
00:00:47
not being there when something happens to your fiance, your woman?" Now, I can't find where police ever came out
00:00:53
and confirm or deny any of this. Was it Is it like they said? Is it like Bobby said? Is it somewhere in the middle?
00:00:59
Which kind of just left everyone with a lot of questions about Bobby, but no physical proof [music] tying him to a
00:01:06
crime. Well, and he had an alibi, right? Kind of. I mean, that's what I That's what I remember knowing back then. Like,
00:01:14
right? He After church, he said that he met up with a cousin and his cousin drove them to the Richmond Square Mall
00:01:19
to get fitted for wedding tuxes. They're together for like an hour and a half or
00:01:23
so, and then Bobby said that he made a couple of pit stops at people's houses before going home between like 5:30 and
00:01:29
5:45, where he expected to meet Nikki. They were going to finish up those wedding invites, but she just never
00:01:34
showed. So, yes, he has an alibi, you know, there's a little bit of wiggle room in there, and
00:01:41
with that, with the quote-unquote failed poly, after he is talked to by police, he kind
00:01:46
of just remains in this gray space that investigators like to call person of interest.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 60
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • Bobby's Polygraph Results
    Bobby failed a crucial question on the polygraph regarding Nikki's disappearance.
    “Did you have anything to do with or know anything about Nikki's disappearance?”
    @ 00m 21s
    February 02, 2026
  • Bobby's Alibi
    Bobby claims he was with a cousin getting fitted for wedding tuxes when Nikki went missing.
    “He has an alibi, but there's wiggle room.”
    @ 01m 38s
    February 02, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • How would any man not feel partially responsible?
    Did He Actually Fail the Polygraph?? #crimejunkie #truecrime

Key Moments

  • Bobby's Suspicion00:08
  • Polygraph Failure00:12
  • Questions Remain01:01
  • Wedding Plans01:32
  • Gray Area01:46