Search Captions & Ask AI

The Doctor Behind the Autopsy... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

April 14, 2026 / 01:57

This episode discusses a controversial incident involving Dr. Shelley, who took a dead Marine's brain home and allowed his children to hold it. The conversation includes details about the investigation led by Wendy Halloran into Dr. Shelley's actions and the repercussions he faced.

Dr. Shelley, a military medical examiner, performed an autopsy on a Marine Corps sergeant in December 2011. Instead of delivering the brain to a naval hospital as required, he took it home, where his children interacted with it while his wife took pictures.

The Virginia Medical Board discovered this incident after receiving an anonymous tip, leading to an investigation. Dr. Shelley was reprimanded and fined $2,500 for his actions.

The discussion also touches on the public's reaction to the incident and the implications of hiring Dr. Shelley for high-profile criminal cases in Maricopa County despite his past.

TLDR

Dr. Shelley took a dead Marine's brain home, allowing his kids to hold it, leading to a reprimand and fine.

Episode

1:57
00:00:00
The clip starts, and there's this newscaster, and they're like, "A doctor takes a dead Marine's brain home with
00:00:06
him and then allows his kids to hold it and take pictures with it." What? [laughter]
00:00:10
And then the anchor pops in, he's like, "Yeah, a decision that led to this doctor being reprimanded. But it didn't
00:00:16
keep Maricopa County from hiring that very same doctor to work on some of the most high-profile criminal cases."
00:00:24
Okay, sorry. I'm like letting the shock like enter wash over my body. >> That's Dr. Shelley.
00:00:30
Okay. >> [laughter] >> Okay. And this is before he did Laura's autopsy. >> Yeah, before Maricopa County hired him.
00:00:40
Wendy Halloran did a full investigation into Dr. Shelley's past, which revealed that in December 2011, when he was a
00:00:48
military medical examiner in Portsmouth, Virginia, [music] he was performing an autopsy on a Marine
00:00:54
Corps sergeant who was found dead in his home. Afterward, he was meant to take the
00:00:59
brain, considered evidence, Right. >> to a naval hospital in Virginia for further examination. But as I just told
00:01:07
you, that's not what he did. Instead, he took it to his house, took it out of the
00:01:13
stock jar, and handed it to his young kids to feel while his wife took pictures. I'm sorry. I'm like literally
00:01:23
>> [laughter] >> speechless. I have like zero words, but all the questions. >> And Dr. Shelley, he did bring the brain
00:01:28
to the hospital the next day, but Medical Board found out about his like little detour from an anonymous caller,
00:01:35
and then they launched this like whole investigation. >> Yeah, I feel like those pictures have to
00:01:38
live on like the wife's Facebook somewhere. >> to imagine someone saw the pictures, and
00:01:42
that's what prompted the call. I don't know. Trust me, we scoured the internet for these pictures. If they're anywhere
00:01:48
out there, zero luck. Now, the Virginia Medical Board ended up reprimanding Dr. Shelley. They slapped him with a $2,500
00:01:55
fine.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 90
    Most shocking
  • 85
    Most controversial
  • 80
    Most surprising
  • 75
    Most unpredictable

Episode Highlights

  • Doctor's Shocking Decision
    A doctor took a dead Marine's brain home for his kids to hold and photograph.
    “What?”
    @ 00m 08s
    April 14, 2026
  • Investigation Launched
    An anonymous tip led to an investigation into the doctor's actions.
    “The Medical Board found out about his like little detour.”
    @ 01m 32s
    April 14, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • What?
    The Doctor Behind the Autopsy... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast
  • Yeah, a decision that led to this doctor being reprimanded.
    The Doctor Behind the Autopsy... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast
  • I'm like literally speechless. I have like zero words, but all the questions.
    The Doctor Behind the Autopsy... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

Key Moments

  • Shocking Revelation00:08
  • Speechless01:23
  • Investigation01:32