Crime Junkie

Podspun

RETURN TO CHANNEL

Search Captions & Ask AI

They Suspected Him Without Evidence?? #truecrime #unsolvedmysteries

February 01, 2026 / 00:46

This episode discusses the case of Bonnie Lee Schultz, focusing on the investigation into her husband, Rick Schultz, following her disappearance. Key topics include the lack of initial searches in their shared home and garage, and the delayed forensic testing that occurred years later.

Investigators suspected Rick Schultz almost immediately after Bonnie went missing, yet they did not search their house or garage until he was selling the property. This raises questions about the thoroughness of the investigation.

When police finally searched the home, they looked for a stain rumored to be blood but found no evidence of bodily fluids. The episode questions the effectiveness of the investigation given the absence of concrete evidence despite suspicion.

The discussion highlights the challenges of proving guilt without physical evidence, emphasizing the need for a more comprehensive investigation in cases of suspected foul play.

TLDR

The episode examines the flawed investigation into Bonnie Lee Schultz's disappearance and the focus on her husband Rick without sufficient evidence.

Episode

0:46
00:00:01
Police zeroed in on Bonnie Lee Schultz's husband almost immediately when she disappeared. But here's the part that
00:00:08
doesn't add up to me. Even though investigators were suspicious of Rick from the beginning, they didn't search
00:00:15
the house that they shared. They didn't search the garage. Nothing until years later when Rick was selling the home.
00:00:20
That's when police tore up the carpet looking for a stain they'd heard about. It turned out to be nothing. No type of
00:00:25
bodily fluid and that was that. So, I mean, if the theory is that Rick may have followed Bonnie home one night,
00:00:30
wouldn't the garage be the first place that you would look? But no forensic testing was ever done there. So, they
00:00:36
had a suspect, but no evidence. And we have to ask ourselves if suspicion is really enough if there's no real
00:00:43
investigation to back it up.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 60
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • Investigation Oversights
    Despite suspicion of Rick, police failed to search critical areas of the home.
    “They didn't search the house that they shared.”
    @ 00m 12s
    February 01, 2026
  • The Stain That Wasn't
    Years later, police searched for a stain but found no evidence of a crime.
    “It turned out to be nothing. No type of bodily fluid.”
    @ 00m 23s
    February 01, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • If the theory is that Rick may have followed Bonnie home one night...
    They Suspected Him Without Evidence?? #truecrime #unsolvedmysteries
  • They had a suspect, but no evidence.
    They Suspected Him Without Evidence?? #truecrime #unsolvedmysteries
  • We have to ask ourselves if suspicion is really enough.
    They Suspected Him Without Evidence?? #truecrime #unsolvedmysteries

Key Moments

  • Suspicion on Rick00:04
  • Search Delays00:12
  • The Unsearched Garage00:16
  • False Leads00:23
  • Questioning Evidence00:41
Sign Up / LoginHomeAboutFAQLearnContact