00:00:00
The poison bottle that was mentioned in the anonymous letter may have led police
00:00:04
to the wrong suspect. But the email address may have led them to the right one. So when detectives traced the Gmail
00:00:11
account used to order the colchicine, it didn't lead to Adam. It led to Kaitlyn Conley, who is Adam's ex-girlfriend and
00:00:17
the office manager at Mary Ann Bills Chiropractic Office. The colchicine was ordered months before Mary died from the
00:00:24
office computer during business hours. The email account used to complete the purchase was accessed from Katie's home
00:00:30
Wi-Fi and it was later deleted from her phone. On that phone, investigators found
00:00:36
deleted notes referencing the password to the email address. And on her iCloud storage, scanned copies of the documents
00:00:42
used to buy the poison. And last but not least, on the bottle itself was her DNA.
00:00:48
Prosecutors said that Katie poisoned Mary to hurt Adam or to maybe win him back and she was convicted of
00:00:53
manslaughter. But here's the twist. In 2025, her conviction was overturned. Now the evidence is sealed even though
00:01:03
the case is technically unsolved. And Mary Ann Otterness's family is still divided over who killed her.
00:01:09
Do you think Katie was framed? Or do you think she finally just got caught?