Search Captions & Ask AI

Could She Have Walked Away?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

May 05, 2026 / 01:34

This episode discusses the complexities of missing persons cases, focusing on societal expectations of mothers and the possibility of women leaving their families. Key cases mentioned include Brenda Heist, who went missing and returned after 11 years, and Michelle Hunley Smith, who was reported missing in 2001 and resurfaced in 2026.

The conversation highlights the challenges in understanding why a mother might choose to leave her family, contrasting societal views on mothers and fathers. The hosts reflect on the implications of these cases and the narratives surrounding them.

Specific examples are provided to illustrate the point, with references to the public's reaction to these women's disappearances and the suspicion often directed at their partners.

TL;DR

The episode examines societal views on mothers leaving families, citing cases like Brenda Heist and Michelle Hunley Smith.

Episode

1:34
00:00:00
I don't usually ask this
00:00:02
cuz normally I can tell. Uh
00:00:05
but I'm kind of dying to know like what
00:00:07
what do you think? This one genuinely
00:00:09
has me in knots. Like there are very few
00:00:12
cases that have me flip-flopping back
00:00:15
and forth by the day the way that this
00:00:18
one does. You cannot argue with that
00:00:20
video. Like she
00:00:22
left her house on her own. She had a
00:00:25
backpack. She lied to everyone about
00:00:27
what she was doing that day.
00:00:29
I do believe that she wiped her phones.
00:00:33
It is so easy to look at this and say
00:00:36
that she left. Especially the more
00:00:38
stories we hear about other women who
00:00:41
have done the same. I feel like mothers
00:00:43
have this different societal expectation
00:00:45
than father or like men do and it's hard
00:00:48
for us to wrap our minds around a mom
00:00:50
leaving. But it does happen, right? Like
00:00:53
I brought this up in another episode
00:00:54
recently, but there was the case of
00:00:56
Brenda Heist who went missing. Lots of
00:00:58
people side-eyed her husband because
00:01:00
they were about to get a divorce and
00:01:02
then poof, 11 years later she shows back
00:01:05
up. Then I don't know if you saw the
00:01:07
story that like everyone was recently
00:01:08
passing around about that woman in North
00:01:10
Carolina, that mom who went missing in
00:01:11
like 2001.
00:01:12
>> Yeah, um
00:01:14
Michelle Hunley Smith.
00:01:15
>> Mhm. So like her husband reported her
00:01:17
missing, suspicion fell on him. Everyone
00:01:19
assumed the worst and then Michelle
00:01:21
turned up alive in February of 2026
00:01:25
having quietly built a whole new life
00:01:27
somewhere else for more than two
00:01:29
decades.
00:01:30
So it's not beyond the realm of
00:01:32
possibility.

Episode Highlights

  • The Mystery of Missing Mothers
    Exploring societal expectations around mothers leaving their families and notable cases of women who went missing.
    “It's hard for us to wrap our minds around a mom leaving.”
    @ 00m 48s
    May 05, 2026
  • Brenda Heist's Disappearance
    Brenda Heist went missing and reappeared 11 years later, challenging assumptions about her case.
    “Lots of people side-eyed her husband because they were about to get a divorce.”
    @ 00m 58s
    May 05, 2026
  • Michelle Hunley Smith's New Life
    Michelle Hunley Smith was reported missing but turned up alive after building a new life for decades.
    “She turned up alive in February of 2026 having quietly built a whole new life.”
    @ 01m 21s
    May 05, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • I'm kind of dying to know like what you think?
    Could She Have Walked Away?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast
  • You cannot argue with that video.
    Could She Have Walked Away?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast
  • It's hard for us to wrap our minds around a mom leaving.
    Could She Have Walked Away?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast
  • It's not beyond the realm of possibility.
    Could She Have Walked Away?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

Key Moments

  • Dying to Know00:05
  • Mothers and Expectations00:48
  • Missing Women Cases00:58
  • New Life After Disappearance01:21