Search Captions & Ask AI

Could a Necklace Be the Biggest Clue? #truecrime #crimejunkie

January 16, 2026 / 00:43

This episode discusses the missing person case of Bonnie Lee Schultz, focusing on a specific necklace that may hold crucial evidence. The conversation centers around the details of the case, including the significance of the necklace and its connection to Bonnie's disappearance.

Gretchen, Bonnie's daughter, recalls her mother wearing a "number one mom" necklace the night she went out with friends. After Bonnie went missing, Gretchen found the necklace in an unusual location in their home.

The episode raises questions about whether the necklace indicates that Bonnie returned home that night and if it suggests that something happened to her at home.

TLDR

A necklace may be key evidence in Bonnie Lee Schultz's disappearance case.

Episode

0:43
00:00:01
What do you think? Is it possible that a necklace could be one of the biggest clues in one of Indianapolis's longest
00:00:08
standing missing person cases? Here's the deal. Bonnie Lee Schultz's daughter, Gretchen, remembers her mom wearing this
00:00:14
very specific number one mom necklace as she left for a night out with friends. But later, when police visit their home
00:00:20
to talk to her, mom's missing at that point, she presents them with the necklace and says that she found it
00:00:26
inside the house in a place where it wasn't usually kept. So, if she really did leave the house wearing it that
00:00:32
night, does this necklace prove that she made it home? And does it prove that something happened to her there at the
00:00:39
house?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 65
    Biggest twist
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Best concept / idea

Episode Highlights

  • The Mystery of Bonnie Lee Schultz
    A necklace may hold the key to understanding what happened to Bonnie Lee Schultz.
    “Could a necklace be one of the biggest clues?”
    @ 00m 03s
    January 16, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • Does this necklace prove that she made it home?
    Could a Necklace Be the Biggest Clue? #truecrime #crimejunkie

Key Moments

  • Missing Person Case00:08
  • Key Necklace00:14
  • Home Investigation00:18
  • Unusual Discovery00:24