Search Captions & Ask AI

A Ransom Call Comes in The Day After Christmas?! #truecrime #crimejunkie

December 01, 2025 / 01:34

This episode covers a mysterious phone call received by Jean, John's brother-in-law, regarding John's safety. The call occurs on December 26th and again on December 29th, with the caller claiming that John and Shelley are alive and being held in Toronto.

Jean answers the phone on the morning after Christmas, where a man with a raspy voice asks for Ruth and then John's sister. After a brief exchange, Jean hangs up, thinking it was just a strange occurrence. However, three days later, he receives another call from the same man.

During the second call, the man reveals that John and Shelley are alive and demands $10,000 for their return. This shocking revelation raises questions about their whereabouts and safety.

The episode highlights the tension and uncertainty surrounding the situation, leaving listeners wondering about the fate of John and Shelley.

TLDR

A mysterious caller claims John and Shelley are alive and demands $10,000 for their return.

Episode

1:34
00:00:00
And Christmas comes and goes without new developments, good or bad. Though after
00:00:06
Christmas, there is a strange development. It's around 8:00 a.m. the morning after Christmas Day, and John's
00:00:15
brother-in-law, Jean, wakes up to John and Shel's home phone ringing. He and his wife, another of John's sisters,
00:00:21
have been staying at their house taking care of the kids. That's why they're there that morning. So, Jean's still
00:00:26
half asleep when he picks up the phone, but he hears a man with a muffled raspy voice on the other end asking to talk to
00:00:35
Ruth. And he tells this guy like, "No, Ruth is asleep." And so then the man asks for John's sister. Gene obviously
00:00:41
assumes this man is talking about like his wife, but she's asleep, too. So he offers to pass along a message like,
00:00:47
"I'll just tell her when she wakes up." But the man threatens to hang up if Jean
00:00:52
doesn't wake up either his wife or Ruth. And in that moment, Jean is like, "Okay,
00:00:57
whatever, dude." And he hangs up before falling back asleep, thinking like, "Yes, what happened was weird, but like
00:01:04
nothing more." You're right. And nothing else happens the rest of that day. Like he probably doesn't even
00:01:08
think about it a ton. But three days later on December 29th, around the same time, like 8 a.m., Jean gets another
00:01:16
call at the Markley house from what sounds like this same man. This call is short. This guy doesn't ask for Ruth or
00:01:23
his wife again, but he tells Jean that John and Shelley are alive and being held in Toronto, and he can bring them
00:01:31
home for $10,000.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most unpredictable
  • 70
    Most dramatic
  • 70
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • A Mysterious Call
    On December 29th, Jean receives a call stating that John and Shelley are alive and being held for ransom.
    “John and Shelley are alive and being held in Toronto.”
    @ 01m 25s
    December 01, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • John and Shelley are alive and being held in Toronto.
    A Ransom Call Comes in The Day After Christmas?! #truecrime #crimejunkie

Key Moments

  • Strange Phone Call00:06
  • Ransom Demand01:25