Search Captions & Ask AI

Did This Suspect Pass His Polygraph Test?

July 14, 2025 / 01:24

This episode discusses the 1996 extortion case involving Steven and the disappearance of John and Shelley Markley. Key topics include Steven's alibi, his polygraph test, and the police investigation.

Steven claims he was at the mall with his child on New Year's Eve, which coincided with the Markleys' disappearance. His story raises questions about its plausibility, especially given the circumstances of his arrest.

The episode details the specific questions asked during Steven's polygraph test, including whether he was involved in the Markleys' case or knew about their disappearance.

The police hope that the results of the polygraph will clarify Steven's involvement in the case, as they suspect he may be hiding information.

The discussion highlights the complexities of the investigation and the challenges faced by law enforcement in solving the Markley case.

TLDR

Steven's alibi and polygraph test raise doubts about his involvement in the Markley disappearance.

Episode

1:24
00:00:00
On January 3rd, 1996, he pleads innocent to his extortion charge and he gets out
00:00:05
on bond and he agrees to take a polygraph for police ostensibly to try and clear his name.
00:00:11
Okay, but like what's his story? Like he just happened to be in both places. Yes, basically. Yeah. Steven says that
00:00:18
he takes his kid to the mall every weekend and New Year's Eve was no different. And then after that, Deanna
00:00:24
had to use the bathroom so he pulled over at the gas station where they ended up getting arrested. So yeah, him being
00:00:29
there is just one big weird coincidence. Got it. And if I were police, I wouldn't buy
00:00:36
that. Like if Steven's lying about the extortion, then like what else is he lying about? So they're probably hoping
00:00:42
that this polygraph, the one he agreed to, will solve John and Shel's case. So here's what they asked. I actually have
00:00:50
like the questions and answers. I put it in your folder. Okay. He was asked, "Were you involved in John and Shelley
00:00:57
Markley's disappearance in any way?" He says, "Nope." "Did you see John and Shelley Markley
00:01:04
after they were reported missing?" "Nope." Again, do you know where John and Shelley are
00:01:09
now? No. Did you know in advance that John and Shelley Markley had disappeared? Last answer, no.
00:01:17
Okay. And drum roll, please.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 60
    Most heartbreaking

Episode Highlights

  • The Polygraph Questions
    Steven answers 'No' to all questions regarding the Markley case during his polygraph.
    @ 00m 55s
    July 14, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Okay, but like what's his story?
    Did This Suspect Pass His Polygraph Test?
  • So yeah, him being there is just one big weird coincidence.
    Did This Suspect Pass His Polygraph Test?
  • If Steven's lying about the extortion, then like what else is he lying about?
    Did This Suspect Pass His Polygraph Test?
  • Drum roll, please.
    Did This Suspect Pass His Polygraph Test?

Key Moments

  • Polygraph Agreement00:05
  • Weird Coincidence00:29
  • Skepticism00:36
  • Suspense Build-Up01:17