Search Captions & Ask AI

She Kept Waiting For ONE Call... #truecrimeshorts #truecrimestories #crimejunkies #podcast

June 03, 2026 / 01:10

This episode covers the kidnapping of 7-year-old Susie Jaeger, the intense waiting period for her mother Marietta, and the taunting calls from the kidnapper, David Meyerhofer.

Marietta Jaeger became consumed by the need to answer every phone call after her daughter was kidnapped from their family tent. The kidnapper demanded money and claimed Susie was still alive, which led Marietta to stay close to the phone at all times.

The FBI assisted the family by setting up recording equipment to capture any calls from the kidnapper. Marietta answered calls from psychics, strangers, and false leads, believing that any call could be the one that brought her daughter home.

In a twist of fate, Marietta briefly left the house to pick up her son from church, and during that time, the phone rang. It was David Meyerhofer, the man who had taken Susie.

Listen to the full episode for a detailed account of this harrowing case.

TLDR

Marietta Jaeger waited for calls from her daughter's kidnapper, David Meyerhofer, until fate intervened when she briefly left the house.

Episode

1:10
00:00:00
For months, this mother barely left her house because she was waiting for the phone to ring. After 7-year-old Susie
00:00:07
Jaeger was kidnapped from her family tent, her mother, Marietta, became consumed by one thing. Waiting. Because
00:00:14
the kidnapper had called not just once, but he was demanding money, taunting the
00:00:20
family, and claiming that Susie was still alive. So, Marietta basically turned her entire life into one job.
00:00:25
Stay near the phone and answer the next call from the kidnapper. She barely left
00:00:30
the house, and the FBI even helped the family set up recording equipment in case the kidnapper called again. And
00:00:36
every time the phone rang, Marietta answered. She answered calls from psychics and strangers, people having
00:00:42
well wishes, even false leads, but it didn't matter. She picked up every single call because what if that next
00:00:48
call was the one she was waiting for? Well, one day, her son called from church asking for a ride home, and
00:00:54
Marietta leaves the house just for a few minutes. And of course, that is when the
00:00:59
phone rang. And it's the man who took her daughter, David Meyerhofer. Listen to our full episode on the case
00:01:06
this week, only on Crime Junkie.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 85
    Most heartbreaking
  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Biggest twist
  • 75
    Most emotional

Episode Highlights

  • A Mother's Vigil
    Marietta Jaeger waited for months by the phone after her daughter was kidnapped, answering every call in hope.
    “She turned her entire life into one job: waiting.”
    @ 00m 23s
    June 03, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • What if that next call was the one she was waiting for?
    She Kept Waiting For ONE Call... #truecrimeshorts #truecrimestories #crimejunkies #podcast

Key Moments

  • Kidnapping00:07
  • Desperate Waiting00:10
  • The Call00:59