Search Captions & Ask AI

Why Was a Pickle Jar Left Behind?! #unsolvedmysteries #truecrime #crimejunkie

February 25, 2026 / 01:13

This episode discusses the mysterious case of Rachel Hansen, who was shot in her apartment after an intruder left behind a jar of kosher dill pickles. Key topics include the strange break-in, the murder, and the police's handling of evidence.

Rachel Hansen experienced a break-in the night before her murder, where an intruder left an unopened jar of pickles in her kitchen. Initially, she thought it was harmless, possibly related to a former subletter.

After her murder, Rachel's parents found the pickle jar still on the counter when they returned to the apartment. They assumed it had been processed as evidence, but police claimed to have no record of it.

The episode raises questions about the police investigation, particularly regarding the lack of evidence collection and documentation surrounding the pickle jar.

Listeners are left to ponder why such an unusual item was overlooked by law enforcement in a murder case.

TLDR

Rachel Hansen's murder mystery involves an intruder leaving a jar of pickles behind, raising questions about police evidence handling.

Episode

1:13
00:00:00
Here's a question for you. Why would an intruder leave pickles behind? The night
00:00:07
before Rachel Hansen was shot, somebody broke into her apartment while she was asleep. They didn't steal anything. They
00:00:14
didn't hurt her. They just ran when she woke up. But they did leave something behind in the kitchen. This brand new
00:00:21
unopened jar of kosher dill pickles. Now, Rachel thought this incident was strange but harmless. maybe just
00:00:27
somebody who was looking for her former subletter. But then the next night, she's murdered in that same apartment.
00:00:34
And days later, when Rachel's parents were allowed to go back into the apartment, the pickle jar was still
00:00:38
sitting on the counter. So, they assumed that police like fingerprinted it or at
00:00:42
least photographed it. But they hadn't. Her mom later asked detectives about it and they said, "What pickle jar?"
00:00:50
I believe someone within the department at least knew about the pickles because there is this body cam clip where an
00:00:56
officer walks through the apartment at some point and says no pickles and that's it. No evidence log, no photos,
00:01:03
no testing. And I wonder why something like that left behind, something especially something as strange as this
00:01:09
was not treated as evidence.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Best concept / idea
  • 65
    Biggest twist

Episode Highlights

  • Rachel Hansen's Tragic Murder
    Rachel is murdered the night after the strange break-in, raising suspicions about the pickles.
    “But then the next night, she's murdered in that same apartment.”
    @ 00m 29s
    February 25, 2026
  • Neglected Evidence
    Despite the oddity of the pickle jar, police failed to document or test it.
    “What pickle jar?”
    @ 00m 46s
    February 25, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • What pickle jar?
    Why Was a Pickle Jar Left Behind?! #unsolvedmysteries #truecrime #crimejunkie
  • No evidence log, no photos, no testing.
    Why Was a Pickle Jar Left Behind?! #unsolvedmysteries #truecrime #crimejunkie

Key Moments

  • Intruder's Oddity00:03
  • Murder Mystery00:31
  • Ignored Evidence01:03