Search Captions & Ask AI

The FBI Said He Would Call... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

June 05, 2026 / 00:59

This episode discusses the 1974 FBI consultation on the disappearance of 7-year-old Susie Jaeger, focusing on the use of criminal profiling.

Investigators had little information to work with, prompting them to try criminal profiling, a new technique at the time. The FBI agents described a potential suspect as a white male in his 20s, a loner, and likely a former military member.

The profiling included predictions about the suspect's behavior, including a forecast that he would contact Susie's family on the anniversary of her disappearance. Despite these insights, local authorities remained skeptical about the validity of profiling.

The episode highlights the challenges faced by law enforcement in adopting new investigative methods and the initial resistance to criminal profiling.

TLDR

The episode covers the FBI's 1974 criminal profiling in Susie Jaeger's disappearance case and local skepticism about its effectiveness.

Episode

0:59
00:00:00
In 1974, the FBI consulted on a Montana case using something that they'd never actually put into practice yet, criminal
00:00:07
profiling. Early on in the investigation into the disappearance of 7-year-old Susie Jaeger, investigators didn't have
00:00:13
much to go off of, so they were willing to try anything, even this brand new thing that the FBI had called criminal
00:00:20
profiling. And it seemed a little out there to local authorities as agents described perpetrators that they'd never
00:00:27
seen, a white guy in his 20s, a loner, unmarried, who's comfortable outdoors, and former military, socially awkward
00:00:35
around women, and likely someone who inserts himself into investigations. And they even had predictions, not only
00:00:40
about who he is, but about what he was going to do next. They said that the killer was probably going to call
00:00:46
Susie's family on the anniversary of the crime. Well, guess what happened next. Would you believe that even then local
00:00:54
investigators were still questioning whether profiling was legit?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 60
    Most heartbreaking
  • 60
    Best concept / idea

Episode Highlights

  • A Killer's Profile
    Investigators described a potential suspect: a white male in his 20s, a loner, and former military.
    @ 00m 25s
    June 05, 2026
  • A Chilling Prediction
    The FBI predicted the killer would call Susie's family on the anniversary of the crime.
    @ 00m 45s
    June 05, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • Would you believe that even then local investigators were still questioning whether profiling was legit?
    The FBI Said He Would Call... #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

Key Moments

  • Criminal Profiling00:03
  • Susie Jaeger Case00:10
  • Suspect Description00:25
  • Predictions Made00:40
  • Skepticism Remains00:52