
This episode discusses the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of John and Shel, featuring insights from former Sheriff Alier. Key topics include police investigations, tips received, and the involvement of family members.
Former Sheriff Alier confirms that Deanna provided information to the police multiple times since 2015, but she often ghosted or backtracked on her statements. This inconsistency raised suspicions about Steven's involvement in the case.
In 2006, police followed a tip related to a rental property owned by John's sister and her husband. The brother-in-law was reportedly seen digging around the time of the disappearances, prompting police to investigate the septic tank on the property, although they found nothing.
In 2024, police returned to the property with permission to search the septic tank but again did not uncover any evidence. The former sheriff noted that some names were investigated but ultimately eliminated as suspects.
The episode covers the investigation into John and Shel's disappearance, featuring insights from former Sheriff Alier about tips and suspects.

This episode stands out for the following:
It's like when one lead fizzles, another one will pop up.Why Didn't Police Look Inside the Septic Tank?