Crime Junkie

Podspun

RETURN TO CHANNEL

Search Captions & Ask AI

It Was Deleted From YOUR Phone #maryyoder #truecrimepodcast #truecrimestories

March 31, 2026 / 01:10

This episode covers the investigation into Adam Yoder, the discovery of colchicine in his car, and the connection to Katie Conley.

Detectives found a bottle of colchicine in Adam Yoder's car, leading them to trace its origin to a chiropractic office in California. The package was addressed to Adam but signed for by office manager Katie Conley.

Further investigation revealed that the email used to order the colchicine was linked to Katie's home IP address. This raised questions about her involvement.

After discovering that the Gmail account was deleted from her phone shortly after their initial conversation, investigators confronted Katie about the discrepancies.

The episode highlights the unraveling of the case as detectives piece together the evidence against Katie and Adam.

TLDR

Detectives investigate Adam Yoder's colchicine, linking it to Katie Conley and uncovering suspicious email activity.

Episode

1:10
00:00:00
As soon as detectives found the colchicine with the receipt in Adam's car, they began trying to trace where it
00:00:06
came from and who it was shipped to. What they found is that the 1 g bottle of powder was mailed from a company in
00:00:13
California to the Yoder's Chiropractic office in February 2015, addressed to Adam. But, the person who signed for it
00:00:22
was the office manager, Katie Conley. Which isn't unusual, right? She signed for most packages [music] at the
00:00:28
practice. What is unusual is her connection to the email address that ordered it. Google
00:00:35
records show that the email used to buy the colchicine, that Mr. Adam Yoder 1990, it was accessed from the Conley's
00:00:42
home [snorts] IP address, where Katie lives with her family. Then, in late November, that entire Gmail account was
00:00:49
deleted using her phone. So, just a few days after they spoke with Katie, Investigator Van Namey and Lieutenant
00:00:56
Nelson asked her to come back in. And they confront her with what they found. You say you've never heard of Mr. Adam
00:01:03
Yoder 1990 email address, but it was deleted from your phone. How do you explain that?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Biggest twist
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Most unpredictable

Episode Highlights

  • The Colchicine Connection
    Detectives trace colchicine back to Yoder's Chiropractic, revealing a surprising connection to Katie Conley.
    “What is unusual is her connection to the email address that ordered it.”
    @ 00m 33s
    March 31, 2026

Episode Quotes

Key Moments

  • Unexpected Links00:33
  • Email Deletion00:49
  • Confrontation00:56
Sign Up / LoginHomeAboutFAQLearnContact