Search Captions & Ask AI

Why Is It Still Undetermined?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

April 04, 2026 / 01:35

This episode discusses the complex case of Joseph, also known as Jojo, who died after being on a ventilator for several days. Key topics include the medical examiner's testimony regarding the presence of water in Joseph's airways, the implications of asphyxia, and the ongoing debate about the cause of death. The episode highlights the state's argument that Brandon, the only other person in the house, caused the asphyxiation, while the defense maintains it was an accident involving a toy chest.

The medical examiner explains that fluid in the airways does not definitively indicate drowning, especially after prolonged ventilator use. This raises questions about how Joseph's oxygen deprivation occurred. The defense focuses on the possibility of an accidental death related to the toy chest, which has become a focal point in the case.

Listeners hear discussions about the relevance of the toy chest theory, with some questioning its importance in the overall narrative. The episode provides a detailed look at the arguments from both sides, making it clear that the case remains unresolved.

TLDR

The episode examines the controversial case of Joseph's death, focusing on the toy chest theory and conflicting medical testimonies.

Episode

1:35
00:00:00
This one is complicated because of the fact that Jojo didn't die right away, right?
00:00:05
In the hospital for days. >> During this hearing, the medical examiner testifies that there was water
00:00:11
present in Joseph's airways, but that doesn't necessarily mean drowning because Joseph had been on a ventilator
00:00:18
for several days before he died, and the ME testified that fluid in the airways can be consistent with prolonged
00:00:25
ventilator use. So, according to this ME, there is just no way to narrow down the list by
00:00:32
testing for drowning in cases like this, which means the autopsy can say asphyxia, meaning he couldn't get
00:00:39
oxygen. It can say that there is a concern for something, but it can't say how the oxygen deprivation happened.
00:00:47
Now, the state's argument is that if the toy chest theory doesn't work and drowning can't be ruled out and there is
00:00:55
no trauma, then the only explanation left is that someone caused the asphyxiation, and the only someone in
00:01:03
that house was Brandon. But the defense argues that it was an accident inside the toy chest.
00:01:11
>> How are we still talking about this toy chest? Like, it feels irrelevant at this
00:01:15
point. >> is undetermined. And [gasps] maybe maybe because this idea about a kid dying by being locked
00:01:23
in a toy chest didn't just come out of thin air for this case. I mean, I did a quick Google search, and there are
00:01:29
stories of children, mostly younger than Jojo, getting stuck in toy chests.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most controversial
  • 65
    Most intense
  • 60
    Most shocking

Episode Highlights

  • The Complicated Case of Jojo
    The medical examiner's testimony complicates the understanding of Jojo's death, leaving many questions unanswered.
    “There is just no way to narrow down the list by testing for drowning in cases like this.”
    @ 00m 29s
    April 04, 2026
  • The Toy Chest Debate
    The defense argues it was an accident inside the toy chest, while the state points to asphyxiation.
    “If the toy chest theory doesn't work... then the only explanation left is that someone caused the asphyxiation.”
    @ 00m 50s
    April 04, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • How are we still talking about this toy chest?
    Why Is It Still Undetermined?? #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts #crimejunkies #podcast

Key Moments

  • Medical Testimony00:06
  • Asphyxia Explained00:37
  • Accident or Intent?01:07
  • Frustration Over Evidence01:13
  • Real-Life Implications01:21