Search Captions & Ask AI

What Was the Biggest Clue She Left Behind? #truecrime #crimejunkie #podcast

September 19, 2025 / 01:34

This episode discusses the cases of Gerald and Dawn, focusing on the judge's harsh remarks about Gerald and the clues in Dawn's diary. Key topics include the judge's description of Gerald as dangerous, the ongoing investigation into Dawn's disappearance, and her complicated feelings for two men, Dan and Nick Katona.

The judge in Gerald's case described him as the most dangerous and remorseless defendant seen in 20 years. This statement sets the tone for the discussion about the implications of his character on the case.

Attention shifts to Dawn's case, where the focus is on her diary, which she started shortly before her disappearance. Notably, the diary does not mention Hawkins or Gerald, but instead details her feelings about her boyfriend Dan and another man, Nick Katona.

Dawn's sister, Kath, reads excerpts from the diary, highlighting Dawn's emotional state and her dissatisfaction in her relationship. This adds a personal touch to the investigation, suggesting that there may be more to the story than initially thought.

The episode encourages listeners to consider the overlooked clues in Dawn's life, emphasizing the importance of her diary in understanding her situation.

TLDR

The episode examines Gerald's dangerous reputation and Dawn's diary, revealing her emotional struggles and potential clues in her disappearance.

Episode

1:34
00:00:00
The judge in Gerald's case called him quote the most dangerous, remorseless, callous defendant I have seen in my 20
00:00:09
years as a judge, >> which I feel like I can't disagree, but now with Don's case, they're back to
00:00:17
Hawkins. Honestly, never really got off him. And again, I get why, but I also again ask, what if the obvious thing
00:00:28
distracted police from the real thing? What if for all these years people ignored the one clue that Dawn herself
00:00:38
left behind, her diary? In this diary, which she seems to have started just three months before her disappearance,
00:00:46
Dawn doesn't mention Hawkins once, and she certainly doesn't say anything about Gerald Bennett. What Dawn does write
00:00:55
about is cheating on her boyfriend, Dan. From her writings, it seems like Dawn had been getting a little bored in her
00:01:03
relationship with Dan. And somehow while in this unsatisfied state, she meets this guy named Nick Katona.
00:01:12
I don't really know how, but she devotes most of the pages of her diary to venting about her complicated feelings
00:01:19
for Dan and Nick. We actually have a copy of Don's diary, which we're going to put in the fan club app if you want
00:01:26
to see it. But Dawn's sister Kath actually read some parts of her diary aloud for us to share.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Biggest twist
  • 65
    Most heartbreaking
  • 65
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • The Judge's Harsh Words
    The judge in Gerald's case called him the most dangerous, remorseless defendant he's seen in 20 years.
    “the most dangerous, remorseless, callous defendant I have seen in my 20 years as a judge”
    @ 00m 02s
    September 19, 2025
  • Dawn's Diary Reveals Secrets
    Dawn's diary, started just months before her disappearance, reveals her complicated feelings for two men.
    “Dawn doesn't mention Hawkins once, and she certainly doesn't say anything about Gerald Bennett.”
    @ 00m 46s
    September 19, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Dawn doesn't mention Hawkins once, and she certainly doesn't say anything about Gerald Bennett.
    What Was the Biggest Clue She Left Behind? #truecrime #crimejunkie #podcast

Key Moments

  • Dawn's Diary00:38
  • Complicated Feelings01:09