Search Captions & Ask AI

Why Have You Never Heard About This Baffling Case?! #truecrime #crimejunkie

November 13, 2025 / 01:43

This episode covers the mysterious case of Teresa Flores and Martha Mesa, two girls who vanished in San Miguel, California, 45 years ago. It discusses the enduring investigation led by a retired detective who solved Kristin Smart's case.

Hosts Ashley Flowers and Britt introduce the story, emphasizing that the case of Flores and Mesa is lesser-known compared to Kristin Smart's, despite its baffling nature. The girls disappeared in broad daylight, and their bodies were later discovered, leaving many questions unanswered.

The episode highlights the current efforts of the lead detective, who has returned from retirement to pursue new leads and DNA evidence. This detective previously solved the Kristin Smart case in 2022, adding urgency to the investigation.

Listeners learn about the challenges faced by law enforcement and the importance of resolving this case for the families involved. The episode underscores the hope for justice as the investigation progresses.

TLDR

The episode discusses the unsolved case of two girls who vanished in San Miguel, California, and the renewed investigation led by a retired detective.

Episode

1:43
00:00:00
Hi Crime Junkies, I'm your host Ashley Flowers. >> And I'm Britt. And the story I have for
00:00:03
you today is one of the San Luis Obispo Sheriff's office's most enduring [music]
00:00:09
mysteries. And it's not the one that you're probably thinking of. I mean, for most Crime Junkies, when you hear San
00:00:14
Luis Obispo, one thing comes to mind. >> Yeah, Kristin Smart. Exactly. But her case, now solved, was never the most
00:00:22
baffling one. Far from it. The strangest case that the Sheriff's office is tasked
00:00:28
with solving is [music] from 16 years before Kristin Smart went missing, when two little [music] girls vanished off
00:00:35
the street in broad daylight in the middle of San Miguel, a town with only 800-ish residents. [music] Everyone is a
00:00:43
suspect, and every theory is still on the table, even after their bodies were discovered [music] and there were plenty
00:00:50
of strange clues and physical evidence. The only reason you don't know about this case is because it's never been
00:00:58
told in full before. Not until today. And this is one that you're going to want to pay attention to, because even
00:01:04
though this [music] case is 45 years old, big things are about to happen. The current lead detective on this case
00:01:10
literally came out of retirement just to solve it. And he just so happens to be the same guy who solved Kristin Smart's
00:01:17
case in 2022. And he has fresh leads and DNA on his side [music] now for this case, and it's closer than ever before
00:01:26
to being solved. But now it's a race against time to make sure that justice comes while the girls' families are
00:01:32
still alive to witness it. This is the story of Teresa Flores and Martha Mesa.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Best concept / idea

Episode Highlights

  • The Vanishing of Two Girls
    A baffling case from 45 years ago resurfaces as new leads emerge.
    “The strangest case that the Sheriff's office is tasked with solving.”
    @ 00m 26s
    November 13, 2025
  • A Detective's Comeback
    The lead detective comes out of retirement to solve the cold case.
    “He literally came out of retirement just to solve it.”
    @ 01m 10s
    November 13, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • This is one that you're going to want to pay attention to.
    Why Have You Never Heard About This Baffling Case?! #truecrime #crimejunkie
  • It's a race against time to make sure that justice comes.
    Why Have You Never Heard About This Baffling Case?! #truecrime #crimejunkie

Key Moments

  • Baffling Mystery00:26
  • Fresh Leads01:10
  • Race Against Time01:28