RETURN TO CHANNEL

Search Captions & Ask AI

A Letter From "Pastor Justice”? #truecrime #crimejunkie #mystery

October 03, 2025 / 00:37

This episode covers the mysterious letter received by Janice regarding her daughter Cherry Mayhem's disappearance, the involvement of a supposed cult, and the search conducted by police.

In 2018, Janice, the mother of missing Cherry Mayhem, received a handwritten letter claiming that her daughter had been murdered by a cult. The letter, signed by someone named Pastor Justice, included details about where Cherry's body could supposedly be found.

Despite the alarming claims, police conducted a search in the area mentioned in the letter but found no evidence of Cherry's remains. The episode raises questions about whether the letter was a genuine lead or simply a cruel hoax.

The discussion includes the emotional impact on Janice and the ongoing mystery surrounding Cherry's disappearance, highlighting the challenges faced by families of missing persons.

TLDR

A mysterious letter claims Cherry Mayhem was murdered, but police find no evidence, raising questions about its authenticity.

Episode

0:37

00:00:00

What if a mysterious letter showed up in your mailbox and claimed to have the answers to an unsolved disappearance?

00:00:07

Well, in 2018, Missing Cherry Mayhem's mom, Janice, received a handwritten note claiming that her daughter, Cherry, had

00:00:14

been murdered by a supposed cult. It even described where Cher's body could be found. But strangest of all, the

00:00:22

letter was signed Pastor Justice. Now, police searched the area that the letter described, but found nothing. So, was

00:00:30

the mystery letter a real lead or just a cruel hoax?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

80
Most shocking
75
Most heartbreaking
70
Most dramatic
70
Best concept / idea

Episode Highlights

The Mysterious Letter
In 2018, Janice received a note claiming her daughter Cherry was murdered by a cult.
“It even described where Cher's body could be found.”
@ 00m 12s
October 03, 2025

Episode Quotes

Was the mystery letter a real lead or just a cruel hoax?
A Letter From "Pastor Justice”? #truecrime #crimejunkie #mystery

Key Moments

Cult Accusation00:14
Search for Truth00:25