Search Captions & Ask AI

How was the Unlimited Suspect Pool Was Limited Down to 3 People? #truecrime #crimejunkie

September 06, 2025 / 01:40

This episode covers the investigation into Jod's murder, focusing on the suspects Steven and David, both deceased. It discusses the challenges of obtaining DNA evidence from them and the police's strategy to reconstruct David's DNA using his ex-wife and son's samples.

The episode highlights that Steven died in an accident in 2017, and his DNA was available but did not match. The investigation then shifted to David, who passed away in 2011, complicating matters further.

Detective Co proposed using the DNA of David's ex-wife and son to create a profile of David. The episode raises the tension of the police needing permission from the family without them knowing the full details of the investigation.

TLDR

The investigation into Jod's murder focuses on deceased suspects Steven and David, with efforts to reconstruct David's DNA from living relatives.

Episode

1:40
00:00:00
In a matter of like a year, he went from an endless pool of suspects to three. Now, as it turns out, both Steven and
00:00:07
David were deceased at this point. They both died after Jod's murder, so that doesn't rule them out, but it does make
00:00:14
getting their DNA slightly more challenging, >> or at least it might have. You see,
00:00:19
Steven passed away in an accident in 2017, which meant that his DNA was actually still on file at the medical
00:00:25
examiner's office. So they get it, they run it, and it's not Steven. As for the dad, Robert, he was totally estranged
00:00:35
from his sons and living in a different area at the time of the murder. Plus, just looking at his age and capability,
00:00:43
like they didn't think they were necessarily compatible with the specific manner of the crime,
00:00:48
>> which really like if they're going to look at anyone, their next person they want to look at is David.
00:00:55
Now, they find out he passed away in 2011, and his DNA is nowhere to be found, but he does have an ex-wife and
00:01:05
an 18-year-old son that are both still living right there in Carlsbad. So, Co gets this idea to have the lab do a sort
00:01:13
of paternity test where they could use the ex-wife's DNA, the son's DNA to basically reconstruct David's. But
00:01:21
obviously like he's going to need permission for that. >> And at this point, no one in the Mabrito
00:01:26
family even knows that police are like going down this road. Can you imagine like the police showing up at your door
00:01:32
and being like, "Hey, we think your ex-husband did this absolutely horrific thing 10 years ago if you knew about

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most intense
  • 60
    Most heartbreaking
  • 60
    Best concept / idea

Episode Highlights

  • Reconstructing DNA
    Police consider using family DNA to reconstruct a deceased suspect's profile.
    “Co gets this idea to have the lab do a sort of paternity test.”
    @ 01m 11s
    September 06, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Can you imagine the police showing up at your door?
    How was the Unlimited Suspect Pool Was Limited Down to 3 People? #truecrime #crimejunkie

Key Moments

  • Deceased Suspects00:07
  • DNA Challenge00:14
  • Family Involvement01:24