Search Captions & Ask AI

Murder by Mushroom?!? #truecrime #murder #crimejunkie #australia #mushrooms

August 07, 2025 / 02:59

This episode covers the case of Aaron Patterson, who allegedly poisoned her arranged family during a dinner. Key discussions include the details of the dinner, the health issues that led to the gathering, and the subsequent poisoning incident involving death cap mushrooms.

Aaron invited her arranged husband Simon and his family for a lunch to discuss her health, claiming she had cancer. However, Simon refused to attend, leading to a dinner where Aaron served beef Wellington. After the meal, multiple guests fell seriously ill.

The source of the illness was traced back to the mushrooms in the beef Wellington. Police began investigating Aaron, suspecting she had intentionally poisoned her family. Evidence included CCTV footage and discrepancies in her health claims.

The episode discusses the trial and the various theories surrounding Aaron's motivations, making it a complex and intriguing case.

TLDR

Aaron Patterson allegedly poisoned her family with mushrooms during a dinner, leading to a criminal investigation and trial.

Episode

2:59
00:00:00
So, I'm finally covering it. So, this is Aaron Patterson, and one day in the summer of 2023, she goes up to her
00:00:07
aranged husband, her in-laws, and she's like, "Hey, I would love to have this lunch in a couple of weeks." The
00:00:14
implication was there was like a health related thing going on that she needed to have a serious conversation about.
00:00:19
So, her aranged husband, his parents, and his aunt and uncle, they all come together and they're like, "Okay, yes,
00:00:25
of course. Like, we'll be there for you." Now, the night before this lunch is supposed to happen, her aranged
00:00:30
husband, Simon, texts her and he's like, "I just like don't want to pretend like
00:00:33
everything's fine. I'm happy to have a phone call with you to talk about whatever hell things, but I'm not coming
00:00:38
to lunch." And she fires back in her text and is just is pretty frustrated. This might be one of the last meals that
00:00:44
I can host like this. Like, it would be really disappointing if you weren't there. He doesn't come. So, the rest of
00:00:50
them come over. They all sit around this table and they enjoy beef Wellington that Aaron had made them. And at some
00:00:58
point during the dinner, she lets all of them know that she has cancer. By that night, when they all go home, everyone
00:01:05
is getting super sick. This is Simon's parents, Don and Gail. They end up going to the hospital by ambulance. Simon ends
00:01:12
up driving his aunt and uncle, Heather and Ian, to a different hospital so they can get treatment. But guess who's not
00:01:19
sick? But the four of the people who had London, four or five are like on death's
00:01:25
doorstep. And for some reason, Aaron is like, "I'm all right." Now, it doesn't take long to narrow down the source of
00:01:34
everyone's illness to the beef Wellington that she made, specifically to the mushrooms. And what the doctors
00:01:40
decide is they likely had what is what they know as death cap mushrooms. And they end up going and getting leftovers
00:01:47
from her trash and determining like, "Yes, these poisonous mushrooms were in the beef Wellington." Pretty quickly,
00:01:53
police start building a case against Aaron, saying like, "You intentionally poisoned your entire family to kill
00:01:59
them." Or she says, "Oh no, I bought those from some Asian ger." By the way, I can't tell you which one. This is a
00:02:07
terrible accident. But is it? Because this is CCTV footage of Aaron dumping the dehydrator. Oh, and by the way, she
00:02:18
doesn't have cancer. She doesn't have many health issues. The police are saying, "You basically made a ruse to
00:02:22
make everyone come over." She is saying that, "Well, I was having this other procedure. I made this up so that they
00:02:30
would still like help me post surgery. The place that she said she booked it didn't even offer that kind of surgery."
00:02:35
Now, this case just came to a close. She went to trial. She had some wild stories. And the really big question is
00:02:44
why? We in our episode of Crime Junkie that comes out this week, August 4th, we dig into all of it. Um there is
00:02:52
potentially a why. We go through all the details, all the evidence, her story. It
00:02:56
is bananas. Don't miss the episode.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 90
    Biggest twist
  • 85
    Most intense
  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 80
    Most surprising

Episode Highlights

  • A Lunch to Remember
    Aaron invites her family for a serious conversation, but her husband refuses to attend.
    “This might be one of the last meals that I can host like this.”
    @ 00m 43s
    August 07, 2025
  • The Poisonous Dinner
    Aaron's beef Wellington leads to a hospital emergency for her family, raising suspicions.
    “You basically made a ruse to make everyone come over.”
    @ 02m 21s
    August 07, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • You basically made a ruse to make everyone come over.
    Murder by Mushroom?!? #truecrime #murder #crimejunkie #australia #mushrooms

Key Moments

  • Cancer Revelation00:59
  • Family Emergency01:08
  • Poisoning Accusation01:55
  • Trial and Evidence02:38

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown