Search Captions & Ask AI

Who Pretended to be Police to the Victim's Family?!

June 13, 2025 / 01:51

This episode discusses a mysterious confession made by a man regarding the deaths of Sarah and Linda, and the implications for Sarah's mother.

The man claims that John confessed to killing Sarah and torturing Linda before her death, but he does not mention Kimberly. This revelation leaves Sarah's mother in shock.

After the man's visit, he leaves a business card, promising to return with updates. However, when Sarah's family tries to follow up, the number is busy, and local police have no record of the visitors.

The episode raises questions about the identity and motives of the man who visited, leaving listeners wondering about the authenticity of his claims.

Overall, the episode highlights the confusion and frustration surrounding the investigation into these tragic events.

TLDR

A man claims John killed Sarah and tortured Linda, leaving her mother confused and seeking answers.

Episode

1:51
00:00:00
According to Tiffany, the man tells Sarah's mom that one night he sat around a fire with John and a few other people.
00:00:09
Everyone was drinking and John made a confession that he quote killed two birds with one stone. Now, we don't know
00:00:16
what that vague statement means, but this guy goes on to say that John said he killed Sarah first and then he
00:00:23
tortured Linda for a long time before finally killing her. But the thing is, he never said anything about killing
00:00:30
Kimberly. So, he drops this bomb on her, on Sarah's mom, telling her that her daughter and possibly her granddaughter
00:00:37
are gone. And then the man's like, "Okay, listen. We're going to come back to you as soon as we make an arrest."
00:00:43
Like, basically, it almost feels like a heads up. Mhm. So, they leave her a business card and they take off. But
00:00:49
here's the thing. Tiffany told us that when she called the number on the card a week later because she hadn't heard
00:00:56
anything, it was just like a busy tone on the other end. And when the family checked with Doorchester and Orangeberg
00:01:05
PD, neither had any idea who those people were that showed up. I mean, okay, okay,
00:01:14
my head is spinning. Like, who were these people? What did they look like? Did they look official? Like and also
00:01:20
like obviously this feels super hoaxy, right? But like but yeah, like but what's the point? What's the end goal of
00:01:28
of doing this? And to go there twice and then come back with an additional person
00:01:35
and leave a card. Like I wish it was this was stuff that they had like kept. I mean, not that we could even do
00:01:39
anything with it now, but like but it's like so much work has to go into like making that feel official and coming
00:01:44
back multiple times and like again years later. Yeah. I don't get it.

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most heartbreaking
  • 70
    Most shocking
  • 70
    Most unpredictable
  • 65
    Most intense

Episode Highlights

  • A Shocking Confession
    John allegedly confessed to killing Sarah and torturing Linda, leaving her family devastated.
    “He killed Sarah first and then he tortured Linda for a long time before finally killing her.”
    @ 00m 23s
    June 13, 2025
  • Mysterious Visitors
    Tiffany's family receives a visit from mysterious individuals claiming to have information.
    “Who were these people? What did they look like?”
    @ 01m 14s
    June 13, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Like, basically, it almost feels like a heads up.
    Who Pretended to be Police to the Victim's Family?!
  • I mean, okay, okay, my head is spinning.
    Who Pretended to be Police to the Victim's Family?!
  • I wish it was stuff that they had like kept.
    Who Pretended to be Police to the Victim's Family?!

Key Moments

  • Shocking Revelation00:11
  • Mysterious Visitors00:47
  • Frustration and Confusion01:41