Search Captions & Ask AI

Should've the Key Evidence Never Been Used?? #maryyoder #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts

March 31, 2026 / 00:27

This episode covers the trial of Katie, who was convicted of first-degree manslaughter in the death of Mary Yoder. Key topics include the mistrial, jury deadlock, and questions surrounding the evidence used in the case.

Katie's first trial ended in a mistrial after the jury was split 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal. The prosecution pursued a second trial, which resulted in her conviction in 2017.

Despite the conviction, the episode raises concerns about the validity of the key evidence that led to her sentencing of 23 years. The discussion questions whether the evidence should have been admissible in court.

TLDR

Katie's manslaughter conviction raises questions about key evidence used in her trial.

Episode

0:27
00:00:00
After 3 weeks, no verdict. Katie's first trial in the murder of Mary Yoder ended
00:00:05
in a mistrial. The jury was deadlocked, 10 to 2 for acquittal. But prosecutors tried again, and in
00:00:11
2017, Katie was convicted not of murder, but of first-degree manslaughter. She was sentenced to 23 years.
00:00:18
Case closed? Not even close. Because what if the key evidence should have never been used?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most heartbreaking
  • 60
    Most shocking
  • 60
    Best concept / idea
  • 60
    Most controversial

Episode Highlights

  • Katie's Conviction
    In 2017, Katie was convicted of first-degree manslaughter and sentenced to 23 years.
    “But prosecutors tried again, and in 2017, Katie was convicted not of murder, but of first-degree manslaughter.”
    @ 00m 10s
    March 31, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • Case closed? Not even close.
    Should've the Key Evidence Never Been Used?? #maryyoder #truecrimestories #truecrimeshorts

Key Moments

  • Mistrial00:05
  • Conviction00:14
  • Key Evidence Questioned00:22