Search Captions & Ask AI

8 Episodes that Define Crime Junkie #crimejunkiespodcast #truecrime

December 30, 2025 / 03:00

This episode features a discussion on eight significant cases that have defined the Crime Junkie podcast, including Israel Keyes, JonBenét Ramsey, and the Alphabet Murders.

Ashley Flowers and Brit reflect on the impact of Israel Keyes, noting how frequently listeners mention this case as a gateway to the podcast. They emphasize its lasting relevance in the Crime Junkie community.

The hosts discuss their first episode on Nikki and Allen, highlighting the immediate feedback they received from the victim's daughter, which shaped their approach to storytelling.

JonBenét Ramsey is mentioned as a pivotal case that illustrates their growth, culminating in an interview with John Ramsey years later. They also touch on the exoneration of James Reyes, showcasing the community's role in seeking justice.

Other cases discussed include the local Indianapolis case of Sherrice Walker Bingham and the issue of sexstortion, emphasizing their commitment to important exposé pieces that resonate with listeners.

TLDR

Ashley and Brit discuss eight defining cases of Crime Junkie, including Israel Keyes and JonBenét Ramsey, reflecting on their impact and listener engagement.

Episode

3:00
00:00:00
Hi Crime Junkies. I'm Ashley Flowers. >> And I'm Brit. In honor of our 8th year anniversary birthday podcast thing,
00:00:08
we're going to talk about eight cases that really defined Crime Junkie. The first one is Israel Keyes.
00:00:15
>> Mostly because it's one that no matter how long ago we did it, everyone brings
00:00:19
it up and somehow he's the guy that like comes up anytime like we don't know what
00:00:22
happened. Could it have been Israel? If it happened before 2012, could it have been?
00:00:26
>> Truly anytime someone comes up and is like, "Oh, I listen to Crime Junkie." or
00:00:30
"I introduced my friend, my significant other to Crime Junkie." it's always because I listened to Israel Keyes, I
00:00:35
showed them Israel Keyes and now we can't stop listening. I honestly think one of like the case that defines us is
00:00:42
the first one that we did, Nikki and Allen. So it was quite literally episode one of Crime Junkie and a couple of days
00:00:47
later I got an email from her daughter and it was like that realization from day one, hey the people you're talking
00:00:53
about are going to hear this and I think it it really like shaped how we think about cases.
00:00:58
>> The case we said we'd never do, JonBenét Ramsey. I I yes, I think it's a a lesson
00:01:05
to never say never. Uh-huh. And this was one where I mean like when you think about how far we've come, like JonBenét
00:01:12
Ramsey was the case that like we knew as little Crime Junkies and you know 30-some years later to be like sitting
00:01:17
in John Ramsey's home across from him and telling the story that we know so deeply. Really really mind-blowing.
00:01:25
Father Patrick Ryan and the exoneration of James Reyes. Just I think it's a a real example of
00:01:32
not only like what the show can do just by getting the word out. >> What our listeners can do. Yeah. Like
00:01:36
it's only because somebody heard that episode and was like, "I should mention this."
00:01:41
>> I should ask a question. And I should go do the thing. Like incredible what the
00:01:45
community is capable of. Also think a big one is Alphabet Murders. Which is like not one that a lot a lot
00:01:51
of people talk about. >> Sleeper hit. >> But it was the biggest episode of 2024 which beat out Donald Trump on Joe
00:01:59
Rogan. Which that is a bad job always there. Another episode is What Serial Didn't
00:02:04
Tell You. It set the precedent for like what I wanted to do which was like as a Crime Junkie, there's like you often get
00:02:10
like this this like one version of things and that doesn't mean it's all that's all that's out there.
00:02:15
>> [laughter] >> I think the next one would be like Sherrice Walker Bingham. It's a local
00:02:19
Indianapolis case. It's still unsolved. >> And a ton of original investigative reporting here.
00:02:24
>> why it stands out to me. That was the first time we had just brought in Nina who's still
00:02:28
with us. >> Nina. And it was the first case like she did from top to bottom where you really
00:02:32
couldn't find that story anywhere else. Another one that comes to mind is sexstortion and online scams.
00:02:38
Some of the episodes that I most enjoy doing and that I think are most important for our community of Crime
00:02:44
Junkies is our big exposé pieces like that where it's not just one story, it's a bunch of little stories that's
00:02:50
happening every day to people. >> There's our eight cases that like I we feel like really shaped the show. We
00:02:55
would love to hear from you. Like what's the stand out? What brought you to Crime
00:02:58
Junkie? What keeps you here?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 70
    Most iconic
  • 70
    Best concept / idea
  • 70
    Most iconic moment
  • 65
    Best overall

Episode Highlights

  • The Case That Defines Us
    Israel Keyes is the case everyone brings up when discussing Crime Junkie.
    “If it happened before 2012, could it have been?”
    @ 00m 24s
    December 30, 2025
  • JonBenét Ramsey Reflection
    Reflecting on how far they've come since discussing JonBenét Ramsey.
    “Really really mind-blowing.”
    @ 01m 22s
    December 30, 2025
  • Impact of Community
    Listeners have the power to make a difference, as shown by James Reyes' exoneration.
    “Incredible what the community is capable of.”
    @ 01m 47s
    December 30, 2025

Episode Quotes

  • Could it have been Israel?
    8 Episodes that Define Crime Junkie #crimejunkiespodcast #truecrime
  • I think it's a lesson to never say never.
    8 Episodes that Define Crime Junkie #crimejunkiespodcast #truecrime
  • Incredible what the community is capable of.
    8 Episodes that Define Crime Junkie #crimejunkiespodcast #truecrime

Key Moments

  • 8th Anniversary00:02
  • Israel Keyes00:13
  • JonBenét Ramsey00:58
  • James Reyes Exoneration01:28
  • Alphabet Murders01:50
  • Sherrice Walker Bingham02:17
  • Sexstortion Exposé02:36

Words per Minute Over Time

Vibes Breakdown