Search Captions & Ask AI

A Confirmed Poisoning… but NO Investigation had started #truecrimeshorts #maryyoder

March 23, 2026 / 01:02

This episode covers the poisoning case of Mary Yoder, the lack of investigation, and her family's efforts to seek justice. Key discussions include the role of the Oneida County Sheriff's Office and the medical examiner's findings.

Mary Yoder died from a colchicine overdose, a drug she was not prescribed. After her death, her family assumed law enforcement was investigating. However, they discovered that no investigation had been initiated.

Mary's sister, Sharon, took the initiative to contact the Oneida County Sheriff's Office to inquire about the case. She was shocked to learn there was no open investigation despite the medical examiner's ruling of poisoning.

The episode raises questions about how a confirmed poisoning could go uninvestigated for weeks, highlighting failures in communication between medical and law enforcement agencies.

Ultimately, it took the family's persistence to prompt the police to open a case, emphasizing the challenges faced by families seeking justice in similar situations.

TLDR

Mary Yoder's poisoning went uninvestigated until her sister intervened.

Episode

1:02
00:00:00
Mary Yoder was poisoned, and no one was investigating. After toxicology confirmed that Mary
00:00:06
died from a massive colchicine overdose, a drug that by the way she was not even
00:00:11
prescribed, her family, specifically her sisters, assumed that police were on it.
00:00:16
So, they waited for updates, or for interviews, or for someone to ask some questions, but nothing came.
00:00:21
So, in mid-October, Mary's sister Sharon picked up the phone and called the Oneida County Sheriff's Office herself.
00:00:28
She basically said like, "Hey, my sister died from a medication that she wasn't taking. What's happening with the case?"
00:00:34
And the response was, "What case?" There was no open investigation. The medical examiner had
00:00:40
ruled her death a poisoning, but law enforcement had never been notified. Somewhere along the way, the findings
00:00:46
just weren't passed on. And Mary's husband hadn't alerted authorities, either. So, it took her sister pushing
00:00:52
for answers for police to finally open a case. How does a confirmed poisoning sit for
00:00:58
weeks without a criminal investigation?

Badges

This episode stands out for the following:

  • 80
    Most shocking
  • 75
    Most heartbreaking
  • 75
    Best concept / idea
  • 70
    Most dramatic

Episode Highlights

  • Sister's Determination
    Sharon Yoder took matters into her own hands by contacting the sheriff's office.
    “Hey, my sister died from a medication that she wasn't taking.”
    @ 00m 26s
    March 23, 2026
  • Negligence in Investigation
    Authorities failed to act on a confirmed poisoning, raising serious questions.
    “How does a confirmed poisoning sit for weeks without a criminal investigation?”
    @ 00m 58s
    March 23, 2026

Episode Quotes

  • Hey, my sister died from a medication that she wasn't taking.
    A Confirmed Poisoning… but NO Investigation had started #truecrimeshorts #maryyoder
  • What case?
    A Confirmed Poisoning… but NO Investigation had started #truecrimeshorts #maryyoder
  • How does a confirmed poisoning sit for weeks without a criminal investigation?
    A Confirmed Poisoning… but NO Investigation had started #truecrimeshorts #maryyoder

Key Moments

  • Sister's Call00:26
  • Investigation Delayed00:58