00:00:09
[Music] our episodes deal with serious and often distressing incidents if you feel at any
00:00:17
time you need support please contact your local crisis center for suggested phone numbers for confidential support
00:00:23
please see the show notes for this episode on your app or on our website [Music]
00:00:33
karina homer scratched the final panel on the lottery ticket and was surprised to discover that she'd won 10 000
00:00:39
swedish krona the win couldn't have come at a better time it was only one week until 19 year old
00:00:47
karina was set to leave her small swedish village in shillinghard to travel to the usa
00:00:54
her unexpected but welcome windfall which in 1996 was the equivalent of roughly 1500 us dollars granted karina
00:01:03
extra spending money for her overseas adventure karina wasn't going to the united states
00:01:10
just for a holiday she had signed up to be an au pair with a company in sweden that matched young women with american
00:01:17
families looking for nannies karina would provide childcare and light housekeeping duties to her host family
00:01:25
and in return they would give her board and a small allowance one of karina's three sisters previously
00:01:32
worked as an au pair and had encouraged her to do the same as a way to experience living
00:01:38
overseas the arrangement would also help karina save money which she could put towards pursuing her ultimate career
00:01:46
goal of becoming a restaurant manager driven and passionate karina had already completed trade school in the
00:01:53
hospitality industry the company matched carina with a family in the affluent town of dover around 15
00:02:02
miles southwest of downtown boston massachusetts she was looking forward to exploring
00:02:09
boston as she'd never experienced life in a bustling city before in march 1996 karina prepared to leave
00:02:19
her small village of fewer than 100 people fedova which had a population of around four thousand
00:02:27
although outgoing and social karina was quite dependent on her friends and family
00:02:34
by working in america she hoped to show her parents that she could stand on her own two feet
00:02:41
karina was happy and excited as she farewelled her family at the airport just before she boarded the plane she
00:02:49
said i hope i'm doing the right thing [Music] [Music] upon arriving in dover karina settled in
00:03:20
well with her host family forty-three-year-old frank rapp worked as a photographer
00:03:26
his wife susan nichter was an artist who painted for a living the couple had two children
00:03:34
a six-year-old boy and a toddler-aged daughter frank and susan weren't strangers to
00:03:41
hosting an au pair karina was the sixth swedish nanny to stay with them described by neighbours as a well-to-do
00:03:50
couple frank and susan's three-story landscaped home offered carina ample space and privacy when needed
00:04:00
naturally athletic as a pony club member and one-time girl scout karina spent her
00:04:05
days playing games such as soccer and basketball with the children her time was also spent completing
00:04:12
household chores the two children quickly grew fond of karina who was gentle patient
00:04:20
affectionate and optimistic in the evenings she often joined other au pairs at nightclubs and cafes in the
00:04:28
boston area she formed close friendships with her colleagues and the young women bonded
00:04:34
over their shared experiences in a foreign country [Music] as karina only worked weekdays frank
00:04:42
rapp made her an offer it was one he had made to all the nannies who had looked after his
00:04:48
children in the past on weekends karina could crash at his loft apartment in south boston which he
00:04:55
used as a photography studio this would allow her to enjoy boston on her days off without having to worry
00:05:03
about making her way back to dover each night karina eagerly accepted and spent the
00:05:10
majority of her weekends in the city with her au pair friends one of the most exciting dates on the
00:05:18
swedish calendar is mid-summer celebrated at the summer solstice the longest day of the year
00:05:25
on friday june 21 1996 when karina holmer was three months into her american adventure she decided that
00:05:33
being on the other side of the world gave her no less reason to celebrate karina told her host family that she
00:05:45
planned to go to boston for the weekend and would be back on sunday evening she pulled on a grey and silver sweater
00:05:53
shiny grey pants and black ankle boots before leaving for the city on friday afternoon with another female nanny
00:06:02
the two made their way to boylston place in downtown boston the area brimming with nightclubs was
00:06:10
known to au pairs and locals alike as a popular place for international tourists
00:06:16
karina and her friend chose to visit two nightclubs zanzibar and mercury bar as many from
00:06:23
their social circle would be there at five foot three inches tall and with a face described as sweet and innocent
00:06:32
karina holmar looked more like a 16 year old than her nearly 20 years this coupled with the fact that the
00:06:41
legal drinking age in the us was 21 meant she had to use a fake id to get into the clubs
00:06:49
it worked as it had many times before karina and her group of approximately a dozen friends spent the night drinking
00:06:59
and dancing at two the following morning they spilled out onto the street as zanzibar closed its doors
00:07:08
karina who was heavily intoxicated began talking and dancing with passers-by including a nearby panhandler
00:07:18
she also stopped to chat to a man walking a large white dog both of whom were dressed in matching superman
00:07:25
t-shirts half an hour after leaving zanzibar karina was still outside the club having
00:07:33
a conversation with two men her friend who was sitting in a nearby car asked her boyfriend to tell karina
00:07:41
they were leaving as the boyfriend spoke with karina the two men she was with began swearing at
00:07:49
him asking who do you think you are when karina heard her friends were leaving she opted to stay behind
00:07:59
replying that she would see them later on sunday june 23 the day karina was expected to return to dover her employer
00:08:12
frank rapp received a phone call it was from karina's friend who had accompanied her to boston that weekend
00:08:22
she was wondering if karina had preemptively returned to dover as no one in the city knew where she was
00:08:30
concerned frank drove to his loft upon entering he saw some of karina's belongings lying around
00:08:39
but the 19 year old wasn't there as no one could pinpoint where karina might have wound up after the clubs
00:08:47
closed in the early hours of saturday morning frank phoned the boston police to report
00:08:53
her missing [Music] hours later a homeless man made his way along boylston street
00:09:02
he passed the closed zanzibar nightclub before turning down ipswich street at the end
00:09:09
although connected to various main thoroughfares the street itself was relatively quiet
00:09:16
it ran parallel with the train track and was overlooked by several apartment blocks
00:09:22
on the other side of the railway was the massachusetts turnpike and above was the
00:09:28
charles gate overpass as the homeless man walked along ipswich street he checked the dumpsters for
00:09:36
recyclable cans that he could trade for cash at around 1 30 pm he was examining a
00:09:42
dumpster behind an apartment building and noticed a plastic garbage bag within inside he came across another plastic
00:09:51
bag he untied this second bag and saw something horrifying it was a woman's arm her fingernails
00:10:01
painted with nail polish terrified the man fled to notify the authorities [Music]
00:10:13
when police arrived at the scene they discovered that the bag contained the upper half of a woman
00:10:20
her lower body and legs were missing it was karina holmar faint ligature marks on karina's neck
00:10:31
indicated she had been strangled with a piece of rope or cord following her murder karina was severed
00:10:39
in two likely by a power saw her makeup had been removed and her body was completely washed clean
00:10:50
it was believed that her remains were dumped on this saturday some time after karina had separated from her friends
00:10:58
her exact time of death was difficult to ascertain as there were no markings on her body caused by blood settling
00:11:07
this suggested she had either been held captive prior to her murder or that she had lost too much blood during the act
00:11:17
the brutal way in which karina had been mutilated by her killer or killers made her murder particularly unusual
00:11:26
the boston police who were no strangers to homicides were left shocked by karina's treatment and vowed to catch
00:11:33
those responsible they speculated that her assailant had sawed her in half because it made her
00:11:41
remains easier to transport or perhaps it was done to cover up evidence of a sexual assault on the
00:11:48
lower portion of her body forensic psychologists believed the seemingly opportunistic crime was
00:11:55
carried out by a first-time killer despite the killer's inexperience they were described as careful cunning and
00:12:04
clever they did not panic in the wake of the crime and were in no rush to determine
00:12:10
how and where to dispose of karina's body alan fox dean of the college of criminal
00:12:18
justice at northwestern university said we're not talking about a bizarre maniac
00:12:26
either it's someone who had some relationship with karina or we're talking about a stranger who has a great
00:12:33
deal of control over his behavior who could very well have a good job and neighbours and friends
00:12:41
but for whom rape and murder is done for pleasure lieutenant robert o'toole who was
00:12:49
assigned to the case confirmed in the boston globe that initial investigations would focus on karina's movements from
00:12:56
the last time her friends reported seeing her cctv footage from inside and outside
00:13:03
zanzibar nightclub was taken for analysis while the boston police department had
00:13:11
confirmed early on that the body was that of karina holmar when they went to check her name through all the various
00:13:18
agencies that hired international au pairs they received a surprise her name wasn't on any of them
00:13:30
over in sweden karina's parents returned from a night out to discover multiple messages on their home phones answering
00:13:38
machine they were from the boston police advising them of their daughter's murder
00:13:46
a media frenzy followed the discovery of karina's body and the story dominated headlines in massachusetts and sweden
00:13:56
boston's mayor implored reporters to let investigators do their job without getting in the way
00:14:04
karina's parents were repeatedly asked for interviews but were too distraught to speak with the press
00:14:11
her sister johanna provided a comment to the boston globe stating of course we know that such things can
00:14:19
happen over there but it's nothing that you expect karina's friends told the press she had
00:14:28
been sensible but also very trusting of others and not particularly streetwise a swedish salon owner who lived and
00:14:37
worked in boston attributed this to a difference in cultures telling the boston globe quote
00:14:44
this is not sweden and the young girls don't realize that there is much more violence around here
00:14:52
and you have to be careful especially when you go drinking sweden is not like this
00:14:59
everything there is on a smaller scale you are more protected all pair agencies offered counselling to
00:15:08
nannies in the area as many struggled to come to terms with the death of one of their friends
00:15:15
a police spokesperson tried to calm the public and reassured them it was still safe to go out stating
00:15:23
there is not a mad killer running through boston scooping up young women from clubs
00:15:30
still local night spots saw a decrease in business with many people reporting that they were choosing to stay home
00:15:38
instead one woman around the same age as karina said i know people that won't even go out now
00:15:47
but if you do it's worth it to take a cab five dollars can save your life law enforcement officials painted karina
00:16:00
homer as a party animal who was known to go out clubbing often one source said it was difficult to
00:16:07
track where she had gone and with whom because she socialized with quote a loose running crowd
00:16:15
the party animals of party animals karina's host mother susan nectar denied these allegations telling the media that
00:16:26
karina had only been drinking a lot on the night she went missing because she was celebrating mid-summer
00:16:32
adding that this was probably why she got into trouble she described karina as typically having
00:16:39
very good judgment meanwhile detectives discovered that karina had gained employment in the
00:16:46
united states through a stockholm or pair agency run by 46 year old target sunden
00:16:54
after learning of karina's death sunden told swedish newspaper expresson that although his agency found work for au
00:17:02
pairs he did not provide them with the special 13-month visa they required to work in the u.s
00:17:10
this was why karina's name was not recorded in any official documentation target sunden who had previously been
00:17:19
charged twice with illegal employment practices admitted that au pairs including karina homer were technically
00:17:27
illegal immigrants although most official agencies checked in with their overseas or pairs to see
00:17:35
how they were going he hadn't heard from karina since she left sweden he was devastated by karina's murder and
00:17:44
publicly claimed responsibility for her death closing down his business soon after
00:17:53
while boston police said that finding out more about karina would help them track down her killer
00:17:59
a spokesperson was quick to point out that investigators were no closer to finding them
00:18:06
a criminologist discussed karina's case with the boston globe saying these kinds of events are incredibly
00:18:15
rare the mutilation of a body is not common in homicide when it does happen it gets a lot of
00:18:22
attention and we tend to think it's more common than it is although karina had only been in the us
00:18:31
for approximately three months investigators worked with the theory that she knew her killer
00:18:38
as it turned out there were multiple people of interest [Music] case file will be back shortly thank you
00:18:55
for supporting us by listening to this episode sponsors you've got back-to-back meetings errands
00:19:02
to run and chores to take care of what's the secret to clearing your to-do list a little help from doordash
00:19:11
along with the restaurants you love you can now get groceries and other essential items delivered with doordash
00:19:18
get drinks snacks and other household items in under an hour with over 300 000 partners you can
00:19:25
support your neighborhood go-to's or choose from your favorite national restaurants
00:19:31
every time you place an order for pickup or delivery you're setting off a chain reaction that helps give back to the
00:19:37
people who make your neighborhood unique from the stores and restaurants to the dashes driving around each purchase
00:19:44
provides a new opportunity for everyone involved because with doordash there is a neighborhood of good in every order
00:19:53
for a limited time our listeners can get 25 percent off on their first order of 15 or more when you download the
00:20:00
doordash app and enter code case file that's 25 off up to 10 value on your first order
00:20:09
when you download the doordash app in the app store and enter code case file don't forget that's code case file for
00:20:18
25 off your first order with doordash subject to change terms apply wealthy businessman casey parker has
00:20:28
been murdered you and a dedicated team of private detectives have been hired to solve the
00:20:34
case the only problem the suspect list is long and the list of potential evidence is even longer
00:20:42
who's on your side who can you trust be the first to solve the mystery when you order case file truth and deception
00:20:51
the riveting endlessly replayable strategy board game based on our podcast put yourself in the detective's shoes
00:20:58
with case file truth and deception using 44 beautifully illustrated cards players take turns trading evidence to
00:21:06
get closer to the truth but remember this is a game of deception as well someone might plant false evidence to
00:21:14
throw you and the other detectives off track be the first detective to solve this
00:21:20
crime by correctly naming the suspect weapon motive and location of casey's murder and bring the killer to justice
00:21:28
same victim different crime will you solve it first case file truth and deception is 100
00:21:37
fictional and not based on any real life events it is available now in the us at walmart
00:21:43
and in the uk at argos and smith's toys it's also available to purchase online at amazon
00:21:51
due to supply chain issues case file truth and deception is not yet available in australia but if you can't wait to
00:21:58
get your hands on a copy you can purchase it from the australian amazon store with free shipping from the us
00:22:06
thank you for listening to this episode's ads by supporting our sponsors you support
00:22:12
case file to continue to deliver quality content karina's employer frank rapp caught the
00:22:29
attention of detectives early in the investigation as one of the individuals closest to
00:22:35
karina the 43 year old had to be questioned investigators first spoke to frank the
00:22:42
day after karina's body was identified he gave an alibi for the night in question telling detectives that after
00:22:50
karina left with her friend to celebrate mid-summer he went with susan and his children to
00:22:56
mcdonald's and a drive-in movie theater after that they all returned to their home in dover where frank stayed for the
00:23:05
remainder of the weekend his wife susan confirmed this as did her parents who had been staying with them
00:23:14
at the time a background check showed that frank rapp had previously run into trouble
00:23:22
with the law five years earlier in 1991 he was arrested for physically assaulting susan
00:23:30
as reported in the boston globe frank appeared in court on charges of assault and battery
00:23:37
susan filed a restraining order against him but later asked that it be removed and all charges against frank be dropped
00:23:45
after he agreed to treatment for alcoholism although susan nectar refused to elaborate on the incident when
00:23:54
interviewed by the media she did say that the arrest turned out to be a very positive thing for both of them
00:24:01
later adding what happened with frank and i in the past is not going to do anything to
00:24:08
help find this person who killed karina i have a very solid loving relationship with my husband
00:24:18
susan told the boston globe that karina was the perfect playmate and caregiver for her children stating
00:24:25
she was a really lovely girl she was the sweetest kindest person who wouldn't hurt a fly
00:24:32
she was so responsible and sensible frank added that their thoughts and prayers were with karina's family
00:24:43
the evening after frank's first police interview homicide detectives and cadaver dogs descended on his downtown
00:24:50
loft after a six-hour search they left with six bags of evidence including a bag
00:24:58
full of karina's clothing and what was described in the media as soft pornography
00:25:05
detectives hoped that an examination of the apartment might reveal whether karina made it back there after her
00:25:12
night out at zanzibar however this was unable to be determined there were no signs that anything
00:25:21
untoward occurred in the loft with cadaver dogs failing to pick up anything of forensic importance
00:25:29
that same night approximately 30 hours after karina's body was found a fire broke out in a dumpster approximately
00:25:38
200 feet from frank and susan's dover home the blazer's proximity to the rap household did not go unnoticed by police
00:25:48
who requested a second interview with frank the next day [Music] this time he attended homicide
00:25:55
headquarters with his lawyer once the interrogation was over frank told the boston globe that he had been
00:26:04
ruled out of the investigation stating i am definitely not a suspect i answered questions and cooperated with
00:26:13
authorities because we want to get this case solved my family is completely devastated
00:26:19
[Music] lieutenant robert o'toole disputed this assertion in a news conference explaining that while investigators had
00:26:29
interviewed a number of people they hadn't ruled anyone in or out later that afternoon boston police
00:26:38
searched through the dumpster that was set on fire near frank and susan's home amongst the ash were the burnt remnants
00:26:47
of some women's clothing no human remains were found police carried away three bags of
00:26:56
evidence and the dumpster was transported to the dover highway department under police guard
00:27:03
later reports confirmed that the clothing did not match karina homer's but investigators soon made a notable
00:27:13
discovery on saturday june 22 the day that detectives suspected karina was murdered
00:27:21
frank rapp had obtained a permit to dump trash at a dover recycling facility on thursday june 27 detectives headed to
00:27:31
the facility they spent five hours sifting through refuse and carted away two dumpster
00:27:38
loads in an attempt to find evidence linking frank to karina's murder susan nichter said in an interview with
00:27:47
the boston globe that like the dumpster fire the permit was nothing more than quote
00:27:54
a weird coincidence she explained that frank had gone to the facility to recycle newspapers and had
00:28:02
taken their son and their nephew with him then she added frank has an airtight alibi
00:28:11
anyone who knows frank knows he does not have it in him to hurt somebody else but law enforcement officials maintained
00:28:21
that the apparent coincidence was quote definitely suspicious while frank rapp and susan nichter
00:28:32
described karina as happy and carefree others had a different impression of the 19 year old's short time in the us
00:28:42
one of karina's friends in sweden contacted police about some correspondence she had received from
00:28:48
karina in one letter karina said she was homesick and wanted to return in august
00:28:55
which would mean cutting her trip short karina also confided in another friend named ulrika svensson
00:29:05
a letter to ulrika read there is always so much cleaning and i think i am stressed all the time
00:29:13
so this is not exactly what i thought it would be just weeks before karina's murder eureka
00:29:22
received another letter this one was more ominous quote something terrible has happened
00:29:32
i cannot tell you right now what it is but i will tell you when i get home none of karina's friends or family had
00:29:42
any idea what terrible thing she was referring to on sunday june 30 a week after karina's
00:29:51
body was found fifty of her friends and other au pairs gathered in boston's public gardens across the road from
00:29:59
zanzibar nightclub for an impromptu memorial service detectives observed them from afar
00:30:08
videotaping the service in the hopes that a person of interest might show up after holding hands and praying for
00:30:16
karina the group made their way to a chain-link fence near the dumpster where karina was found and decorated it with
00:30:24
brightly coloured roses afterwards detectives questioned some attendees and were able to further
00:30:32
account for karina's final movements during the night karina was seen dancing and talking with two men in zanzibar
00:30:43
witnesses described the man as well dressed it was unclear whether they were the
00:30:49
same man karina was seen talking to on the street after the club closed but one of her friends thought they
00:30:56
might be despite appeals for them to come forward these men would not identified
00:31:06
the more witnesses investigators interviewed the more varying accounts they received regarding karina's last
00:31:13
known whereabouts it was difficult to know how seriously to take some statements as almost all
00:31:21
witnesses who had last seen karina alive were inebriated at the time one person came forward to say he had
00:31:29
seen karina sitting in a grey mitsubishi with two men he stuck his head in the car and said to
00:31:36
karina let's go you can come with us in response one of the men threatened him to get away from the car or his head
00:31:46
would be crushed another witness said there had been four men in the car it wasn't determined who these men were
00:31:58
others who said they had seen karina in an alleyway had actually confused her with another blonde woman
00:32:06
a friend of karina's told authorities she saw her leaving zanzibar with an older man and that they were supposedly
00:32:14
going to an after-hours party investigators knew that karina had been spotted chatting to a man wearing a
00:32:22
superman t-shirt and walking a large dog cctv footage revealed the man to be tall
00:32:30
with a muscular build while witnesses described him as quiet and shy karina had padded his dog and was
00:32:38
overheard telling the man that her friends had left the bar without her in response he allegedly offered her a
00:32:46
lift home while investigators believed that karina never went back to the loft apartment
00:32:54
where she was staying they were unsure whether or not she'd accepted a ride with the man
00:33:01
the dog walker called the boston police department and identified himself as 48 year old herb whitton
00:33:10
herb who was six foot two and 240 pounds owned a three foot tall 120 pound great
00:33:18
pyrenees dog named pierre he didn't live in the neighborhood instead he had driven 30 minutes from
00:33:27
his home in andover just to walk pier through boston's downtown streets in the early hours of the morning
00:33:35
this struck investigators as suspicious locals who frequented the area claimed that herb was in the habit of doing this
00:33:44
as an excuse to speak to women who were leaving nightclubs when herb was asked to come down to
00:33:51
homicide headquarters for questioning his lawyer sent a letter asserting that he was not to be interviewed
00:33:59
given there was no evidence against him herb could not be compelled to attend detectives also tracked down a 31 year
00:34:10
old panhandler named juan polo who was seen dancing with karina homer outside of zanzibar nightclub
00:34:19
like frank rapp paolo also had previous run-ins with the law in april 1995 more than a year before
00:34:28
karina's murder a woman named evelyn alvarez was found strangled to death by a dumpster behind
00:34:35
a bowling alley she was juan paolo's ex-girlfriend paulo had been questioned by police in
00:34:44
july 1995 after they made the link between him and evelyn but he had a strong alibi for the night of his former
00:34:52
girlfriend's murder the murder of evelyn alvarez remained unsolved but plymouth district attorney
00:35:00
michael sullivan didn't think her case was related to karina homers unlike karina
00:35:08
evelyn had not been disfigured and there was no evidence she'd been sexually assaulted
00:35:16
nevertheless in a rap sheet that dated back to 1985 juan paulo had a total of 42 records
00:35:24
including a rape charge that was later dismissed he adamantly denied being involved in
00:35:31
karina's murder telling the boston herald that while they were dancing he had begged karina to return to the
00:35:38
safety of her friends with no evidence linking him to the killing polo was free to go
00:35:47
[Music] one more person raised suspicions when investigators canvassed the area talking
00:35:54
to those who lived in the apartment buildings near where karina's body was discovered
00:36:00
as reported in the boston globe a man named john lived two blocks from the scene
00:36:07
he was the lead singer in a local band which often included s m and bondage routines in their performances
00:36:15
[Music] like juan polo jon had some previous run-ins with the law and was also known to collect animal
00:36:24
and human bones but he denied being involved in any way and investigators could find nothing to
00:36:32
tie him to the case on july 1 1996 forensic experts successfully lifted a partial fingerprint from the plastic bag
00:36:45
karina's upper body was dumped in finally it seemed investigators had the breakthrough they'd been waiting for
00:36:55
when they tried to enhance the print however they were disappointed to discover that it contained less than a
00:37:02
necessary number of identifying characteristics to make a successful match without the crime scene where karina's
00:37:11
murder took place investigators efforts were significantly hampered and they were still missing the lower
00:37:18
portion of karina's body which may have contained crucial evidence by the start of july just a week after
00:37:27
karina's murder detectives already conceded that they might never find the rest of her remains
00:37:36
one law enforcement officer reported we haven't given up but the longer it goes on the more
00:37:43
difficult it becomes karina homer's upper body was returned to sweden and on july 5 a funeral was
00:37:54
held in her hometown at orca's church her family requested that attendees wear colorful clothes in celebration of
00:38:03
karina's life and as the mourners gathered their bright garments cast a vibrant scene against the white stone
00:38:10
building karina's family decorated the church with wild flowers they'd picked from an
00:38:17
adjacent forest and her coffin was adorned with white roses the officiating reverend said it was one
00:38:26
of the hardest ceremonies he had to lead and described the hundred mourners who attended as haunted by feelings of
00:38:34
devastation anger frustration and powerlessness karina was laid to rest in the nearby
00:38:43
cemetery back in boston leads in the case quickly ran dry yet on august 23 two months after
00:38:54
karina's murder the boston police commissioner told the public that the case was still very actively being
00:39:02
investigated when detectives failed to find any tangible evidence linking karina's
00:39:09
employer frank rapp to her murder he was officially ruled out as a suspect local media ignored this development and
00:39:18
continued to describe frank as a person of interest his wife susan publicly stated that she
00:39:26
found this astounding and insulting it was hoped that the garbage bags used to dispose of karina's upper body would
00:39:35
reveal a vital clue forensic experts tried to uncover where they'd been manufactured and whether
00:39:43
they were for commercial or retail use unfortunately the bags were made from a very common type of plastic and the
00:39:52
search went nowhere detectives thought they had another breakthrough when the skeletal remains
00:40:00
of two legs belonging to a white female aged between 20 and 40 were found in the
00:40:06
rural foothills of virginia's blue ridge mountains but they turned out not to belong to
00:40:13
karina holmar in november 1996 wcvb tv reported that a week before karina's murder she and
00:40:24
another au pair spent a night in the company of two police officers it was rumored that one of the officers
00:40:32
who worked paid detail at zanzibar nightclub and briefly dated karina had been interviewed by detectives
00:40:42
however investigators said they found no evidence tying him to the crime and just
00:40:48
like all the other persons of interest he was ultimately ruled out then new information sent detectives
00:40:58
looking in another direction the last known sightings of karina had placed her in the alley outside zanzibar
00:41:06
nightclub at around 2 30 a.m now some additional witnesses suddenly came forward to say they had seen karina
00:41:15
outside a 24-hour convenience store between 3 30 and 4 am the store was close to the dumpster
00:41:24
where karina's torso was subsequently found detectives wondered if this sighting
00:41:31
indicated that karina had been planning to head out again maybe she was on her way to an
00:41:37
after-hours party they just had no idea as to how or whether she got there or if she was alone
00:41:46
[Music] on january 9 1997 police were called to the home of herb whitton the man who had
00:41:57
been walking his dog in a superman t-shirt on the night of karina's murder they were met at herb's door by a
00:42:05
concerned relative who had called the police when she couldn't get a hold of him
00:42:11
inside they found herb whitton deceased on the bathroom floor an investigation determined that herb
00:42:20
had taken his own life those who knew him speculated that he ended his life due to his severe mental
00:42:28
health issues combined with the notoriety that had come from being associated with karina holmes murder
00:42:36
although herb was never mentioned by name in the media he was so well known as the burly man who walked his large
00:42:44
white dog in the middle of the night that locals knew exactly who the police were referring to
00:42:51
rumors also circulated that herb suicided because he had murdered karina and could no longer live with the guild
00:43:01
following herb's death his lawyer explained that herb had never been interviewed by the homicide detectives
00:43:07
because his mental state would have made a police interrogation inappropriate the lawyer told the boston globe quote
00:43:17
i can't comment on what he said but i feel confident based on my own investigation that he had no connection
00:43:24
whatsoever to the death of karina holmer i think his death related to the pressure he felt in being considered a
00:43:33
suspect in this slaying he always felt scrutinized by police and the public family and friends
00:43:42
he felt like he had a scarlet letter on his chest it was very tough the first anniversary of karina's murder
00:43:53
arrived and detectives were no closer to apprehending her killer despite interviewing hundreds of witnesses and
00:44:00
clocking up more than a thousand hours of investigative time now they were leaning toward the theory
00:44:08
that karina was last seen at 3am on boston common likely walking back to frank rapp's south boston loft
00:44:18
whilst those in sweden celebrated 1997's mid-summer karina's family marked one year since
00:44:25
her death by visiting her grave and decorating it with evergreen and wild flowers
00:44:32
karina's father ulla gave an interview with the journalist from the associated press and remarked on the strange use of
00:44:40
the word anniversary saying you call it an anniversary that's a very odd word for me
00:44:49
anniversary for me is some kind of celebration he explained that the period he most
00:44:57
struggled with in dealing with the loss of his daughter was when the initial leads ran dry and the case development
00:45:04
stopped ulla still spoke occasionally to police but they had a little to report quote
00:45:13
they only give out what they think they need to give out but i think i know that they have come
00:45:19
up with zero absolutely zero that's nothing at all that should worry america a bit
00:45:31
meanwhile a photograph of karina halma sat in the office shared by detective sergeant thomas o'leary and his three
00:45:38
homicide squad partners detective juan torres whose first homicide case was that of carinas said
00:45:47
to the boston globe it serves as a reminder of a task unfinished in february 1999 susan nichter presented
00:46:01
an exhibition of her paintings at a boston gallery as reported in the boston globe some of
00:46:08
the pieces explored her experience during karina holmer's murder with two paintings depicting a woman
00:46:16
wrestling with a well-meaning angel of death over the years a few more persons of
00:46:24
interest came up in police investigations but all were quickly dismissed as suspects
00:46:30
as of 2021 the murder of karina holmar remains unsolved the crime scene where she was killed has
00:46:39
not been identified and the lower half of her body was never recovered nor have investigators figured out what
00:46:47
might have caused her to write home and tell a friend quote something terrible has happened
00:46:57
soon after karina's death a friend of hers in sweden jenny was interviewed by the aftonbladet newspaper
00:47:05
in her hands jenny clasped her dick book a book that teenage girls in sweden circulate amongst friends to share
00:47:15
messages and thoughts as reported by the associated press jenny turned to a page written by karina
00:47:25
it had been decorated with drawings of wild flowers and karina had written the following
00:47:31
message i sit and look out to see the soft sand is red colored and my cheek is damp because my heart is
00:47:42
bleeding and my eyes are crying when i open my eyes i see a bird sitting with me on the ground
00:47:51
he looks at me and begins to sing a song my dear child life has returned to you and you will again feel happy
00:48:01
your soul is clean and the life spirit is glowing in your eyes the finest gift you ever get is life
00:48:11
you should not throw it away or trample on it but you should hold it high in your
00:48:16
hands [Music] [Music] [Music] you