00:00:09
[Music] our episodes deal with serious and often distressing incidents if you feel at any
00:00:18
time you need support please contact your local crisis center for suggested phone numbers for confidential support
00:00:26
and for a more detailed list of content warnings please the show notes for this episode on your app or on our
00:00:34
website today's episode involves crimes against children and won't be suitable for all
00:00:45
listeners at about 7:40 on the morning of Tuesday December 21 1982 Frank Church headed out of his home in Westborn Grove
00:00:53
northcut and walked towards the front gate the rubbish bins had gone out for collection the previous night and Frank
00:01:01
was going to bring his empty one in as Frank exited his front gate he noticed his nextdoor neighbor Maran standing on
00:01:08
the footpath outside of her home while Frank had resided on westborne Grove for the past 27 years
00:01:16
Maran and her 6-year-old daughter Bonnie were relative newcomers they'd moved into the inner
00:01:22
city Melbourne Street about 2 years ago although their Victorian Terrace houses sat quite close to each other the
00:01:29
residential Street was wide and fairly quiet Frank didn't really know Maran or Bonnie except to exchange pleasantries
00:01:37
whenever they bumped into one another as soon as Marian spotted Frank she called out to him shouting Frank
00:01:47
Frank as Frank looked at the young mother he noticed how distraught her expression was and that her face was
00:01:53
stre with tears concerned Frank approached Maran as he neared her she leaned into
00:02:01
him collapsing into his shoulder and cried my baby is dead what do you mean your baby is dead
00:02:09
Frank asked Maran replied that her daughter Bonnie had been [Music] stabbed shocked Frank told Marian he'd call the
00:02:43
police Marian said that she'd already done so then continued to sob and scream as she leaned heavily on Frank seemingly
00:02:52
unable to support herself Frank's wife Mavis was just getting out of bed when she heard
00:02:58
Marian's distraught cry Frank began to call out mavis's name asking for her help Mavis quickly pulled
00:03:06
on a dressing gown and ran outside to investigate she only knew Maran to say hello to in the street but now the young
00:03:14
mother was a sobbing Rack in Frank's arms it's her little girl Frank said without hesitating Mavis ran towards
00:03:23
maran's home the front door was wide open Mavis looked in into the first room but that
00:03:31
appeared to be maran's bedroom along the right side of the house was a long hallway while a second o-shaped
00:03:38
passageway LED from Marian's room to the home's left side Mavis hurried down the
00:03:43
hallway looking into each room as she passed the second bedroom was a guest room that appeared to be empty but the
00:03:51
third was clearly Bonnie's children's clothing and toys lay on the floor a single bed was pushed
00:03:59
up against one wall while a bunk bed sat opposite on a bedside table was a lamp which was switched
00:04:07
on lying on her back in the single bed was 6-year-old Bonnie Clark her arms were straight by her
00:04:15
sides and she was naked with a blue Duna bunched around her waist and covering the lower half of her
00:04:21
body Mavis immediately noticed how incredibly pale Bonnie was she had a bloody wound just below her chest
00:04:31
hoping she might be able to save the girl via resuscitation Mavis lifted the back of Bonnie's neck Bonnie's skin was
00:04:39
ice cold next Mavis felt for a heartbeat she found none realizing that Bonnie was dead
00:04:48
Mavis immediately dropped her hands and hurried from the room meanwhile outside on Westborn Grove
00:04:58
two con pulled up in their patrol car having responded to Marian Clark's call as they pulled up at her house they saw
00:05:06
Marian standing on the footpath still being held by Frank Church Marian suddenly pulled away from
00:05:13
Frank's Embrace and kicked out at a small Terrier standing nearby why didn't you bark you always
00:05:21
bloody bark why didn't you bark she screamed at the dog the constables rushed to 6-year-old
00:05:28
Bonnie's bedroom it looked like an ordinary children's bedroom except for Bonnie lying cold and
00:05:35
still in her bed the constables were joined a few minutes later by two paramedics who
00:05:41
confirmed that Bonnie was deceased furthermore riger mortise had set in indicating that Bonnie had been
00:05:48
dead for some time she had been digitally raped and suffered injuries to her janitors there was no Seaman found
00:05:56
at the scene com pressions to Bonnie's neck pointed to Suffocation a 3 cm Stab Wound was
00:06:05
visible in her chest but there was only a small amount of blood around it beneath her body the mattress was soaked
00:06:12
with water Bonnie's bed was kept pushed up against one wall and her pillows lay against this wall instead of beneath
00:06:20
Bonnie's head when police pulled the bed away they found her pajamas stuffed beneath the pillows between the mattress
00:06:28
and the wall the pajama top was heavily stained with blood Bonnie's Underpants had been cut
00:06:36
with two slashes made by either a knife or scissors extending from the elastic waistband to the bands where each of
00:06:43
Bunny's legs would go given the amount of blood on bonny's pajama top it seemed strange there was
00:06:49
so little around her actual wound it appeared that after the killer stubbed Bonnie they had rolled her over
00:06:56
onto her stomach then removed her pajamas and washed her with water which soaked the
00:07:02
mattress faint smearing across Bonnie's torso indicated that her body had been wiped
00:07:08
[Music] clean Frank and Mavis Church ushered Mariam back to their home to comfort her
00:07:16
while the police remained at the Clark residence with Bonnie at 8:05 a.m. one of the
00:07:22
constables called northcut police station to request detectives from the crime investigation Bureau attend the
00:07:28
scene along with crime scene investigators almost 15 minutes later the detectives arrived and took note of
00:07:36
the properties's layout a crime scene investigator noted there was no sign of forcible entry the
00:07:44
long single fronted weatherboard house had three bedrooms one after another flanked by two
00:07:50
hallways after the third bedroom which was Bonnies there was a living room with a couch and a television set a small
00:07:58
coffee table was cled Ed with cups and empty bottles including one beer bottle and one soft
00:08:04
drink at the rear of the house was the kitchen laundry and bathroom Another Empty beer bottle was found in the
00:08:12
laundry a sliding door in the kitchen led to the Back Garden where there was an ouse a Hills hoist washing line with
00:08:19
the dry clothes hanging from it two empty beer bottles and a set of tall Double Gates that led to a
00:08:26
lanway these were closed and there were no prints or marks on either side to suggest that someone had climbed
00:08:34
them Maran said that neither She nor Bonnie ever went into the laneway or used the back gate at all she also
00:08:42
explained that while the front door was always locked she never completely closed the rear sliding door it was
00:08:49
always kept slightly a jar so that one of the family's dogs a small Terrier named Troy could go outside whenever he
00:08:57
needed Troy slept on a couch in the living room while Bonnie's dog a poodle chihuahua cross named mumi slept in
00:09:05
Bonnie's room on the bunk bed in the kitchen a Cutlery drawer was slightly open prompting investigators to
00:09:13
wonder if the killer had used one of the household knives to stab Bonnie but no weapon matching her injury
00:09:20
was recovered Maran Clark briefly spoke to detectives in her home while B's body
00:09:29
still lay in her bed before being formally interviewed in the Presbytery of a church that also sat on westborne
00:09:36
Grove according to Marian the previous night had been peaceful the only hiccup had been that Bonnie didn't want to go
00:09:44
to her own bed she had asked Maran if she could sleep with her instead Bonnie was afraid of the dark for that reason
00:09:53
she always slept with her bedside lamp on and kept the door slightly ajar Bonnie's pet dog mumi would also
00:10:01
keep her company by curling up on the bunk bed in her room but this wasn't always enough to calm the little
00:10:09
girl Maran had been tired and reluctant to agree to Bonnie's request the leadup to Christmas was always a busy time but
00:10:18
this year Marian's schedule was particularly hectic she worked as a nurse and was undertaking extra
00:10:25
full-time studies with final exams as a single mother with no partner to help carry the load these commitments had
00:10:33
left Maran extra Keen for a good night's sleep pointing out that it was only four
00:10:39
more days until Christmas Maran had encouraged Bonnie to go to her own room stating sleep in your bed Santa won't
00:10:47
know where to find you Bonnie agreed and at 8:30 that night Maran tucked her in Maran had gone to bed before 11:00
00:10:58
p.m. only getting up once during the night at around 1:30 a.m. to go to the toilet she had checked in on her
00:11:05
daughter as she walked by her room Bonnie had been awake and asked her mother for a drink which Marian got her
00:11:13
both mother and daughter had gone back to sleep straight after shortly before 700 a.m. Maran had
00:11:21
been woken by the telephone ringing it was the nursing agency that employed her asking if she could come in for a shift
00:11:28
right away Maran accepted and immediately began getting ready as she made her way to the
00:11:35
bathroom she glanced in at Bonnie's room she saw Bonnie was still asleep in her single bed her Duna pulled over her
00:11:43
up to her chin Maran dressed and made breakfast by 7:45 there was still no sign of Bonnie stirring so Maran went to
00:11:54
wake her as she approached Bonnie's bed Maran in stly knew that something was wrong
00:12:02
Bonnie was lying completely still and her face was extremely pale Maran reached for the bed's Duna
00:12:09
and lifted it underneath Bonnie lay on her back her arms beside her she was naked her neck appeared bruised and
00:12:19
there was a hole in her chest Maran said she immediately knew her daughter was dead
00:12:30
distraught she phoned the police unable to stay in the house where her daughter lay dead for a moment
00:12:37
longer Maran rushed out into the street as she stood on the footpath outside she saw her neighbor Frank
00:12:45
church and ran to him for Comfort Maran was adamant that an intruder must have broken into the home
00:12:51
in the middle of the night and killed Bonnie while Maran was sleeping the case was aign to lead
00:12:59
homicide investigator detective senior Sergeant Eric Lily detective Lily was dubious of
00:13:06
maran's version of events for starters according to both Maran and her neighbors neither of the family's dogs
00:13:13
had barked at all during the night yet whenever a stranger came to the house both dogs were known to bark
00:13:22
incessantly any Intruder also would have had to navigate a very difficult layout
00:13:27
to reach Bonnie's room with the home's front door closed and locked it seemed the perpetrator must
00:13:33
have entered by the rear sliding door that was always kept slightly open but hanging at the back entrance to the
00:13:40
house was a beaded curtain which made noise when walked through or pushed aside along the hallway that led to
00:13:47
Bonnie's room were a number of hanging plants suspended from the ceiling an intruder fumbling in the dark
00:13:54
would have been caught off guard by these and found it difficult to access Bonnie with without waking her mother
00:14:00
yet Maran insisted she'd heard nothing none of the neighbors reported seeing a Prowler in the area or hearing
00:14:08
anything suspicious either everything was pointing to a perpetrator who knew the home
00:14:15
well the only people who lived in the residence were Marian and Bonnie Marian said she'd left Bonnie's father Dennis
00:14:23
due to his alcoholism and occasional violent outbursts although this description
00:14:29
might have made Dennis sound like a possible suspect he had a solid Alibi for the night of December 20 and was
00:14:35
quickly ruled out of the investigation but there was something about Bonnie's mother that gave
00:14:42
detective Lily pause although Bonnie's murder looked to have a sexual component there was no
00:14:51
Seaman present and the assault of Bonnie had been digital these factors led detective Lily
00:14:57
to suspect that a woman was behind the crime and the most obvious woman was Maran perhaps something had happened
00:15:07
which caused Marian's temper to flare she had snapped and killed Bonnie in an angry rage then tried to cover up her
00:15:14
actions by staging the sexual assault there were other elements to the crime scene that caused the detective to
00:15:21
consider Maran Clark to investigators the number of empty beer bottles recovered around the
00:15:27
property Poss indicated poor parenting and loose morals detective Lily didn't beat around
00:15:35
the bush during his very first conversation with Maran in her Lounge room while Bonnie's body lay Dead one
00:15:42
room over he said you did it didn't you tell us now we can help you Maran fiercely denied killing her
00:15:53
daughter replying no I didn't do it I don't understand why why you say that because you don't know
00:16:01
me detective Lily wasn't [Music] dissuaded the crime scene yielded little physical evidence Searchers of the house
00:16:14
and neighboring Properties by a total of 32 officers failed to uncover the weapon
00:16:19
used to stab Bonnie nor did detectives find Whatever item had been used to wash and wipe down her body after the murder
00:16:29
a white coat with a small blood stain on it was found in a laundry and was initially thought to be
00:16:34
important but this was later ruled out as having nothing to do with the crime the house and items within it were
00:16:43
dusted for fingerprints everything came back as belonging to Marian Clark her daughter
00:16:49
Bonnie and two of Marian's acquaintances who were known to visit the home there were no prints to indicate an
00:16:56
unidentified offender as detective Lily dugged deeper into the case his suspicions against Maran grew
00:17:05
stronger While most who knew her described her as a loving mother a couple said she could be physically and
00:17:11
verbally abusive towards Bonnie Maran also had a history of depression she'd attributed this to a difficult period of
00:17:19
adjustment she'd gone through after moving to Melbourne from country Victoria however she had recently made
00:17:26
phone calls to a parents helpline as she was Finding single motherhood difficult
00:17:31
to detective Lily this hinted at someone who wasn't coping he made several requests to
00:17:39
interview Marian again and she always obliged each time she spoke to him he used an increasingly adamant and
00:17:47
assertive tone after interviewing Maran on two more occasions for a total of almost 5
00:17:53
hours detective Lily asked if she would be willing to be hypnotized he suggested that this might reveal if
00:18:01
there was something she was subconsciously hiding about the night of Bonnie's murder Maran agreed but then police were
00:18:09
contacted by a solicitor that she had retained Marian was withdrawing her consent and wouldn't be participating in
00:18:16
the hypnotism session after all this was Clear Proof to detective Lily that Maran was guilty but without
00:18:25
any forensic evidence or a confession from his suspect there was little more that he could
00:18:32
[Music] do in February 1983 2 months after bonny's murder a young reporter for the
00:18:40
local northcut Leader newspaper approached the suburbs homicide squad for a story journalist Ian Monroe was writing
00:18:48
an article about several unsolved murders in the area and one of the cases he wanted to cover was that of Bonnie
00:18:56
Clark Ian spoke with one of the the northcut detectives but when he raised Bonnie's murder he was reassured that
00:19:03
there was no need to further publicize that case the police already knew who was
00:19:10
responsible yet months continued to pass with no breakthroughs occasionally names of
00:19:17
other possible suspects came up detective Lily interviewed at least one other individual in connection with
00:19:23
Bonnie's murder but this led nowhere and he remained convinced of Marian Clark's
00:19:30
guilt in February 1984 an inquest was held into Bonnie's murder detective Lily gave evidence
00:19:38
while Maran Clark was absent her lawyer attended in her place the coroner found that 6-year-old
00:19:47
Bonnie Clark had been killed by an unknown as salant no recommendations were made that
00:19:53
anyone be charged and the case continued to languish [Music] meanwhile Mary and Clark was
00:20:05
experiencing unimaginable grief Bonnie's death felt like a nightmare that she kept waiting to wake up from as well as
00:20:14
struggling with the loss of her daughter Maran was overwhelmed with guilt for not
00:20:18
allowing Bonnie to sleep with her that night as she'd requested one day Marian was driving
00:20:24
somewhere when she was suddenly overcome by the need to pull over when she did she burst into
00:20:31
tears from that moment on the loss of her daughter finally seemed real at the same time that she was
00:20:39
processing Bonnie's murder Marian felt as though all lies in Melbourne were on her being in crowded spaces and catching
00:20:48
public transport became unbearable it seemed like everyone was staring at her judging her for being quote the worst
00:20:56
kind of woman and mother sometimes when her phone rang at home she would hear an unfamiliar voice on
00:21:03
the other end strangers calling to abuse her you did it just admit it some of them said Maran just hung up on
00:21:14
them every day she half expected the police to arrest her she felt as though detective Eric Lily was biased against
00:21:22
her purely because she was a single mother Maran would later tell a reporter from the Sunday newspaper quote I
00:21:30
honestly reckon he hated single mothers he had a real thing about single mothers when the detective asked Maran
00:21:39
to undergo hypnosis she instinctively agreed but she later riged at her sister Jill's
00:21:46
encouragement Jill warned Maran that her distress might make her vulnerable to suggestion and advised she retain a
00:21:53
lawyer instead Maran was stunned upon learning that some people were reportedly accusing her of being physically abusive
00:22:02
towards Bonnie she had yelled at her daughter on occasion as a form of discipline but never hit
00:22:08
her on one occasion detective Lily told Maran nobody's going to believe you you're just like Lindy
00:22:18
Chamberlain this was a reference to the mother of baby aaria chamblain who disappeared during a family camping trip
00:22:25
in mid 1980 as covered in episode 136 of case File Lindy had been convicted of murdering her daughter just 2 months
00:22:35
before Bonnie was killed despite asserting her innocence from the start years later she would be released and
00:22:43
acquitted at the time Marian knew that if it was possible for Lindy Chamberlain to be arrested the same thing could
00:22:50
happen to her Maran dropped out of her university studies she contemplated suicide
00:22:58
living with her grief felt impossible the only thing that stopped her from taking her own life was the
00:23:05
thought of how detective Lily would interpret such an action in a 2006 interview with the
00:23:11
Sunday age Maran said I thought no as soon as you do that that bastard's going to turn around and
00:23:19
say guilt got her and he was not going to do that to Bonnie they would have shut the book and I wasn't going to let
00:23:27
them do that she was worth more than that during the first couple of years after Bonnie's death Maran kept waiting
00:23:37
for the pain to subside she expected that one day she would wake up and feel normal
00:23:43
again but on the third anniversary of her daughter's murder Maran realized that was never going to happen quote I
00:23:52
realized that it was never going to go away and I was going to have to live with it and I better get cracking on
00:23:59
this because it was ridiculous it was time I started to live for me and by living for me I would be
00:24:07
living for her too while attending a Catholic Retreat Maran met a man who she later married
00:24:15
and changed her name to Maran Wishard she left Melbourne for a quieter life in one thy a Seaside town almost 150 km
00:24:25
away Maran and her husband went on to have four children together framed pictures of her babies were kept on a
00:24:33
dresser in the family's Lounge room and in the middle was a single photo of Bonnie holding her pet dog
00:24:43
mumi Bonnie's father Dennis Clark was also grappling with the mystery of what had happened to his daughter almost two
00:24:51
decades past with no developments in the case over that time Dennis's Health began to deine line and he was diagnosed
00:24:59
with cancer aware that he didn't have long to live Dennis was desperate to see the
00:25:05
case solved before he died one day in 2001 Dennis was reading the newspaper when he saw an article
00:25:13
about Victoria police's new cold Cas Squad he decided to reach out to them directly and phoned detective Ron idles
00:25:21
who had been mentioned in the article the detective paid a visit to Dennis's home and Dennis showed a photo
00:25:28
of his daughter he explained his need to see the case resolved detective ID promised he would
00:25:35
take a look at Bonnie's case File together with his colleague Tim day the detective dug out the original case
00:25:42
report and poured over its Pages they also went to the media which was something their predecessor Eric
00:25:49
Lily had refused to do not long after detective idles met with Dennis he spoke with the herald son
00:25:57
newspaper and they ran an article about the 1982 Cold Case one person who read the article was
00:26:06
a woman in her mid-20s named Kylie Ward Kylie had a particular interest in the case she had been a friend of
00:26:14
Bonnie's and had always wondered what had happened to the little girl she used to play with she also had her own
00:26:21
suspicions about who might have been involved throughout 1982 Kylie used to go over to Bonnie's house to play after
00:26:30
school from January through to September of that Year Bonnie and Maran weren't the only people living there struggling
00:26:38
to make ANS meet as a newly single mother Maran had to let out the third bedroom to a border a 28-year-old man
00:26:45
named Mal there was something about Mal that made Kylie uncomfortable she knew he made Bonnie
00:26:53
feel the same way Bonnie had told Kylie that M was really creepy he looked at her a lot and sometimes he would make
00:27:02
Bonnie sit on his knee Bonnie tried to avoid him as much as possible and Kylie noticed how
00:27:09
cautious she seemed in his company even though Mal had moved out 3 months before
00:27:15
Bonnie was killed Kylie had never been able to shake the thought that he might have been the
00:27:21
killer after reading that Victoria police were reinvestigating the case Kylie reached out to the authorities to
00:27:28
report what she knew case detective Tim day had been going over and over Bonnie's case File
00:27:37
but when he received Kylie Ward's tip off he couldn't remember reading about a border named M after combing through the
00:27:45
pages again he finally came across the name Mal Clark who was no relation to Bonny Clark or her
00:27:53
family he was the most recent of several borders who'd resided with with Marian and Bonnie and had left 3 months before
00:28:00
Bonnie's murder Mal had moved into the house next door for about a month before leaving
00:28:06
for his parents' house in the nearby suburb of Brunswick because he couldn't afford the
00:28:11
rent it turned out that Kylie wasn't the only one who'd suspected him Bonnie's mother Maran had mentioned him to
00:28:19
detective Eric Lily immediately after the Murder She noted that he was the one other person who was as familiar with
00:28:26
the home as she was because he had lived there for 9 months both dogs knew him well and didn't bark at him M knew the
00:28:36
layout of the house and the family's routines Mal had been spoken to by the original
00:28:44
investigators he'd said he had an alibi for the night in question he'd been working at the cinema where he was
00:28:50
employed as an assistant projectionist the police in 1982 had ruled him out and gone back to the Dr
00:28:57
drawing board detective Tim day decided to search the criminal records Branch for
00:29:03
any mention of a Mal Clark he couldn't find anything the closest he could find was
00:29:10
an offender named Joe Clark who had been convicted of two separate violent crimes
00:29:15
committed in the years before and after Bonnie's murder in June of 1980 Theresa Crow was
00:29:26
a 22-year-old Who loved to dance a friendly outgoing and vivacious young woman one of her favorite things to do
00:29:34
was go to a disco named chases in the inner city Melbourne suburb of pan Theresa became a fixture at chases
00:29:42
which led to her meeting a wide circle of friends she was something of a social butterfly rushing from one group to the
00:29:49
next and greeting those she knew with a big hug on the afternoon of Thursday June 19
00:29:56
1980 Teresa visited her friend Zena at Zena's workplace and mentioned that she had an upcoming date at an expensive
00:30:05
restaurant she seemed happy and excited Zena asked if Theresa would like to come over to her place later that
00:30:13
evening Teresa said she had to drop in at the pizza shop where she worked to see if they needed her that night if
00:30:20
they didn't she would come over when Teresa didn't show up that night Zena assumed she was working
00:30:28
the pair had made plans for the following afternoon but Theresa failed to show for those too although Zena was
00:30:35
upset that her friend had stood her up she didn't think that anything was wrong several days went by with no word
00:30:43
from Theresa almost a week later on Wednesday June 25 Theresa's employer grew concerned when she didn't pick up her
00:30:53
wages her landlord Simon was contacted and decided to go check on her Teresa rented a small Factory Loft space just
00:31:02
down the street from the Chasers disco she loved to go to a few days earlier Simon had left a letter that arrived for
00:31:09
Theresa on the ladder that led to her apartment as he approached the ladder to check on her now he noticed the letter
00:31:17
was still lying there untouched Simon climbed up to the trapped door that led to Theresa's Loft
00:31:25
he clambered into the apartment which was a small cluttered Studio space a few pictures hung from the brick walls
00:31:33
there was a television in one corner and a rack with Theresa's clothing in the other hanging from the middle of the
00:31:40
room was a love seat style couch suspended from the ceiling with ropes and lying on the floor next to the couch
00:31:47
was what looked like a mannequin tightly swaddled in a white blanket Simon approached the mannequin
00:31:54
and lifted a corner of fabric that was covering ing its head to his shock the face underneath was
00:32:05
real police were summoned after photographing the scene they carefully unwrapped Theresa Crow from the
00:32:12
blanket underneath she was completely naked with her arms folded across her chest whoever had killed her had
00:32:19
carefully posed her before wrapping her like a mommy there was a horseshoe shaped cut to her left cheek es to her
00:32:27
neck and a number of other small grazes bite marks and abrasions on her body most notable was a long dark
00:32:35
incision that stretched from her throat to her groin it cut through all of Theresa's
00:32:42
layers of skin judging from the lack of blood this cut had been made postmortem an autopsy would indicate
00:32:51
that the cause of death was asphixiation it was difficult for investigator is to determine when
00:32:58
exactly Theresa had been murdered her body showed very few signs of decomposition even though she hadn't
00:33:05
been seen for almost a week however the cold winter weather could have played a role in preserving her remains there was
00:33:13
some indications that Theresa had been attacked at night just as she was readying for bed her face was clean of
00:33:20
makeup and the contact lenses she wore during the day were found in a container on a dresser
00:33:27
a nighty was lying on the floor near The Swinging couch some cushions on the couch were
00:33:33
crumpled as though someone had been lying on them there was also a seamen stain investigators came up with a
00:33:42
theory based on this evidence one evening shortly after Theresa was last seen she was at home either in bed or
00:33:50
preparing to sleep when someone showed up unexpectedly at her apartment Theresa let the visitor in he
00:33:59
subsequently attacked and sexually assaulted her police believed the perpetrator had
00:34:05
struck ter raser in the face with a solid object causing the horseshoe shaped cut to her face then removed her
00:34:12
NY he then pinned Theresa Face Down On The Swinging couch during the struggle the attacker bit Theresa's back and she
00:34:20
sustained several other bruises and grazes Theresa's throat was also pressed tightly against one of the Couch's
00:34:27
wooden armrests which ultimately caused her to asfixiate after Theresa died her Killer
00:34:34
cut down the middle of her body for reasons unknown then carefully wrapped her in a
00:34:41
blanket the bizarre mutilation and posing of Theresa's body prompted detectives to look into whether the
00:34:47
killing could be occult related no evidence was found that confirmed this several hundred individuals were
00:34:55
interviewed by investig ators and they looked into Theresa's personal relationships and Social Circles
00:35:02
carefully they couldn't find anything that pointed to a particular suspect the case gradually went
00:35:14
cold more than 3 years later on Friday August 26th 1983 25 year-old Jane not her real name was suddenly woken in the
00:35:24
middle of the night in her Brunswick home she had heard a creaking sound just outside of her bedroom it was the
00:35:32
floorboards it sounded as though someone was crawling along their hallway on their hands and
00:35:39
knees Jane was scared her husband was working the night shift at his job and the noise was too heavy to be the
00:35:46
couple's 5-year-old daughter who was asleep in her room Jane reached for the rotary phone
00:35:53
by her bed as she picked up the receiver and began to dial for the police she suddenly felt a huge weight as a large
00:36:00
heavy set man pounced on top of her he was holding a knife which he stabbed into one of Jane's legs causing a
00:36:08
significant injury then he let go of the knife and wrapped a hand around her throat he used his other hand to smother
00:36:17
Jane's mouth preventing her from screaming desperately fighting back Jane bit down hard on the man's
00:36:25
thumb let my thumb go he demanded Jane ignored him so he squeezed her throat this prompted Jane to stop
00:36:35
biting feeling more confident the man warned her not to make any wrong moves or he would kill
00:36:43
her the man pulled Jane down to lie on the floor with him and began to talk he said he'd just escaped from prison and
00:36:52
that three of his friends were waiting outside her home for him the man told Jane that he'd cut off another woman's
00:37:00
breasts then he demanded she remove her NY Jane didn't understand his request as
00:37:07
she had been sleeping naked and had nothing on the man began to sexually assault
00:37:14
her as he did so Jane heard her daughter calling out to her perhaps woken by the commotion the
00:37:22
little girl had come to her mother's bedroom and was leaning over the bed looking at her mother and her attacker
00:37:28
lying on the floor hoping it was too dark for her daughter to make out the man's features
00:37:34
Jane explained that she and daddy were just playing a game and told her to go back to
00:37:39
bed after the little girl left the man grabbed a Jane's throat and said how easy I could kill you I could
00:37:48
cut you up like the other girl terrified of what the man might do Jane replied I'll do anything you want
00:37:57
but please don't hurt my daughter over 3 hours the man raped Jane repeatedly at knife Point while telling
00:38:05
her in detail about other violent sexual assaults he'd committed he also bit her
00:38:12
repeatedly Jane tried to memorize details about the man so she could report them later it was too dark for
00:38:19
her to see him but she felt the texture of his hair it was coarse and Sandy the men finally left just before 6:30
00:38:30
the time Jane's husband always returned from his night shift but first he cleaned up the scene removing evidence
00:38:38
of his presence before departing he told Jane if you have a baby I don't want you
00:38:45
to get rid of [Music] it Jane reported the assault to the police providing a statement with an
00:38:53
immense amount of details a few few days later two Brunswick detectives began door knocking
00:38:59
the neighborhood to see if anyone had seen or heard anything on the night in question next door to Jane's home was a
00:39:06
block of flats some of which overlooked her house detectives Mark Harris and Wayne McDonald meticulously made their
00:39:14
way through the building eventually knocking on the door of one second floor apartment it was answered by a tall
00:39:21
heavys set man in his late 20s with distinctive wiry hair both detectives immediately noted that
00:39:29
the man's hair and build were remarkably similar to what Jane had described as they explained why they
00:39:36
were there and began to ask if he'd noticed anything suspicious there was something strange about the man's
00:39:42
demeanor that also gave them both Paws he also had an injury to one thumb consistent with a
00:39:50
bite the detectives left and returned with a search warrant once inside the man's home they
00:39:58
noted that his Lounge room window had a clear view of Jane's backyard a washing basket full of dirty
00:40:04
clothes contained several blood soaked garments the blood would prove to be Janss and then while flipping through an
00:40:14
old diary from the Year 1980 the detectives found something else several newspaper clippings about a
00:40:22
murder that had been committed that same year the murder Teresa [Music] Crow the man's name was Joe Clark he was
00:40:35
arrested and taken to the local police station where he agreed to a medical examination following the examination
00:40:43
Clark abruptly told detective Mark Harris that he had something to tell him he announced quote you were right it was
00:40:52
me I went next door and had sex with the woman Clark confessed that he'd been fantasizing about Jane for some time and
00:41:02
had been watching her from his flat he said he was frustrated because quote I have never been able to get sex
00:41:10
from any woman voluntarily sick of paying to see sex workers he decided to attack Jane at a
00:41:17
time when he knew her husband wouldn't be home he'd lied to her about being a prison escape with friends waiting
00:41:24
outside hoping to both scare and trick her Clark made a full confession about the rape confirming the same details
00:41:33
Jane had provided the homicide detectives who'd been working on Theresa Crow's case 3
00:41:40
years earlier were notified about the arrest Clark had told Jane that he had cut up a previous victim this detail
00:41:49
combined with the clippings about Theresa's murder found in his home was the best lead that the Cold Case had
00:41:55
ever had when detectives from The Crow case arrived to interview Joe Clark he made
00:42:01
another prompt confession Clark had met Theresa crow in 1975 when he was 21 and she was
00:42:10
17 the pair were introduced by a mutual friend and Clark was instantly obsessed he began stalking Teresa at the
00:42:19
discos she was known to frequent Clark's fixation with Theresa grew over the next 5 years culminating
00:42:27
on the night of Thursday June 19 1980 when he saw her at Chase's nightclub and proposed that they get
00:42:35
married Theresa who didn't know Clark well had laughed at his suggestion then given him an annoyed look she left the
00:42:44
nightclub shortly after and Clark followed her home Clark told the detectives that he
00:42:50
climbed the ladder that led to her loft apartment and knocked on the trapo entrance Theresa had answered the door
00:42:57
in a nighty and let him inside it wasn't the first time he'd been there once Theresa had let him
00:43:05
sleep on her couch when he was too drunk to go home Clark claimed he made them both a
00:43:11
coffee and that when he carried Theresa's drink over to her she removed her nighty then she lay Face Down On The
00:43:19
Swinging couch suspended from the ceiling and he lay on top of her still fully dressed Clark said he bit ter Ra's back
00:43:27
as part of a consensual sexual encounter as he held her arms she started to struggle Clark wanted to have
00:43:36
sex with Theresa but she refused so instead he masturbated while lying on top of her before falling into a deep
00:43:43
sleep when he woke still lying on Teresa she was still and wasn't breathing panicked Clark moved her to
00:43:52
the floor and tried mouth-to-mouth resuscitation when this didn't work he used a sharp piece of metal to mutilate
00:43:59
Theresa's body in an attempt to throw police off making the accidental death look like an occult sacrifice
00:44:07
instead then he cleaned the apartment locked the door behind him and threw the key down a
00:44:13
[Music] drain the detectives didn't buy Joe Clark's story for a second they believed
00:44:21
he'd attacked Theresa like he'd attacked Jane removing her nighty himself then sexually assaulting her after forcing
00:44:28
her face down onto the couch with his hand holding her head down against the arm of the couch he had cut off her Air
00:44:35
Supply killing her Joe Clark was subsequently convicted of Theresa Crow's manslaughter and
00:44:44
sentenced to 15 years the longest manslaughter sentence ever imposed in the state of Victoria at that
00:44:51
time Clark later appealed the severity of his sentence and it was reduced to 9 years with a minimum of seven for raping
00:45:00
Jane he was given an additional 4 years almost two decades later in 2001 detective Tim day was reading about Joe
00:45:14
Clark's crimes while looking into the Cold Case murder of 6-year-old Bonnie Clark he'd gone looking for records of
00:45:22
someone named Mal Clark who'd been named by a friend of Bonnie as a possible suspect according to Bonnie's childhood
00:45:30
friend Kylie Ward Mal Clark had been a border who had lived with Bonnie and her mother his behavior had been creepy and
00:45:37
Bonnie had told Kylie that she didn't like him as detective day examined Joe Clark's file one detail stood out to him
00:45:48
his occupation at the time of his arrest in 1983 was listed as an assistant projectionist at a greater Union Cinema
00:45:56
Mel clarkk had also been an assistant projectionist at the same Cinema some further digging revealed Joe
00:46:04
Clark's full name Malcolm Joseph Thomas Clark he was the same person as the Border who' rented a spare room from
00:46:14
Marian Clark just going by a different name Bonnie had been killed in December of
00:46:21
1982 this was 2 and A2 years after the murder of Theresa TR and 8 months before the rape of Jane that led to his
00:46:30
arrest there was something else in 1983 when detectives investigating Jane's rape had searched
00:46:38
Malcolm Clark's Home they'd found some children's socks and underwear purchased from a budget store and a greeting card
00:46:46
addressed to Bonnie Clark just as they'd informed investigators working the Theresa Crow
00:46:52
case about the clippings relating to her murder the Brunswick detectives had notified the northcut investigators
00:46:59
about the possible connection to Bonnie Clark at that time detective Eric Lily was still in charge of Bonnie's case
00:47:08
he'd briefly spoken to Malcolm Clark shortly after Bonnie's murder but had ruled him out as a suspect convinced
00:47:15
from the start that Bonnie's mother Maran was the killer after hearing from his Brunswick
00:47:21
colleagues he agreed to meet with Clark again Clark explained away the greeting card as something he'd written for
00:47:29
Bonnie while she was still alive but never got around to sending and Mar and Clark couldn't say with any certainty
00:47:36
that the children's underwear found in his home had belonged to Bonnie detective Lily told his
00:47:43
colleagues in Brunswick that Bonnie's murder didn't fit the mo of the offenses Malcolm Clark was convicted of and said
00:47:50
they remained certain that Marian Clark was the culprit but but in 2001 Cold Case
00:47:58
detective Tim day was struck by the similarities between all three crimes all involved some kind of sexual
00:48:06
assault all of the victims had been attacked with a knife and all of the crime scenes had been
00:48:12
cleaned every one of the victims was known to Malcolm Clark in some respect and he was familiar with their homes and
00:48:20
routines on the day of Bonnie's murder Maran had actually told detectives about Malcolm Clark insisting that they speak
00:48:28
to him investigators had tracked Clark down but ruled him out after he provided an alibi that had been at the cinema
00:48:36
working detective Tim day couldn't find anything indicating the original investigators had verified this Alibi
00:48:44
almost 20 years later detective day wondered if he could finally do so it took some time but the detective
00:48:53
managed to track down shift record records for greater Union Cinemas in 1982 these confirmed that Malcolm Clark
00:49:02
had been employed by one of the company's movie theaters in December of 1982 he worked a shift there from 9:25
00:49:10
a.m. until 4:25 p.m. on Monday December 20 1982 finishing well before Bonnie Clark
00:49:18
was attacked later that night Malcolm Clark had the following day off and hadn't returned to work
00:49:25
until Wednesday December 22 his Alibi for the time of Bonnie's murder was [Music]
00:49:44
invalid by early 2002 Malcolm Joseph Thomas Clark was a free man now 47 years old he'd received parole 8 years earlier
00:49:54
in 1994 and had buil a new life for himself post prison sentence he was working as a personal
00:50:01
care attendant had gotten engaged to a girlfriend and spent his spare time exploring his passions and
00:50:08
hobbies Clark was a train Enthusiast and had a particular interest in puffing Billy a Narrow Gauge Heritage raway that
00:50:15
winds through the foothills of Victoria's dandong ranges it opened in 1900 and is one of
00:50:22
the most popular steam Heritage Railways in the world today beginning in the town of belgrave
00:50:29
and terminating in janbrook puffing Billy attracts families and tourists from Australia and all over the world
00:50:36
Malcolm Clark was also drawn to the steam train and in the year 2000 he took up a position as one of puffing Billy's
00:50:43
volunteer guards he received no money for the role but didn't mind being a part of the
00:50:50
iconic raway was payment enough one day in March 2002 Malcolm Clark was at puffing Billy's starting
00:50:59
point of belgrave train station when he struck up a conversation with a fellow train Enthusiast
00:51:05
there Phil was a tough-looking character who looked like an aging biky but he was
00:51:10
as passionate about puffing Billy as Clark was the two men hit it off and over the next couple of months they
00:51:18
built a friendship it soon became evident that Phil was part of a gang that was involved D in organized crime gradually
00:51:28
Clark began to join Phil in some of his illegal Ventures accompanying him when he
00:51:33
burgered a factory going to brothel with him to collect a large amount of cash and secretly snapping photographs of a
00:51:40
woman engaging in an adulterous affair on Friday May 17 2002 Phil took Clark to a hotel lounge where a number
00:51:50
of his criminal Associates were gathered he pointed these individuals out to Clark and provided descriptions
00:51:57
of them one was a corrupt police officer another was Steve the head honcho who Phil had to answer to known as the
00:52:07
boss Phil confided in Clark that Steve was scoping Clark out for a big job that was in the
00:52:14
works a couple of weeks later Phil took Clark on a different errand that involved meeting up with the corrupt
00:52:20
officer at the back of Victoria police's headquarters in St Kilda Road Melbourne
00:52:26
despite having seemingly gone on the straight and narrow since his release from prison Malcolm Clark appeared to
00:52:32
enjoy his new proximity to organized crime after assisting Phil with robbing some jewelry Clark was told he'd receive
00:52:40
$8,000 in payment this was in stark contrast to what he made in his job as a personal
00:52:47
care attendant which had been one of the only positions available to him with a wedding and a honeymoon to plan Clark
00:52:54
was appreciative of what the extra cash could pay for on Sunday June 2 an article was
00:53:04
published in the herald son newspaper about the Cold Case murder of Bonnie Clark its headline read DNA evidence
00:53:12
could hold the key to solving a 20-year-old child sex murder case Malcolm Clark read the
00:53:20
article it was a followup to a story about the case that had run the previous year and it featured brand new
00:53:27
information according to homicide Squad detective Ron idles investigators were now pursuing a line of inquiry that
00:53:34
indicated Bonnie's killer may have been a border who resided with the family they were aware of around 12 to
00:53:42
14 people who had rented rooms in the house prior to Bonnie's murder and planned to interview all of
00:53:48
them thanks to recent breakthroughs in DNA technology they were hopeful of identifying the perpetrator through some
00:53:55
hair samples cigarette butts and fingernail scrapings that had been saved from the crime
00:54:01
scene the following evening Malcolm Clark returned home to find a calling card had been left at his
00:54:07
residence it belonged to detective idles he'd paid a visit while Clark was at work and left a message with his
00:54:15
fiance Lynn he wanted Clark to come down to the station for DNA and polygraph testing this news sent Clark into a
00:54:25
Panic he phoned his friend Phil right away after telling Phil about the situation Clark assured him I can tell
00:54:34
you I had nothing to do with it Phil didn't seem phased by the Revelation that his new friend might be
00:54:43
a suspect in a child murder case he told Clark quote if you have done it I don't give a
00:54:50
rat's ass but we have got to know the full story so we can put wheels into motion
00:54:56
what's the polygraph going to say have you got anything to hide Clark insisted that he
00:55:03
didn't if you have we can make it go away Phil added Clark continued to deny any
00:55:11
involvement in the crime but Phil was persistent he told Clark that he could help him get rid of the issue due to his
00:55:18
Connections in Victoria police but only if Clark was completely honest I had just got my life worked out
00:55:26
getting my interests back Clark complained I never expected this to turn up you have got no idea how I am feeling
00:55:34
at the [Music] moment the following day Clark opened up to Phil some more about how he'd been a
00:55:43
border in Bonny Clark's home and had stayed in touch with the little girl even after moving out when he'd briefly
00:55:49
rented a room in the house next door to Bonnie he'd sometimes chat to her mother
00:55:53
Maran over the fence Clark claimed that sometimes Bonnie would be home alone which made her
00:56:00
scared on those occasions he invited her in and she would sit in a bean bag and watch television for a while before
00:56:06
heading back home upon maran's return Clark said he hadn't seen Bonnie after he moved back in with his parents
00:56:14
in October of 1982 2 months later on December 21 he'd been at home watching the news when he
00:56:21
saw a broadcast about Bonnie's murder the night before that was the first he knew of Bonnie being
00:56:28
harmed Phil said that if Clark was now a suspect then he wanted to help him he cared about Clark and enjoyed working
00:56:36
with him but the problem was word had already gotten back to Steve the boss that Clark might be in
00:56:44
trouble Steve needed this matter resolved and in order for that to happen Phil needed all of the information so he
00:56:51
could help Clark beat a police polygraph test if Clark wasn't being completely honest about the situation Steve would
00:56:59
abandon him without a second thought and Clark wouldn't receive the $8,000 from the jewry host that was still being held
00:57:06
for him a couple of days later Phil took Malcolm Clark to meet with Steve for an
00:57:14
official job interview at a hotel in Crown Casino in Melbourne CBD the pair went into a private Suite
00:57:21
where Steve and another associate were waiting for them Clark sat down on a couch in front of a
00:57:27
low coffee table while Steve sat opposite Steve greeted Clark and Phil then quickly got down to
00:57:36
business he was eager to have Clark join them but only if he could trust him 100% being part of their gang would be
00:57:44
highly lucrative for Clark he could quit his low-paying job and earn enough money
00:57:49
to buy his own train if he wanted the only problem was that homicide investigators were now looking
00:57:57
at Clark as the number one suspect in the 1982 murder of a 6-year-old girl Steve told Clark that he couldn't have
00:58:05
any more police heat on him if he tried stating you at the moment are [ __ ] red hot
00:58:13
right he produced a document for Clark to look at it was a three-page confidential police report stamped with
00:58:21
the Victoria Police seal and dated May 15 2002 less than 1 month earlier Clark scanned the documents
00:58:32
Pages they detailed the latest status of the Bonny Clark investigation and how it
00:58:37
seemed police finally had the suspect's DNA via some items recovered at the crime scene now they just needed a
00:58:44
sample of Clark's DNA to compare Steve told Clark that detectives could force him to provide a sample via
00:58:53
a court order but Steve's corrupt police connections could make the matter go away
00:58:58
entirely it would cost $5,000 which Steve was willing to pay but only if Clark told him
00:59:07
everything I am telling you this is not going to go away Steve said you can deny
00:59:12
it till the cows come home I can't have you hanging around with us you can see why can't
00:59:19
you yes Clark replied he was silent for a long time then he finally began to speak [ __ ] hell it was an accident
00:59:31
she [Music] died Malcolm Clark told Steve that late on the night of Monday December 20 1982
00:59:40
he had been out drinking at a pub in Brunswick for some reason he' had drunkenly decided to go to the home of
00:59:47
mar and Clark to quote play with Bonnie he left the pub and either walked to Mar 's house in northcut or caught a
00:59:56
tram there very familiar with the area he walked down the laneway that sat at the rear of the property and clambered
01:00:03
over the fence into the backyard Clark entered via The house's rear sliding door and headed up the
01:00:11
passageway to Bonnie's bedroom her bedside lamp was on and her small pet dog was sleeping on the top
01:00:18
bunk across from Bonnie's single bed Clark walked over to where Bonnie lay sleeping and began to sexually
01:00:25
assault her she woke and opened her mouth to scream but Clark grabbed a pillow and pressed it over her face he
01:00:33
used his other arm to pin her down Bonnie raised a hand in protest but eventually her arm went limp and fell
01:00:41
back down this caused Clark to panic he claimed he hadn't wanted to kill Bonnie he just wanted to keep her
01:00:50
quiet Clark happened to have a small carving knife which he said he carried for protection due to issues with some
01:00:56
local youths he told Steve that when Bonnie went still he impulsively stubbed her
01:01:03
quote I think I may have had the knife and I may have I think I may have just shoved it
01:01:10
into into the side of her chest wall when the wound didn't spurt blood upwards Clark believed this confirmed
01:01:19
Bonnie was already dead when he stabbed her Clark claimed he had an undressed Bonny but he had cleaned up with a cloth
01:01:28
or towel which he took with him afterwards then he pulled her bedding up over her body up to her chin before
01:01:34
faying out the back in all he estimated he had only been in the house for about 10 to 15
01:01:41
minutes he washed his clothes the next day and eventually threw away his shoes but couldn't remember what he did with a
01:01:49
knife it had a sheath that he was worried he may have left behind perhaps the DNA had come from that Clark
01:01:58
speculated or maybe from his saliva he knew that no Sean was left at the scene prior to the DNA Revelation Clark
01:02:07
had been confident that he' never be suspected as he had never done anything to Bonnie prior to that
01:02:14
[Music] night after listening to Malcolm Clark's confession Steve said he had to make
01:02:20
some phone calls and that Phil would take Clark to go get a coffee in the me time Clark and Phil got back into Phil's
01:02:28
car as they drove Phil told Clark that he had to collect something from the corrupt police officer they knew he
01:02:36
began heading towards the police headquarters in St Kilda road driving to the rear of the building as he'd done
01:02:43
previously already standing there waiting to arrest Malcolm Clark where detectives Tim day and Ron
01:02:53
idles after detective day's digging the previous year left him convinced that Malcolm Clark was the prime suspect in
01:03:01
Bonnie Clark's murder he began to push for an undercover operation the Canadian model or Mr big
01:03:08
was the name given to a practice in which undercover detectives trick suspects into confessing to their Crimes
01:03:14
by recruiting them into fake gangs the procedure was originally developed by the Royal Canadian Mounted
01:03:21
Police or RCMP during the 1960s and it eventually made its way to law enforcement agencies in other countries
01:03:29
including Australia the Canadian model was employed in the case of missing Queensland child Daniel morham covered
01:03:37
in episode 54 of case File it's a controversial practice that has come under scrutiny at times but has been
01:03:44
upheld by the Australian courts when detective Tim day needed a confession from Malcolm Clark to solve
01:03:52
the bnny Clark case the Canadian model appeared to be the ideal approach a strategy was devised and
01:03:59
dubbed operation Marauder as part of operation Marauder an undercover officer approached Clark
01:04:07
as Phil and the operation unfolded from there for months officers had been working their way into Clark's life
01:04:15
building trust with him and recording their interactions The Herald Sun News article
01:04:20
about a DNA breakthrough was planted to Spook Clark and Phil had deliberately brought it to his
01:04:27
attention in truth no DNA was able to be gleaned from the crime scene at all the Victoria Police case progress
01:04:36
report that Steve showed him was fake and similarly designed to scare Clark his ultimate confession had been
01:04:44
filmed via covert cameras and microphones set up throughout the hotel room once Clark was done the officer
01:04:52
posing as Phil drove Malcolm Clark to Victoria Police Headquarters to be arrested at 7:45 p.m. on Thursday June 6
01:05:03
2002 detective Tim day began recording a formal interview with Malcolm Clark faed with his confession to the
01:05:11
fictitious crime gang he finally ditched his false eliy he gave a detailed description of
01:05:18
Bonnie's murder as he recorded including her bedroom adding that he had been drunk as a skunk
01:05:24
he admitted to digitally raping the six-year-old smothering her and stabbing her Clark insisted it had never been his
01:05:33
intention to kill Bonnie quote God knows why I went round to that place and whatever happened had happened
01:05:41
and when I came to my senses I realized that Bonnie was deceased malol Clark was subsequently
01:05:49
charged with the murder of Bonny Clark and taken away to be held on Rand [Music]
01:05:58
by the time Malcolm Clark's trial began in Victoria's Supreme Court 2 years later he had riged his confessions and
01:06:04
was pleading not guilty the now 49-year-old Clark claimed that he'd only confessed to killing Bonnie because he
01:06:12
believed that was the only way he was going to get hired by the organized crime gang when the undercover officer
01:06:19
he knew as Phil took him to Police Headquarters and he was arrested and interviewed there Clark thought this was
01:06:25
an extension of his hotel room confession his lawyer argued that Clark had believed detectives Ron idles and
01:06:33
Tim day were corrupt officers on the gang's payroll not appreciating the reality of the situation he kept up the
01:06:40
charade instead of requesting a lawyer and maintaining his right to silence to support their argument that
01:06:48
Clark had made a false confession his defense pointed to some discrepancies between his statement and the crime
01:06:54
scene Clark had claimed he'd left Bonnie fully dressed in her pajamas but she was
01:06:59
found naked with her pajamas wedged between her bed and the wall Clark said he'd smothered Bonnie
01:07:06
yet there were bruises on her neck that indicated strangulation or that she'd been grabbed
01:07:12
roughly the defense argued that Clark was able to provide some correct details due to his familiarity with the victim's
01:07:19
house and reports he'd heard in the news however the prosecution pointed to details that were withheld from the
01:07:27
media that Clark had correctly described these included the fact that Bonnie was digitally raped the lack of
01:07:35
seen at the scene the stab wound to Bonnie's chest and the specific way it had blurred at least one media report which
01:07:44
Clark claimed to have read had actually stated that Bonnie was killed by strangulation however Bonnie's autopsy
01:07:51
was more consistent with Clark's claim that she was smothered and didn't struggle under cross-examination Clark
01:08:00
amended his story somewhat claiming the information he decided had actually come
01:08:05
from conversations he'd had with detectives 20 years earlier while incarcerated for his previous
01:08:11
crimes he named the case's original lead investigator detective Eric lily as one
01:08:17
of these detectives and said there were others he didn't want to name detective Lily did did briefly
01:08:24
speak to Clark following his 1983 arrest but no report of this interview was made
01:08:29
and Clark wasn't asked to provide a formal statement the prosecution suggested that
01:08:36
any discrepancies between Clark's confession and the crime scene were down to Clark forgetting some details due to
01:08:42
the passage of time his claimed that he'd believed he was still talking to gang members was
01:08:48
impossible due to the detectives explaining that they were from the homicide Squad and and cautioning him
01:08:54
before commencing their interview the jury of nine men and three women weren't told about Malcolm Clark's
01:09:02
previous convictions for manslaughter and rape they heard nothing about his prior victims or the similarities
01:09:09
between their cases and Bonnies on Thursday June 17 2004 the jury delivered their verdict
01:09:19
guilty Malcolm Clark was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum of 25 years after learning his fate Clark
01:09:29
turned around to look at the public Gallery he found detective Tim day and one of his undercover officers amongst
01:09:36
the crowd and glared at them with an enraged expression mouthing silent threats they stared straight back at him
01:09:44
in [Music] reply two months after Malcolm Clark was sentenced Bonny Clark's father Dennis
01:09:58
passed away he had been battling cancer for years but lived long enough to finally see Justice for his
01:10:05
daughter at the time of Clark's conviction Dennis told one reporter quote it's the best news I have ever had
01:10:14
after 21 years I am so glad I just think I'll get on with my life a lot better and not look at everyone and say this
01:10:24
isn't the person now I know for Bonnie's mother Marian Wishard Clark's conviction was particularly
01:10:33
gratifying as well as knowing her child's killer was finally being held accountable Maran was freed from the
01:10:39
suspicion that dogged her ever since the original investigators set their sights
01:10:43
on her in the Years prior to the Cold Case team taking up Bonnie's case police officers had occasionally called Marian
01:10:51
to check in but but it had never felt like they were following up with the victim of a
01:10:57
crime it felt like they were sending a subtle message that she was still their top
01:11:04
suspect during the 20 years following Bonnie's murder Marian had often woken in the middle of the night haunted by
01:11:10
the thought that Bonnie's killer was free to harm others her fears were confirmed upon finally learning who the
01:11:17
murderer was Maran was distraught that the lack of police attention on Clark had allowed
01:11:23
him to brutally rape at least one other woman in 1983 she had tried to tell investigators
01:11:30
that Malcolm Clark could be a suspect immediately after Bonnie's body was found but she hadn't been listened
01:11:37
to Marian Wishard passed away in 2018 from pneumonia before her death Marian spoke
01:11:46
with the journalist Ian Monroe who was now working for the Sunday age during the interview Marian
01:11:53
reminisced about her daughter describing Bonnie as a very strong willed funny little girl Marian
01:12:00
said one of her favorite memories of how attached Bonnie was to an imaginary friend she named
01:12:07
chitty on one occasion the mother and daughter were on a tram when Bonnie suddenly panicked because chitty hadn't
01:12:13
boarded with them to soothe her daughter Marian asked the driver to stop then pretended to fetch chitty from the
01:12:20
street outside all of the other passengers had laughed as Maran put chitty down beside
01:12:28
Bonnie reflecting on the daughter she'd lost Maran stated she's there all the time there
01:12:37
really isn't a time when Bonnie's not with [Music] me [Music]