00:00:00
foreign [Music] this was strange [Music] that happened in Dundee it's a classic neighborhood the heart of
00:00:18
Omaha [Music] violent crime does not happen then Dundee the mundane world of after school and
00:00:30
then it's just shattered by a monster [Music] I remember walking in their front door
00:00:39
into this very nice home there's a little boy lying face down in a very large pool of blood
00:00:51
you know you think of Tommy Hunter you can't imagine what the last few seconds of his life were like
00:00:57
smart kid love science math every parent's son and then as you walk through the house
00:01:06
and you get to the back door you see this large pool of blood this lady who had very evidently been pushed down to
00:01:14
the ground and attacked Shirley Sherman grandma gentle soul [ __ ] working to have anybody murdered is a shock to
00:01:25
the community but to have an 11 year old boy and a housekeeper killed in a manner
00:01:30
they were I think is a whole number level there didn't appear to be anything missing in the house no robbery no there
00:01:38
was no readily explainable reason behind what you see on that day one of the neighbors
00:01:44
happened to notice a car that she wasn't familiar with was a fleeting glance at him and his vehicle
00:01:55
silver Honda CRV [Music] things went cold after the first couple months how frustrated were you getting
00:02:05
incredibly I don't even know if I can put it into words beautiful Mother's Day tragedy strikes again
00:02:19
Dr Roger Brumback and his wife Mary yeah murdered detective do you remember the first time
00:02:27
you walked into this house I did what it looked like the aftermath of an incredibly brutal murder
00:02:36
Roger Brumback devoted portions of his medical career to Childhood disease and then to Alzheimer's
00:02:44
Mary Brumback could not have had an enemy in the world let me walk through that first door
00:02:52
Scott and I had a real definitive moment after we walked through that house where
00:02:56
we're like you know I've seen these things before specifically with the wounds to the
00:03:01
right side of the neck you don't see a lot of knifings that are stabbings that are that are like that when had the last
00:03:08
time been that you had seen stabbings like that it was 2008. with Thomas and Shirley
00:03:16
the mindset at that point was there's a connection here light bulb must have gone off very brightly
00:03:24
it's incredible on so many levels you can't help but be touched by the Innocence
00:03:31
of all of these victims and then it's in peaceful neighborhoods on beautiful days
00:03:37
this is a once in a lifetime type story [Music] thank you [Music] Omaha Nebraska a proud Beacon of
00:04:16
America's Midwest spreading out from the Majestic banks of the Missouri River home of the College World Series
00:04:25
and Warren Buffett Rich enough to live anywhere he chooses might take out all my overalls is a terrific place to live
00:04:34
according to Todd Cooper court reporter for the Omaha World Herald the secret heartbeat of this town is Creighton
00:04:41
Medical Center it resonates throughout the community you can't go anywhere without running into someone who is
00:04:49
Creighton born and bred how long was your career at Creighton 40 years Dr Shonda and a Gaines are butra loved and
00:04:57
respected their Creighton colleagues you both knew Dr Hunter yes his office is right next to my office the butras were
00:05:07
close friends with doctors Bill and Claire Hunter the parents of 11 year old Thomas
00:05:13
what were they like nice people dedicated to their Hospital he was very well loved by residents and
00:05:21
students the hunters and their four children lived here a handsome home in that upscale close-knit neighborhood known as
00:05:31
Dundee it's a classic neighborhood Neighbors in each other's business common areas where kids play
00:05:40
March 13 2008 Dr Claire Hunter was attending a conference in Hawaii and Bill was busy at the Pathology Lab
00:05:49
[Music] the school bus camera captures Tom arriving home smart kid love to play Xbox drink Dr
00:05:58
Pepper eat potato chips Tom Hunter a very bright very normal sixth grader his three older brothers
00:06:06
already out of the house waiting for Tom the Hunter's part-time housekeeper Shirley Sherman
00:06:13
when you think of your mom what are some of the words that come into mind mother
00:06:18
caregiver grandmother nurturer for her son Jeff and her younger brother Brad Shirley was the
00:06:25
Rock Solid hard-working centerpiece of their extended family anytime you go over there first thing she'd always want
00:06:33
to do is make sure she had coffee and you want something to eat I'll fix you something
00:06:42
Tom grabbed a snack and settled into this basement playroom with his chips soda and his Xbox
00:06:50
[Music] five o'clock Dr Hunter left his Pathology Lab at Creighton and began the
00:06:59
10 minute ride home he came home from work immediately walking in the back door and
00:07:05
he encountered Shirley and just a few feet away lay his son Tom the doctor knew immediately it was too
00:07:14
late for an ambulance he called 9-1-1 they told him to get out of the house and wait for First Responders to come
00:07:23
detective Derek Moyes 19 years with the Omaha PD and his partner Sergeant Scott Warner describe a crime scene that would
00:07:31
consume and haunt them incredibly sad scenario just the manner and the brutality of it
00:07:41
and in the basement cops found that still life of Tom's World interrupted by Madness his Xbox was
00:07:51
online and you could see his bag chips and his Dr Pepper not surprisingly it was evident surely
00:07:58
had been hard at work do you see her bucket of cleaning supplies just kind of dropped haphazardly right where Thomas
00:08:06
was Hunter and Shirley Sherman had been stabbed to death and as if sending some dark raging homicidal message knives had
00:08:17
been left in the victims and around the house but what was the motive for murder
00:08:26
something's just not adding up here my mom had 833 dollars in cash in a purse it wasn't even touched the hunters have
00:08:35
a lot of valuables or none of that appeared to have been touched I imagine the community must have been
00:08:43
unglued I think a city as a whole an 11 year old boy doesn't get killed in his home it just doesn't happen
00:08:52
for detectives Moyes Warner and the other investigators the horror of these gut-wrenching murders would soon be
00:08:58
paired with a deep frustration the crime scene left them little to go on no DNA no motive no apparent suspects
00:09:09
one of the neighbors happened to notice a car that she wasn't familiar with that was the first clue and it would one
00:09:18
day prove critical the neighbor's sighting of a silver Honda SUV with out of state plates prowling the streets of
00:09:26
Dundee it caught her attention not only because of the car but watching an individual that had exited the car take
00:09:34
a satchel and then walk Northbound on this street [Music] Moyes and Warner played out one scenario
00:09:43
after the next and it occupied our lives every day and when I say every day and I mean all
00:09:50
day was surely the target my Tom have attracted an online Predator to his basement playroom was there something
00:09:58
that occurred online over his gaming over a computer and there was Creighton itself
00:10:05
where the murders a gruesome active Vengeance by a disgruntled former employee targeting Tom's parents the
00:10:13
hunters detectives briefly considered this man Dr Anthony Garcia a former resident in
00:10:19
the pathology program Bill Hunter had fired Garcia back in 2001. but Bill Hunter dismissed Anthony
00:10:29
Garcia when they brought up his name in an interview now I yeah he got fired but
00:10:35
he left quietly every lead seemed like a dead end leaving nothing but shattered families
00:10:43
you just can't put it out of your mind we did not want it to just go away disappear
00:10:51
they want answers and the only people they can really turn to Is Us is there ever a point for either of you
00:10:59
where you thought we're just never going to find out who did this sure yes absolutely yeah there was
00:11:08
[Music] clear to us that Thomas had been attacked first the horrific crime scene
00:11:28
in the Hunter House in Dundee gave investigators plenty to puzzle over and think through
00:11:35
we just didn't see anything that would have precipitated the murders even after a couple of weeks into the investigation
00:11:42
we didn't know if Thomas was the intended victim if it was Shirley if it was the Hunter House the hunters
00:11:48
themselves or if it was a completely random act Moyes and Warner kept grinding and getting nowhere
00:11:57
it was a mystery for years let's talk about Mother's Day 2013. we took a couple and we took them
00:12:08
out for Mother's Day brunch and they're older people and he was with the Walker that Mother's Day fate brushed the
00:12:18
butres and it all started after that brunch with their slow-moving elderly guest he took forever to get to his car
00:12:28
and Dr butcher's husband ribbed him at the time and said you are killing us here like you are taking forever the
00:12:36
irony being he actually may have been saving their lives the butras both doctors at Creighton finally began their
00:12:44
short drive home when they got a call their Burglar Alarm was going off so I went to the basement
00:12:53
this door was open about an inch pushed it back in the door was a jar but nothing was out of place they had no
00:13:02
idea how lucky they were cops say the Intruder moved on just a few miles down the road to the home of
00:13:10
Dr Roger Brumback and his wife Mary Roger Brumback was in his old clothes painting the entryway of his house
00:13:19
getting it ready to to sell they were moving away they were going to retire they were on the cusp of what we all
00:13:25
work for and they had talked to their daughter via FaceTime his daughter cracked a joke she screenshot it it was
00:13:34
shortly after that FaceTime chat that Creighton Dr Roger Brumback answered a knock at the door
00:13:40
and boom just immediately shot it would be two days before anyone knew the extent and
00:13:50
the nature of the Carnage inside the brumback's OWN we showed up to move a piano here and
00:13:57
nobody answered the door Jason Peterson a piano mover showed up as scheduled and
00:14:04
I opened up the front glass door to yell inside hello and that's when I seen a gun clip on the floor like a magazine on
00:14:11
the floor the piano mover s called the cops there's a gun clip and some bullets on
00:14:17
the floor I just think there's something going on in this house that day detectives Derek Moyes and Scott Warner
00:14:23
just happened to be on call let me walk through that front door there was the loaded magazine that the
00:14:32
movers had spotted he also found a spent shell casing stuck between the double doors and just beyond that in the
00:14:40
entryway was Roger Brumback where you could see he had gunshot wounds we would also see very evident stab marks on the
00:14:47
right side of his neck just below his right ear [Music] and inside the main living room area of
00:14:53
that main floor and that's where we would find Mary Brumback she had very clear defensive wounds on her hands
00:15:01
which were indicative of her trying to put up a defense and we had knives that were left in that crime scene the
00:15:08
Carnage just inside the front door of the brumback's house was shocking even for long time homicide detectives but
00:15:16
there was something else about the crime scene that hit them almost instantly a sickening familiarity specifically
00:15:24
with the wounds to the right side of the neck and when I saw those both on the male victim and on the female victim you
00:15:32
don't see a lot of knifings that are stabbings that are that are like that the wounds were a mirror image to those
00:15:39
suffered by Tom Hunter and Shirley Sherman in 2008 and then you find out the victim worked as a doctor at
00:15:48
Creighton's medical school yeah then you two must look at each other and say we we can't ignore this we got something
00:15:56
here oh no Roger Brumback was not only a doctor at Creighton but he worked out of
00:16:01
the same office as Tom Hunter's father Bill the Pathology Department Roger Brumback was chairman and Bill Hunter
00:16:09
was in charge of the residence we knew we had these similarities in the crime scenes and the weapons that were used
00:16:16
in in this connection to the Pathology Department the cold case that had mystified Omaha for five frustrating
00:16:23
years was heating up your mind's going a million miles an hour you consciously have to make
00:16:29
yourself slow down the next day cops got a call from the butras telling detectives about that alarm
00:16:37
that went off at their home on Mother's Day the same day the brumbax were believed to have been murdered we have
00:16:45
Dr Hunter whose son Tom had been murdered in 2008. we have Dr Brumback who had just been gunned down in his
00:16:52
doorway and now Dr beatra a colleague of doctors Hunter and Brumback in Creighton's Pathology
00:16:59
Department who are they in a position to of effect the most and the obvious answer was of
00:17:06
course the the residents at that pathology training program and from that point on that's what
00:17:14
we looked at we went to Creighton University and we pulled the files from every resident within that program
00:17:20
starting I think in 2000 and one of the files you got belonged to Anthony Garcia
00:17:27
Anthony Garcia Omaha Police had heard his name before that Creighton pathology resident the
00:17:34
cops had barely considered back in 2008 he had been fired and Garcia's professor
00:17:41
in the Pathology Department Dr Shonda Putra what kind of student was he bad guy and
00:17:47
a bad student and Dr butra didn't hold back on her feelings in several performance reviews she prepared for
00:17:54
Bill Hunter I was trying very hard to convince Bill to get rid of him yes and that's exactly what happened Hunter and
00:18:04
Brumback fired Garcia his letter of termination began to look like a Smoking Gun and the signatures
00:18:13
are Dr William Hunter and Dr Roger Brumback correct so in his mind if he's trying to
00:18:21
figure out who's responsible for his termination he's thinking of three people Brumback
00:18:30
Hunter and butra every time Anthony Garcia is looking for a job this letter signed by Brumback and
00:18:43
Hunter kind of seemingly was coming back to haunt him [Music] thank you where does this case where is
00:19:01
it in terms of your your frontal lobe or present it's at the Forefront for sure it's been a constant since 2008
00:19:11
two sets of murders five years apart with a Common Thread Creighton University I always felt there's something to do
00:19:20
with Creighton meanwhile detective Derek Moyes was learning as much as he could about
00:19:26
former Creighton resident Anthony Garcia after I got the Garcia book every time I
00:19:33
I turned a Paige I was learning something new that I felt was relevant that I felt was going to carry me on to
00:19:40
the next step for Moyes Garcia was looking more and more like his number one suspect
00:19:47
but an unlikely one Anthony Garcia who is he you know a decidedly middle class kid played
00:19:57
football grew up in Walnut California Walnut California is a place where dreams really do come true a pristine
00:20:07
suburb in a Golden Valley about an hour east of Los Angeles it was a loving home we're encouraged to
00:20:15
you know do the right thing Fernando Garcia is Anthony's younger brother keenly aware of what his family has
00:20:23
accomplished my mom was born in Mexico and came here and you know my dad was born here you know my dad fought in
00:20:30
Vietnam they didn't have a lot they were able to achieve you know the American dream for Fred who worked for
00:20:37
the post office San estela a registered nurse a Cornerstone of their dream was their firstborn child
00:20:45
Anthony he was healthy playful he played football what kind of student was Anthony it was
00:20:55
good he was a good student he was an auto boy who wanted to get along with people
00:21:00
not confrontational there was College in California and then med school in Utah he wanted to be a
00:21:08
brain surgeon you must have been enormously proud oh yes yeah then in 1999 came a journey most parents
00:21:18
only dream of his dad described packing all of Anthony's belongings into a van and driving cross-country Father and Son
00:21:29
dad couldn't have been prouder [Music] Father and Son were headed here Bassett Saint Elizabeth in Utica New York it
00:21:39
would be Anthony Garcia's first residency and it didn't go well I did not know he was having trouble
00:21:48
Garcia's professors accused him of Behaving unprofessionally including yelling at a radiology technician Under
00:21:56
Pressure Garcia resigned and firstborn son headed back home when he came back he was not the same
00:22:06
he looked very tired almost exhausted but he wasn't giving up and in July of 2000 Anthony Garcia got what few
00:22:16
residents ever do a second chance I was happy he was getting a job that's when Garcia began his residency
00:22:25
in the Pathology Department at Creighton academically he was very poor but there
00:22:31
was much more than poor academics pranking a chief resident rolling a body onto its face so it becomes disfigured
00:22:41
he would write emails to Dr Hunter complaining about Dr butra I mean this guy was a child cloaked
00:22:49
and cloaked with a medical degree then in 2001 after multiple incidents and those bad performance reviews by Dr
00:22:58
butra Creighton had its fill of Anthony Garcia what does it mean for a resident to be
00:23:07
terminated pretty serious it pretty much ends your medical career Anthony Garcia headed home once again he
00:23:19
said it didn't work out did he complain about the people he did not complain about the people I never
00:23:25
complain about anybody those who knew and still love him believe Anthony's struggled with
00:23:31
depression and migraine headaches and was overwhelmed by the rigorous work required to fulfill his American Dream
00:23:38
of becoming a doctor I can see that taking a toll on somebody psychologically emotionally and did you
00:23:45
get the sense at all that Anthony felt he had failed not at all I think he was adamant about
00:23:54
continuing with that career and miraculously in 2003 Anthony Garcia got a third chance working as a resident
00:24:04
at the University of Illinois hospital he somehow managed to get a medical license to practice in the state of
00:24:11
Illinois but for the state of Illinois this guy does not have a medical license anywhere
00:24:18
for the next few years Garcia bounced around the country working where he could clinics even a
00:24:26
prison hospital with every new state he moved to Garcia had to apply for a medical license there
00:24:33
and those who had the authority to grant that license would learn of his dismissal from Creighton
00:24:39
and each time he would pay a price for his past to get licensure in another state they
00:24:46
would be sending Creighton University very specific requests about or Anthony Garcia's time at Creighton University
00:24:55
and those responses were not positive they were not positive it doesn't take a detective or even a physician to read
00:25:02
those as a layperson and say that's not going to help him get get licensure or a
00:25:07
job investigators discovered that in February 2008 Garcia was living in Louisiana
00:25:14
the state denied his application for a medical license due in part to his termination from Creighton
00:25:22
three weeks later Tom Hunter and Shirley Sherman were brutally murdered [Music] the pieces of Anthony Garcia's past were
00:25:35
coming together in front of Moyes and Warner but could they Place him in Dundee in 2008 on the day of Tom and
00:25:43
Shirley's murder Moyes wondered what kind of car Garcia was driving back then so he checked his reports and I remember
00:25:51
it was on page 11 of that report that between July of 2007 in July of 2009 Anthony Garcia had a Honda CRV
00:26:04
registered to him at a Shreveport Louisiana address after discovering the make and model
00:26:13
moist ran the VIN number to get the color and it came back as a silver Honda CRV
00:26:19
[Music] it was 2013. the slaughter of four innocent people over the course of five
00:26:35
years had left Omaha staggered and searching for answers this is something that really had upset
00:26:43
the community the city the the region it evolved into something so much bigger than any of us we're used to
00:26:51
but its origin was right here the Pathology Department at Creighton University Medical Center where Dr
00:26:59
Brumback was the head of the department and Dr Hunter was in charge of the residence
00:27:04
it was also here investigators allege that Anthony Garcia developed his Twisted motive for murder it's
00:27:13
unfathomable a grudge that festers for seven years before the first killings in 12 years before the second set of
00:27:21
killings that's unheard of a grudge that wouldn't quit revenge for being fired was the motive the theory of the case
00:27:29
Moyes and Warner began to build but Fernando Garcia Anthony's younger brother wasn't buying it there's been
00:27:37
millions of people fired who don't come back and kill somebody and by 2013 Garcia was long gone from
00:27:44
Omaha living 500 miles away in Terre Haute Indiana he had been fired again this time from
00:27:53
that job as a medical worker in a prison still he had a Ferrari in his driveway and appeared to be living the High Life
00:28:01
but that wasn't the information cops craved I needed to find out where he was on May 12
00:28:08
2013. the day Roger and Mary Brumback were murdered Garcia's electronic records lit up the
00:28:16
trail we have this phone call accessing a cell tower in Atlantic Iowa which is only an hour away from Omaha he had made
00:28:24
a purchase at a Wingstop restaurant in Omaha and Anthony Garcia was caught on camera just outside Omaha buying a case
00:28:33
of Bud Light that very same day at this point do you have a suspect you want to arrest yes
00:28:41
detectives headed for Garcia's Terre Haute home but when they got there he was nowhere
00:28:48
to be found our concern was that he was leaving Terre Haute and he was headed south towards Louisiana where there were
00:28:55
other people that you felt he perceived had wronged him yes cops feared Garcia was out to kill again
00:29:04
Omaha detectives were now working with nearby law enforcement agencies and the FBI
00:29:11
and at 8 30 a.m Illinois State Police spotted Garcia's car he was pulled over drunk and on his knees in the middle of
00:29:21
the road Anthony Garcia was arrested in his car a crowbar a sledgehammer and a gun
00:29:34
we got a call that he was in custody and what did that sound like relief yeah with Garcia under arrest cops entered
00:29:43
his house in Terre Haute it was apparent it didn't look like somebody planned on on really coming
00:29:50
back Omaha Detective Ryan Davis got the first look into a dark and conflicted world through Garcia's chilling words we
00:29:59
live we die we live we die on top of the dining room table are all these documents I would call
00:30:08
them documents of success a medical degree a deed to his house and then he's got this bag
00:30:15
this trash bag in his kitchen sink inside the trash bag were more documents submerged in a liquid
00:30:23
it looked at detectives like someone was trying to destroy them these documents really give you chills he's talking
00:30:32
about going to the store buying broccoli butter shrimp Anthony Garcia's shopping
00:30:38
list from the ordinary to the ominous as you can see here it says invade Ridge House torture
00:30:47
murder over here it says Rich children gun invade kill knife kidnap family SUV torture kill
00:30:56
and there was also something familiar soaking in the sink those negative performance reviews written by Dr Shonda
00:31:04
butra and Garcia's termination letter signed by doctors Hunter and Brumback the motivation for these murders was all
00:31:13
right there in that sink that sink full of evidence wasn't all detectives found their investigation LED them to a key
00:31:24
witness at Garcia's favorite haunt Club Coyote who's Cecilia Hoffman at the time she
00:31:31
was a stripper at a strip club in Terre Haute Indiana Mr Garcia was a a regular customer
00:31:40
a roadside strip joint the one place Anthony Garcia's childhood dreams still had life
00:31:47
when he came in the door they would announce that Dr Tony was in the house and he had all this money and Cecilia
00:31:54
told detective Davis that Garcia wanted more than just a dance he wanted a girlfriend that wasn't what she wanted
00:32:02
so she stated to us that she started to try to distance herself from him Omaha cops recorded Cecilia's haunting
00:32:12
story I'm putting on my little voice and saying well Dr Tony I only like bad boys
00:32:17
I'm a bad girl he couldn't you know you couldn't handle a girl like me and then definitely told me he told me I wasn't
00:32:23
as good as he thought he was he thought I killed people before he said I killed a young boy and an old
00:32:29
woman Anthony Garcia confesses to the murders of Thomas Hunter and Shirley Sherman as a way to try to impress a
00:32:38
stripper right the police fugitive unit would extradite Garcia back here to Omaha and on July 23
00:32:45
2013 right here at the Douglas County Courthouse Dr Anthony Garcia was formally charged with four counts of
00:32:54
first-degree murder there wasn't anything in this case I don't think that was like our big piece
00:33:00
of evidence I think there were a lot of pieces and when you put them together that's what makes it overwhelming it all
00:33:06
points to Anthony Garcia lead prosecutor Don Klein and his Deputy Brenda Beadle would lay out Nebraska's capital murder
00:33:14
case against Anthony Garcia they're trying to put my client to death and I was going to do whatever I had to do to
00:33:22
get him a fair trial if at all possible and Bob Mata Jr his father and their legal Associates with the chicago-based
00:33:30
PowerHouse defense team Anthony Garcia's parents spent their entire life savings
00:33:36
to hire did your son kill Tommy Hunter Shirley Sherman Roger and Mary Brumback I don't know
00:33:47
if if it did it's a totally different person that they're talking about [Music] September 26 2016.
00:34:06
15 years after he was fired from Creighton the quadruple murder trial of a very different looking Anthony Garcia
00:34:15
finally began [Music] just the innocence in this every one of those people were just going about their
00:34:25
days their lives and then Anthony Garcia comes knocking knocking with his Grudge Garcia's Moto
00:34:33
summed up by the prosecution in a single word Revenge he Googled it he searched for it he
00:34:42
searched for that term including a quote in his phone Shakespeare quote Merchant
00:34:48
of Venice if you harm us shall I not Revenge their theories Revenge Revenge if you
00:34:56
take out that element that leaves them with absolutely a giant gaping hole in their tapestry
00:35:04
where the entire thing becomes unwoven No cameras were allowed in court the Matas of Chicago went at the prosecution
00:35:14
like heavyweights they brought a lot of fire Revenge suggested the Matas was just a fancy Theory and in fact the
00:35:23
Matas produced this letter of recommendation for Anthony Garcia written by Dr Hunter just a few days
00:35:30
after Garcia was fired from Creighton we terminated him but we don't want him to
00:35:36
be jobless destitute we want him to rehabilitate and find some other job and the modest take on the star witness
00:35:45
Cecilia Hoffman who Garcia had allegedly confessed to a strung out stripper at the time I
00:35:53
think she's a liar the time that she gives the interview she's intoxicated she's popping script pills every day she
00:36:00
has no credibility well I thought she was extremely incredible and she had nothing to gain by coming forward
00:36:06
she was subjected to a very long and extensively vigorous cross-examination and she didn't waver and the jury saw
00:36:15
that and the jury saw this the other piece of the gun was found off the highway on an exit ramp right by
00:36:27
Terre Haute Indiana cops believe Garcia used to kill Roger Brumback that's an unbelievable
00:36:35
coincidence it's amazing real number matches the one on this gun box found in his Terre Haute apartment
00:36:43
but at the butra's home on this doorknob there was DNA there was DNA evidence that pointed to
00:36:51
Anthony Garcia but the mod has insisted cops could not Place Garcia in Omaha for the first set
00:36:58
of murders and they argued this Anthony Garcia was not the only disgruntled employee at Creighton that buying
00:37:06
chicken wings and beer on the day of the brumbax murder didn't make their client
00:37:11
a killer and that he was simply looking for a job again in the Omaha area if Nebraska puts Anthony Garcia to death
00:37:21
is an innocent man dying I believe so I believe so after more than 50 Witnesses and 15 days
00:37:30
of emotional testimony the case went to the jury it took just seven hours and then the
00:37:37
jury spoke as one [Music] Anthony Garcia guilty of murder and the deaths of Thomas Hunter Shirley Sherman
00:37:45
and Roger and Mary Brumback Anthony Garcia who didn't testify guilty on all counts
00:37:57
you know the breath just kind of comes out of you and it brings a lot of emotions back
00:38:04
because you think about I can see about Thomas and and Shirley and Roger and Mary
00:38:13
thank you for two cops it was the answer to nearly a decade of Relentless work you have
00:38:22
been called the hero of this story you can't shake that off fast enough oh no not at all
00:38:28
you're describing to me a tireless investigation by a lot of detectives in our department and other
00:38:36
agencies but Omaha that proud Midwestern City wasn't buying Derrick Moyes and Scott Warner's modest ways and when they
00:38:46
approached a room full of the victim's loved ones tell me what happened you walked in
00:38:52
I don't even want to say it why not I don't know I can see it in your face this was the
00:39:01
most emotional moment wasn't it one of them yes for sure [Music] the victims families stood and applauded
00:39:15
it's very gratifying that's that's I think why we do what we do and just finally after seven years you
00:39:23
can kind of let it go a little bit say okay these families have got their answer
00:39:28
[Music] three families shattered three plus one they got the wrong person I still don't
00:39:38
believe it will you be at the sentencing oh yes the firstborn son of hard-working people
00:39:48
he grew up and a healthy environment what changed them I don't know the boy who followed his dream now up
00:39:59
for the death penalty I have to be there I don't know if I ever see him again [Music]
00:40:12
if there is room for irony in a murder story it belongs to the butres police believe that the butras not the
00:40:21
brumbax would be dead the butris had not been at that Mother's Day brunch with their slow-moving
00:40:27
elderly friend if you had been home 20 minutes earlier what would have happened we were both
00:40:34
dead we would be having this conversation that was either them or us outside Creighton Medical Center
00:40:44
where every single day countless doctors bind wounds help and heal their sits in the cool Stillness a
00:40:54
statue [Music] it is Tom Hunter forever an 11 year old child at play for eternity
00:41:07
[Music] foreign [Music]